Trump Says German Reliance on Russian Gas Compromises NATO Defense

Associated Press

Germany has become captive to Moscow by phasing out domestic coal and nuclear power in favor of pipeline deals that enrich the very adversary the alliance protects against.

AI-assisted summary of Trump: Germany 'Totally Controlled By Russia' — original source. Check the original for full context.

Source published: 2018-07-11

Key ideas

President Donald Trump challenged Germany's pipeline deals at a NATO breakfast, arguing that Berlin pays billions of dollars to Russia while relying on U.S. military protection. (0:00)
Trump highlighted political entanglements behind Russian gas imports, noting that a former German Chancellor heads the pipeline consortium. (0:00)
The U.S. president asserted that Germany is becoming a 'captive of Russia' after shutting down domestic coal and nuclear power plants. (1:00)
Germany's pipeline framework is projected to leave between 60% and 70% of its gas and energy imports under Russian influence. (1:00)
Trump called on NATO leadership to directly examine Germany's energy dependency as a fundamental threat to collective Western security. (1:00)

Detailed notes

## Background Published on YouTube by the Associated Press on July 11, 2018, this video documents remarks made during a combative breakfast at the start of a fraught NATO summit in Brussels. According to the page description, President Donald Trump claimed that a major pipeline project has made Germany 'totally controlled' by and 'captive to Russia.'

## TL;DR President Donald Trump challenges the core dynamic of the NATO alliance, questioning why the United States should defend European nations while Germany sends billions of dollars directly to Russia for natural gas. He highlights that a former German Chancellor heads the pipeline consortium and projects that Russia will soon control up to 70 percent of Germany's energy supply. Trump blames Germany's phase-out of domestic coal and nuclear energy for forcing this reliance, directly labeling Germany a 'captive of Russia' and demanding that NATO leadership address the strategic vulnerability.

## Atmosphere & style The clip carries a blunt, combative, and tense atmosphere as Donald Trump disregards standard diplomatic decorum to confront allies head-on. His tone is laden with frustration and disbelief, turning a breakfast meeting into a sharp, unvarnished interrogation of Western defense contradictions. The viewing experience feels inherently fraught and uncomfortable, defined by raw geopolitical friction and a direct challenge to the transatlantic partnership.

## Bulletin - [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=0s) President Donald Trump challenged Germany's pipeline deals at a NATO breakfast, arguing that Berlin pays billions of dollars to Russia while relying on U.S. military protection. - [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=0s) Trump highlighted political entanglements behind Russian gas imports, noting that a former German Chancellor heads the pipeline consortium. - [01:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=60s) The U.S. president asserted that Germany is becoming a 'captive of Russia' after shutting down domestic coal and nuclear power plants. - [01:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=60s) Germany's pipeline framework is projected to leave between 60% and 70% of its gas and energy imports under Russian influence. - [01:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=60s) Trump called on NATO leadership to directly examine Germany's energy dependency as a fundamental threat to collective Western security.

## Key takeaways - [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=0s) Trump condemned the contradiction of the U.S. and NATO defending Germany from Russian aggression while Germany finances Moscow through energy purchases. - [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=0s) Germany has committed to paying billions of dollars annually for Russian natural gas via major pipeline infrastructure. - [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=0s) A former Chancellor of Germany leads the consortium operating the pipeline supplying Russian natural gas. - [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=0s) The Trump administration claimed to have opposed these German-Russian pipeline agreements since taking office. - [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=0s) New pipeline deals are projected to place up to 70% of Germany's natural gas supply under Russian control. - [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=0s) Trump labeled NATO allies funding the Russian state while receiving alliance protection as 'very inappropriate.' - [01:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=60s) Germany's domestic energy policies, specifically the closure of coal-fired plants, accelerated its reliance on foreign energy. - [01:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=60s) The systematic phase-out of domestic nuclear power left Germany without sufficient baseload energy, compelling Russian imports. - [01:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=60s) Trump directly labeled Germany as a 'captive of Russia' due to its extreme reliance on imported Russian oil and gas. - [01:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=60s) Pipeline projects are projected to leave Germany reliant on Russia for 60% to 70% of its total energy imports. - [01:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=60s) Trump urged NATO leadership to confront Germany's energy posture, warning that it compromises collective defense strategy.

## Detailed walkthrough ### [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=0s) U.S. Protection and German Pipeline Deals with Russia

President Donald Trump expresses deep frustration over the economic and geopolitical contradictions within the NATO alliance, taking direct aim at Germany’s energy agreements with Moscow. In a blunt and combative tone, he questions why the United States, along with the broader alliance, is responsible for defending European allies from Russian aggression while those same allies pour vast financial resources directly into the Russian economy. Trump points out that while the U.S. is committed to protecting nations like Germany and France, Germany has committed to paying billions of dollars annually for Russian natural gas through major pipeline projects, effectively funding the very adversary the alliance was built to deter. Highlighting the political entanglements behind these infrastructure deals, Trump explicitly points out that a former Chancellor of Germany serves as the head of the pipeline company supplying the gas.

He makes clear that this arrangement is deeply problematic and claims that his administration has pushed back against it since his first day in office. Trump argues that these energy deals will soon leave Germany severely compromised, projecting that Russia will end up controlling nearly 70 percent of Germany's natural gas supply. Condemning the alliance's acquiescence, Donald Trump asserts: “So, we're supposed to protect you against Russia, but they're paying billions of dollars to Russia, and I think that's very inappropriate.”

- The United States is actively defending allies such as Germany and France while European nations transfer billions of dollars into Russian state coffers. - Germany’s reliance on Russian natural gas via new pipeline construction is projected to place nearly 70% of its gas supply under Russian influence. - The former Chancellor of Germany leads the consortium responsible for the gas pipeline supplying the country.

[01:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=60s) Energy Dependency: Germany Labeled a 'Captive of Russia'

Trump intensifies his criticism by arguing that Germany’s domestic energy transition has created a dangerous strategic vulnerability, leaving the nation entirely compromised by Moscow. He details how Germany actively accelerated this dependence by shutting down its domestic coal-fired power plants and systematically decommissioning its nuclear power facilities. With domestic base-load power dismantled, the country has been forced to import massive amounts of oil and natural gas from Russia, leaving its economy reliant on a single foreign adversary.

Framing the issue as a direct hazard to collective Western defense, Trump insists that the security bloc can no longer ignore the situation, urging NATO leadership to directly confront the dependency. He stresses that reliance on Russian resources fundamentally undermines the alliance's purpose and strategy. Emphasizing the extent of this vulnerability, Donald Trump states: “Now, if you look at it, Germany is a captive of Russia, because they supply—they get rid of their coal plants, they get rid of their nuclear.”

- Germany is projected to obtain between 60% and 70% of its overall energy imports from Russia through the pipeline framework. - The country's phase-out of domestic coal power and nuclear energy is identified as the primary catalyst for its dependence on Russian fossil fuels. - Trump calls on NATO to formally examine Germany's energy posture, maintaining that both he and his interlocutors agree the current arrangement is inappropriate.

## Notable quotes > [01:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=60s) Germany is a captive of Russia, because they supply—they get rid of their coal plants, they get rid of their nuclear. — Donald Trump

## Mentioned Donald Trump, Germany, France, Russia, United States, NATO

## Video description President Donald Trump claimed a pipeline project has made Germany "totally controlled" by and "captive to Russia" during a combative breakfast Wednesday that kicked off what was already expected to be a fraught NATO summit in Brussels. (July 11)

Subscribe for more Breaking News: http://smarturl.it/AssociatedPress Get updates and more Breaking News here: http://smarturl.it/APBreakingNews

Find the 45th President of the United States Donald Trump's latest press conferences, announcements, speeches and highlights here: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLnwt1fUa-EVgihKJ_26XtMdmGDOmABAAa

The Associated Press is the essential global news network, delivering fast, unbiased news from every corner of the world to all media platforms and formats. AP’s commitment to independent, comprehensive journalism has deep roots. Founded in 1846, AP has covered all the major news events of the past 165 years, providing high-quality, informed reporting of everything from wars and elections to championship games and royal weddings. AP is the largest and most trusted source of independent news and information. Today, AP employs the latest technology to collect and distribute content - we have daily uploads covering the latest and breaking news in the world of politics, sport and entertainment. Join us in a conversation about world events, the newsgathering process or whatever aspect of the news universe you find interesting or important. Subscribe: http://smarturl.it/AssociatedPress

http://www.ap.org/ https://plus.google.com/+AP/ https://www.facebook.com/APNews https://twitter.com/AP

[Source](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I)

中文简报

特朗普称德国对俄罗斯天然气的依赖损害北约防务德国因逐步淘汰国内煤电和核电而转向管道协议，使自身沦为莫斯科的俘虏，进而让北约本应防范的对手坐享巨额财富。唐纳德·特朗普总统质疑北约联盟的核心机制，质问当德国向俄罗斯直接支付数十亿美元购买天然气时，美国为何还要保卫欧洲国家。他指出一位德国前总理执掌该管道财团，并预计俄罗斯很快将控制德国高达70%的能源供应。特朗普指责德国逐步淘汰国内煤电和核能迫使其产生这种依赖，直接称德国是“俄罗斯的俘虏”，并要求北约领导层解决这一战略脆弱性。唐纳德·特朗普总统在北约早餐会上对德国的管道协议提出质疑，认为柏林方面在依靠美国军事保护的同时，向俄罗斯支付数十亿美元。 (0:00) 特朗普强调了俄罗斯天然气进口背后的政治纠葛，指出一位德国前总理正执掌该管道财团。 (0:00) 这位美国总统断言，德国在关闭国内煤电和核电站后正沦为“俄罗斯的俘虏”。 (1:00) 根据预测，德国的管道框架将使其60%至70%的天然气和能源进口受制于俄罗斯的影响。 (1:00) 特朗普呼吁北约领导层直接审查德国的能源依赖，将其视为对西方集体安全的一项根本威胁。 (1:00)

Reading summary

President Donald Trump criticized Germany's major energy agreements with Moscow, arguing that Berlin is financially backing an adversary while relying on the United States and NATO for military protection. Geopolitical Contradictions in Defense and Energy Deals (0:00) Trump argued that a fundamental contradiction exists within the NATO alliance, questioning why the United States commits vast resources to defend European partners like Germany and France while those nations send billions of dollars annually to Russia for natural gas. Highlighting the political connections behind these projects, Trump pointed out that a former German Chancellor serves as head of the pipeline consortium supplying the fuel, an arrangement Trump claimed his administration has opposed since taking office. Framing the financial transfers as fundamentally inappropriate, Trump projected that these pipeline projects will soon leave Germany severely compromised by placing nearly 70 percent of its natural gas supply under Russian influence. In his view, these infrastructure agreements effectively fund the exact adversary that NATO was established to deter. Domestic Phase-Outs and Strategic Energy Vulnerability (1:00) Trump labeled Germany a "captive of Russia," asserting that the country's domestic energy transition created a dangerous strategic vulnerability. He contended that Germany accelerated this dependency by shutting down its domestic coal-fired power plants and systematically decommissioning its nuclear facilities, leaving the economy reliant on massive imports of Russian oil and gas for base-load power. Estimating that Germany is projected to receive between 60 and 70 percent of its energy imports from Russia through these pipeline frameworks, Trump described the reliance as an immediate hazard to Western collective defense. Consequently, he called on NATO leadership to formally confront and examine Germany's energy posture, maintaining that reliance on an adversary undermines the alliance's core purpose. Trump urged NATO leadership to formally evaluate Germany's reliance on Russian energy infrastructure, though the source does not include responses from German representatives or alliance officials.

精炼阅读摘要

Donald Trump 批评北约防务保护与盟友经济利益之间存在地缘政治矛盾，指责德国因管道项目和关停本土能源而深度依赖俄罗斯，在经济与战略上沦为俄罗斯的“俘虏”，并要求北约正视这一安全隐患。防务保护与对俄资金转移的矛盾 (0:00) Trump 质问为何美国需承担防务责任以保护德国和法国等欧洲盟友免受俄罗斯侵略，而德国每年却通过大型管道项目向俄罗斯支付数十亿美元购买天然气，等同于为联盟旨在遏制的对手提供资金。他特别提及背后的政治纠葛，指出德国前总理担任了负责输气管道的财团负责人。Trump 称其政府自执政第一天起便反对此类安排，并依据预测指出，该管道将使俄罗斯控制德国近 70% 的天然气供应，使德国陷入极度被动的局面。本土能源退役加剧对俄战略依附 (1:00) Trump 进一步指出，德国自身的能源转型政策加剧了其战略脆弱性。通过关闭国内燃煤电厂并系统性退役核能发电设施，德国本土的基荷电力被大幅削减，直接迫使其从俄罗斯大量进口石油和天然气，导致本国经济过度受制于单一外部对手。根据 Trump 援引的预测，通过既有管道框架，德国将有 60% 至 70% 的整体能源进口来自俄罗斯，他因此直言德国已经成为“俄罗斯的俘虏”。能源漏洞对西方集体防御的挑战 (1:00) Trump 将德国对俄能源依附定性为对西方集体安全的直接威胁，认为这种深度经济绑定从根本上动摇了北约联盟的战略初衷与运作目的。他敦促北约最高领导层不可再忽视这一现状，必须直接正视并正式审查德国的能源立场，坚称盟友对敌对力量的资金输送与能源依附在联盟安全框架下极不合时宜。本简报反映了 Trump 对德国能源政策削弱北约集体安全的批评与推测；材料仅记录了 Trump 单方面的严厉指责及其引用的能源依赖数据（如 60% 至 70% 的依赖预测），并未包含德国官方或北约领导层对此作出的回应或辩护证据。

Detailed notes — zh

## Background 该视频由美联社（Associated Press）于2018年7月11日发布在YouTube平台上。视频内容源自布鲁塞尔北约峰会开幕时一场火药味十足的早餐会，描述了美国总统唐纳德·特朗普指责天然气管道项目使德国“完全受俄罗斯控制”并成为其“俘虏”。 ## TL;DR 在布鲁塞尔北约峰会期间，特朗普总统强烈谴责德国与俄罗斯签署巨额天然气管道协议，批评美国投入巨资保护欧洲免受威胁，盟友却反手向莫斯科输送数十亿美元资金。他特别提及德国前总理在涉事管道公司任职，指出这种政商关联极不恰当。特朗普进一步痛批德国关停本土煤电厂与核电设施、转而让自身60%至70%的能源依赖俄罗斯的政策，直言德国已沦为俄罗斯的“俘虏”，并敦促北约严正审查这一威胁联盟安全的局面。 ## Atmosphere & style 整段视频气氛剑拔弩张、极具火药味与压迫感。特朗普的语气直白而激愤，带着毫不掩饰的质问与难以置信的挫败感，情绪层层递进；面对盟友代表，他毫不留情地直戳痛处，将外交互动变成了公开的问责与抨击，让观众隔着屏幕也能清晰感受到北约内部战略裂痕带来的沉重紧张感。 ## Bulletin - [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=0s) 在2018年布鲁塞尔北约峰会早餐会上，美国总统特朗普公开抨击德国与俄罗斯达成巨额油气管道交易，批评其每年向莫斯科输送数十亿美元资金。 - [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=0s) 特朗普指出德国前总理担任输气管道公司负责人，认为盟国内部存在严重的不当政商捆绑与战略矛盾。 - [00:43](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=43s) 特朗普声称新管道建成后德国将有60%至70%的能源依赖俄罗斯，使德国沦为俄罗斯的“俘虏”并损害北约安全利益。 - [00:43](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=43s) 特朗普批评德国一边淘汰本国煤电与核电，一边加大对俄能源采购，敦促北约正视并审查该能源项目。 ## Key takeaways - [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=0s) 特朗普在北约峰会开场早餐会上猛烈抨击德国的能源政策，认为这一交易破坏了北约防范俄罗斯威胁的核心宗旨。 - [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=0s) 特朗普点明美国在防务保障上的不对等负担：美国全力保护德国、法国等盟友，盟友却每年向俄罗斯国库输送数十亿美元。 - [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=0s) 特朗普直指德国前总理担任供气管道公司负责人，批评政界高层与俄罗斯能源项目的利益链条极其不妥。 - [00:43](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=43s) 特朗普声称根据协议与规划，德国未来将有近70%的天然气或60%至70%的能源供应完全受控于俄罗斯。 - [00:43](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=43s) 特朗普表示自上任以来便持续就该管道协议提出抗议，坚决认为此类让步从一开始就不应被允许发生。 - [00:43](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=43s) 特朗普直言德国因过度依赖外部能源供应已成为俄罗斯的“俘虏”（captive），失去了地缘战略与经济自主权。 - [00:43](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=43s) 特朗普痛批德国关停本土煤电厂并淘汰核能的能源转型政策，认为自废产能加深了对地缘对手的依赖。 - [00:43](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=43s) 特朗普严正敦促北约组织必须介入并全面审查俄德管道项目，认定该依赖对北约集体安全造成了极其恶劣的负面影响。 ## Detailed walkthrough ### [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=0s) 特朗普抨击德国与俄罗斯的天然气管道交易在布鲁塞尔北约峰会期间的一场气氛紧张的早餐会上，美国总统唐纳德·特朗普对德国及其能源政策发起了猛烈抨击。他开门见山地表达了自己的不满，指出当北约的职责本应是防范俄罗斯威胁时，德国却与俄罗斯达成了巨额石油与天然气协议，每年向莫斯科输送数十亿美元的资金，这种情况令人感到十分可悲。特朗普直接点出其中的巨大矛盾：美国正倾尽全力保护德国、法国以及所有这些盟国，然而德国等多个国家却转头与俄罗斯修建管道，把白花花的数十亿美元直接存入俄罗斯的国库。特朗普对这种防务与经贸严重割裂的现状感到不可理喻，并特别点名了德国政界与该项目的深层关联，直言德国前总理（格哈德·施罗德）如今正是负责供气的管道公司负责人。特朗普情绪激动地向北约领导人抛出质问，指责这一局面在盟友关系中极其不合时宜，并完整阐述了美国在安全保障与盟国资金流向之间的失衡： > “So, we're supposed to protect you against Russia, but they're paying billions of dollars to Russia, and I think that's very inappropriate.”（所以，我们本该保护你们免受俄罗斯的威胁，但他们却向俄罗斯支付数十亿美元，我认为这极其不妥。） - **防务与利益倒错**：特朗普强调美国承担了保卫德国、法国及其他欧洲国家的重担，但盟国却通过巨额管道交易向潜在对手输送资金。 - **利益链条关联**：特朗普特别提到德国前总理亲自掌管负责输送天然气的管道公司（指北溪项目），批评这种政治与商业捆绑极不恰当。 --- ### [00:43](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I&t=43s) “受俄罗斯完全控制”：德国能源转型与北约内部安全隐患特朗普进一步深入到具体数据和能源政策的细节，声称根据现有的能源协议和新管道规划，德国最终将有近 70% 的天然气或 60% 至 70% 的能源供给来自俄罗斯。他表示自自己上任以来就一直在就此提出抗议和抱怨，坚称这种情况原本决不该被允许发生。在特朗普看来，通过对俄罗斯天然气的高度依赖，德国在经济和战略层面上已经失去了自主权，这直接损害了北约整体的安全利益。特朗普还痛批了德国国内的能源转型举措。他指出，德国一方面选择关停本国的煤电厂，逐步淘汰核能发电，另一方面却大幅增加对俄罗斯石油和天然气的采购量，这种自废武功式的政策最终导致自身沦为了地缘政治对手的附庸。特朗普在总结这一局面时直言不讳地断言： > “Now, if you look at it, Germany is a captive of Russia, because they supply They get rid of their coal plants, they get rid of their nuclear.”（现在，如果你仔细观察就会发现，德国成了俄罗斯的俘虏，因为他们供给——德国关掉了自己的煤电厂，淘汰了自己的核能。）他严正敦促北约必须正视并介入审查这一严重问题，再次强调德国依赖俄罗斯能源对于北约联盟是一件非常糟糕的坏事，不仅打破了联盟的战略平衡，而且在安全立场上完全站不住脚。 - **能源依赖预估**：特朗普声称德国将有 60% 到 70% 的能源依靠俄罗斯及新天然气管道供应，这使得德国完全受制于俄罗斯。 - **淘汰煤炭与核电**：德国主动关闭国内的煤电厂与核电设施，转而加深对俄罗斯油气进口的依赖，特朗普认为这让德国彻底沦为俄罗斯的“俘虏”（captive）。 - **北约议程问责**：特朗普强调北约盟国必须全面审视这项管道项目，并表示盟友之间早该认识到这种深度依赖是完全不恰当的。 ## Mentioned 唐纳德·特朗普, 北约, 德国, 俄罗斯, 法国, 格哈德·施罗德, 北溪天然气管道项目, 布鲁塞尔 ## Video description President Donald Trump claimed a pipeline project has made Germany "totally controlled" by and "captive to Russia" during a combative breakfast Wednesday that kicked off what was already expected to be a fraught NATO summit in Brussels. (July 11) Subscribe for more Breaking News: http://smarturl.it/AssociatedPress Get updates and more Breaking News here: http://smarturl.it/APBreakingNews Find the 45th President of the United States Donald Trump's latest press conferences, announcements, speeches and highlights here: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLnwt1fUa-EVgihKJ_26XtMdmGDOmABAAa The Associated Press is the essential global news network, delivering fast, unbiased news from every corner of the world to all media platforms and formats. AP’s commitment to independent, comprehensive journalism has deep roots. Founded in 1846, AP has covered all the major news events of the past 165 years, providing high-quality, informed reporting of everything from wars and elections to championship games and royal weddings. AP is the largest and most trusted source of independent news and information. Today, AP employs the latest technology to collect and distribute content - we have daily uploads covering the latest and breaking news in the world of politics, sport and entertainment. Join us in a conversation about world events, the newsgathering process or whatever aspect of the news universe you find interesting or important. Subscribe: http://smarturl.it/AssociatedPress http://www.ap.org/ https://plus.google.com/+AP/ https://www.facebook.com/APNews https://twitter.com/AP [Source](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLZBVTid4I)

Source quotes

[1:00] Donald Trump: Germany is a captive of Russia, because they supply—they get rid of their coal plants, they get rid of their nuclear.

Original transcript

[0:00] Well, I have to say, I think it's very [0:03] sad when Germany makes a massive oil and [0:06] gas deal with Russia, where you're [0:09] supposed to be guarding against Russia, [0:10] and Germany goes out and pays billions [0:12] and billions of dollars a year to [0:15] Russia. So, we're protecting Germany, [0:17] we're protecting France, we're [0:18] protecting all of these countries, [0:21] and then numerous of the countries go [0:23] out and make a pipeline deal with [0:24] Russia, where they're paying billions of [0:27] dollars into the coffers of Russia. [0:30] So, we're supposed to protect you [0:31] against Russia, but they're paying [0:33] billions of dollars to Russia, and I [0:35] think that's very inappropriate. And the [0:37] former Chancellor of Germany is the head [0:39] of the pipeline company that's supplying [0:41] the gas. [0:43] Ultimately, Germany will have almost 70% [0:47] of their country [0:49] controlled by Russia with natural gas. [0:52] So, you tell me, is that appropriate? I [0:54] mean, we've like been complaining about [0:56] this [0:57] from the time I got in. It should have [0:58] never been allowed to have happened. [1:00] But, Germany is totally controlled by [1:02] Russia, because they will getting from [1:04] 60 to 70% of their energy [1:07] from Russia and a new pipeline. And you [1:09] tell me if that's appropriate, because I [1:11] think it's not, and I think it's a very [1:13] bad thing for NATO, and I don't think it [1:15] should have happened. [1:17] Now, if you look at it, [1:19] Germany is a captive of Russia, because [1:21] they supply They get rid of their coal [1:22] plants, they get rid of their nuclear. [1:25] They're getting so much of the oil and [1:27] gas from Russia. I think it's something [1:30] that NATO has to look at. I think it's [1:31] very inappropriate. You and I agreed [1:33] that it's inappropriate.