Reddit's Ohanian Rebuffs CNN Accusations, Says Site Hosts No Images

tjandthetux

Alexis Ohanian argues platforms cannot police legal speech reflecting human nature, urging media to educate the public that any digitized image is permanently accessible.

AI-assisted summary of Reddit.com co-Founder Alexis Ohanian fires back at CNN and Anderson Cooper — original source. Check the original for full context.

Source published: 2011-10-11

Key ideas

Alexis Ohanian rebuts CNN and Anderson Cooper's coverage of Reddit, asserting that none of the panel members appeared to understand how the platform actually works or had ever visited the site. (0:03)
Ohanian clarifies Reddit's technical infrastructure, emphasizing that the platform does not host user images on its servers and functions strictly as a link aggregator. (1:14)
Addressing content moderation, Ohanian states that while Reddit upholds the law, platforms cannot effectively police distasteful yet legal material because such content reflects broader human nature. (1:14)
Ohanian argues CNN wasted an educational opportunity, suggesting cable news should warn youth that any digital image sent via email, text, or social media must be assumed completely public forever. (1:14)

Detailed notes

## Background This interview was published on YouTube by the channel tjandthetux on October 11, 2011. According to the page description, Reddit co-founder Alexis Ohanian joined TJ and the Tux to respond to Anderson Cooper's recent on-air segment slamming Reddit.

## TL;DR In the interview, Alexis Ohanian responds to a controversial CNN broadcast where Anderson Cooper and a panel accused Reddit of spreading inappropriate and underage content. Ohanian laughs off notions of an organized media conspiracy against the platform, but criticizes the panel for attacking a website none of them appeared to understand or use. He explains that Reddit functions as a link aggregator rather than an image host, operating strictly within legal boundaries while mirroring the broader human condition found across Twitter and the open web. Rather than broadcasting sensationalized outrage, Ohanian argues CNN should have delivered a practical educational message warning young people and parents about digital permanence.

## Atmosphere & style The conversation carries a relaxed, conversational, and slightly sardonic tone, with Ohanian using self-deprecating humor to defuse heavy allegations. Despite the gravity of the accusations, the discussion feels grounded and rational rather than combative, balancing deadpan jokes about Cooper with serious commentary on internet architecture. It leaves listeners with the impression of an exasperated technologist calmly trying to explain the realities of digital media to an entrenched, sensationalist television landscape.

## Bulletin - [00:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=3s) Alexis Ohanian rebuts CNN and Anderson Cooper's coverage of Reddit, asserting that none of the panel members appeared to understand how the platform actually works or had ever visited the site. - [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) Ohanian clarifies Reddit's technical infrastructure, emphasizing that the platform does not host user images on its servers and functions strictly as a link aggregator. - [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) Addressing content moderation, Ohanian states that while Reddit upholds the law, platforms cannot effectively police distasteful yet legal material because such content reflects broader human nature. - [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) Ohanian argues CNN wasted an educational opportunity, suggesting cable news should warn youth that any digital image sent via email, text, or social media must be assumed completely public forever.

## Key takeaways - [00:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=3s) Alexis Ohanian dismisses claims of an organized mainstream media conspiracy against Reddit, remarking that the site is not important enough to warrant such a coordinated plot. - [00:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=3s) A CNN segment led by Anderson Cooper and three pundits framed Reddit as an adversary, reflecting cable news's broader failure to understand open internet platforms. - [00:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=3s) Television commentators frequently misunderstand Reddit despite the platform often showcasing the internet at its absolute best. - [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) Anderson Cooper faced criticism from Ohanian for sensationalizing the controversial 'jailbait' section rather than presenting the technical reality of how content is shared. - [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) Reddit operates solely as a repository of user-submitted links directing users to third-party hosts rather than storing images directly on its own servers. - [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) Critiques regarding inappropriate or offensive links apply equally to open platforms across the wider web, including Twitter. - [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) Platforms have a responsibility to uphold the law, but expecting companies to eradicate all distasteful but legal content is impossible because such material naturally reflects human nature. - [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) CNN missed a vital public service opportunity to educate parents and teenagers on the permanent reality of the digital landscape. - [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) Ohanian emphasizes the core digital rule that any photo converted into digital format—whether via email, MMS, Facebook, or Twitter—must be treated as fully public.

## Detailed walkthrough ### [00:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=3s) Mainstream Media Misconceptions and the CNN Smear Piece

The interviewer asks Alexis Ohanian to characterize Reddit's relationship with mainstream media and whether the platform faces organized detractors who want to see it fail, given that Reddit operates as an open, populist democracy. Ohanian laughs off the notion of a coordinated plot against the site, remarking, “I'd love to think Reddit were important enough to have like a conspiracy against it but I don't think it is.” However, he points to a recent, deeply frustrating smear piece broadcast on CNN. In the segment, Anderson Cooper and a panel of three pundits discussed and condemned Reddit, even though it was apparent none of them had ever actually visited the site or understood its basic mechanics.

Ohanian explains that witnessing influential cable news figures lambaste Reddit without comprehending how it operates was disheartening. The segment treated Reddit as an enemy simply for being a platform for free speech, reflecting widespread misunderstandings about the internet at large. To Ohanian, Reddit frequently showcases the web at its absolute best, making it exasperating to watch a panel of confused television journalists broadcast misinformed criticisms to a massive audience.

- Alexis Ohanian dismisses grand conspiracy theories about media opposition, but highlights pervasive ignorance among television commentators. - The CNN segment featured Anderson Cooper and three pundits criticizing Reddit despite none of them ever having used the platform. - Ohanian emphasizes that the network fundamentally mischaracterized Reddit's identity and its role as an open venue for free expression.

---

[01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) Addressing Anderson Cooper's Allegations and Digital Permanence

The host presses Ohanian on Anderson Cooper's specific allegation: that Reddit was effectively peddling child pornography through communities like the controversial "jailbait" section, which featured suggestive, non-nude photos of supposedly underage girls. Ohanian breaks the tension with a deadpan joke about Cooper, quipping, “I wish I'd been invited Anderson just to stare into those blue eyes would have been lovely.” Pivoting to the actual mechanics of the site, Ohanian clarifies that Reddit does not host any user images; rather, it functions solely as a repository of user-submitted links directing traffic elsewhere on the web.

Ohanian argues that this exact indictment could be leveled against Twitter or the broader web, where accounts share garbage, vitriol, and inappropriate content every day as an inevitable reflection of human nature. Society cannot expect platforms to scrub away everything distasteful: “As long we obviously uphold the law as long as what's going on is legal there is nothing we can do to effectively police it because these things will always continue to exist on the internet because they'll always continue to exist in humanity.” The host interjects that even members of Congress and upstanding citizens engage in questionable online behavior, underlining Ohanian's point.

```mermaid flowchart TD accTitle: Content Distribution vs Platform Role accDescr: Diagram contrasting third-party content hosting with Reddit's link indexing and the reality of digital permanence.

subgraph Origin["Web & User Activity"] A["Third-Party Web Hosts / Image Sites"] B["User-Submitted Images (Email, MMS, Social Media)"] end

subgraph Aggregation["Link Aggregation Platforms"] C["Reddit (Link Repository)"] D["Twitter (Public Feeds)"] end

subgraph LegalBoundary["Platform Scope & Responsibility"] E{"Is Content Legal?"} F["Uphold Law / Remove Illegal Material"] G["Cannot Police Legal but Distasteful Content"] end

subgraph Reality["The Digital Rule"] H["Once Digitized, Assume Content is Public Everywhere"] end

A --> C A --> D C --> E D --> E E -->|"No"| F E -->|"Yes"| G B --> H ```

Rather than squandering two minutes on sensationalized outrage, Ohanian insists CNN missed an opportunity to deliver real public education. The network should have used its platform to warn parents and teenagers about the permanent nature of the digital world. Whenever young people put a photo into digital form—whether sending it in a private email, a direct MMS text, Facebook, or a tweet—they must assume that image is now public and accessible everywhere. Ohanian concludes that delivering this critical privacy warning would have been a far more responsible use of airtime than inventing what he describes as sensationalized "jibber jabber" about Reddit.

- Reddit operates strictly as a link aggregator, hosting no image content on its own servers. - The platform adheres strictly to the law; while illegal material is removed, legal online expression cannot realistically be micromanaged away from the human condition. - The proposed educational message for CNN: once an image is created in digital format (via email, MMS, Facebook, or Twitter), it should be treated as entirely public.

## Notable quotes > [00:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=3s) I'd love to think Reddit were important enough to have like a conspiracy against it but I don't think it is. — Alexis Ohanian

## Mentioned Alexis Ohanian, Anderson Cooper, CNN, Reddit, TJ and the Tux, Twitter, Facebook, United States Congress

## Video description Alexis Ohanian, co-founder of the 1 billion pageviews a month serving news engine known as Reddit, spoke with TJ and the Tux about Anderson Cooper's recent on-air rant slamming his site. Hear the full interview at: http://tjandthetux.com

@tjanthetux @reddit @kn0thing @andersoncooper @cnn

http://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/kw0cc/anderson_cooper_accuses_reddit_of_spreading_child/

[Source](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE)

中文简报

Reddit联合创始人奥哈尼安反驳CNN指控，称网站不存储图片亚历克西斯·奥哈尼安认为平台无法监管反映人性的合法言论，并敦促媒体教育公众：任何数字化的图片都将永久可被访问。在采访中，亚历克西斯·奥哈尼安对CNN的一档争议节目作出回应；该节目中安德森·库珀及嘉宾小组指责Reddit传播不当和未成年人内容。奥哈尼安对所谓媒体针对该平台存在有组织阴谋的说法一笑了之，但批评该小组攻击了一个似乎无人理解或使用过的网站。他解释称，Reddit是一个链接聚合平台而非图片托管网站，在严格遵守法律界限的同时，也映射了Twitter和开放网络上普遍存在的人性百态。奥哈尼安认为，CNN不应播出耸人听闻的愤怒言论，而应传递切实的教育信息，告诫年轻人和家长数字信息的永久性。亚历克西斯·奥哈尼安反驳了CNN及安德森·库珀对Reddit的报道，坚称小组中似乎没有任何人了解该平台的实际运作方式，也从未访问过该网站。 (0:03) 奥哈尼安澄清了Reddit的技术架构，强调该平台并不在自身服务器上托管用户图片，其功能严格属于链接聚合器。 (1:14) 在谈及内容审核时，奥哈尼安表示，尽管Reddit恪守法律，但平台无法有效监管令人反感却合法的材料，因为此类内容反映了更广泛的人性。 (1:14) 奥哈尼安认为CNN浪费了一次教育机会，指出有线新闻理应告诫年轻人：任何通过电子邮件、短信或社交媒体发送的数字图片，都必须被视为永久完全公开。 (1:14)

Detailed notes — zh

## Background 该视频由 YouTube 频道 tjandthetux 于 2011 年 10 月 11 日发布。视频内容源于 TJ and the Tux 对月浏览量达 10 亿的新闻引擎 Reddit 联合创始人亚历克西斯·奥哈尼安（Alexis Ohanian）的访谈，旨在针对 CNN 主播安德森·库珀（Anderson Cooper）此前在节目中抨击 Reddit 的言论进行公开回应与反驳。 ## TL;DR 奥哈尼安在访谈中驳斥了主流媒体对 Reddit 的误导性指控，指出 CNN 的安德森·库珀及嘉宾在完全未用过该网站的情况下就对其妄加评论。他强调 Reddit 本质上只是用户提交外部链接的聚合平台，并不在自身服务器上托管相关争议图片，与 Twitter 等社交网络并无二致。最后，奥哈尼安呼吁媒体与其盲目制造恐慌，不如切实提醒公众与家长：任何数字化的图片一旦发出就应被视为完全公开且无法收回。 ## Atmosphere & style 整个访谈流露出一种既幽默自嘲又尖锐克制的氛围，奥哈尼安以轻快的语调打趣库珀的“迷人蓝眼睛”和假想中的阴谋论，但切入核心事实时则显得冷静而专业。面对主流传统媒体对互联网逻辑的无知与偏见，他毫不掩饰内心的沮丧与荒谬感，对话在揭示电视媒体脱节现实的荒诞之余，最终落脚于对数字时代隐私安全的严正提醒。 ## Bulletin - [00:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=3s) Reddit 联合创始人亚历克西斯·奥哈尼安回应 CNN 针对平台的指责，指出主播安德森·库珀及其嘉宾对 Reddit 的实际运作机制毫无了解，批评主流媒体脱离网络产品现实。 - [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) 针对传播不良内容的指控，奥哈尼安澄清 Reddit 本质上是用户提交外部链接的聚合器，本身不托管任何争议图片或多媒体内容。 - [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) 奥哈尼安呼吁主流媒体利用黄金时间普及数字安全常识，警告公众和未成年人一旦图片数字化并发出，就必须默认其已对全网公开且无法撤回。 ## Key takeaways - [00:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=3s) 奥哈尼安幽默回应主流媒体是否存在反 Reddit 阴谋，认为网站目前尚未重要到引来系统性阴谋对抗的程度。 - [00:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=3s) CNN 主播安德森·库珀及节目嘉宾在从未实际访问或使用过 Reddit 的情况下，在有线电视新闻中对平台进行抨击。 - [00:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=3s) 主流电视评论员对网络产品逻辑及底层运行机制缺乏基础认知，导致公众对互联网的开放与民主属性产生误解。 - [00:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=3s) 奥哈尼安强调 Reddit 展现了互联网开放、互联与民主的积极一面，主流媒体的指责暴露出认知脱节。 - [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) 针对传播争议未成年人照片的指责，奥哈尼安从技术和法律层面澄清 Reddit 仅是外部链接聚合器，而非内容托管服务器。 - [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) Twitter 等其他大型社交平台同样存在指向不良或垃圾内容的链接，这是人性丑陋面的投射而非单一平台特有现象。 - [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) 在遵守现有法律框架的前提下，任何开放式社交平台都无法单方面根除所有源于人性的负面或低俗内容。 - [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) 媒体黄金时间应致力于公众数字素养教育，而非制造空洞的恐慌与无端攻击。 - [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) 家庭数字安全的关键准则是建立防范意识：任何照片无论通过邮件、推特、Facebook 还是 MMS 发送，一旦数字化即视同永久公开。 ## Detailed walkthrough ### [00:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=3s) 主流媒体的偏见与 CNN 的误导性报道主持人首先询问 Reddit 与主流媒体的关系，并提出是否存在不希望看到 Reddit 成功的反对者，毕竟在外界看来，Reddit 就像是一个极其开放、属于人民的民主平台。联合创始人亚历克西斯·奥哈尼安（Alexis Ohanian）幽默地回应称，他很希望 Reddit 已经重要到足以引来某种阴谋反对它，但现实并非如此。然而，他提到了近期 CNN 针对 Reddit 播出的抹黑报道，令他感到十分沮丧。在这期节目中，主播安德森·库珀（Anderson Cooper）以及连线的嘉宾没有一个人真正访问过 Reddit，他们对网站的实际运作机制一无所知，却在一个极具影响力的有线新闻频道上大放厥词。奥哈尼安指出，几位电视评论员在完全不懂网络产品逻辑的情况下，公然抨击一个本质上是言论自由平台的网站，这种现象令人心寒。他认为公众对整个互联网原本就存在大量误解，而 Reddit 展现了互联网最好的一面——开放、互联与民主。看着这群困惑的记者对着自己根本不理解的事物大加指责，奥哈尼安感到既荒谬又无奈。 > “I'd love to think Reddit were important enough to have like a conspiracy against it, but I don't think it is.” —— 亚历克西斯·奥哈尼安 --- ### [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) 平台属性的辩护与数字时代的真正警告针对安德森·库珀在节目中直接指责 Reddit 传播儿童色情（源于当时网站上存在的诸如争议子版块 /r/jailbait 的链接，内容多为衣着完整的未成年女孩照片），奥哈尼安首先开玩笑说真希望自己当时能被邀请上节目，好有机会凝视库珀“那双迷人的蓝眼睛”。随后他严肃阐明了核心的技术与法律事实：Reddit 本身并不托管任何此类图片或多媒体内容，它纯粹是一个由用户提交、指向互联网其他站点的链接聚合器。 ```mermaid flowchart TD accTitle: Reddit 内容传播逻辑对比 accDescr: 对比 Reddit 作为链接聚合器与内容托管服务器的区别 subgraph 平台架构区分 U["用户提交"] --> R["Reddit 平台<br/>（仅作为链接聚合器）"] R -.->|"外部链接指引"| OS["第三方外部网站<br/>（实际托管内容/服务器）"] end subgraph 监管现实 T["Twitter / 其他社交网络"] --> OS L{"合法合规底线"} -->|"在法律范围内"| R end ``` 奥哈尼安强调，同样的指控完全可以直接套用在 Twitter 等其他社交平台上。Twitter 上每天同样充斥着指向互联网垃圾内容、恶意言论甚至低俗材料的链接，这种现象之所以存在，是因为它们本身就是人性丑陋面的一部分，甚至连国会议员或所谓体面的社会人士都会卷入其中。只要内容在法律允许的范围内，平台在严格守法的前提下根本无法完全杜绝这种人性的投射。奥哈尼安认为，CNN 本可以用这短短一两分钟的有线电视黄金时间做一些真正有益的公众科普，而不是制造空洞的胡言乱语。与其攻击 Reddit，媒体更应该告诫天下的父母：必须让孩子们明白，一旦任何照片被数字化——无论是发邮件给一个人、发推特、发在 Facebook 上还是通过彩信（MMS）发送——就必须默认它已经彻底公之于众，且永远无法收回。 > “All Reddit is a repository of links submitted by users that go to other sites on the internet.” —— 亚历克西斯·奥哈尼安 > “Your kids need to know that anytime they take an image and put it in a digital format whether it is an email to one person whether it's in a tweet whether it's on Facebook whether it is an MMS they should assume that it is now public content they should it is everywhere.” —— 亚历克西斯·奥哈尼安 - **CNN 评论员认知脱节**：参与该期节目的安德森·库珀及其三位现场嘉宾此前均未使用过 Reddit，对链接聚合与底层服务器托管的区别毫无概念。 - **与主流平台的对比**：Twitter 等平台同样充斥着大量指向不良内容的外部链接，奥哈尼安指出技术平台无法单方面审查所有源于人性的阴暗信息。 - **家庭数字安全建议**：奥哈尼安建议家长教育孩子建立“数字化即公开”的安全意识，防范隐私泄露。 ## Notable quotes > [00:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=3s) I'd love to think Reddit were important enough to have like a conspiracy against it, but I don't think it is. — 亚历克西斯·奥哈尼安 > [01:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE&t=74s) All Reddit is a repository of links submitted by users that go to other sites on the internet. — 亚历克西斯·奥哈尼安 ## Mentioned Reddit, 亚历克西斯·奥哈尼安 (Alexis Ohanian), 安德森·库珀 (Anderson Cooper), CNN, Twitter, Facebook, TJ and the Tux, /r/jailbait ## Video description Alexis Ohanian, co-founder of the 1 billion pageviews a month serving news engine known as Reddit, spoke with TJ and the Tux about Anderson Cooper's recent on-air rant slamming his site. Hear the full interview at: http://tjandthetux.com @tjanthetux @reddit @kn0thing @andersoncooper @cnn http://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/kw0cc/anderson_cooper_accuses_reddit_of_spreading_child/ [Source](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXZYvrue1BE)

Source quotes

[0:03] 亚历克西斯·奥哈尼安: I'd love to think Reddit were important enough to have like a conspiracy against it, but I don't think it is. [1:14] 亚历克西斯·奥哈尼安: All Reddit is a repository of links submitted by users that go to other sites on the internet.

Source quotes

[0:03] Alexis Ohanian: I'd love to think Reddit were important enough to have like a conspiracy against it but I don't think it is.

Original transcript

[0:03] I mean like well first first describe [0:05] the relationship more with the [0:06] mainstream media and are there any [0:08] detractors are there any people that [0:10] don't like Reddit I mean it seems like a [0:13] very wide open like for the people [0:14] democracy you mentioned I mean are there [0:16] people that don't want to see succeed [0:18] and who are these people if so well I [0:20] don't all right so I don't think there [0:21] is like a i' I'd love to think Reddit [0:24] were important enough to have like a [0:25] conspiracy against it but I don't think [0:27] it is um but there was recently this [0:30] really frustrating smear piece on CNN uh [0:32] about Reddit and Anderson Cooper and his [0:34] guests none of whom had actually been to [0:36] the site before which was a little [0:38] disheartening because it was clear that [0:40] none of them actually knew how it worked [0:42] and it was it was a little frustrating [0:43] because you hear three pundits on a [0:45] fairly influential Cable News Network [0:47] talking about something they don't at [0:49] all understand uh and lambasting it [0:51] basically for being a platform for uh [0:54] free speech um but it was just [0:56] frustrating [0:57] because there are a lot of [0:59] misconceptions about the internet as a [1:01] whole and I feel like Reddit represents [1:04] a lot of the internet at its best and so [1:07] to see this piece about a bunch of [1:08] confused journalists talking about [1:10] something they didn't really understand [1:11] criticizing something that was yeah [1:14] anyway well I mean specifically Anderson [1:17] Cooper basically accused you guys of [1:19] pedaling child porphy because if there's [1:21] a stream for for uh jail bait or [1:23] whatever which was young girls not naked [1:26] but whatever supposedly underage I mean [1:28] what do you have to say to people [1:29] Anderson Cooper the I and I wish I wish [1:32] I'd been invited Anderson just to stare [1:34] into those blue eyes would have been [1:36] lovely um so here's the thing Reddit [1:40] does not actually host any of this [1:41] content all Reddit is a is a repository [1:44] of links submitted by users that go to [1:47] other sites on the internet [1:49] now I could make the exact same [1:52] indictment of Twitter there are Twitter [1:53] accounts right now that are just links [1:56] to the same garbage and the same [1:58] nonsense and all kinds of vital and all [2:00] kinds of things on the internet that [2:01] exist because they are a part of human [2:03] nature unfortunately and we got [2:06] congressmen doing them I [2:08] mean got upstanding citizens of the of [2:11] society doing these and and [2:13] unfortunately there is no just like [2:15] Twitter can't police this stuff there's [2:17] no mechanism to really as long we [2:19] obviously uphold the law as long as [2:21] what's going on is legal there is [2:23] nothing we can do to effectively police [2:25] it because these things will always [2:26] continue to exist on the internet [2:28] because they'll always continue to exist [2:29] in humanity and what would be a more [2:31] interesting discussion what would have [2:32] been a so much more useful use of that [2:36] minute and a half or 2 minutes would [2:37] have been to tell parents all the [2:39] mothers and fathers out there that your [2:41] kids need to know that anytime they take [2:44] an image and put it in a digital format [2:46] whether it is an email to one person [2:49] whether it's in a tweet whether it's on [2:50] Facebook whether it is an MMS they [2:53] should assume that it is now public [2:54] content they should it is everywhere and [2:57] and that's the warning that parents need [2:58] to do uh need to be giv to their kids [3:00] and that's the useful thing I think Cena [3:03] and could have reported on instead of [3:04] making up a bunch of jibber jabber about [3:07] uh Reddit