Officer Philip Brailsford Shoots Daniel Shaver in Hotel Hallway

Body-Cam Video Of Daniel Shaver Shooting | Los Angeles Times — Los Angeles Times

Los Angeles Times

Officer Philip Brailsford shot Daniel Shaver after police issued physically contradictory commands to crawl forward while keeping his hands elevated.

AI-assisted summary of Body-Cam Video Of Daniel Shaver Shooting | Los Angeles Times — original source. Check the original for full context.

Source published:

Key ideas

  • Daniel Shaver was fatally shot five times with an AR-15 rifle by Arizona police officer Philip Mitchell Brailsford in a hotel hallway on January 18, 2016. (0:03)
  • The commanding officer established an intensely hostile environment, explicitly warning Shaver that any mistake or failure to follow instructions would likely result in him being shot. (0:11)
  • During the high-stress encounter, Shaver was given physically contradictory commands, including being ordered to keep his hands in the air while simultaneously being told to crawl forward. (3:16)
  • Officer Brailsford opened fire when Shaver, weeping and terrified, instinctively reached toward his waistband to pull up his slipping shorts while crawling. (3:16)

Detailed notes

## Background This video was published on YouTube by the Los Angeles Times on December 8, 2017. The description notes that the graphic body-cam footage depicts the fatal shooting of Daniel Shaver by Arizona police officer Philip Mitchell Brailsford in a hotel hallway, shared following Brailsford's acquittal of murder charges.

## TL;DR The footage documents a highly volatile police encounter in a hotel hallway where officers confront Daniel Shaver and a female companion. After detaining the woman, the commanding officer issues a series of aggressive, physically contradictory commands to Shaver under the constant threat of lethal force. Terrified and weeping, Shaver attempts to comply by crawling forward on the floor. When his hand instinctively reaches toward his waistband to pull up his slipping shorts, Officer Philip Brailsford fires five rounds from his AR-15 rifle, killing him.

## Atmosphere & style The atmosphere of the video is intensely hostile, chaotic, and terrifying, driven by the commanding officer's aggressive shouting and uncompromising demands. Watching the footage evokes a profound sense of dread as Shaver's desperate, tearful pleas for compliance contrast sharply with the rigid, high-stakes pressure of the police. The emotional arc builds with agonizing tension, culminating in a sudden and devastating burst of lethal violence.

## Bulletin - [00:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=3s) Daniel Shaver was fatally shot five times with an AR-15 rifle by Arizona police officer Philip Mitchell Brailsford in a hotel hallway on January 18, 2016. - [00:11](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=11s) The commanding officer established an intensely hostile environment, explicitly warning Shaver that any mistake or failure to follow instructions would likely result in him being shot. - [03:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=196s) During the high-stress encounter, Shaver was given physically contradictory commands, including being ordered to keep his hands in the air while simultaneously being told to crawl forward. - [03:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=196s) Officer Brailsford opened fire when Shaver, weeping and terrified, instinctively reached toward his waistband to pull up his slipping shorts while crawling.

## Key takeaways - [00:11](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=11s) Officers confront Daniel Shaver and a female companion in a hotel hallway, immediately ordering them face down onto the carpet. - [00:11](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=11s) The commanding officer establishes a highly punitive tone, warning that any mistake will carry a very severe possibility of being shot. - [00:11](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=11s) The officer aggressively silences Shaver's attempts to explain his situation, demanding absolute obedience and suspending standard courtesy. - [00:11](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=11s) Shaver is ordered to interlace his fingers on top of his head and cross his left foot over his right foot while lying prone. - [01:41](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=101s) The officers first focus on detaining the female companion, ordering her to rise to her knees and crawl down the hallway toward them. - [01:41](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=101s) The female companion is successfully secured in handcuffs and cleared from the immediate line of fire. - [03:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=196s) The officer turns his attention back to Shaver, warning him not to make a mistake as he prepares to move him. - [03:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=196s) When Shaver's legs separate while trying to kneel, the sergeant angrily threatens to shoot him if it happens again. - [03:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=196s) A terrified and trembling Shaver pleads for his life, but the officer shouts over him to listen to instructions. - [03:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=196s) The sergeant issues contradictory demands, ordering Shaver to keep his hands straight up in the air but also to crawl toward the officers. - [03:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=196s) Shaver is warned that if he falls, he must fall directly onto his face rather than reaching down to brace himself. - [03:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=196s) While weeping and crawling forward, Shaver's shorts begin to slip down, prompting him to instinctively reach toward his waistband. - [03:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=196s) Officer Philip Brailsford fires five rounds from his AR-15 rifle at close range, fatally shooting Shaver in the hallway.

## Detailed walkthrough ### [00:11](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=11s) Initial Confrontation and Warnings in the Hallway

Officers confront Daniel Shaver and a female companion outside their hotel room door, immediately ordering them face down onto the hallway carpet. When the commanding officer demands to know who else remains inside the room, Shaver insists that no one else is present. Sensing hesitation or confusion, the sergeant cuts off any further explanation with sharp hostility, asserting that the subjects have already demonstrated an inability to follow basic directions. He establishes an intensely punitive environment, laying out strict ground rules and warning that any deviation will result in lethal force: “If you make a mistake, another mistake, there's a very severe possibility you're going to get shot. Do you understand?”

When Shaver attempts to respond or clarify his situation, the officer aggressively silences him, making it clear that standard conversational courtesy is suspended: “Shut up! I'm not here to be tactful and diplomatic with you. You listen, you obey.” The officer instructs Shaver to place both hands on top of his head with fingers interlaced and to cross his left foot over his right foot while lying prone. After confirming that no one else is in the room, the officer asks if both individuals are sober, demanding that they look directly down into the carpet and warning that any movement whatsoever will be interpreted as a deadly threat that they might not survive.

[01:41](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=101s) Detaining the Female Companion

The commanding officer directs his attention to the woman, ordering Shaver to remain completely motionless with his eyes fixed on the floor while she is brought forward. Addressing the woman, the officer reiterates that she must not speak, instructing her to maintain crossed feet, place her palms flat on the carpet, push herself up into a kneeling position, and raise both hands high into the air.

Once upright on her knees, she is commanded to crawl down the carpeted hallway toward the officers' position. The camera records her slowly crawling past the hotel room doors until she reaches the officers at the threshold of the hallway corner. The officers direct her to move toward them, quickly taking hold of her, conducting a pat-down, and securing her in handcuffs before clearing her from the immediate line of fire.

[03:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc&t=196s) Conflicting Commands, Escalation, and Fatal Shooting

With the woman secured, the officer turns his attention back to Daniel Shaver, ordering him to undergo the same sequence while remaining under the immediate threat of gunfire: “Young man, listen to my instructions and do not make a mistake.” Shaver is ordered to keep his legs crossed, place his hands flat on the floor, and push up to a kneeling position. As Shaver attempts to maneuver his body upright, his legs separate, prompting an immediate shout of anger from the sergeant, who warns, “If you do that again, we're shooting you, do you understand?” Visibly terrified and trembling, Shaver pleads for his life, but the officer shouts over him: “Listen to my instructions! Don't talk, listen!”

The sergeant then issues a series of physically contradictory demands. He orders Shaver to raise his hands straight up into the air and warns that if he falls, he must fall directly onto his face rather than brace himself: “Your hands go back in the small of your back or down, we are going to shoot you. Do you understand me?” Immediately following the command to keep his hands straight up in the air, the officer shouts, “Crawl towards me!” Weeping and begging, Shaver attempts to crawl down the hallway on his hands and knees. As his shorts slip down and his right hand instinctively reaches toward his waistband to hitch them up, Officer Philip Brailsford discharges five rounds from his AR-15 rifle at close range, fatally wounding Shaver in the hallway.

- Commands given to Shaver required keeping his hands elevated in the air while simultaneously crawling on the floor. - Shaver was explicitly warned that moving his hands toward his waistband or small of his back would result in officers opening fire. - Officer Philip Brailsford opened fire as Shaver reached toward his waistband while crawling forward.

## Mentioned Daniel Shaver, Philip Mitchell Brailsford, Los Angeles Times, Chicago Tribune, Arizona police, AR-15

## Video description GRAPHIC FOOTAGE: Daniel Shaver was fatally shot by Arizona police on Jan. 18, 2016, in the hallway of the hotel where he was staying. Philip Mitchell Brailsford, the officer who killed Shaver, was acquitted of murder charges on Dec. 7, 2017. Story: http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/ct-daniel-shaver-police-video-20171208-story.html

SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE VIDEOS AND NEWS http://www.youtube.com/subscription_center?add_user=losangelestimes

LET'S CONNECT: Google+ ► https://plus.google.com/+latimes Facebook ► https://www.facebook.com/latimes Twitter ► https://twitter.com/LATimes L.A. Times ► http://www.latimes.com/

[Source](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBUUx0jUKxc)

中文简报

警官菲利普·布雷斯福德在酒店走廊开枪打死丹尼尔·沙弗 在警方发出既要求向前爬行又要求举起双手这一自相矛盾的指令后，警官菲利普·布雷斯福德开枪打死了丹尼尔·沙弗。 现场录像记录了酒店走廊内一次极度紧张的警民对峙，警官在现场与丹尼尔·沙弗及其一名女性同伴对峙。在控制住该女子后，指挥警官在持续的致命武力威胁下，向沙弗发出了一系列极具攻击性且自相矛盾的指令。极度恐惧并哭泣的沙弗试图照做，在地上向前爬行。当他的手本能地伸向腰带试图提上滑落的短裤时，警官菲利普·布雷斯福德用AR-15步枪连开五枪将其击毙。 2016年1月18日，在一家酒店的走廊里，亚利桑那州警官菲利普·米切尔·布雷斯福德使用AR-15步枪连开五枪，将丹尼尔·沙弗当场打死。 (0:03) 现场指挥警官营造了极具敌意的环境，并明确警告沙弗，任何失误或未能遵从指令的行为都极可能导致他被开枪击中。 (0:11) 在这场高压对峙中，沙弗收到了在肢体动作上自相矛盾的指令，包括被要求在双手举在空中的同时向前爬行。 (3:16) 当哭泣且极度恐惧的沙弗在爬行过程中本能地伸手摸向腰带以提上滑落的短裤时，警官布雷斯福德开枪射击。 (3:16)

Reading summary

Body-camera footage published by the Los Angeles Times documents the fatal police shooting of Daniel Shaver, illustrating how severe verbal escalation and physically contradictory police orders culminated in lethal gunfire. Punitive Escalation and Lethal Threats (0:11) From the initial moments outside the hotel room, the commanding officer established an intensely punitive environment, cutting off Shaver's explanations and preemptively threatening lethal force. Shaver and his companion were ordered face down onto the hallway carpet, with the officer declaring that standard diplomatic courtesy was suspended. Insisting that the pair had already shown an inability to follow directions, the sergeant explicitly warned that any further error carried a 'very severe possibility' of being shot. To enforce total submission, the officer commanded Shaver to remain prone, interlace his fingers atop his head, cross his feet, and look directly into the carpet. Shaver was warned that any movement would be treated as an immediate deadly threat that he might not survive, setting a zero-tolerance standard for subsequent physical movements. The Controlled Detainment Protocol (1:41) Officers first applied their compliance sequence to Shaver's female companion, demonstrating the rigid procedural expectations required by the commanding officer. Ordered not to speak, she was directed to keep her feet crossed, place her palms on the carpet, elevate into a kneeling position, and raise her hands high into the air. While Shaver remained motionless on the floor under armed cover, the woman was instructed to crawl forward along the hallway to the officers' threshold. Upon reaching them, she was taken into custody, searched, handcuffed, and removed from the hallway, establishing the exact movement pattern the officers subsequently demanded of Shaver. Contradictory Commands and Lethal Rifle Fire (3:16) The encounter turned fatal when officers subjected Shaver to rapid, conflicting instructions under the continued threat of gunfire. When Shaver's legs separated as he attempted to kneel, the sergeant shouted that he would be shot if it happened again, ignoring Shaver's terrified, tearful pleas to listen. The officer then ordered Shaver to keep his hands held straight up in the air, explicitly warning that reaching down or toward the small of his back would result in officers opening fire, and demanding that he fall directly onto his face if he lost balance. Immediately after commanding Shaver to keep his hands raised high, the officer shouted at him to crawl forward. As Shaver wept and attempted to crawl down the carpeted hallway on his hands and knees, his shorts slipped down. When Shaver's right hand instinctively moved toward his waistband to hitch up his clothing, Officer Philip Brailsford fired five rounds from an AR-15 rifle at close range, fatally wounding him. The video highlights the lethal consequences of issuing mutually exclusive commands—requiring a suspect to keep his hands raised in the air while simultaneously crawling on the floor—under explicit warnings that lowering his hands would trigger deadly force.

精炼阅读摘要

洛杉矶时报（Los Angeles Times）发布的随身摄像机记录显示，警员在酒店走廊对 Daniel Shaver 发出一系列极度严苛且自相矛盾的肢体指令，最终警员 Philip Brailsford 在其爬行拉提裤腰时连开五枪将其击毙。 高压恐吓与惩罚性指令环境 (0:11) 现场指挥警官在酒店走廊将 Daniel Shaver 及其女性同伴制服在地后，立即确立了极其敌对和惩罚性的沟通基调。当 Shaver 试图回应或澄清房间内是否还有他人时，该警官严厉打断并警告两人已表现出无法遵守基本指令的情况，明确表示标准的外交辞令与礼貌已被暂停，直接发出“闭嘴！听从并服从”的斥责。警官向当事人施加了极端的致命武力威胁，声称只要出现任何差错，就有极大概率遭到枪击，并要求两人将双手抱头十指交叉、双脚交叉俯卧，视线必须死死盯住地毯，任何多余动作都会被视作致命威胁。 同伴拘留与危险命令的推进 (1:41) 在控制局面的过程中，警方先行拘留了同行的女性。指挥警官命令 Shaver 保持绝对静止并将视线固定在地面，随后要求该女性在保持双脚交叉的同时将手掌平放在地，推起身体转为跪姿并将双手高举过头。在女性按要求完成跪姿后，警员命令她沿着铺有地毯的走廊向警方掩体位置爬行。该女性最终爬过走廊拐角处的警员面前，被警方控制、搜身并戴上手铐，顺利脱离了直接交火线，随后警方将注意力全部转回到 Shaver 身上。 矛盾要求与致命开火事件 (3:16) 对 Shaver 执行拘留程序时，警官施加的要求演变出严重的身体控制冲突。警官先要求 Shaver 双腿交叉并用手推地跪起，当 Shaver 在起身过程中双腿分开时，警官立即愤怒威胁若再犯就会开枪，甚至要求他在跌倒时必须直接面朝下摔倒而绝不能用手支撑。随后，警官在警告双手伸向腰部或背后就会被射杀的同时，发出了“双手高举朝天”与“朝我爬过来”互相抵触的口头命令。惊恐哭泣的 Shaver 在手膝着地爬行时，其短裤滑落，右手下意识提拉腰带，警员 Philip Brailsford 随即使用 AR-15 步枪近距离连开五枪，导致 Shaver 当场死亡。 该随身摄像机记录呈现了从严苛言语控制迅速升级为致命武力使用的全过程，突显了警务战术指令在缺乏可行性与自相矛盾时所产生的致命后果。

Original transcript

[0:11] both of you lay down on the ground lay [0:14] down on the ground who else is in the [0:19] room nobody nobody else is in the room [0:22] really awesome nobody that I was looted [0:24] positive okay since apparently we have a [0:28] failure for you to comprehend simple [0:30] instructions I'm going to go over some [0:31] of them again [0:32] okay can you both hear an understanding [0:34] yeah alright if you make a mistake [0:38] another mistake there's a very severe [0:41] possibility you're going to get shot do [0:43] you understand yes all right what this [0:47] is shut up I'm not here to be tactful [0:51] diplomatic with you you listen you obey [0:55] for one things I tell you to move young [0:58] man they tell you to put both our hands [1:02] we're both your hands on the top of your [1:05] head and interlace your fingers take [1:08] your feet and cross your left foot over [1:11] your right foot who else is in the room [1:16] nobody [1:30] are you both strong all right so you're [1:36] not going to have any problems [1:38] understanding anything that I tell you [1:40] right great [1:41] all right no you're not going to end if [1:46] I come towards us young man you're not [1:50] to move you're to put your eyes down and [1:52] look down with the carpet you're to keep [1:54] your fingers interlaced behind your head [1:56] you're to keep your feet crossed [1:58] if you move we're going to consider that [2:01] a threat and we are going to deal with [2:03] it and you may not survive do you [2:05] understand me this young lady shut up [2:08] and listen [2:10] right you are to keep your feet crossed [2:13] take both of your hands put them flat in [2:16] front of you you are to push yourself up [2:20] to a kneeling position kneeling position [2:26] now put both your hands in the air [2:30] okay crawl towards us [2:49] no rich poll this way let me know when [2:57] you're clear now we're here Chris [3:00] Turkish hey were you doing that labor [3:09] flat okay I need one more Cup row okay [3:16] this is a joke I'm going to do almost [3:18] like we did before okay young man listen [3:24] to my instructions and do not make a [3:26] mistake you are to keep your legs across [3:30] do you understand me you are to put both [3:34] of your hands palm down straight out in [3:37] front of you push yourself up to a [3:40] kneeling position I said keep your legs [3:44] crossed I didn't say to the conversation [3:55] you knew then again we're shooting you [3:57] do you understand listen to my [4:01] instructions don't talk listen [4:04] hands straight up in the air do not put [4:08] your hands down for any reason you think [4:10] you're gonna fall you're gonna fall on [4:11] your face your hands will make in the [4:13] small your bag or duck we are going to [4:15] shoot you do you understand me crawl [4:19] towards me towards me [4:33] [Music] [4:34] okay hold on him one with me key car key [4:48] car key car same anyone [4:52] [Music] [4:59] I gave you two