Apple Music on Mac Drops Basic OS Features, Traps Users in UI Loops

Your Product Sucks

Apple shipped an unpolished desktop application that abandons decades of core Mac conventions like drag-and-drop and navigation history while trapping paying subscribers in looping interface errors.

AI-assisted summary of Your Product Sucks — Apple Music macOS review — original source. Check the original for full context.

Source published: 2020-10-30

Key ideas

The Music app on macOS Catalina suffers from critical playback loops, where attempting to play tracks without an active subscription causes unhandled errors that continuously cycle through playlists instead of halting. (0:01)
Core desktop usability patterns are broken, including the complete absence of drag-and-drop support for adding songs to playlists and a navigation stack that drops back buttons or traps users in loops. (7:16)
Basic visual synchronization fails across the application, leaving sidebar selections mismatched with the content displayed in the main window. (12:37)
Despite Apple's immense resources, the host criticizes the company for shipping what feels like an unpolished internal developer build as a public stable release for paying customers. (16:48)

Detailed notes

## Background This review was published on YouTube by the channel 'Your Product Sucks' on October 30, 2020. The video description concisely summarizes the content by noting that the Apple Music app on macOS Catalina is 'not so great.'

## TL;DR The host documents his deep frustration with the desktop Apple Music app on macOS Catalina, demonstrating on camera why he considers the software fundamentally broken and unusable. After re-subscribing for $10 just to show its flaws, he encounters infinite playback error loops, broken billing entry points, and onboarding screens that reset unexpectedly. Across his testing, fundamental desktop features fail entirely: navigation history vanishes, drag-and-drop does not work, contextual menus display contradictory options, and the playback queue interface creates persistent confusion. He concludes that shipping software in such an unpolished, buggy state to paying customers is inexcusable for the wealthiest tech company in the world.

## Atmosphere & style The video carries an exasperated, darkly comedic tone, driven by the host's disbelief that basic operating system standards have been utterly abandoned. What starts as a measured critique quickly turns into an emotional, unhinged journey through UI hell, where every click unearths a new bug or dead end. Watching the host cycle between biting sarcasm, pure bewilderment, and genuine exasperation creates a palpable feeling of secondhand frustration that perfectly captures the ordeal of dealing with broken desktop software.

## Bulletin - [00:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=1s) The Music app on macOS Catalina suffers from critical playback loops, where attempting to play tracks without an active subscription causes unhandled errors that continuously cycle through playlists instead of halting. - [07:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=436s) Core desktop usability patterns are broken, including the complete absence of drag-and-drop support for adding songs to playlists and a navigation stack that drops back buttons or traps users in loops. - [12:37](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=757s) Basic visual synchronization fails across the application, leaving sidebar selections mismatched with the content displayed in the main window. - [16:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=1008s) Despite Apple's immense resources, the host criticizes the company for shipping what feels like an unpolished internal developer build as a public stable release for paying customers.

## Key takeaways - [00:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=1s) The host argues that calling the macOS Catalina Music app 'not so great' downplays the reality that desktop software has become fundamentally unusable. - [00:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=1s) The sluggish webview shoehorned into iTunes for Apple Music was the real problem with iTunes, rather than the core application itself. - [00:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=1s) Without an active subscription, attempting to play a track triggers an uncontrollable loop that rapidly skips down the playlist, ignoring pause commands. - [02:46](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=166s) Onboarding and subscription renewal paths are broken; promo banners fail to launch billing flows, forcing users to dig into deep account menus to pay. - [02:46](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=166s) Completing the initial genre and artist onboarding preference flow fails to save state, immediately resetting back to the selection screen upon song playback. - [07:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=436s) Navigating into a newly created playlist destroys navigation history, leaving no back button and forcing users to manually guess where they came from. - [07:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=436s) Context menus present contradictory options, such as showing 'Delete' for songs that were never added to the user's library. - [10:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=604s) Playback history frequently loads blank 'Unknown Title' metadata entries that only resolve erratically, occasionally routing to incorrect artist pages. - [10:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=604s) Standard macOS desktop conventions like dragging and dropping a song onto a sidebar playlist are completely unsupported. - [10:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=604s) Duplicate track additions to playlists fail silently with no confirmation modal or notification to explain what happened. - [12:37](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=757s) The left sidebar fails to update its selection state, remaining locked on an unrelated personal playlist while the user browses an entirely different store album. - [12:37](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=757s) Navigation stacks duplicate screens when selecting 'Show in Apple Music,' causing the back button to cycle endlessly on the exact same view. - [12:37](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=757s) Adding tracks to the playback queue triggers confusing modal warnings asking whether to clear hundreds of previously queued songs. - [16:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=1008s) The queue layout is so unintuitive that users easily confuse playback history for upcoming tracks, with no clear indication of what will play next. - [16:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=1008s) Months after launch, these glaring usability issues persisted in Apple's stable production build rather than being addressed before general release.

## Detailed walkthrough ### [00:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=1s) The Abomination on macOS Catalina

The reviewer introduces the premise after seeing a comment on Reddit claiming that the Music app on macOS Catalina is “not so great.” To him, calling it “not so great” implies that it is tolerable or acceptable, when in reality he considers it completely unusable. He clarifies that his anger is directed entirely at the desktop macOS version rather than the iOS app, observing that tech giants seem to have abandoned desktop software altogether. While people spent years complaining about iTunes, the reviewer maintains that iTunes itself was never the core problem; the real issue was the sluggish webview shoehorned into iTunes for Apple Music. Despite his frustration, he genuinely wants to love Apple Music over Spotify. He dislikes Spotify's aggressive push of podcasts and Facebook-style algorithms, preferring Apple Music's record-store aesthetic—at least when it functions.

Having recently canceled his subscription, the host decides to spend $10 to re-subscribe on camera just to document how fundamentally broken the software is. Launching the application immediately triggers an alert stating, “You are no longer subscribed to Apple Music.” Dismissing the alert leads to a welcoming prompt that leaves the app in an ambiguous state: it still displays personalized "For You" recommendations, yet clicking on recently played items either does nothing or reveals empty screens. When he attempts to play a song from a playlist that was updated only the day before, the app displays a "No Apple Music Subscription" dialog. Instead of halting playback, the app enters an uncontrollable loop, rapidly skipping from track to track down the list. Attempting to pause playback merely triggers the app to advance to the next song.

> “Do you know how much money they have? It's like the wealthiest company in the history of the planet, can they just like put an if statement or something?”

```mermaid flowchart TD accTitle: Playback Failure Loop without Subscription accDescr: Diagram illustrating the unhandled error loop when playing music without an active Apple Music subscription.

Start["User plays song without active subscription"] --> ErrorPopup["Display error dialog: 'No Apple Music Subscription'"] ErrorPopup --> Skip["App automatically skips to next track"] Skip --> ErrorPopup Skip -.->|"User hits Pause"| Skip ```

---

[02:46](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=166s) The Ordeal of Trying to Give Apple Ten Dollars

Curious about how far the application will push this skipping behavior, the host wonders whether starting an endless song radio will crash his computer. Selecting "Create Station" produces an upbeat prompt reading "Get on our wavelength" with an invitation to join Apple Music. Clicking "Join Apple Music" completely fails to initiate an onboarding or billing flow; instead, it immediately triggers the "No Apple Music Subscription" error again and resumes cycling relentlessly through tracks.

Desperate to just hand over his money, the reviewer embarks on a convoluted hunt across the interface to find a working subscription button: - Clicking on his profile avatar only surfaces a "Music + Friends" social setup prompt that requires accessing contacts. - Context menus and account menus offer irrelevant options like "Upgrade to Family," leaving him wondering what plan he would even be upgrading from. - Navigating deeply into "View My Account" brings up an obscure list of active and past subscriptions. - Locating the expired Apple Music entry allows him to manually select the individual $9.99 monthly plan and click "Confirm."

Just when success seems imminent, the transaction fails with a "Payment method declined" notification followed by an "Unable to send code" error, forcing him to leave his desk to retrieve a physical credit card. Upon returning, the interface abruptly updates itself. A "Try it now" promotional banner appears, replacing the "For You" tab with a machine-learning onboarding screen to pick favorite genres and artists. After clicking through the artist selection circles and clicking "Done," the transaction finally goes through. Yet the victory is short-lived: the moment he begins playing a song, the app abruptly resets itself back to the initial genre onboarding screen, completely ignoring what he had just selected.

---

[07:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=436s) Disappearing Navigation and the Lost Back Button

The interface descends into a state of structural confusion. The host clicks through to the "Browse" tab, but the main window continues displaying the "For You" recommendations alongside a back arrow that leads nowhere before vanishing from the screen entirely. Attempting basic media management proves just as bewildering. When he right-clicks a track in a playlist and selects "Add to Playlist" followed by "New Playlist," the interface freezes for five seconds without giving any visual feedback before quietly appending the new playlist to the sidebar.

```mermaid flowchart LR accTitle: Broken Navigation Flow accDescr: Flow diagram showing how entering a new playlist destroys the navigation history and back button.

Once the user clicks into the newly generated playlist, the software traps him. Unlike Spotify, web browsers, or standard macOS software, there is no back button or navigation history. To return to the album he was just browsing, the user must rely on pure memory: - He guesses he came from the "Browse" section, but finds nothing. - He checks "Recently Added," which also fails to show it. - He finally locates the track under the "New Releases" shelf within "For You."

Contextual menus exhibit completely contradictory logic. When clicking on an unadded track, the menu simultaneously offers the options to "Delete" and "Add to Library." When he clicks "Delete" on a song that was never added to his library in the first place, the app executes no action and updates nothing. As the reviewer remarks:

> “Honestly it feels like a little kid wrote this while being on drugs.”

---

[10:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=604s) Phantom History and Missing Drag-and-Drop

Seeking refuge, the host navigates to a curated section titled "Comfort Zone" and creates a radio station from a song. He quickly mutes the audio to avoid automated YouTube copyright claims, only to discover another series of bizarre software bugs: - Opening the playback history reveals a sequence of blank entries titled "Unknown Title." - The "Unknown Title" entries dynamically shift and load metadata only when the user looks away, but freeze as soon as he watches the screen. - Selecting "Show in Apple Music" on one of these mystery entries redirects to a completely unfamiliar artist page that he has never visited. - The custom radio station he just spawned does not appear under the "Radio" sidebar tab, forcing him to hunt down its footprint under "Recently Played" in "For You."

The host then tests core desktop capabilities that have been standard on the Mac operating system for decades, specifically drag-and-drop. Attempting to click and drag a song from a playlist onto a custom playlist in the left sidebar yields nothing. Drag-and-drop is completely unsupported. Adding a track to a playlist requires clicking through nested contextual menus. When an item is finally added, the app displays a sluggish "Adding item" notification that takes multiple seconds to complete. Furthermore, attempting to re-add a track results in silent failure; the app does not allow duplicates, but never informs the user or asks for confirmation.

> “What about such advanced features like drag and drop? Can I drag this song from a playlist to one of those playlists on the left? No, there's no way to drag and drop. Just fuck that, it was a mistake for 20 years, it was a bad user experience pattern.”

---

[12:37](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=757s) Mismatched UI States and Queue Madness

Basic library viewing options are severely stripped down. The host finds no way to sort playlists by criteria like release year or artist, nor can he customize table columns. Instead, the menu presents cryptic, unexplained options such as "Copy to Play Order."

Visual state synchronization breaks down entirely when exploring music: - While browsing through an album titled *Best of Mushroom Jazz, Vol. 1–5*, the sidebar on the left keeps an unrelated personal playlist highlighted. - A user glancing at the window would assume the tracks on screen belong to the highlighted sidebar playlist, when the two views share no relationship at all. - Clicking "Show in Apple Music" while already viewing an Apple Music page causes the app to push duplicate states onto the navigation stack. The user can hit the back arrow five times in a row and remain pinned to the exact same screen.

Finally, the reviewer attempts to use the "Play Next" queue functionality. Rather than smoothly lining up the requested song, the software interrupts playback with an ambiguous modal warning: *"You are about to start playback. Do you want to clear the 250 songs previously added to Playing Next?"* The dialog offers confusing choices between "Clear Songs" and "Play Song," alongside another dead-end navigation arrow pointing nowhere, leaving the user baffled as to what will actually happen to his queue.

[16:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=1008s) The Queue Mystery and macOS Catalina’s Broken Polish

The host finds himself completely lost trying to figure out what track the Apple Music app is going to play next. After setting songs to play, he cannot even tell whether his first playlist has resumed, admitting, “I have no idea because I don’t know how to access my queue.” He fumbles through the interface until the queue suddenly reveals itself, prompting him to realize that the view he had been looking at earlier was actually the listening history rather than the upcoming tracklist.

Seeing how unintuitive and unpolished the interface remains, the reviewer vents his disbelief at the fact that Apple actually released the software in this state. He points out that this level of broken behavior might be excusable for an early developer build meant solely for internal review, but not for software distributed worldwide. Venting his frustration at the lack of quality control, the host remarks: “It’s okay if that’s some that is some internal temporary version like you know they showed to the managers saying oh we're gonna fix all this of course like we're not gonna ship this to millions of people who pay money or if we do we're gonna fix this as soon as possible but no it has been months like that and this is the current stable version.”

- The queue toggle is so confusingly laid out that it is easy to mistake playback history for the upcoming queue. - The host characterizes the interface blunders as “childish” and “ridiculous” for a paid commercial product. - Despite months having passed since release, these usability issues remain unresolved in the public stable build on macOS Catalina.

## Mentioned Apple, Apple Music, macOS Catalina, iTunes, Spotify, Reddit, Best of Mushroom Jazz, Vol. 1–5

## Video description Apple Music app on macOS Catalina is "not so great"

[Source](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU)

中文简报

Mac版Apple Music丢失基础系统功能，用户陷入界面循环死循环苹果发布了一款未打磨的桌面端应用，不仅摒弃了拖拽、导航历史等数十年来的Mac核心交互惯例，还将付费订阅用户困在界面的死循环错误中。主持人记录了自己对macOS Catalina桌面版Apple Music应用的极度失望，并在镜头前演示了为何他认为该软件在根本上已彻底损坏且无法使用。为了展示其缺陷，他特意重新花费10美元订阅，结果遇到了无限播放错误循环、账单入口失效以及新手引导界面意外重置等问题。在整个测试过程中，基础桌面功能全面失效：导航历史消失、拖拽功能无法使用、上下文菜单显示矛盾选项，播放队列界面也让人持续摸不着头脑。他总结道，作为全球最具财力的科技公司，苹果将如此粗糙且漏洞百出的软件推给付费用户，是完全不可原谅的。 macOS Catalina上的Music应用存在严重的播放死循环问题，在没有有效订阅的情况下尝试播放曲目会导致未处理的错误，应用会在播放列表内不断循环跳歌而非停止播放。 (0:01) 核心桌面可用性模式被破坏，包括完全不支持通过拖拽向播放列表添加歌曲，以及导航堆栈丢失返回按钮或将用户困在循环中。 (7:16) 整个应用的基础视觉同步出现故障，导致边栏选中的项目与主窗口显示的内容不匹配。 (12:37) 尽管苹果拥有巨额资源，主持人仍批评该公司向付费用户公开发布了一款感觉像未经打磨的内部开发者测试版的所谓正式版。 (16:48)

Reading summary

In a review of Apple Music for macOS Catalina, the host of Your Product Sucks argues that the desktop client is fundamentally broken and practically unusable due to critical navigation flaws, unhandled error states, and the absence of basic Mac interface conventions. Broken Error Handling and Subscription Friction (0:01) The application fails to gracefully handle inactive accounts, entering unhandled playback loops instead of guiding the user. Attempting to play a song without an active subscription triggers an alert dialog that, once dismissed, causes the app to skip uncontrollably from track to track, treating pause commands merely as prompts to advance to the next song. In-app prompts such as 'Join Apple Music' fail to launch onboarding flows and instead re-trigger the missing subscription error while resuming playback cycling. Completing a subscription requires navigating deeply into account management to manually pick the $9.99 monthly plan. Even after navigating payment errors and completing an initial onboarding setup where genres and artists are selected, the application abruptly resets back to the initial genre selection screen the moment playback begins, completely ignoring the user's input. Disorienting Navigation and Inconsistent UI States (7:16) The interface regularly traps users and displays contradictory information. Navigation controls such as back arrows frequently lead nowhere or vanish entirely, forcing users to rely on memory to retrace their steps back to previously viewed albums. Furthermore, pressing 'Show in Apple Music' repeatedly pushes duplicate states onto the navigation stack, causing the back button to loop on the same screen up to five times. Visual cues consistently desynchronize from active tasks. While browsing albums such as Best of Mushroom Jazz, Vol. 1–5, the left sidebar continues to highlight an unrelated personal playlist, misleading users about what content is being displayed. Context menus also present conflicting actions on unadded songs, showing options to 'Delete' alongside 'Add to Library,' with the delete command producing no effect. Missing Desktop Conventions and Media Management (10:04) The desktop client omits basic capabilities that have been standard on macOS for decades, most notably drag-and-drop. Users cannot drag a song from a playlist onto a custom playlist in the sidebar, relying instead on nested context menus accompanied by a sluggish multi-second notification. Re-adding duplicate songs fails silently without prompting for user confirmation. Library organization and playback queues remain similarly impaired. The app lacks basic options to sort playlists by release year or artist, as well as table column customization, offering only obscure commands like 'Copy to Play Order.' Queuing logic behaves erratically: selecting 'Play Next' prompts a modal dialog asking whether to clear 250 previously queued tracks, and confusing visual design makes it easy to mistake past playback history for the upcoming queue. The reviewer maintains that while severe interface bugs might be excusable in early internal developer builds, their persistence across multiple months in a commercial stable release reflects a severe breakdown in quality control for a paid product.

精炼阅读摘要

测评频道《Your Product Sucks》指出，macOS Catalina 上的 Apple Music 桌面端存在严重的基础体验缺陷，甚至无法稳定履行音乐播放、账户订阅及基本窗口交互等核心职责。作者认为该应用并非仅有微小瑕疵，而是彻底不可用，暴露出大型科技公司对桌面软件品质把控的忽视。未订阅状态下的播放异常与充值阻碍 (0:01) 在未激活订阅的状态下，Apple Music 桌面端展现出极不稳定的错误处理机制。当用户尝试播放前一天刚更新的播放列表曲目时，应用不仅弹出缺少订阅的警告弹窗，还陷入不受控制的跳歌死循环；此时点击暂停键不但无法终止播放，反而会直接触发跳至下一首曲目。此外，界面虽仍保留“为你推荐”（For You）等个性化推荐内容，但点击最近播放项目却常常毫无反应或呈现空屏。更为反常的是，用户若试图主动付费订阅，流程同样布满障碍。点击曲目电台生成界面的“加入 Apple Music”按钮并不会弹出付款引导，而是再次触发无订阅错误并继续疯狂跳歌。用户不得不深入“查看我的账户”等深层嵌套菜单，在过往订阅记录中手动选择每月 9.99 美元的个人方案。即便在遭遇扣款失败并完成物理信用卡验证后，好不容易填完喜好流派与艺术家的引导页，应用在播放首支曲目瞬间又会强行重置回初始流派选择页，彻底无视刚完成的用户偏好输入。导航层级断裂与基础交互缺失 (7:16) macOS Catalina 版本的 Apple Music 在界面层级管理上表现出严重的结构混乱。用户在新建播放列表并点击进入后，界面完全缺少常规的返回按钮与历史导航，致使用户被困在当前页面；若想返回此前浏览的专辑，必须完全依赖记忆去“为你推荐”中的“新发行”货架重新翻找。在切换“浏览”（Browse）标签页时，主窗口甚至会持续滞留原内容，原有的返回箭头也在闪烁后直接凭空消失。与此同时，该应用遗弃了 Mac 操作系统传承数十年的核心交互习惯。用户完全无法通过鼠标将歌曲直接拖拽到左侧边栏的自定义播放列表中；要将曲目添加到列表，必须依赖多层右键上下文菜单，且每次操作都会触发长达数秒的“正在添加项目”加载停顿。更离谱的是，未加入音乐库的歌曲右键菜单中会同时出现“删除”与“添加到音乐库”两个矛盾选项，点击“删除”后界面没有任何实际反应；当用户重复添加曲目时，应用不会弹出任何重复提示，仅以静默方式直接失败。界面状态脱节与播放队列混乱 (12:37) 应用在视图状态同步与多媒体元数据呈现方面频现漏洞。例如在浏览特定专辑时，左侧边栏却持续高亮显示与当前内容毫无关联的个人播放列表，极易对用户的归属判断造成误导；在已处于 Apple Music 页面时再次点击“在 Apple Music 中显示”，会导致导航栈推入重复页面，用户甚至需要连续点击五次回退键才能跳出死循环。此外，由曲目生成的电台不仅不会列入左侧“广播”标签，在播放历史记录中还会出现一批名为“未知标题”的空白占位符，其元数据加载极不稳定，点击相关条目甚至会跳转至从未访问过的陌生艺术家主页。播放控制核心“待播清单”（Playing Next）同样混乱不堪。当用户试图使用“播放下一首”功能时，系统并不能无缝衔接，而是弹出一个令人费解的模态警告，询问是否要清除先前已添加的 250 首歌曲，并附带一个指向不明的失效导航箭头。播放队列的切换开关与入口布局极其隐晦，普通用户极易将收听历史记录与接下来的待播列表混淆，完全无法直观获知软件接下来将要播放何种内容。测评者总结指出，这些粗糙的界面交互失误与严重逻辑漏洞本应只属于公司内部供管理层预览的早期开发版本，但该软件作为面向全球付费用户的正式稳定版，在发布数月后仍未得到修复。这表明 Apple 在 macOS Catalina 上的桌面端音乐体验缺乏起码的质量控制与维护投入。

Detailed notes — zh

## Background 该视频由 YouTube 频道「Your Product Sucks」于 2020 年 10 月 30 日发布。视频简介简短指出，macOS Catalina 上的 Apple Music 应用体验“不算太好”（not so great）。 ## TL;DR 博主因不满 Reddit 上将 macOS 版 Apple Music 轻描淡写为“不算太好”，自掏腰包 10 美元重新订阅，以实操演示这款应用的糟糕体验。在体验过程中，软件先后暴露出未订阅状态下疯狂跳歌报错、订阅购买路径极其曲折、界面返回键无故消失、不支持基础的拖拽加歌，以及播放历史出现“未知曲目”等严重交互缺陷。博主虽认可 Apple Music 专注淘歌的理念优于 Spotify，但对其桌面端宛如半成品 Webview 且数月无人维护的低劣品质表达了极为强烈的抨击。 ## Atmosphere & style 整段视频充满着辛辣嘲讽与近乎歇斯底里的崩溃感，博主全程情绪饱满、语速飞快，将满腔怒火倾泻在每一次反直觉的点击操作上。观看体验就像在围观一场荒诞的灾难现场：博主一边被层出不穷的低级 Bug 气得苦笑连连，一边对着全球市值最高科技巨头的产品水平发出难以置信的拷问，既极其解气又令人啼笑皆非。 ## Bulletin - [00:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=1s) 博主严厉批评 macOS Catalina 上的 Apple Music 应用体验极其糟糕，指出其本质上只是包装在原生外壳里的低质 webview，苹果对桌面端产品长期严重缺乏打磨与维护。 - [01:35](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=95s) 在未订阅状态下，应用尝试播放歌曲会陷入无限切歌报错循环且无法被暂停中断，展现出基础逻辑控制（如 if 条件判断）的严重缺失。 - [10:05](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=605s) 应用的核心交互多处断裂：丢失了 Mac 平台存在二十年的原生拖拽加歌交互，全局导航历史与返回按钮经常失效或彻底消失。 - [16:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=1008s) 虽然整体理念上博主更偏好 Apple Music 的淘歌模式而非 Spotify 的生硬推荐，但 macOS 版却充斥着未完成 demo 级别的低级缺陷，且以稳定版形式长期面向付费用户发布。 ## Key takeaways - [00:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=1s) 博主认为 Spotify 像 Facebook 一样强行推销歌单和播客，而 Apple Music 正常运作时更接近传统唱片店的淘歌体验，但其桌面端实现完全毁了这一理念。 - [00:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=1s) macOS 版 Apple Music 本质上是嵌入在 iTunes 遗留架构中的蹩脚网页视图（webview），桌面端长期得不到苹果足够的工程投入与重视。 - [01:35](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=95s) 未订阅用户点击单曲播放时，软件无法终止播放动作，而是在歌单中以极高频率自动连续跳过所有曲目并疯狂报错，且暂停按钮完全失效。 - [04:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=254s) 订阅付费链路极其曲折，主界面缺乏直接购买入口，反而充斥着针对非订阅用户的“升级到家庭共享”等荒谬菜单选项，支付与验证流程频繁中断。 - [07:20](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=440s) 用户选择偏好艺术家后界面会无故重置要求重新选择，且切换到“浏览”页面时顶部标题仍错误显示为“为您推荐”。 - [07:20](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=440s) 全局导航层级彻底破碎，用户点击进入自建播放列表后返回按钮直接失效或从界面上彻底消失，迫使用户依靠记忆重新在菜单中定位页面。 - [07:20](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=440s) 右键上下文菜单逻辑混乱，对从未保存过的在线单曲竟然同时并列出现“删除”与“添加到资料库”选项，点击删除也无任何反馈。 - [10:05](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=605s) 历史记录中频繁出现“未知曲目”（Unknown Title），且该列表需要用户视线移开后切回才会刷新，点击跳转还会定向到完全不相关的全新单曲。 - [10:05](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=605s) 软件彻底废弃了 Mac 平台上存在二十余年的基础拖拽（drag and drop）操作，用户无法直接将曲目拖入左侧播放列表，只能忍受耗时数秒的右键加载菜单。 - [10:05](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=605s) 当向歌单重复添加曲目时，应用没有任何动静，既不提示重复也不提供保留或覆盖的选择弹窗。 - [13:30](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=810s) 界面视觉状态与左侧边栏导航严重脱节，用户正在浏览某张专辑时，侧边栏高亮项却错误停留在毫不相干的播放列表上，缺乏任何面包屑路径指示。 - [13:30](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=810s) 页面返回历史存在死循环 Bug，连续点击五次回退按钮仍被困在同一个页面原地不动。 - [13:30](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=810s) 播放队列（接着播放 / Playing Next）管理逻辑反直觉，随意点播新歌曲会频繁弹出清除数百首待播曲目的阻断式确认框，入口位置与历史记录常发生混淆。 - [16:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=1008s) 博主质疑苹果作为全球顶级科技巨头对软件交付品质的把控，认为当前版本的粗糙程度顶多算公司内部演示原型，却作为正式稳定版面向付费用户发布且数月未予修复。 ## Detailed walkthrough ### [00:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=1s) 缘起与对 macOS 版 Apple Music 的强烈不满视频开篇，博主提到自己在 Reddit 上看到有人发帖称 macOS Catalina 上的音乐 App（Apple Music）“不算太好”（not so great）。博主对此说法极为光火，认为用“不算太好”来形容简直是在美化，甚至显得这种体验是可以接受的。在他看来，这款软件糟糕透顶、简直是“怪胎”，直言：“It's [ __ ] awful it's an abomination, there could be no god if that thing exists.” 他明确指出，这番吐槽仅针对 macOS 桌面端，iOS 版本虽然也有瑕疵，但整体还过得去；而如今苹果根本不在乎桌面端用户。以往很多人抱怨 iTunes 难用，但博主认为 iTunes 本身没问题，Apple Music 无论过去还是现在本质上都只是嵌入其中的蹩脚网页视图（webview），至少当年的 iTunes 还能正常工作。博主坦言自己其实更喜欢 Apple Music 的理念而不是 Spotify。Spotify 像极了 Facebook，只会不断向用户脸上生硬地硬塞各种随机播放列表和播客；而 Apple Music 正常运作时，更像是一家让人可以静心淘歌的实体唱片店。博主原本长期订阅该服务，为了做这期视频特意退订，现在必须自掏腰包花 10 美元重新订阅，以实际演示其产品设计有多么崩溃。 ```mermaid flowchart LR accTitle: 音乐平台理念与产品体验对比 accDescr: 展现博主对 Apple Music 理念的喜爱与其 macOS 糟糕实现的对比。 subgraph Ideology["平台理念对比"] SP["Spotify: 像 Facebook 硬塞推荐/播客"] AM["Apple Music: 像传统唱片店专注淘歌"] end subgraph Reality["macOS 桌面端现实"] DESK["严重缺乏维护与打磨"] BUG["死循环报错 / 交互断裂 / 导航混乱"] end AM --> DESK DESK --> BUG ``` ### [01:35](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=95s) 未订阅状态下的死循环与荒谬报错重新打开 Apple Music 应用后，系统弹窗提示“您已不再订阅 Apple Music”。博主点击确定后，弹出的却是“欢迎使用 Apple Music”的宣传页。当他点击“现在不要”（Not Now）后，界面依然显示为他推荐内容的“为您推荐”（For You）标签页，但下方的“最近播放”（Recently Played）却空空如也，连点击展开都毫无反应。博主在推荐列表里找到一个昨天刚更新的歌单并尝试播放其中的歌曲，软件随即报错提示没有订阅权限。然而，接下来软件展现出了匪夷所思的逻辑漏洞：系统没有停止播放动作，而是自动跳到下一首歌曲再次尝试播放，失败后再跳下一首，形成无限循环。博主尝试按暂停，软件依然无视并疯狂切歌。面对这个全球市值最高、资金最雄厚的科技巨头，博主哭笑不得地质问：“Do you know how much money they have? It's like the wealthiest company in the history of the planet, can they just like put an if statement or something?” 界面上甚至为了单独放一个向右的箭头，硬生生留出了一整条空荡荡的灰色空白行。博主随后尝试通过歌曲创建电台，弹出的“加入 Apple Music”推广按钮在点击后直接卡死报错，软件继续在其曲库中疯狂尝试切歌，整个交互彻底失控。 - 未订阅用户点击播放后，播放器不会终止动作，而是在歌单内以高频自动跳过下一首并不断报错。 - 用户尝试暂停播放无法打断自动切歌的报错循环。 - 通过歌曲右键菜单“创建电台”后，引导订阅的入口无法完成正常跳转。 ### [04:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=254s) 历经坎坷的“花钱订阅”之路面对失灵的推广弹窗，博主只想赶紧把钱付出去：“Just how do i subscribe? I just take my money now, okay I'm just telling you please take my money.” 他尝试点击个人头像，却被直接引导去设置“音乐与好友”共享并扫描通讯录，完全没有订阅入口。在菜单栏中翻找时，他看到了令人啼笑皆非的“升级到家庭共享”（Upgrade to Family）选项，让他纳闷自己明明连基础订阅都没有，到底是从什么级别开始“升级”。无奈之下，博主进入“查看我的账户”，在累计多达 12 项历史订阅的底层列表中找到已于 10 月 6 日过期的 Apple Music 订阅，手动选择每月 9.99 美元的个人方案。输入密码并确认购买后，系统竟提示“支付方式被拒”（Payment method declined），随后尝试发送双重验证码又提示发送失败。博主只能离开座位去翻实体信用卡。折腾良久后，界面才终于刷新出“立即试用”按钮，“为您推荐”页面短暂消失。博主冷嘲热讽道：“It understood through machine learning and AI, it was able to somehow understand my intent.” 随后应用进入让用户挑选喜好艺术家（如 Hardcore）的气泡选择界面，最终才勉强完成了订阅激活。 ### [07:20](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=440s) 毫无逻辑的导航与“消失”的返回按钮成功扣费并恢复播放后，软件立刻展现出更多令人费解的界面状态。刚设置完喜好，界面竟直接重置并再次要求他重新选择艺术家。博主点击切换到“浏览”（Browse）标签页，顶部显示的标题依然是“为您推荐”，并且还附带了一个左向返回箭头；而当博主点击这个箭头时，它没有返回上一层，而是直接从界面上彻底消失了。随后博主尝试最基本的音乐管理功能：在“为您推荐”中看中一首歌，右键选择“添加到播放列表”并新建歌单。点击后界面卡顿整整五秒毫无动态反馈，新歌单默默出现在左侧边栏，没有任何视觉聚焦或动效提示。更致命的是，用户一旦点击进入左侧新生成的播放列表，界面上的“返回”按钮就彻底失效了。在现存几乎所有的现代软件中，用户进入下一级页面都能轻松返回，但在这里，博主必须凭自己的人脑记忆去回想刚刚是怎样一路点进来的： > “And now that I clicked in this playlist, I cannot go back. Like in Spotify or anywhere on the planet basically in any interface you can go back, right? If you click somewhere you can go back. Here I don't know how to go back.” 博主为了找回刚才的歌，不得不手动在“浏览”、“为您推荐”和“最新发行”之间来回翻找。好不容易找到那首单曲，右键菜单中竟然同时并列出现“删除”与“添加到资料库”。博主点击删除一首从未添加过的歌，界面没有任何反应。目睹此景，博主彻底无奈地评价道：“Honestly it feels like a little kid wrote this while being on drugs.” ### [10:05](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=605s) “未知曲目”、幽灵历史与不可思议的拖拽缺失博主转而测试基于单曲创建电台的功能。为了防止 YouTube 触发版权警报，他迅速将声音静音。然而打开播放历史列表时，里面赫然罗列着数条名为“未知曲目”（Unknown Title）的记录。这些“未知曲目”十分诡异，如果盯着它看就不更新，当视线移开再切回来时又会突然刷新显示；当博主点击某首未知曲目的“在 Apple Music 中显示”时，跳转出的却是一首自己从没听过的全新单曲。博主试图寻找刚才创建的电台，无论是在左侧的“广播”标签页还是“为您推荐”的“最近播放”里，都看不到清晰的电台轨迹。随后他尝试了一项在 Mac 上存在了数十年的基础交互操作——将一首歌从当前播放列表直接“拖拽”（drag and drop）到左侧边栏的自建歌单中。结果发现 Apple Music 完全不支持这一动作。博主极其讽刺地调侃道：“Just [ __ ] that, it was a mistake for 20 years. It was a bad user experience pattern, [ __ ] drag and drop.” 用户要添加歌曲，只能忍受繁琐的多级右键菜单，并且每次添加都要经历长达数秒的“正在添加项目”加载停滞。当尝试往歌单中添加一首已经存在的歌曲时，软件直接毫无动静，既不弹出是否保留重复项的确认框，也不给任何提示。 ### [13:30](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=810s) 错位的视觉状态、死循环历史与混乱的播放队列在尝试对播放列表进行排序时，博主发现该应用根本没有常规的按年份等属性添加列的选项，菜单里只躺着一个语义不明的“拷贝至播放顺序”（Copy to Play Order）。更荒谬的是界面的视觉分离：博主当前正在浏览一张名为《Best of Mushroom Jazz Vol. 1-5》的专辑，但在左侧边栏中，高亮选中的却是一个完全不相干的自定义播放列表。界面的当前状态与侧边栏导航彻底脱节，没有任何面包屑或路径提示，让人感觉像在做荒诞的梦境。在搜索和页面历史方面，博主点击“在 Apple Music 中显示”，连续点击了数次，随后发现点击返回按钮整整五次，页面都原地不动地停留在同一个界面上。当博主准备往后继续听歌、研究其播放队列（Queue / Playing Next）时，软件又弹出了令人困惑的对话框：“您即将开始播放。是否要清除之前添加到‘接着播放’的歌曲？”两个选项按钮的文案竟然被切成了令人摸不着头脑的“清除歌曲”与“播放歌曲”。博主想要点播新歌，又被警告“是否清除之前添加到接着播放的 250 首歌曲”，交互逻辑完全背离直觉。整个操作链路充满了莫名其妙的阻碍与死胡同，将基础的听歌体验切得支离破碎。 ### [16:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU&t=1008s) 混乱的播放队列与不合格的正式版本视频作者在测试歌曲播放顺序时陷入了彻底的困惑。当几首歌曲陆续播放完毕后，他不确定应用目前是在播放最初选定的播放列表还是别的曲目，因为他根本弄不清楚该怎么查看当前的待播队列。在界面上一顿摸索后，作者才发现队列入口竟然变化了，忍不住吐槽道：“oh it's here now so it was history before oh i see”（哦，它现在在这里了，所以刚才显示的是播放历史，好吧我明白了）。这种捉摸不透的交互逻辑让他感到极度无语。随后，作者对 macOS 上的 Apple Music 应用品质发出了严厉的批评，认为这种软件设计简直幼稚且荒谬：“oh okay you have to agree right this is just childish like it's ridiculous”（好吧，你不得不承认，这简直太小儿科了，太荒唐了）。他尖锐地指出，如果这只是公司内部拿给管理层过目的临时预览版本，大家承诺说“我们当然会把这些问题都修好，绝不可能把这种半成品推送给成千上万付了费的用户”，或者哪怕先上线也很快会热修解决，那还可以理解。然而残酷的现实却是，数个月过去了，这种充斥着低级交互缺陷的状态依旧没有改善，甚至就是目前面向大众推送的正式稳定版。 - **队列与历史记录切换混乱**：播放队列界面的状态显示和入口逻辑不直观，导致用户在切歌或查看下一首待播曲目时无法快速掌握播放状态。 - **软件交付品质饱受质疑**：作者认为当前应用的完成度顶多算内部半成品 demo，但 Apple 却将这种体验长达数月不修地推给付费用户：“no it has been months like that and this is the current stable version”（不，这种情况已经持续好几个月了，而这居然就是目前的正式稳定版）。 ## Mentioned Apple, Apple Music, macOS, macOS Catalina, iTunes, Spotify, Facebook, Reddit, YouTube, Best of Mushroom Jazz Vol. 1-5 ## Video description Apple Music app on macOS Catalina is "not so great" [Source](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE8ZikfrpFU)

Original transcript

[0:01] [Music] [0:12] i didn't want to do this but someone on [0:14] the reddit said [0:15] music app on mac os catalina [0:18] is not so great not so great that sounds [0:21] like it's [0:22] okay like it's acceptable it's not not [0:25] so great [0:26] it's [ __ ] awful it's an abomination [0:29] there could be no god [0:30] if that thing exists now i'm only [0:33] talking about mac os [0:35] not the ios version ios version is fine [0:38] it has problems but whatever [0:39] nobody gives a [ __ ] about desktop [0:41] nowadays right apple doesn't give a [ __ ] [0:43] about desktop [0:44] and people say well itunes itunes was so [0:47] bad itunes was [0:48] fine it wasn't a problem with itunes [0:50] apple music was always this [ __ ] [0:52] weird [0:53] webview within itunes and it was at [0:55] least it was working [0:57] it's i'm biased as you can hear [1:00] i actually like apple music i i want to [1:03] love it i [1:03] i really do because i i like it in [1:06] principle more than spotify [1:08] because spotify is like facebook it just [1:12] pushes random playlists into your face [1:14] and podcasts all that stuff [1:15] apple music at least feels like they [1:17] care about music it feels like a record [1:19] store where you [1:20] browse music and stuff when it works [1:23] i've been a subscriber to apple music [1:24] for a long time [1:26] and then i quit just for you now i'm [1:28] gonna re-subscribe just [1:29] to show you how bad it is so right this [1:31] video cost me 10 bucks [1:35] when i run this apple music thing it [1:37] says you are no longer subscribed to [1:38] apple music [1:39] sure make sense right i hit okay [1:42] and it's what was that okay [1:45] welcome to apple music am i a subscriber [1:48] or not [1:48] i don't know not now okay so it still [1:52] shows me [1:53] for you like recommended music so also [1:56] what is this [1:57] like what is this recently played [1:59] nothing [2:00] it doesn't even open [2:03] okay so this was updated yesterday which [2:07] is i guess [2:08] great so can i open it [2:12] yeah i can open it i have songs here wow [2:15] okay let's play it [2:20] no apple music subscription i knew it so [2:23] okay and what it does now it just tries [2:26] all the next songs [2:28] look and you can't stop it like if you [2:30] pause it it goes to the next song [2:34] how like do you know how much money they [2:37] have [2:38] it's like the wealthiest company in the [2:40] history [2:41] of the planet can they just [2:44] like put an if statement or something [2:46] okay also what is this [2:48] empty gray line for the sake of this one [2:51] arrow [2:53] okay so same here right [2:57] it just says and then it tries all the [2:59] next songs i wonder what would happen [3:01] if i play a radio right you can you can [3:05] have a song radio which is endless so [3:08] would that just [ __ ] kill my computer [3:10] okay create station get on our [3:12] wavelength [3:13] nice some humor good [3:16] join apple music okay sure let's let's [3:19] join apple music [3:20] [ __ ] what [3:26] am i uh [3:30] then i should no no apple music [3:32] subscription [3:33] but okay and it it goes through all the [3:36] [ __ ] [3:37] [ __ ] okay okay [3:41] uh so let me try again create station [3:45] join apple music [3:49] you are [ __ ] okay maybe [3:52] how do i do this uh oh [3:58] this now appears when i go back no no [4:01] nothing [4:01] okay [ __ ] piece of [ __ ] [4:07] um so feeling good yeah [4:10] i'm feeling so good um [4:14] just how do i subscribe i just take my [4:18] money now [4:18] okay i'm just telling you please take my [4:21] money [4:22] ah [ __ ] okay [4:26] um oh i know i'll click on my face [4:30] music plus friends see what your friends [4:32] are listening to and find the best [4:34] um uh i guess get started [4:38] continue to find contacts no that's not [4:40] i just want to subscribe [4:43] how do i [ __ ] subscribe to apple [4:46] music [4:47] okay not now um [4:51] is it this play next no is it this [4:54] upgrade to family i upgrade from what [4:58] manage family view my account okay [5:02] here we go yeah [5:05] okay [5:08] i'm gonna view my account because [5:14] [Music] [5:16] subscriptions 12 all time [5:20] i guess let's try subscriptions because [5:23] i i want [5:24] apple music subscription expired october [5:27] 6. [5:28] uh okay and so apple [5:31] this yeah [ __ ] i found it [5:35] individual one month 9.99 [5:38] subscribe okay confirm [5:44] yeah [ __ ] so [5:47] payment method declined you [ __ ] [5:53] um [5:54] [Music] [5:56] okay sure [6:04] sure let's let's try this [6:07] unable to send code okay wait i'm gonna [6:11] i'm gonna go and get my credit card wait [6:15] [Music] [6:18] oh now i have this try it now [6:24] okay oh and now [6:27] for you it's gone and i have this [6:31] this thing it understood through [6:34] machine learning and ai [6:38] it was able to somehow understand my [6:41] intent [6:42] i'm gonna start [ __ ] listening now [6:46] start listening oh yeah [6:49] take my money [6:51] [Music] [6:56] choose you okay [7:02] what is this a hard draw okay yeah sure [7:06] i love this choose more of your favorite [7:08] or click done [7:14] okay [7:16] that sounds good now at least we have a [7:19] subscription [7:20] right so this thing should play i guess [7:24] is it play [7:27] all right it plays [7:32] now it just resets to this intro [7:35] selection thing again what [7:44] okay i i have done this already [7:49] i don't want to [7:54] what the [ __ ] now i'm in browse and it [7:57] still shows for you [8:00] but with this back arrow which leads [8:03] to [ __ ] nowhere and now it [8:05] disappeared [8:08] this is amazing like ah [ __ ] man [8:12] okay let's just go back for you [8:16] let's say i want to go into this [8:19] playlist or whatever this is let's say i [8:22] want to add this song [8:24] to a playlist i can right click and it [8:27] shows [8:28] add to playlist new playlist and you [8:31] click it [8:32] and what what's happening i don't know [8:36] it took five seconds and it doesn't even [8:38] show like [8:39] you don't know where to look but the new [8:41] playlist is now here [8:43] and now that i clicked in this playlist [8:45] i cannot go back [8:47] like in spotify or anywhere [8:50] on the planet basically in any interface [8:53] you can go [8:54] back right if you click somewhere you [8:56] can go back [8:57] here i don't know how to go back i have [9:00] to remember that [9:01] i was okay i was in a playlist [9:04] which i accessed from [9:07] for you i think so if i go back to [9:11] what was it browse the browse [9:14] okay no it was for you [9:18] [ __ ] i don't know [9:21] was it in recently not it's not added [9:24] right it's not recently [9:25] added i wasn't oh yeah i was here [9:29] in new releases see how easy it is to go [9:32] back [9:33] uh delete how can i delete this [9:37] and add to library at the same time [9:40] i i what okay delete [9:43] like what i didn't okay [9:46] what would happen if i delete something [9:49] that i haven't added [9:53] well nothing apparently and nothing [9:55] changes here [9:56] honestly it feels like a little kid [9:59] wrote this [10:00] while being on drugs okay let's try [10:04] something else [10:05] let's go to browse and something like [10:09] this [10:12] comfort zone because i'm i'm clearly [10:16] in my comfort zone now and i [10:20] would like to create station based on [10:23] this [10:24] song [10:27] okay that's good i can hear music i'm [10:30] gonna turn it off [10:31] because youtube will punish me for [10:33] having human music [10:35] on my video so um [10:39] what is this like it plays a station [10:43] and like [10:46] where is it if i go to history [10:51] it just shows this unknown title [10:55] like what the [ __ ] is this [11:00] [Music] [11:02] oh it loads so this [11:05] unknown titles they actually like they [11:08] change [11:09] if if you don't look okay if you look [11:12] away [11:12] like let's look away [11:17] yeah no it doesn't load anymore [11:21] so let's see show an apple music show me [11:24] this unknown title [11:27] now i'm i don't know much about myself [11:31] right i'm still exploring [11:35] i know for sure i haven't listened to [11:38] this [11:39] this whatever this is let's go to radio [11:42] because [11:43] maybe that station that i created is [11:46] in radio no it's not here [11:49] maybe it's in for you in recently played [11:53] yes [11:54] like can i go in can i see anything [11:57] about it [11:58] share station sure um [12:01] i cannot get up [12:04] get up mix yo mix get up [12:08] what about such advanced features [12:12] like drag and drop can i drag this [12:17] song from a playlist to [12:21] one of those playlists on the left [12:24] no there's no way to drag and drop [12:28] just [ __ ] that it was a mistake for 20 [12:32] years [12:33] it was a bad user experience pattern [12:37] [ __ ] drag and drop if i want to add this [12:40] to here i have to go through this [12:44] [ __ ] [12:45] and when i do let's say i do to neopop [12:51] adding item did you see it it took [12:54] seconds again let's go to [12:57] the search again oh no i wasn't for you [13:02] okay this is so disorienting [13:05] prosthetic head [13:17] it doesn't do anything now maybe this is [13:19] also by design because the song is [13:21] already in this playlist [13:22] it does the smart thing of not [13:25] duplicating the song but [13:27] maybe ask me maybe i want to duplicate [13:30] can i sort my playlist is there a way to [13:34] sort this [13:36] no can i show more [13:39] columns like maybe the year [13:44] no copy to play order [13:48] uh what [13:53] what does what does it mean [13:56] i don't know what that means also [14:00] where is this coming from who are these [14:03] people [14:04] like i don't think i am i going crazy [14:09] am i like losing it now i [14:12] i don't listen to 50 cent i [14:16] best of mushroom jazz [14:19] [ __ ] that idea of showing any navigation [14:23] i'm right now inside of this best of [14:26] mushroom jazz [14:27] volume one to five [14:30] and on the left i have this playlist [14:33] selected [14:35] so you might think this is my playlist [14:37] but [14:38] these are not related just some line it [14:41] doesn't mean [14:42] anything nothing means anything right [14:44] nothing [14:45] makes any sense just forget about it [14:48] it's like a dream man [14:49] anything could happen in a dream relax [14:52] just get some mushrooms oh it's trending [14:57] right uh clear can i clear trending [15:00] no showing apple music [15:04] showing apple music [15:08] and again showing up on me and if i go [15:11] once again [15:12] to show an apple music i can now go back [15:17] five times and stay on the same page [15:22] can i maybe drag and drop from here [15:24] still no [15:25] okay more [15:30] that's unfortunate [15:34] did they copy pasted from wikipedia they [15:37] saw the song is also nice [15:40] i would like to drag and drop oh no i [15:42] cannot [15:44] maybe if i play this next [15:47] something nice will happen [15:49] [Music] [15:52] can i see my queue somewhere is there a [15:55] queue [15:57] oh okay [16:01] you're about to start playback [16:06] do you want to clear the song previously [16:08] added to playing next [16:11] play song like which [16:15] play song [16:18] clear songs or plays on how i don't [16:21] understand it [16:22] and now i have this arrow which leads [16:26] to absolutely nowhere [16:29] let's play this do you want to clear the [16:32] 250 songs previously added to playing [16:35] next [16:37] uh oh no [16:41] i want to play song [16:44] and so it plays and what would play next [16:48] the next song and then after they all [16:52] play [16:53] [Music] [16:54] i don't know perhaps that first playlist [16:58] is now playing [16:58] i have no idea because i don't know how [17:01] to access my queue [17:03] oh it's here now so it was history [17:07] before oh [17:08] i see [17:12] oh okay you have to agree [17:16] right this is just childish [17:20] like it's ridiculous it's okay if that's [17:23] some [17:23] that is some internal temporary version [17:26] like you know [17:27] they showed to the managers saying oh [17:30] we're gonna fix all this of course like [17:32] we're not gonna ship this [17:33] to millions of people who pay money [17:37] or if we do we're gonna fix this [17:41] as soon as possible but no it has been [17:44] months [17:44] like that and this is the current stable [17:52] [Music] [17:54] version