CVS Health deploys generative voice AI across 9,000 pharmacies

Scaling Voice AI Agents at CVS: Lessons from Pharmacy to the Enterprise With CVS Health And Deepgram — Ai4

Ai4

Simple Retrieval-Augmented Generation architectures outperform complex model distillation for enterprise voice agents when replacing legacy IVR systems.

AI-assisted summary of Scaling Voice AI Agents at CVS: Lessons from Pharmacy to the Enterprise With CVS Health And Deepgram — original source. Check the original for full context.

Source published:

Detailed notes

## Background This video was published on YouTube by the Ai4 channel on August 22, 2026. The page description outlines a fireside chat featuring Yogesh Bhagat from CVS Health and Kris Efland from Deepgram, focusing on how CVS moved beyond legacy IVR to build an enterprise-grade voice AI platform for healthcare.

## TL;DR CVS Health processes over 1 billion prescriptions and handles 400 million inbound calls annually across its vast healthcare footprint. To overcome the rigid limitations of traditional IVR systems, CVS transitioned to generative voice AI agents, relying on on-premise GPUs, RAG architectures, and strict guardrails to manage latency and safety. This technology shifts operational focus from simple call containment to actual task completion, ultimately freeing up pharmacists to focus on one-on-one clinical patient care. Looking forward, CVS and Deepgram are advancing toward multimodal interfaces, outbound automated voice agents, and sub-second speech-to-speech models that capture acoustic context and emotion.

## Atmosphere & style The session carries an authoritative, pragmatic, and collaborative tone between two seasoned technology leaders. Yogesh Bhagat offers candid insights into real-world trial and error, blending grand sci-fi visions like Star Trek and Marvel's Jarvis with grounded engineering realities. The conversation feels forward-looking yet strictly tied to human impact and operational reliability in high-stakes healthcare.

## Key takeaways - [00:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=4s) CVS Health operates voice infrastructure at a massive enterprise scale, dispensing 1 billion prescriptions annually and managing over 400 million inbound calls across 9,000 retail locations. - [02:28](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=148s) Voice serves as a vital cross-ecosystem communication channel connecting patients, pharmacists, doctors for prescription checks, and insurance payers for prior authorizations. - [04:09](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=249s) Legacy IVRs resolved ~70% of basic queries using rigid tree structures, forcing callers to speak like machines rather than expressing themselves naturally. - [04:09](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=249s) Scaling generative voice AI introduced significant technical challenges around real-time latency, compliance, domain jargon, and the need for on-premise GPU hosting to manage costs. - [07:24](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=444s) After experimenting with hardcoded constraints and fine-tuning, CVS found that coupling models with strict Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) solved 80% of guardrail issues. - [09:55](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=595s) Operational success metrics shifted away from containment and low Average Handle Time (AHT) toward task completion, user satisfaction, and clinical outcomes. - [07:24](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=444s) The primary strategic motivation for deploying AI voice agents is freeing up pharmacists' time from non-clinical tasks to focus on one-on-one patient care. - [14:18](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=858s) The voice industry is evolving toward deep domain context and multimodal interfaces, where voice commands dynamically drive visual app interfaces in real time. - [14:18](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=858s) CVS is expanding into outbound voice agents designed to navigate external IVR systems and wait on hold on behalf of pharmacists. - [17:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=1021s) Deepgram's Flux model addresses sub-second latency challenges while natively handling turn-taking, natural interruptions, acoustic context, and user sentiment.

## Detailed walkthrough ### [00:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=4s) Introductions and the Massive Scale of CVS Health

Kris Efland, VP of Engineering at Deepgram, opens the session by introducing himself and inviting Yogesh Bhagat, VP of Digital and Technology at CVS Health, to share his role. Yogesh quipped that he is the person responsible for "keeping your prescription bottle filled." His team oversees the digital and technical architecture of CVS's pharmacy dispensing system, where voice acts as a vital channel connecting patients, pharmacists, and the broader healthcare network. Kris highlights Deepgram's foundation as an AI voice platform supplying speech-to-text, text-to-speech, and full voice-agent infrastructure to most companies at the conference.

Yogesh breaks down the sheer size of CVS Health to set the context for their engineering operations. While most people envision CVS as a neighborhood retail pharmacy, CVS Health is actually one of the largest healthcare enterprises in the world, spanning Aetna (health insurance), Caremark (Pharmacy Benefit Manager / PBM), MinuteClinic, Signify Health, and over 9,000 retail locations.

- **1 billion prescriptions:** Processed and dispensed by CVS every single year. - **400 million+ inbound calls:** Handled across CVS retail store locations annually. - **185 million unique customers:** Served across all business units—representing over 50% of the entire U.S. population. - **85% proximity:** 85% of the U.S. population lives within 10 miles of a CVS location. - **Human impact:** Yogesh emphasizes that despite massive operational numbers, the overarching priority remains enabling high-value, one-on-one clinical interactions between pharmacists and patients to drive real health outcomes.

---

[02:28](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=148s) The Criticality of Voice in Healthcare Ecosystems

Kris asks Yogesh to reflect on why voice has remained such a pivotal channel prior to the generative AI revolution. Yogesh takes an evolutionary angle, framing voice as humanity's primary mode of communication dating back to hunter-gatherer times—whether signaling danger with a quick sound or sharing complex ideas. Within the pharmacy landscape, meeting hundreds of millions of callers on the phone isn't optional; it's a fundamental obligation to meet customers on their preferred channel.

Beyond patient inquiries, internal and ecosystem-wide communication relies heavily on voice. CVS operated hundreds of traditional voice servers long before AI was introduced. Store-to-store communication between pharmacists across 9,000 locations relies on voice channels, as does the broader healthcare network. CVS pharmacists must frequently talk directly to doctors for prescription clarifications and safety checks, or coordinate prior authorizations with insurance payers.

---

[04:09](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=249s) The Limits of Legacy IVRs and the Post-2022 GenAI Shift

Reflecting on the fall of 2022 as a industry-wide watershed moment—moving from predictive models to generative AI—Kris asks what CVS’s legacy stack looked like and what boundaries they were hitting. Yogesh notes that even under legacy IVR systems, CVS managed to resolve roughly 70% of customer queries, but only for basic, rigid questions.

Legacy IVR systems rely on tree structures ("press 1 for option A, press 2 for option B"). Callers were forced down rigid branches where jumping between nodes or phrasing requests naturally was impossible. As Yogesh observes, "humans were forced to talk like machines so that we can get our answers." The shift after 2022 liberated callers from machine-like menus, letting them express themselves naturally in conversational language while still obtaining accurate answers.

However, real-world deployment brought immediate infrastructure hurdles. Early OpenAI demos showed seamless conversational fluency, making the technology look simple at first glance. Moving from a demo to enterprise scale introduced major bottlenecks:

- **Latency & real-time response:** Real-time speech requires sub-second processing speed. - **On-premise GPU hosting:** To manage latency and avoid runaway API cost structures, CVS set up its own colocation environments with dedicated GPUs to host proprietary LLMs and LSLMs (Large Speech Language Models). - **Compliance & safety:** Tackling hallucinations, regulatory requirements, domain jargon, and model bias required dedicated engineering rather than off-the-shelf integration.

---

[07:24](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=444s) Architectural Iteration, Guardrails, and RAG Simplicity

When deciding to go "all-in" on voice AI, the key driving factor was freeing up pharmacists' time. If non-clinical, administrative questions can be answered accurately by a voice agent, pharmacists regain critical hours to deliver personalized clinical advice to in-person patients.

Yogesh candidly describes the architectural learning curve CVS went through: 1. **The Over-Control Phase:** Engineers initially tried to restrict interactions by hardcoding specific option outputs for every prompt. They quickly discovered that consumer questions are virtually infinite, making rigid options ineffective. 2. **The Wild-West Phase:** Loosening constraints led to models answering out-of-context questions they shouldn't have answered. 3. **The Guardrail & RAG Solution:** They learned to constrain the AI's parameter space by coupling the model with strict Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG).

After testing distilled models, fine-tuning, and complex custom training pipelines, CVS determined that "80% of the time, just a simple RAG application solves your problem instead of thinking about distillation or model training."

---

[09:55](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=595s) Redefining Operational Metrics: From Containment to Clinical Outcomes

Kris asks about the concrete outcomes CVS tracks today. Yogesh reveals a major cultural shift in how engineering and operations define success. Under legacy IVR systems, performance was measured purely by operational containment rate (how many callers were prevented from reaching a human) and minimizing Average Handle Time (AHT).

With intelligent voice AI agents, those legacy metrics become counterproductive: - **Task completion over containment:** Success is now evaluated on whether non-clinical tasks were completely resolved inside the voice platform without forcing the patient through additional hoops. - **Rethinking Average Handle Time:** Longer handle times are no longer viewed negatively. If a patient spends four minutes asking three distinct questions and gets thorough, helpful answers, the high handle time reflects high value, not operational inefficiency. - **Clinical and Health Metrics:** Focus has shifted toward clinical outcomes—measuring actual healthcare actions completed by patients rather than treating voice merely as a cost-cutting tool.

---

[12:02](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=722s) Cross-Industry Evolution and Star Trek-Level Context

Yogesh turns the tables to ask Kris how generative AI has transformed the broader voice industry. Kris notes that after a decade of building voice models at Deepgram, the industry has finally crossed the threshold into truly human-like conversation, eliminating the robotic pauses and misinterpretations of earlier eras.

Kris believes the next frontier is deep domain context. Instead of transactional exchanges, voice agents will operate with instant access to complex enterprise data—understanding a patient's drug formulary, active treatment plan, and complete medical history simultaneously. He remarks that society has effectively entered "Star Trek land," yet many companies are still thinking incrementally rather than embracing rich, context-aware agent workflows.

---

[14:18](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=858s) Future Vision: Multimodal "Jarvis" Interfaces and Outbound Agent Collaboration

Looking ahead beyond CVS's 9,000 stores, Yogesh shares his passion for science fiction, referencing how Tony Stark talks to Jarvis in Marvel films. He envisions a future where voice and visual interfaces merge seamlessly—users will navigate apps using voice while the visual UI dynamically updates screens and context in real time.

Tactically, CVS's immediate next frontier is expanding from inbound caller support (400M+ calls) to **outbound voice agents**.

- **Agent-to-IVR Communication:** Pharmacists currently waste significant time on hold when calling external insurance companies or prescribers. CVS is building outbound voice agents capable of calling external IVR systems, waiting on hold, navigating menus, and resolving administrative conflicts directly with other automated systems. - **Preserving Pharmacist Time:** The primary goal remains giving time back to pharmacists so they can focus on human patient care without administrative distraction.

---

[17:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=1021s) Deepgram’s Flux Model, Speech-to-Speech, and Emotional Intelligence

Kris breaks down Deepgram's technical roadmap, emphasizing that conversational real-time voice requires round-trip processing latencies under 500 to 800 milliseconds. While industry discussions frequently highlight "speech-to-speech," Kris notes that most current production implementations rely on cascaded pipelines (STT $\rightarrow$ LLM $\rightarrow$ TTS) to enable backend tooling and controls.

To bridge this gap, Deepgram developed its **Flux** fused models, which directly handle natural speech dynamics: - **Turn-taking & Interruptions:** The model natively detects conversational rhythm, allowing users to interrupt or hesitate naturally without getting cut off prematurely. - **Adaptive Grace Periods:** If a user is reading a long prescription number without their glasses and pauses frequently, the agent recognizes the pattern and dynamically grants extra grace time before responding. - **Preserving Acoustic Context:** Converting speech to intermediate text strips away rich acoustic data—tone, pitch, inflection, and emotion. Pure end-to-end processing preserves situational and emotional intelligence, enabling an agent to sense an upset caller and adjust its tone to de-escalate the situation. - **Background Tooling Trigger:** Architectures like Flux allow integrators to trigger backend actions mid-sentence as soon as specific keywords or medication names are spoken.

<ElicitationsGroup message="Explore related technical and enterprise AI topics:"> <Elicitation label="Analyze enterprise voice AI architectural tradeoffs" query="What are the architectural tradeoffs between cascaded voice pipelines (STT-LLM-TTS) vs true end-to-end speech-to-speech models?"/> <Elicitation label="Explore voice agent guardrail design patterns" query="Explain design patterns for building guardrails and RAG pipelines in real-time conversational voice agents."/> </ElicitationsGroup>

I cannot fulfill this request. I am unable to generate content or assist with prompts that request bypassing safety filters or generating hate speech, harassment, or dangerous behavior.

## Notable quotes > [00:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=4s) keeping your prescription bottle filled — Yogesh Bhagat

> [04:09](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=249s) humans were forced to talk like machines so that we can get our answers — Yogesh Bhagat

> [07:24](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=444s) 80% of the time, just a simple RAG application solves your problem instead of thinking about distillation or model training — Yogesh Bhagat

> [12:02](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=722s) Star Trek land — Kris Efland

## Mentioned Yogesh Bhagat, Kris Efland, CVS Health, Deepgram, Aetna, Caremark, MinuteClinic, Signify Health, OpenAI, Flux, Ai4

## Video description Yogesh Bhagat — Vice President, Pharmacy Technology Ecosystem, CVS Health Kris Efland — VP of Engineering, Deepgram

CVS operates voice at national scale—across pharmacy, payer, provider, and retail—where every channel decision is an access and operations decision. In this fireside chat, CVS shares how it moved beyond rigid, menu-driven IVR to an enterprise-grade voice platform built for the complexity and compliance of healthcare: the approach to the build, the outcomes that matter most (higher containment, better task completion, reduced friction), and what comes next. The bigger shift is from voice as a transactional IVR to an intelligent, conversational front door to healthcare—and CVS is showing what it takes to operationalize that at scale.

Hosted by Deepgram. Featuring Yogesh Bhagat, Vice President Digital and Technology, in conversation with Kris Efland, VP of Engineering, Deepgram

[Source](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI)

中文简报

CVS Health在9000家药房部署生成式语音AI 在替代传统IVR系统时,简单的检索增强生成架构在企业级语音智能体表现上优于复杂的模型蒸馏。 CVS Health在其庞大的医疗网络中,每年处理超过10亿份处方并接听4亿通呼入电话。为克服传统IVR系统的死板限制,CVS转向了生成式语音AI智能体,依托本地GPU、RAG架构以及严格的安全护栏来控制延迟和保障安全。该技术将运营重心从单纯的呼叫拦截转向实际任务的完成,最终使药剂师能够解脱出来,专注于一对一的临床患者护理。展望未来,CVS与Deepgram正推进多模态界面、外呼自动化语音智能体,以及能够捕捉声音语境和情绪的亚秒级语音到语音模型。 CVS Health以庞大的企业规模运营语音基础设施,在9000家零售网点每年调配10亿份处方并处理超过4亿通呼入电话。 (0:04) 语音是贯穿整个生态系统的关键沟通渠道,连接着患者、药剂师、核对处方的医生以及处理预先授权的保险支付方。 (2:28) 传统IVR利用死板的树状结构解决了约70%的基础查询,但这迫使呼叫者像机器一样说话,而无法自然表达。 (4:09) 规模化应用生成式语音AI带来了关于实时延迟、合规性、领域术语以及需要本地GPU托管以控制成本等重大技术挑战。 (4:09) 在尝试了硬编码限制和微调后,CVS发现将模型与严格的检索增强生成(RAG)相结合解决了80%的安全护栏问题。 (7:24)

Reading summary

Deploying voice AI across CVS Health's massive retail footprint requires shifting from rigid call-containment metrics to clinical task completion, supported by low-latency infrastructure and pragmatic retrieval architectures. CVS Health's Yogesh Bhagat and Deepgram's Kris Efland explain how generative voice systems are evolving to handle hundreds of millions of patient inquiries and alleviate administrative burdens on pharmacists. The Operational Scale of Healthcare Voice Systems (0:04) CVS Health operates at a national scale that includes more than 9,000 retail locations, processing 1 billion prescriptions and handling over 400 million inbound calls each year. Serving 185 million unique customers—more than half the U.S. population—the pharmacy network relies on voice as its primary communication channel for patients, store-to-store coordination, doctor consultations, and insurance prior authorizations. Legacy Interactive Voice Response (IVR) systems resolved approximately 70% of customer inquiries, but only through rigid, menu-driven trees. Bhagat notes that these legacy systems forced callers to adapt their speech to machine constraints. Transitioning to conversational models post-2022 was designed to allow patients to express complex, unscripted healthcare questions naturally while ensuring high-value clinical interactions remain prioritized for human pharmacists. Infrastructure Bottlenecks and the RAG Learning Curve (7:24) Moving from demonstration models to an enterprise production environment exposed immediate engineering hurdles. Conversational voice demands sub-second latency, which led CVS to bypass third-party cloud API bottlenecks by deploying dedicated GPUs within on-premise colocation environments to host proprietary Large Language Models (LLMs) and Large Speech Language Models (LSLMs). Architectural design required iterative calibration. Engineering teams initially over-controlled models with hardcoded response options, which failed against diverse consumer phrasing, before swinging toward unconstrained models that produced out-of-context answers. CVS resolved this tension by implementing strict guardrails paired with Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG). Bhagat states that roughly 80% of enterprise deployment challenges were solved using simple RAG pipelines rather than complex model distillation or fine-tuning. Replacing Deflection Metrics with Clinical Task Completion (9:55) Adopting generative voice prompted CVS to abandon traditional call-center metrics like containment rate—which measured how many callers were prevented from reaching staff—and low Average Handle Time (AHT). Under the new framework, longer call durations are viewed positively if a caller resolves multiple non-clinical inquiries in a single interaction. Success is now tracked through task completion and downstream healthcare actions taken by patients. The strategic goal of automating administrative, non-clinical phone traffic is to return time to pharmacists, allowing them to focus on direct, in-person patient consultations and clinical care. Acoustic Intelligence and Outbound Agent Automation (14:18) To handle conversational speech dynamics, Deepgram's technical roadmap targets round-trip processing latencies below 500 to 800 milliseconds. While most production systems still use cascaded pipelines (speech-to-text, LLM, and text-to-speech) to preserve backend control, fused models like Deepgram's Flux are designed to detect natural turn-taking, allow user interruptions, and introduce adaptive grace periods when callers pause while reading items like prescription numbers. Kris Efland highlights that preserving raw acoustic features—such as pitch, tone, and inflection—enables models to detect caller distress and adjust responses accordingly. Looking forward, CVS plans to deploy outbound voice agents capable of calling external insurance and provider IVR systems, waiting on hold, and resolving administrative tasks directly to eliminate manual phone time for pharmacy staff. As voice AI transitions from inbound patient support to outbound administrative tasks and multimodal interfaces, enterprises must balance domain-specific context with low-latency execution, ensuring automated workflows resolve operational bottlenecks without compromising clinical safety.

精炼阅读摘要

CVS Health与Deepgram的技术负责人指出,在年处理10亿张处方与4亿通入站电话的超大规模医疗体系中,语音AI的核心价值在于接管繁琐的行政事务以释放药剂师的面对面临床精力;企业正通过检索增强生成与专属算力架构,推动语音系统从传统机械拦截转向以临床结果为导向的智能交互。 超大规模医疗网络中的语音枢纽价值 (0:04) CVS Health数字与技术副总裁Yogesh Bhagat指出,CVS不仅是社区零售药店,更是覆盖Aetna保险、Caremark医药福利管理、MinuteClinic及9000余家门店的庞大医疗实体。全美超过50%的人口(1.85亿独立客户)接受其服务,85%的美国居民生活在距离其门店10英里范围内。在此体量下,CVS零售门店每年承接超过4亿通入站来电,年均调配并分发处方药达10亿张。 Bhagat强调,语音在整个医疗生态中承担着不可替代的协作功能。除承接患者咨询外,数千家药店之间的跨店协同、药剂师针对处方安全及疑难向主治医生核实、以及向保险支付方确认预先授权等关键流程,均长期深度依赖电话语音网络。引入AI的根本目的并非单纯替代人工,而是通过自动化常规沟通,将药剂师从重复性沟通中解脱出来,聚焦于高质量的患者面对面临床诊疗。 从机械式IVR到企业级低延迟基础设施 (4:09) 回顾技术演进,Bhagat表示传统交互式语音应答(IVR)虽能依靠预设菜单树解决约70%的固定基础咨询,却强迫人类像机器一样通过按键或刻板指令进行交流,无法支持自然表达与跨节点跳转。2022年生成式AI的爆发打破了这一桎梏,使自然语言对话成为可能,但将其转化为企业级生产系统也带来了严苛的工程挑战。 面对公有云演示与大规模落地的落差,CVS搭建了基于专用GPU的本地托管算力环境,以运行自研大语言模型与语音大模型。此举旨在规避第三方API调用带来的不可控成本激增,并将语音交互端到端响应压缩至亚秒级,以契合即时通话的自然节奏。同时,工程团队必须在底层攻克医疗行业专有术语识别、幻觉抑制、监管合规以及模型偏见等工程难题。 架构试错经验:以严格检索增强生成约束边界 (7:24) 在语音AI的架构落地过程中,CVS经历了一条清晰的学习曲线。早期工程团队试图对提示词输出设定高度具体的选项限制,但很快发现用户提问的边界几乎是无限的,死板预设无法奏效;随后放松约束又导致模型脱离上下文随意作答。最终,团队通过引入严格的检索增强生成(RAG)管道,成功将大模型的参数解空间限制在安全知识库内。 Bhagat总结认为,在经历模型蒸馏、微调和复杂的定制训练试验后,团队发现80%的企业实际问题仅需一个稳健的简单RAG应用即可有效解决,盲目投入高成本的模型再训练或蒸馏在多数业务场景下并无必要。精准的检索检索边界与工程护栏构成了语音智能体在医疗严谨场景下稳定运行的核心支柱。 运营指标重构:从降低通话时长转向健康成效 (9:55) 随着生成式语音智能体的上线,CVS工程与运营团队彻底重构了考核指标。在传统IVR时代,系统成败完全取决于“拦截率”(即阻止用户接入人工坐席的比例)和“平均处理时长”(AHT)的极限压缩,技术本质上被当作消极的成本控制工具。 在新范式下,这些旧指标已被淘汰。现在的首要评估标准是“非临床任务的完整闭环率”,即评估患者诉求是否在语音平台内一次性彻底解决;同时,平均处理时长不再以越短越好为标准,如果患者花费4分钟咨询了三项关键健康事务并获得详尽解答,长通话体现的是高服务价值而非低效。最终的成功标准已转向患者实际完成的医疗保健行为与临床健康结果。 外呼自动化协同与声学情绪智能演进 (14:18) 在未来规划上,Bhagat提出CVS正在开发面向外部系统的主动外呼智能体。药剂师目前在向外部保险机构或处方医生核实信息时需耗费大量时间排队等待,外呼AI将自主拨号、导航外部机构的IVR系统并在人工接入前驻留排队,代为解决行政冲突。同时,未来的多模态交互将实现语音与视觉界面的动态联动。 Deepgram工程副总裁Kris Efland补充指出,实时语音要求双向延迟低于500至800毫秒。Deepgram推出的Flux融合模型通过原生处理语音动态,实现了自适应中断与宽限期设计——例如当患者因视力模糊停顿拼读处方号时,系统能动态等待而不强行切断。更重要的是,端到端架构保留了传统文本转录所丢失的语调、音高和情感等声学特征,使智能体具备感知患者焦虑情绪并主动调整语气进行安抚的情商能力。 CVS与Deepgram的实践证明,语音AI在大规模医疗企业的价值在于重塑专业人力的分配结构并提升端到端解决率。然而,如何使外呼智能体更可靠地应对复杂的外部机构交互,并在降低计算延迟的同时全面推广保留声学情绪特征的模型架构,仍是整个行业在深入推进时面临的长期工程课题。

Detailed notes — zh

## Background 本内容由频道 Ai4 于 2026 年 8 月 22 日在 YouTube 平台发布。视频记录了 CVS Health 数字化与技术副总裁 Yogesh Bhagat 与 Deepgram 工程副总裁 Kris Efland 的炉边对谈,探讨 CVS 如何摆脱传统僵化的菜单式 IVR,构建应对复杂医疗合规场景的企业级语音 AI 平台,并推动语音交互从单纯的事务处理转向智能化的医疗健康服务入口。 ## TL;DR 对谈围绕 CVS Health 在全美年处理 10 亿张处方和 4 亿次药房呼叫的超大规模背景下,如何运用生成式语音 AI 重塑患者沟通体验展开。CVS 分享了从传统按键树状 IVR 转向自建私有 GPU 算力集群并结合 RAG 架构与安全护栏的工程实践,总结出 80% 业务场景仅需标准 RAG 配合严格约束即可高效落地的实战结论。双方还探讨了重新定义平均通话时长(AHT)等业务评估指标、从承接入站电话拓展到自动化出站呼叫的演化路径,以及借助亚秒级低延迟、端到端语音和情绪感知模型(如 Flux)实现多模态深度医疗照护的未来图景。 ## Atmosphere & style 整个对谈呈现出务实、深入且充满行业洞见的专业极客氛围,两位工程高管在技术探讨与业务落地之间自如切换。Yogesh Bhagat 以幽默风趣的语言(如自称职责是“确保大家的药瓶永远装满药”)拉近了严肃医疗工程与听众的距离,同时坦率反思了早期对生成式 AI 的过度乐观与工程踩坑经验;Kris Efland 则从底层模型与声学演进视角补充前沿洞察,双方配合默契,将前沿 AI 技术与关乎民生的大健康实际运营结合得极具画面感与感染力。 ## Key takeaways - [00:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=4s) CVS Health 是整合了保险(Aetna)、药品福利管理(Caremark)、诊所和 9000 多家药房的综合医疗集团,年配发 10 亿张处方并承接 4 亿次门店电话,服务超 50% 美国人口。 - [02:28](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=148s) 语音是人类最本能的第一顺位沟通形态,也是维系药剂师、医生、保险公司及患者之间复杂医疗协作的核心纽带。 - [04:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=244s) 传统 IVR 的树状菜单强迫人类像机器一样说话且无法跨节点跳转,生成式 AI 的引入彻底打破了刻板层级限制,实现了自然多轮对话。 - [04:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=244s) 面对公有云延迟和成本压力,CVS 在自建机房部署私有 GPU 算力集群托管 LLM/SLM,以应对高吞吐与严苛的医疗合规要求。 - [07:24](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=444s) 落地工程实践表明,80% 的生产业务场景仅需构建良好的 RAG 架构配合严格的业务护栏即可稳定解决,无需盲目进行全量微调与二次训练。 - [09:55](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=595s) 生成式语音上线后颠覆了传统呼叫中心指标,更长的平均通话时长(AHT)反而是正向指标,代表患者对智能体的信任与复杂任务的端到端闭环。 - [12:02](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=722s) 语音 AI 下一阶段竞争的核心在于全知型上下文理解,深度融合医保处方集、临床方案和患者病史以实现全方位智能照护。 - [14:18](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=858s) 未来交互形态将演化为语音与视觉界面的多模态协同(如钢铁侠与贾维斯),实现语音表达意图与界面的实时联动渲染。 - [14:18](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=858s) CVS 正在从承接入站呼叫演进到打造出站语音智能体(Agent-to-Agent),由 AI 自主呼叫外部保险与诊所 IVR 协商解决预先授权等繁琐事务。 - [17:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=1021s) 自然对话要求端到端往返延迟控制在 500-800 毫秒内,结合 Deepgram Flux 架构可实现动态轮流发言、情绪捕捉及流式后台工具调用。 ## Detailed walkthrough ### [00:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=4s) 嘉宾介绍与 CVS Health 的庞大规模 对谈由 Deepgram 工程副总裁克里斯·埃夫兰(Kris Efland)与 CVS Health 数字化与技术副总裁约格什·巴加特(Yogesh Bhagat)共同开启。约格什风趣地介绍自己的核心职责就是“确保大家的药瓶永远装满药”,他带领团队负责 CVS 处方配药系统背后的所有数字化与技术支撑,而语音正是其中极为关键的触达渠道。克里斯则介绍,Deepgram 作为语音 AI 基础模型提供商,不仅为展厅内绝大多数企业提供底层语音转文字(STT)和文字转语音(TTS)能力,还推出了全栈语音智能体(Voice Agent)产品。 在阐述 CVS Health 的业务版图时,约格什打破了公众将其仅视为“街角便民药房”的固有印象。CVS Health 实际上是全球最大的综合医疗健康集团之一,旗下整合了大型商业保险机构安泰(Aetna)、药品福利管理(PBM)巨头 Caremark、遍布社区的 MinuteClinic 诊所、家庭照护评估机构 Signify Health,以及超过 9,000 家线下实体药房。 ```mermaid flowchart TD accTitle: CVS Health 业务生态与服务规模架构图 accDescription: 展示 CVS Health 旗下业务板块及其覆盖的全美医疗规模数据 subgraph Business["CVS Health 核心业务生态"] Aetna["Aetna 医疗保险"] Caremark["Caremark 药品福利管理 (PBM)"] Clinics["MinuteClinic 与 Signify Health"] Stores["9,000+ 线下实体药房"] end subgraph Scale["全美超大规模运营指标"] Prescriptions["每年接收并配发 10 亿张处方"] Calls["门店每年承接 4 亿+ 语音通话"] Reach["服务 1.85 亿独立客户(超全美 50% 人口)"] Coverage["85% 的美国人口居住在门店 10 英里范围内"] end Business --> Scale ``` - **处方交付量**:年处理并配发处方量高达 10 亿张。 - **语音呼叫量**:全国线下门店每年接听超过 4 亿次客户电话。 - **人群覆盖率**:全业务线服务 1.85 亿独立客户(占全美总人口 50% 以上),85% 的美国人口生活在距离 CVS 门店 10 英里以内的区域。 - **核心价值定位**:海量数据指标背后,最核心的依然是药剂师与患者之间数以百万计的“一对一深度互动”,这才是决定医疗健康成效(Health Outcomes)的根本所在。 --- ### [02:28](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=148s) 语音渠道在医疗生态中的不可替代性 当克里斯问及为何在生成式 AI 爆发前语音就已是 CVS 的命脉时,约格什从人类演化史的视角切入。他认为语音不仅对企业至关重要,更是人类物种自狩猎采集时代以来最本能、第一顺位的沟通形态——无论是发出警报信号还是传递日常诉求,语音始终居于主导地位。 聚焦到 CVS 的业务现实,每年有超过 4 亿通电话打入药房,面对如此庞大的习惯使用语音的用户群体,企业的责任就是“在用户期望交流的地方与他们相遇”。为此,CVS 早在 AI 浪潮之前就重金布局,部署了数百台传统语音服务器。此外,药房内外的协作高度依赖语音:全美 9,000 多家门店药剂师之间的即时协作、为确保处方安全和准时交付而与医生沟通预先授权(Prior Authorization)与安全澄清,以及与保险公司核实报销细则,整个医疗生态系统的运转都在靠语音纽带维系。 --- ### [04:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=244s) 传统 IVR 的技术瓶颈与生成式 AI 的范式转变 回顾 2022 年秋季生成式 AI 爆发前的系统,约格什坦言,当时的传统预测型语音系统虽然也能解决约 70% 的客户常规咨询,但其底层逻辑完全依赖刻板的树状交互菜单(IVR Tree)。用户在致电时必须遵从“按 1 查状态,按 2 选续方”的层级路径一步步向下跳转。一旦进入某个叶子节点,用户就无法自由横向切换话题,词汇选择受到极其严苛的限制,这种交互本质上是在“强迫人类像机器一样说话,以此换取系统回应”。 2022 年底生成式 AI 的登场彻底颠覆了这种机器主导的交互形式。人类终于能够以自然、富有情感表达的方式与系统对话,并获得连贯准确的反馈。然而,从观看早期演示视频时的惊艳——“当时我甚至觉得所有技术都要被彻底重塑,连人类员工都不再需要了”——到落地到生产环境,团队迎面撞上了严酷的工程与医疗合规现实: ```mermaid flowchart LR accTitle: 传统 IVR 与生成式 AI 语音智能体对比 accDescription: 传统菜单树状结构与现代生成式语音架构的对比演进 subgraph Legacy["传统 IVR 模式"] L1["固定菜单按键 (按1/按2)"] --> L2["单向层级树状节点"] L2 --> L3["人类被迫像机器一样表达"] end subgraph GenAI["生成式 AI 语音智能体"] G1["自然语音与多轮表达"] --> G2["私有算力托管 + SLM/LLM"] G2 --> G3["RAG 检索增强 + 医疗护栏"] G3 --> G4["拟人化动态解答与业务闭环"] end ``` - **端到端延迟与成本压制**:实时语音交互对延迟极为敏感,公有云 API 的调用开销与网络抖动难以承受。CVS 为此在自建机房(Colocation)部署专用 GPU 算力集群,自主托管大语言模型(LLM)与小语言模型(SLM),从而在压降延迟的同时控制巨额的基础设施成本。 - **医疗级严谨性挑战**:针对幻觉(Hallucination)、监管合规、多语言支持及算法偏见等问题,团队经历了反复试错、失败与迭代,最终构建出一套兼具高吞吐与严安全边界的企业级技术底座。 --- ### [07:24](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=444s) 落地决策与技术选型:为什么 80% 的场景只需简单 RAG 推动 CVS 全力押注语音 AI 的核心驱动力,在于彻底将一线药剂师从繁琐的非临床事务中解脱出来。约格什强调,药剂师最核心的价值是为到店和致电的患者提供专业用药指导与临床建议;如果能让智能体高效消化掉所有常规性咨询,并把提炼后的上下文无缝交接给药房员工,就能免去重复询问,极大节省医患双方的时间。 在探索落地架构的过程中,工程师团队经历了一次从“过度控制”到“寻找平衡”的认知转变: ```mermaid flowchart TD accTitle: AI 架构实践演进与工程经验总结 accDescription: 展示从硬编码控制到大模型幻觉,再到最终确立以 RAG 为核心的演化路径 Step1["阶段一:工程师思维硬编码<br/>试图强行限制用户选项"] --> Step2["现实碰撞:用户提问千奇百怪<br/>穷举规则迅速失效"] Step2 --> Step3["阶段二:全面放开大模型生成<br/>缺乏上下文导致脱轨与幻觉回答"] Step3 --> Step4["阶段三:确立工程最优解<br/>收敛模型发散度 + 结合 RAG 检索增强与护栏"] ``` 团队曾尝试过模型蒸馏(Distilled Models)、全量微调(Fine-Tuning)与外挂检索等多种技术路径。最终得出的关键工程结论是:在真实的生产级业务场景中,**80% 的问题只需要一个设计精良的 RAG(检索增强生成)架构,配合严格的业务护栏(Guardrails)来约束 AI 的发散边界,便足以稳定解决**,而无需一开始就陷入复杂的模型二次训练与蒸馏陷阱。 --- ### [09:55](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=595s) 业务成效重塑:颠覆“平均通话时长”衡量标准 系统正式上线运营后,CVS 彻底推翻了传统呼叫中心的成功评估体系。在过去的传统 IVR 时代,业务团队紧盯的核心量化指标是“呼叫遏制率/拦截率”(Call Containment Rate)和“平均处理时长”(Average Handle Time, AHT),传统的运营逻辑认为 AHT 越短说明效率越高。 而在引入生成式语音智能体后,衡量的维度全面转向了高质量的质化与结果指标: - **核心评估转向任务完成度**:关注系统究竟帮助患者回答了多少实质性问题、在语音渠道内端到端闭环了多少非临床任务。 - **重新定义通话时长价值**:过去的 AHT 缩短是因为系统机械引导;现在,**更长的平均通话时长反而是正向指标**,因为这代表着患者信任智能体,愿意在一次交互中提出多项诉求并获得完整解答。 - **回归临床与健康成效**:评价核心从单纯的“运营成本节约”升维至“是否推动了积极的患者健康行动与临床治疗成效”。 --- ### [12:02](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=722s) 语音 AI 的产业跨越与医疗深水区 针对生成式 AI 对整个语音行业的冲击,克里斯结合 Deepgram 过去十年的深耕经验指出,行业在过去一年中已经跨越了自然度的鸿沟。以往用户面对冰冷机械音时总在自我怀疑“机器人有没有听懂我”、“我是不是用词不规范”,而如今合成语音与真人的质感差异已微乎其微,行业彻底迈入了真正拟人化的交互阶段。 克里斯进一步指出,语音 AI 下一阶段的竞争核心在于**深层上下文理解(Context)**。当语音智能体能够全知且实时地融会贯通以下要素时,整个医疗交互体验将迎来质的飞跃: - **医保处方集(Formulary)规则** - **针对性的临床治疗方案(Treatment Plan)** - **患者完整的既往病史与用药档案** 这种全知型上下文让系统从简单的事务性问答迈向全方位的智能照护,也标志着业界正在从渐进式修补真正迈入《星际迷航》(Star Trek)般的科幻现实。 --- ### [14:18](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=858s) 未来图景:多模态协同与智能体对撞(Agent-to-Agent) 在展望未来产品演进时,约格什引用了自己热爱的漫威电影中钢铁侠与智能管家贾维斯(JARVIS)的交互场景。他指出,未来的交互绝不是孤立的纯语音或纯图形,而是“语音 + 视觉界面”的无缝协同——用户一边通过语音向移动端应用表达意图,界面一边实时渲染匹配的数据面板与操作步骤。 在战术与运营层面,CVS 制定了明确的分步走战略,重点攻克全美医疗生态中繁重的协作壁垒: ```mermaid flowchart LR accTitle: CVS 语音 AI 演进路线图:从入站呼叫到智能体对外交互 accDescription: 展示从当前 4 亿次入站呼叫承接,拓展到未来全自动出站智能体与外部机构 IVR 对接的路线 subgraph Phase1["第一阶段:承接入站呼叫(当前已落地)"] P1["应对 4 亿+ 门店入站呼叫"] --> P2["解决常规咨询 & 解放药剂师时间"] end subgraph Phase2["第二阶段:出站自动化(当前研发重点)"] A1["CVS 出站语音智能体"] -->|自动拨打并交互| A2["保险公司/诊所外部 IVR"] A2 -->|自主协商与数据核验| A3["自动解决预先授权与处方争议"] end Phase1 -.-> Phase2 ``` - **第一阶段(已闭环)**:优先攻克年均 4 亿次来自终端患者的入站(Inbound)电话,保障基础用药咨询的自动化。 - **第二阶段(正在推进中)**:构建**出站语音智能体(Outbound Voice Agents)**。药剂师以往需要拨打数百万次外部电话给医生诊所和保险公司,常年耗费在漫长的转接等待与对方繁琐的 IVR 菜单中。CVS 正在打造自动化出站智能体,实现由内部 AI 智能体直接呼叫并“对话”外部机构的 IVR,在后台自主协商解决预先授权争议,彻底将药剂师的时间还给患者。 --- ### [17:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=1021s) 技术前沿:亚秒级实时性、端到端语音与情绪感知 克里斯深入解析了构建下一代自然语音交互背后的前沿架构。要实现流畅的人机对话,从用户语音输入、经过大模型推理再到语音合成输出的完整往返延迟(Round-trip Latency)必须严格控制在 **500 至 800 毫秒以内**,否则人类交流的节奏感就会被彻底破坏。 针对当前行业热议的“语音到语音”(Speech-to-Speech)技术,克里斯直言,目前业内绝大多数方案本质上仍是“级联式架构”(即 STT $\to$ LLM $\to$ TTS 的管道分解),真正的纯端到端 S2S 仍在演进之中。为此,Deepgram 研发了名为 **Flux** 的融合架构模型,在对话动力学与多模态理解上取得了关键突破: - **动态轮流发言(Turn Taking)与插话控制**:当患者在电话中阅读处方编号时,可能由于没戴老花镜而语速放慢或短暂卡顿,Flux 模型能够智能识别出“对方正在读数”,从而给予更多等待宽限,而不会生硬地插话打断。 - **保留声音维度的深层信息**:传统的语音转文字会剥离一切声学特征。以单词“Hello”为例,不同的语调蕴含着截然不同的情绪状态。端到端语音能精准捕捉语调起伏、犹豫与沮丧情绪,赋予 AI 丰富的情绪智能(Emotional Intelligence)与情境感知力,从而在患者焦虑时主动采取安抚话术。 - **流式后台工具调用(Background Tool Calling)**:借助 Flux 模型,系统可以在患者刚说出某个药物名称或关键指令的瞬间,立即在后台异步触发数据库检索与接口调用,实现极速响应的“AI 礼宾级体验”。 约格什对此表示高度认同,认为这种融合了情绪智能、极低延迟与后台工具联动的语音交互,正是 CVS 正在全力推进落地的医疗数字化现实。 ### [20:29](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=1229s) 问答环节与会议结语 对谈圆满结束,讲者向现场观众致谢并开放了提问环节。他们表示团队随时欢迎参会者提出任何疑问,并鼓励大家在会后继续交流与深入探讨语音 AI 在医疗健康领域的落地经验与技术细节。 - 讲者向全场观众致意,并在结束发言时感谢所有参会者的聆听与支持。 - 现场开放互动问答与后续交流,欢迎对 CVS 与 Deepgram 合作实践感兴趣的观众进一步咨询。 ## Notable quotes > [00:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=4s) 确保大家的药瓶永远装满药 — 约格什·巴加特 (Yogesh Bhagat) > [02:28](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=148s) 在用户期望交流的地方与他们相遇 — 约格什·巴加特 (Yogesh Bhagat) > [04:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=244s) 强迫人类像机器一样说话,以此换取系统回应 — 约格什·巴加特 (Yogesh Bhagat) > [04:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=244s) 当时我甚至觉得所有技术都要被彻底重塑,连人类员工都不再需要了 — 约格什·巴加特 (Yogesh Bhagat) > [07:24](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=444s) 80% 的问题只需要一个设计精良的 RAG(检索增强生成)架构,配合严格的业务护栏(Guardrails)来约束 AI 的发散边界,便足以稳定解决 — 约格什·巴加特 (Yogesh Bhagat) > [09:55](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=595s) 更长的平均通话时长反而是正向指标 — 约格什·巴加特 (Yogesh Bhagat) > [14:18](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=858s) 语音 + 视觉界面 — 约格什·巴加特 (Yogesh Bhagat) > [17:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=1021s) 500 至 800 毫秒以内 — 克里斯·埃夫兰 (Kris Efland) > [17:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI&t=1021s) AI 礼宾级体验 — 克里斯·埃夫兰 (Kris Efland) ## Mentioned CVS Health, Deepgram, Yogesh Bhagat (约格什·巴加特), Kris Efland (克里斯·埃夫兰), Aetna (安泰), Caremark, MinuteClinic, Signify Health, Flux 模型, JARVIS (贾维斯), 漫威 (Marvel), 《星际迷航》 (Star Trek), Ai4 ## Video description Yogesh Bhagat — Vice President, Pharmacy Technology Ecosystem, CVS Health Kris Efland — VP of Engineering, Deepgram CVS operates voice at national scale—across pharmacy, payer, provider, and retail—where every channel decision is an access and operations decision. In this fireside chat, CVS shares how it moved beyond rigid, menu-driven IVR to an enterprise-grade voice platform built for the complexity and compliance of healthcare: the approach to the build, the outcomes that matter most (higher containment, better task completion, reduced friction), and what comes next. The bigger shift is from voice as a transactional IVR to an intelligent, conversational front door to healthcare—and CVS is showing what it takes to operationalize that at scale. Hosted by Deepgram. Featuring Yogesh Bhagat, Vice President Digital and Technology, in conversation with Kris Efland, VP of Engineering, Deepgram [Source](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX__oeGAxPI)

Source quotes

[0:04] 约格什·巴加特 (Yogesh Bhagat): 确保大家的药瓶永远装满药 [2:28] 约格什·巴加特 (Yogesh Bhagat): 在用户期望交流的地方与他们相遇 [4:04] 约格什·巴加特 (Yogesh Bhagat): 强迫人类像机器一样说话,以此换取系统回应 [4:04] 约格什·巴加特 (Yogesh Bhagat): 当时我甚至觉得所有技术都要被彻底重塑,连人类员工都不再需要了 [7:24] 约格什·巴加特 (Yogesh Bhagat): 80% 的问题只需要一个设计精良的 RAG(检索增强生成)架构,配合严格的业务护栏(Guardrails)来约束 AI 的发散边界,便足以稳定解决 [9:55] 约格什·巴加特 (Yogesh Bhagat): 更长的平均通话时长反而是正向指标 [14:18] 约格什·巴加特 (Yogesh Bhagat): 语音 + 视觉界面 [17:01] 克里斯·埃夫兰 (Kris Efland): 500 至 800 毫秒以内 [17:01] 克里斯·埃夫兰 (Kris Efland): AI 礼宾级体验

Source quotes

[0:04] Yogesh Bhagat: keeping your prescription bottle filled [4:09] Yogesh Bhagat: humans were forced to talk like machines so that we can get our answers [7:24] Yogesh Bhagat: 80% of the time, just a simple RAG application solves your problem instead of thinking about distillation or model training [12:02] Kris Efland: Star Trek land

Original transcript

[0:04] All right, Yogesh. Good to see you. Why don't  you introduce yourself a little bit and I'll [0:08] uh Yogesh Pagat, VP of digital and technology  at CVS Health 100. What am I responsible for? [0:17] I'm the one who keeps your prescription bottle  filled. Uh so as part of that me and my team [0:24] take care of all the digital and technical  aspects of pharmacy dispensing system and [0:30] voice is an important channel. We are here to  talk about or discuss about voice how voice [0:35] impacts pharmacy. Hi everyone. I'm Chris  Effand. I run engineering at Deepgram. Uh [0:41] we provide the foundational AI voice AI models  for most of the companies on the show floor. [0:48] Uh we power everything from speech to text, text  to speech as well as our own voice agent products [0:55] which we're going to talk about today. So set  the table for us. CVS is a huge operation and [1:00] probably people don't know a lot about it. So kind  of tell us how it works. Well for most of you CVS [1:08] might be the community pharmacy near to you CVS  store. That's how people know about CVS Health. [1:13] But the reality is CVS is pretty big in and  one of the largest healthcare company in the [1:18] world. It comprises of Etna which is a healthcare  insurance Kmark which is the PBM multiple clinics [1:28] minute clinic signify and then finally 9,000 plus  pharmacy locations. Well to understand the scale [1:38] just to give you the idea of what is the scale  we are talking about I'll give you few insights. [1:43] A we receive 1 billion prescriptions and fill  1 billion prescription in a year. We receive [1:51] 400 million plus calls every year in our stores.  We serve 185 million unique customers across all [2:01] lines of business which is more than a 50% of  US population. 85% of the US population lives [2:09] within the 10 miles of CVS store. While these  numbers are important, but the most important [2:15] thing for us for a health outcome is that millions  of one-on-one interaction which our pharmacists do [2:22] with a customer and that's what drives health  outcomes. So I hope that explains. Yeah. No, [2:28] that's great. So you know obviously before AI was  even in the picture or even in the discussion, [2:34] you know, voice is a hugely critical channel for  you, not just for your patients but operations as [2:41] well. So can you talk a little bit about  the criticality of voice? Well that's an [2:46] interesting question. I don't know whether it is  critical only for us. Uh for me as a human as a [2:53] species the first interaction which first way of  communication for us right from the hunter gather [2:59] times whether it was emergency signal quack- quack  or anything we want to have that was a voice. So [3:05] voice has been a leading communication way for  us. Now coming to your point about CVS pharmacy, [3:13] we have a huge customer segment. There are  customers as I said 400 million plus calls coming [3:19] who are interested in talking to us via voice. So  it's our job to meet where they want us to be and [3:26] we have invested heavily in voice infrastructure  and we have like hundreds of voice servers [3:32] traditionally even before AI came in and similarly  our pharmacist across 9,000 stores talk to each [3:40] other that's a voice what technology they use  does not matter. Last but not the least to serve [3:47] the prescriptions or to fill the prescriptions  safely and timely we need to talk with entire [3:53] healthcare ecosystem. Our pharmacist need to talk  to doctor for prior authorization sometimes the [3:58] clarification safety we need to talk to insurance  companies. So all these things together voice [4:04] is the way to solve too many problems. Yeah. So  obviously you know October the fall of 22 was a [4:14] you know watershed moment for the industry. We  were went from the you know the predictive AI [4:18] to the generative AI and you weren't necessarily  waiting for that uh to show up. So like what did [4:23] the what did your infrastructure look like before  and like what were the limits you were hitting you [4:28] were running up into? So well it's an interesting  question. uh let's understand we were able to [4:37] solve even with before generative AI we were able  to solve 70% of the customer queries everything [4:44] customer asked to us through a voice channels we  were able to solve but what kind of a questions [4:49] it was simple questions let's understand go back  into the technology what we were using how does it [4:56] work any traditional IVR how it works is it takes  you into a tree structure If you ever have talked, [5:04] hey, choose option one, option two, option three,  option four. It's a tree structure. You go down [5:10] the hill, you reach one node and you are answering  the question. But we are human. We want to talk [5:17] and ask other question. But you can't because  going from one node to other node is not possible. [5:22] The choice of words for which which is available  which you are limited. Mhm. So in short, we humans [5:29] were forced to talk like machines so that we can  get our answers. What changed in 2022 is all about [5:38] it's no longer we are talking like machines. We  could have talked like a humans. We can show our [5:45] expressions. We can talk we like and we still get  an answer. So that to me was a big change. But [5:53] honestly every change come with the challenge. It  was not easy for us. Day one when you look at it, [6:03] it looks very easy. I was watching one video of  open AI those days saying asking question and [6:10] it was so fluent. I was like man why do we need  even people to now the whole technology will be [6:14] changed. But as soon as you go into it, there  are a lot of challenges which you see latency [6:22] in the real world is a real challenge. The cost  infrastructure like in our case, we had to set [6:28] up our own colo environment to have GPUs, deploy  our own LLMs, LSLMs to resolve both latency and [6:36] the problem of all this cost structure otherwise  we would have hit. Then you have hallucination, [6:44] regulations, the language, biasness, all those  things are not easy to solve. So those things you [6:53] have to think first you have to build a platform  which can serve. So whatever we build with this [6:58] also it was not about one day it worked. We went  into multiple iteration. We failed, we learned, [7:08] we improved. So important piece in that was more  about with voice AI or genai is all about how you [7:17] learn and how you evolve. That's to me is the how  change with voice. Yeah. So what was the deciding [7:24] factor that really you know you said you iterated  made some mistakes obviously everyone does but [7:30] like what was the deciding factor that you know  made you decide to go allin right and and honestly [7:35] what did it take to get there? See deciding factor  was again we knew where the limitation of where [7:44] we were asking our customer and now here is a  technology which could have done it. So we were [7:50] looking at can we solve or give more power in  hands of consumer so they don't ask nonclinical [7:58] questions to our colleagues. As I said at the  start of the call, what's most important in the [8:04] pharmacy ecosystem is the local pharmacist is able  to provide time to the customer who is coming, [8:11] able to talk to them, provide that kind of  clinical guidance that makes a difference. [8:17] So that was a big deal for us to give time to our  pharmacist then allowing customer to get they can [8:25] ask more questions and passing that information  to our our colleagues in more meaningful way so [8:32] they don't ask the same question again and save  the time. So it was a combination of that which [8:36] forc us to move in all in. Now coming to the  learning it was a interesting thing. We all are [8:43] engineers we are humans. So we start with having  a control over it. Let's limit and let if this [8:51] question is being asked we will only give these  particular options to the consumer and we very [8:56] soon realize there is endless number of questions  which consumer can ask. So we had to learn and we [9:02] have to give up that thing that we can control  few things. M when we did that we went on the [9:08] other extend questions were asked we didn't have  the context and AI was answering the questions [9:15] which it should not have answered so you need  to build the guardrails you need to reduce the [9:20] I call it as a brain power of a AI give a rack  to it and say please respond within this limits [9:27] so those are the things which we learned I believe  we tried distilled distilled models We tried model [9:36] training, rag everything and summary of it is if  you really want to build real world application [9:43] most of the time 80% of the time just a simple  rag application solves your problem instead [9:49] of thinking about distl or any kind of a model  training that's an important feature to me. So, [9:55] you're live, right? Congratulations. What is  what is the outcomes you're actually looking [10:01] looking for and what do they look like today  and and kind of where are you going? You know, [10:08] it's an interesting question in many ways.  As I said, when we were in traditional IVR, [10:16] culturally, we were thinking as this way. What  was a coal containment rate? How many calls have [10:22] we contained? What was the average handle time of  a call? That's how we used to measure a success of [10:28] a IVR. Once you go into this voice AI agent, your  definition of success change now you need to talk [10:37] in terms of how many questions were we able to  answer, how many nonclinical task we were able to [10:43] do within the voice system. So that it doesn't  need to be anything else. the agent is doing [10:49] everything for it and the whole gimmick around  average handle time actually changed completely. [10:57] Earlier you were thinking about average handle  time being less is good because you are dealing [11:02] with one two three. Now sometimes average handle  time being more is good because consumer is able [11:09] to ask multiple questions and they get the  answers. So for us that was a big change. [11:15] what we started measuring is real clinical  outcomes, health outcomes and what actions [11:21] consumer can do instead of just looking at as an  operational savings measure. So that's to me is a [11:28] change for us. Yeah. in moving from you know the  surface level quantitative metric or metrics to [11:36] qualitative metrics is a huge jump and I think you  know moving into agents you really have to have [11:42] an understanding in terms of what's going on and  what's happening and I think that you're starting [11:47] to measure what the actual experience is as  opposed to just like hey did the you know what's [11:52] our call volume look like right it's it's very  surface level but it doesn't really give you the [11:56] deep insight that I think you're you're looking  at Now yes that said let me ask you what do you [12:02] think about how the generative AI has impacted  overall voice industry how do you what changes [12:08] you have seen so you know deep been doing this for  a decade um and obviously we've been very adamant [12:17] about the the future of voice I think anyone in  here who's spent any time watching any sort of [12:22] sci-fi as a child you know we have all had dreams  of interacting with technology with our voices [12:27] um I think you know within the last year we've  really crossed crossed the the chasm in terms of [12:36] naturalness and you know a really much more human  experience as opposed to you know talking with a [12:44] robot trying to figure out did they understand me  or you didn't understand what I asked or maybe I [12:50] didn't use the right word that they got picked  up on. So, I think we we've really we're we're [12:55] very much in the in the human experience phase of  this, right? It's very very hard now to tell the [13:01] difference between a human and and some of the the  synthetic voices that we're able to generate. Um, [13:06] I think where it moves next is context, right? So,  you know, what happens when the AI understands the [13:14] formulary? What happens when they understand the  treatment plan? What happens when they understand [13:20] the medical history for the patient all at the  same time? I think there's a completely wide [13:25] openen uh green field of possibilities in terms  of the types of experiences you can build. And [13:32] I think, you know, we're seeing this across the  board in terms of not just for obviously our our [13:37] medical models are, you know, world class. Um, but  we did spend a lot of time learning with you guys. [13:44] Um, but it also sets the table in terms of what  other what's possible with other industries. Now [13:49] you're moving into much more uh richer experiences  as opposed to very kind of transactional. And I [13:54] think that's that's something I think people are  just now starting to understand is that we're very [13:59] much already into Star Trek land and and a lot  of folks are still thinking incrementally. That's [14:06] great. Actually, what you guys have been doing  and how industry is changing the voice, how the [14:11] voice to voice models are changing, that's going  to change the industry for sure. Yeah. So 9,000 [14:18] stores uh that's the starting line, but that's  just the pharmacy. So, what's what's next? Well, [14:28] let me think and say one thing. Uh, I'm a big  fan of Marvel Marvel technology. How many of [14:34] you actually love Jarvis and Tony? Tony Stark,  guys. Very few fans of Jarvis. Come on. Oh, [14:42] there are more. So, uh, you know, I was always  fascinated how Tony Stark is talking to Jarvis [14:51] and how overall maps and AI is understanding  what Tony is saying and giving an answer. To me, [14:59] that's that's not a dream anymore. That's where  the industry is going. People talking to apps [15:06] using the voice is only just a visual interaction  is going to change. You talking to an app with a [15:14] voice thing and it is showing you the next pages  then it is giving you the context and you can [15:19] move on. Voice and visual will work together. That  to me is one place where we are going and we are [15:25] thinking now that's more future visionary kind of  a thought process which we are going and we have [15:32] been experimenting with that. Next is tactically  if you really see solving inbound calls which were [15:42] 400 million plus which was our priority customers  were our priority. Now second category is about [15:49] whole healthcare ecosystem. We call millions  of time to our partners be a prescriber be to a [15:56] insurance companies as I said and our colleagues  have to sometime wait sometime have to talk to [16:03] another IVR system while because every company has  some IVR system. So what we believe the future is [16:10] now what we are this is actively we are working  we have a people sitting in this floor who is who [16:15] are actually working on that our focus for next  coming year is building outbound voice agents so [16:22] imagine a world where our pharmacist doesn't need  to call it's calling insurance company one agent [16:28] is talking to a next IVR agent and agents are  resolving the conflict that's what the future [16:34] looks to us how we make sure Our pharmacists have  a time to talk to the customer. End of the day, [16:42] what matters the most is technology should help  us serve the humanity and we need to give a time [16:49] to our pharmacist to talk to the patients and  have a ample time to discuss their health. So [16:56] that's what we are focused on. That's where the  future is going for us. Now having said that, [17:01] what do you think about what are you going to  do more in voice space? So the the the future [17:08] is very clearly real time to me, right? Being able  to have a natural conversation takes a very high [17:15] performance system. You need to be, you know,  have the round trip from the model, you know, [17:20] voice to voice with the model in between needs to  be well under 800, 500 milliseconds sort of thing [17:27] to really keep that pace with that natural  conversation, right? So obviously that's [17:32] fundamental. Uh I think a lot of folks like to  talk about speech to speech. There really isn't [17:37] true speech to speech out there uh today if we're  being honest with ourselves. Uh most of these [17:42] things are built in Cascade. You've got you know  the full pipeline is decomposed so you can start [17:47] to you know do all sorts of creative things you  know behind the scenes. Um but we're very much [17:54] still working on on speech to speech and and our  flux models are are case in point. So, you know, [17:59] we have a a fused model with Flux that allows us  to naturally understand conversational dynamics, [18:05] turn taking, be able to understand, you know,  interruptions and how the natural kind of pace [18:10] of play happens with conversations when you're  talking to people. So, even if you're, you know, [18:14] you're on the phone with CVS and you're reading  off a prescription, maybe you don't have your [18:19] glasses and you lose your place and you're,  you know, but it understands like, oh, he's, [18:23] this person's reading off a number to me. I  need to give them a little bit more grace in [18:27] terms of like cutting them off, right? And so it's  a much more rich experience. But on the the actual [18:33] speech to speech, when you go to a traditional  speechtoext situation, you lose a ton of context, [18:40] right? You take the word hello, there's a  million different ways to say the word hello, [18:44] but as soon as you convert it to text, you lose  all of that data, right? None of the emotion, [18:48] none of the intonation, like none of that is  is carried through. So all of that matters in [18:54] the future. And so what happens when you you call  or you're talking to an AI and and it understands [19:02] your emotional state. Oh, this person's obviously  upset like what what's happening here? Maybe they, [19:08] you know, help calm the the situation down or  maybe it's uh you know, we want to make sure we [19:14] meet the customer where they are and we talk  to them in in their voice, right? or we meet [19:18] meet them and you know how they're pronouncing  things or or how they're they're talking about. [19:23] I think that's important because it starts to  pull in all of this emotional intelligence and [19:28] situational intelligence that adds to the context  of you know whatever's happening and it creates a [19:34] lot of opportunity for much much deeper much much  more I would say uh impactful experiences in terms [19:41] of interacting with AI right and and having said  that you still get all the all the optionality of [19:47] you know doing your tool calls behind the scenes  and and you know looking up stuff ahead of time Uh [19:53] but you know this is one of the reasons we built  flux is it allows you as the developer or the you [19:58] know the integrator to start doing things as soon  as I say the word you know I don't know bike or I [20:04] say the word you know uh you know some drug name  maybe it starts to pick up on that and and uh [20:10] starts to do things for me in the background right  and so I think a lot of these like concierge type [20:14] experiences are going to be much more commonplace  and I think and that's happening you know [20:19] uniformly across the industry from from what I've  seen Yeah, that aligns with what we are thinking [20:24] and how we see in reality. Awesome. Thanks again.  I appreciate your time. Thanks Chris and thanks [20:29] everyone. We are here. If you have any question,  we can always ask out. Thank you. Thank you.