KeyBank Focuses AI on Operations and Tech Over Client-Facing Chatbots

When the Rubber Meets the Road: How the Consumer Bank is Realizing Value With  KeyBank — Ai4

Ai4

KeyBank finds enterprise AI delivers maximum economic return when automating back-office document processing and employee workflows rather than deploying customer-facing conversational bots.

AI-assisted summary of When the Rubber Meets the Road: How the Consumer Bank is Realizing Value With KeyBank — original source. Check the original for full context.

Source published:

Detailed notes

## Background Published on YouTube by the Ai4 channel on August 19, 2026, this presentation features Keenan Moukarzel, Head of Consumer AI & Data at KeyBank. According to the video description, the session explores how established banks can generate real business value through AI by focusing on the operational challenges of people and process rather than purely technological solutions.

## TL;DR Keenan Moukarzel breaks down KeyBank's strategic framework for driving measurable value with AI across consumer banking, focusing primarily on technology and operations. He details three core execution pillars: unifying customer data for Next Best Action sales enablement, automating document-heavy workflows such as merchant statements and lending procedures, and supporting fast custom application prototyping. To scale impact safely, KeyBank implements a tiered delivery model covering broad employee copilots, vendor-embedded features, and prioritized custom builds under calibrated risk governance. The talk concludes with practical lessons on overcoming organizational resistance, maintaining tokenized data pipelines, and nurturing a dynamic project backlog.

## Atmosphere & style The presentation is refreshingly pragmatic, conversational, and energetic, cutting through abstract AI hype with grounded corporate realism. Moukarzel maintains an approachable, humorous tone—cracking jokes about charging audience members for slide photos and questioning the competitive value of finance spreadsheets. The session feels like an authentic field report from the banking trenches, balancing technical rigor and governance constraints with relatable anecdotes about grassroots innovation and frontline adoption.

## Key takeaways - [00:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=4s) The core promises of retail banking come down to safeguarding funds, growing wealth, and facilitating transactions, with competitive differentiation increasingly driven by Technology and Operations rather than administrative functions. - [03:36](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=216s) KeyBank structures its operational and technical AI initiatives into three core pillars: Data and Business Intelligence, Document Management, and Fast Custom Solutions. - [03:36](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=216s) Banks hold massive proprietary transactional datasets, and generative AI accelerates achieving a true Customer 360 view to power Next Best Action recommendations for frontline bankers. - [03:36](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=216s) Lightweight, bespoke web-based visualizations built with AI can replace rigid, heavy Business Intelligence platforms like Tableau or Power BI with lower engineering overhead. - [07:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=436s) AI transforms heavy document workflows across banking by instantly analyzing competitor merchant fee statements, navigating complex wealth management trust documents, and surfacing branch standard operating procedures. - [09:02](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=542s) Internal AI coding tools enable business line employees to prototype their own functional applications rapidly, though formalizing production pathways for citizen-developed tools remains a challenge. - [10:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=625s) AI tooling is deployed in three tiers: enterprise-wide readily available general AI, vendor-embedded capabilities (such as Salesforce or Tableau Data Stories), and internally developed custom AI solutions. - [10:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=625s) General-purpose enterprise AI yields massive cumulative value through small incremental wins, scaling to 17,000 saved hours weekly across 17,000 employees if each saves just one hour per week. - [13:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=805s) Successful AI deployment requires a cross-functional 'village' comprising business units, operations, engineering, and risk partners rather than an isolated data science team. - [13:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=805s) Navigating executive buy-in across a 200+ idea backlog requires patience, as initial rejections frequently turn into approvals after industry readiness and internal awareness mature. - [15:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=948s) KeyBank protects customer privacy by ensuring raw PII like Social Security numbers never reaches AI modeling environments, utilizing tokenized and obfuscated data layers in the enterprise data lake. - [15:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=948s) Overcoming internal adoption friction relies on solving acute frontline pain points and delivering immediate utility rather than imposing top-down mandates.

## Detailed walkthrough ### [00:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=4s) Defining Banking Value and Core Functions

Keenan Moukarzel opens his presentation by introducing his background, noting that while he has worked in artificial intelligence for about eight years, he has spent the last four years at KeyBank—the past ten months of which have been dedicated specifically to directing the consumer bank's AI strategy and execution. Setting an informal and engaging tone, he jokes with the audience that while many industry events rely on high-level panel discussions, his goal is to deliver actionable content, quipping that he will be monitoring the room and charging a fifty-dollar fee for anyone taking photos of the slides. He explains that after days of deeply technical presentations, his focus is grounded squarely in the mechanics of generating tangible business value from AI within the banking sector, particularly in consumer banking.

To frame how AI can deliver economic impact, Moukarzel steps back to define the core value proposition of a bank. Stripped down to its fundamentals, a bank fulfills three primary promises for its customers:

- **Safeguarding Funds:** Providing a secure place for individuals to deposit and protect their money. - **Growing Wealth:** Offering mechanisms, interest, and investment products that help customer balances appreciate over time. - **Facilitating Transactions:** Providing seamless money movement services, such as transferring funds to family members or paying vendors.

---

[01:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=76s) Finding Where AI Truly Moves the Needle

Executing these three core functions requires a complex web of internal divisions across an enterprise, including customer-facing branch bankers, back-office operations (such as loan servicing), human resources, legal, risk management, finance, and technology. For a bank executive evaluating AI investment while competing against roughly 4,500 to 5,000 other financial institutions across the United States, determining where AI yields the highest return on investment is a critical strategic decision. Moukarzel engages the audience to poll which department holds the greatest potential value, hearing suggestions ranging from customer experience and operations to risk management.

While acknowledging that risk and customer experience are strong contenders, Moukarzel humorously dismisses finance as the primary differentiator, questioning whether generating slightly better spreadsheets will meaningfully alter a bank's competitive standing. Instead, he highlights the combination of **Technology** and **Operations** as the twin engines capable of driving sustainable competitive advantage. Technology teams can leverage AI to write and refactor code substantially faster, while operations teams can automate complex back-office workflows to scale productivity.

```mermaid flowchart TD accTitle: Core Pillars of AI Value in Consumer Banking accDescription: Three pillars of AI implementation showing Data and BI, Document Management, and Fast Custom Solutions.

subgraph BI["Data & Business Intelligence"] A["Customer 360 Acceleration"] B["Next Best Action for Sales"] C["Lean Web Visualizations"] end

subgraph DOCS["Document Management"] D["Competitor Statement Analysis"] E["Trust Document Navigation"] F["Lending & Procedure Search"] end

subgraph SOLUTIONS["Fast Custom Solutions"] G["Task Queue Automation"] H["Conversational & Copilot Tools"] I["Rapid Web App Prototyping"] end

BI --> Impact["Enterprise Value Creation"] DOCS --> Impact SOLUTIONS --> Impact ```

---

[03:36](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=216s) Pillar 1: Data, Customer 360, and Business Intelligence

KeyBank breaks down its operational and technical AI focus into three foundational pillars: **Data and Business Intelligence**, **Document Management**, and **Fast Custom Solutions**. Within the data pillar, banks maintain an unmatched advantage: they hold vast amounts of personal transaction history and behavioral data, often exceeding what any other commercial entity possesses.

The primary prize in this pillar is the elusive "Customer 360." When polling the room, Moukarzel observes only three audience members raise their hands to confirm their organizations have successfully achieved a true Customer 360 view. While AI is not strictly required to unify customer data, it acts as a massive accelerator. KeyBank uses AI to rapidly build data stores, analyze transaction views, and track significant fund flows—such as spotting when clients begin moving capital out of the institution.

Closely coupled with Customer 360 is the development of "Next Best Action" capabilities for branch and relationship bankers. Armed with deep behavioral context, front-line staff can initiate higher-quality, tailored sales conversations and proactively address specific client needs. Moukarzel notes that his manager, Ramesh, has been passionately driving this initiative across the bank for over a year. Additionally, AI streamlines internal data engineering pipelines and replaces traditional, rigid Business Intelligence platforms like Tableau or Power BI—which can be slow, difficult to maintain, and cumbersome to configure—with lightweight, bespoke, web-based visualizations that require far less engineering effort.

---

[07:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=436s) Pillar 2: Document Intelligence and Procedure Search

Because banking is one of the most heavily regulated industries in the United States, institutions are inundated with enormous volumes of structured and unstructured paperwork, from regulatory disclosures and bank statements to internal standard operating procedures. AI transforms this documentation burden into operational leverage across several distinct areas:

- **Key Merchant Services (KMS) & Competitor Analysis:** KeyBank invites prospective clients to submit merchant statements from competing banks. AI analyzes these complex fee schedules instantly, allowing the bank to generate a competitive, optimized pricing quote faster and win deals at the point of sale. - **Trust & Wealth Management Documentation:** Trust documents in wealth management are intricate legal instruments that frequently evolve over time. AI organizes and surfaces the exact governing documents and legal clauses needed, cutting through hours of manual legal search. - **Home Lending Processing:** Given the standardized yet document-heavy nature of mortgage origination, AI extracts and cross-checks data rapidly while keeping human underwriters firmly in the loop for final decision-making. - **Branch Procedure Search:** Branch bankers often encounter unfamiliar transaction requests, such as complex ACH transfers. Rather than forcing employees to sift through ten pages of irrelevant keyword search results, AI delivers precise, contextual procedural instructions instantaneously.

---

[09:02](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=542s) Pillar 3: Fast Custom Solutions and the Prototyping Surge

The third major operational pillar focuses on deploying bespoke software solutions rapidly to eliminate operational bottlenecks. A major upcoming area of focus is automating administrative task queues within operational processing centers to clear work backlogs faster.

When discussing conversational AI, Moukarzel notes that while internal contact centers have adopted it extensively, deploying fully autonomous customer-facing conversational agents remains tricky. Customers frequently prefer speaking directly with human bankers, and enterprise comfort around conversational risk continues to mature.

Meanwhile, internal AI-assisted coding has created a groundswell of grassroots innovation across business units. Employees are using AI to solve day-to-day workflow friction on their own. Moukarzel shares an anecdote about a national director in wealth management who used generative AI tools to code three to five functional prototype applications on his own and immediately asked the engineering team to push them straight to production. While Moukarzel chuckles that these bespoke tools were essentially built to solve problems for only three people and highlights the ongoing challenge of establishing formal production pipelines for citizen-developed tools, he emphasizes that empowering business teams to rapidly build their own functional solutions represents an exciting shift in enterprise productivity.

[10:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=625s) AI Enablement: Readily Available Tools, Vendor Solutions, and Governance

Beyond targeted priority projects, empowering the broader organization requires a tiered strategy for AI tooling. The goal is to provide everyday employees with tools that solve routine problems without requiring dedicated engineering teams with "all these eyes and hands on keyboard." The first tier is "readily available AI"—corporate-grade, secure equivalents of consumer tools like ChatGPT or Microsoft Copilot. The enterprise value of these broad deployments compounds rapidly through incremental productivity gains. Across KeyBank’s roughly 17,000 employees, saving just a single hour per employee per week scales to 17,000 hours saved weekly across the enterprise, creating immense operational efficiency.

The second tier leverages built-in AI capabilities from existing enterprise vendors, such as Salesforce or Tableau's automated Data Stories. Enabling AI within tools that staff already use every day lowers the barrier to adoption. When neither general-purpose AI nor out-of-the-box vendor capabilities can solve a specialized business challenge, the internal AI team steps in to build custom AI solutions. These custom projects are drawn from a actively managed backlog of business ideas and prioritized based on strategic impact.

Underpinning this tiered approach is a disciplined governance and risk framework. Different AI applications carry vastly different risk profiles, and low-risk applications may require different governance tracks than high-risk models. The priority is ensuring rigorous oversight rather than pursuing business expansion at all costs.

```mermaid flowchart TD accTitle: KeyBank AI Tooling and Delivery Tiers accDescr: Three tiers of AI delivery leading to governance and deployment.

subgraph Tiers["AI Delivery Tiers"] A["Readily Available AI<br/>(Copilot, Internal LLM Tools)"] B["Vendor-Embedded AI<br/>(Salesforce, Tableau Data Stories)"] C["Custom AI Development<br/>(Prioritized Line-of-Business Backlog)"] end

subgraph Oversight["Oversight & Review"] G["Risk & Governance Framework<br/>(Differentiated by Risk Tier)"] end

subgraph Production["Production"] P["Secure Business Value & Deployment"] end

A --> G B --> G C --> G G --> P ```

- **Enterprise Scale Math**: Saving 1 hour per week across 17,000 employees generates 17,000 saved hours per week enterprise-wide. - **Vendor Native Features**: Taking advantage of native features like Tableau Data Stories brings AI to users already comfortable in their existing software workflows. - **Risk-Calibrated Governance**: Ensuring risk oversight matches the complexity and exposure of each use case rather than applying a one-size-fits-all blocker.

---

[13:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=805s) Key Takeaways from 10 Months in Production: People, Ecosystems, and Backlogs

Reflecting on lessons gathered over ten months of scaling AI within KeyBank, successful execution relies on organizational alignment rather than pure technology. AI delivery "takes a village"—the myth of a single, isolated data science team delivering end-to-end transformation is unsustainable. Sustainable AI requires tight, day-to-day collaboration among business units, core technology teams, risk partners, and operational leaders.

Engaging openly with the broader vendor ecosystem is another vital asset. Rather than dismissing vendor representatives as mere salespeople, maintaining strong partner relationships exposes internal teams to emerging market frameworks and external innovations. Crucially, engineering must always be reverse-engineered from genuine business pain points. As the speaker highlights by referencing Elon Musk, spending resources engineering the wrong solution is wasted effort. Navigating executive buy-in also requires patience; out of a backlog containing roughly 200 ideas, receiving an initial "no" is routine. Many ideas need six months to simmer before broader industry awareness and leadership readiness turn them into a "yes."

- **Cross-Functional Village**: Successful deployment demands active integration across business leaders, operations, technology, and risk partners. - **Ecosystem Learning**: Vendor relationships serve as an intelligence pipeline for new industry architectures and best practices. - **Bidirectional Buy-In**: Solutions must secure high-level executive sponsorship alongside bottom-up grassroots support from end users. - **The Backlog Pipeline**: Managing a backlog of over 200 ideas means accepting that rejected proposals often resurface and gain traction as market conditions evolve.

---

[15:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=948s) Audience Q&A: Data Architecture, Tokenization, and Adoption Strategies

The session closes with an audience Q&A, where the speaker invites his manager, Umesh, and lead architect, Chris, to chime in on the technical and structural foundations supporting their work.

An audience member asks whether KeyBank runs AI models directly against raw customer records or relies purely on metadata and obfuscated data layers. The speaker explains that KeyBank enforces strict data supply chain safety: direct personal identifiers (such as Social Security numbers) never enter the modeling pipelines. The enterprise data lake contains tokenized and obfuscated customer information, ensuring that when developers pull data into development sandboxes to build prototypes and productionalize pipelines, customer privacy remains fully protected under standard enterprise analytics protocols.

```mermaid flowchart LR accTitle: KeyBank Secure AI Data Pipeline accDescr: Data flow from raw storage through tokenization, data lake, sandbox, and production.

A["Raw Core Banking Systems"] --> B["Tokenization & Obfuscation Layer"] B --> C["Enterprise Data Lake"] C --> D["Secure Sandbox Prototyping"] D --> E["Production AI Deployment"] ```

A second audience question addresses overcoming institutional resistance and employee fear to drive AI adoption. The speaker jokes that progress often comes through "sweat and blood," but emphasizes that genuine user adoption hinges on user-centric design. Rather than forcing top-down tools onto reluctant teams, the AI group focuses on directly addressing acute frontline pain points. Delivering tangible time savings and practical utility makes end users enthusiastic partners in adopting AI technologies.

## Notable quotes > When you think about effective management strategy for operational success, you think of People, Process and Technology. The latter (Technology) is not the problem in generating value in the AI field - it's mostly solved. It's the People and Process part that is challenging in an already existing business. — Keenan Moukarzel

> It's not always the most complex things that can give your business quick wins. — Keenan Moukarzel

> [10:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=625s) all these eyes and hands on keyboard — Keenan Moukarzel

> [13:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=805s) takes a village — Keenan Moukarzel

> [03:36](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=216s) Customer 360 — Keenan Moukarzel

> [10:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=625s) readily available AI — Keenan Moukarzel

> [15:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=948s) sweat and blood — Keenan Moukarzel

> [03:36](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=216s) Next Best Action — Keenan Moukarzel

## Mentioned Keenan Moukarzel, KeyBank, Ai4, Ramesh, Umesh, Chris, Elon Musk, Key Merchant Services (KMS), ChatGPT, Microsoft Copilot, Salesforce, Tableau, Power BI, Tableau Data Stories

## Video description Keenan Moukarzel - Head of Consumer AI & Data, KeyBank

When you think about effective management strategy for operational success, you think of People, Process and Technology. The latter (Technology) is not the problem in generating value in the AI field - it's mostly solved. It's the People and Process part that is challenging in an already existing business. In this talk, we will discuss how to think about generating value for the business in the banking world, how to effectively identify AI opportunities that don't disrupt the business but add value. It's not always the most complex things that can give your business quick wins.

[Source](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo)

中文简报

KeyBank聚焦运营与技术AI,而非面向客户的聊天机器人 KeyBank发现,企业AI在自动化后台文档处理和员工工作流时能带来最大的经济回报,而非部署面向客户的对话机器人。 Keenan Moukarzel深入阐述了KeyBank在零售银行业务中利用AI创造可衡量价值的战略框架,重点聚焦于技术和运营。他详细说明了三大核心执行支柱:统一客户数据以赋能“下一步最佳行动(Next Best Action)”销售、自动化商户对账单与贷款审批等文档密集型工作流,以及支持快速构建定制化应用原型。为安全扩展AI影响,KeyBank在精细化的风险治理下推行分层交付模式,涵盖面向广泛员工的Copilot、供应商内置功能以及优先推进的定制化开发。演讲最后分享了克服组织阻力、维护标记化数据管道以及培育动态项目储备库的实用经验。 零售银行业务的核心价值在于保障资金安全、促进财富增长与便利交易,而未来的竞争差异化正日益由技术与运营两大引擎驱动,而非传统行政职能。 (0:04) KeyBank 将其业务与技术 AI 战略划分为三大核心支柱:数据与商业智能、文档管理以及快速定制化解决方案。 (3:36) 银行正借助生成式 AI 加速构建“客户 360 度画像”以赋能一线员工的“下一步最佳行动(Next Best Action)”推荐,并通过轻量级定制化 Web 可视化工具降低对传统重型商业智能平台的依赖。 (3:36) AI 在文档流转中发挥显著效益,不仅能即时解析竞争对手的商户费率单,还能高效检索复杂的财富管理信托条款和网点标准作业程序。 (7:16) KeyBank 采用涵盖通用工具、供应商内置功能与自研定制方案的三层部署体系;即使每名员工每周仅节省一小时,在全行 17,000 名员工规模下也能累计节省 17,000 小时。 (10:25)

Reading summary

Keenan Moukarzel argues that consumer banks realize the highest return on artificial intelligence by pairing back-office operations with software engineering across targeted data, document, and automation workflows. Supported by tiered enablement and risk-calibrated governance, KeyBank focuses deployment on acute frontline friction rather than high-risk, fully autonomous customer-facing interfaces. Targeting Operations and Technology for Competitive Leverage (1:16) Moukarzel outlines the core purpose of banking as safeguarding customer deposits, growing wealth, and facilitating transactions. In an industry with roughly 4,500 to 5,000 competing U.S. institutions, choosing where to allocate AI investment determines commercial differentiation. While corporate departments like finance yield minimal strategic advantage from incremental improvements, Moukarzel asserts that combining technology teams with back-office operations delivers the strongest operational leverage. Within this framework, technology units utilize AI to write and refactor code rapidly, while operations teams automate manual processing pipelines. This dual approach focuses institutional capital where it directly accelerates transaction cycle times and expands labor capacity. Three Execution Pillars: Data, Documents, and Rapid Prototyping (3:36) KeyBank organizes technical and operational deployment across three functional pillars: data and business intelligence, document management, and fast custom solutions. Within data, AI accelerates the creation of a 'Customer 360' view and supports 'Next Best Action' sales recommendations for frontline bankers. It also allows the institution to track outbound capital flows and replace complex, traditional reporting platforms like Tableau with lightweight, bespoke web visualizations. In document processing, AI extracts structured intelligence from regulatory filings, wealth management trust agreements, and mortgage applications with human underwriters kept in the loop. It also rapidly parses competitor merchant fee statements to generate instant pricing quotes and answers branch procedural queries. Under the custom solutions pillar, the bank focuses on clearing operational task queues while managing a surge of employee-coded prototypes. However, Moukarzel notes that fully autonomous customer-facing conversational agents remain deliberately restricted due to customer preferences for human contact and institutional risk concerns. Tiered Tooling Enablement and Secure Data Architecture (10:25) To scale capability without overwhelming software engineering resources, KeyBank implements a three-tier delivery model: enterprise-grade general productivity assistants (such as Microsoft Copilot equivalents), vendor-embedded AI features (like Salesforce and Tableau Data Stories), and custom AI builds prioritized from an active business backlog. Moukarzel highlights the cumulative math of broad adoption, noting that saving just one hour per week across KeyBank's approximately 17,000 employees frees 17,000 operational hours weekly. This delivery structure operates under a risk-calibrated oversight framework that adjusts governance rigor to the sensitivity of the specific use case. To safeguard client privacy, direct personal identifiers such as Social Security numbers never enter modeling environments; raw core banking records pass through a tokenization and obfuscation layer before landing in the enterprise data lake for development sandboxing and production deployment. Cross-Functional Delivery and Grassroots Adoption (13:25) Reflecting on ten months directing the consumer bank's AI strategy, Moukarzel emphasizes that successful enterprise delivery requires an integrated 'village' spanning business leadership, operations, technology, and risk partners rather than an isolated data science team. Engaging the external vendor ecosystem acts as an intelligence pipeline for emerging architectures, while internal engineering efforts must strictly reverse-engineer solutions from confirmed business bottlenecks. Managing an active backlog of roughly 200 proposals requires navigating executive skepticism, where rejected initiatives often require six months of market maturation before securing approval. Moukarzel notes that driving adoption across frontline staff relies on user-centric design that directly eliminates acute daily pain points, turning reluctant employees into enthusiastic partners. While KeyBank demonstrates measurable operational gains in document extraction and employee productivity, challenges remain in establishing formal production pipelines for citizen-developed prototypes and safely navigating consumer preference and risk boundaries surrounding autonomous conversational agents.

精炼阅读摘要

KeyBank 零售银行人工智能战略主管 Keenan Moukarzel 指出,银行在全美数千家机构竞争中实现 AI 商业价值的核心抓手在于技术与运营部门的协同,而非泛化的财务或前端炒作。该行通过数据智能、文档处理与快速定制方案三大支柱,配合分级交付与严格治理,推动规模化降本增效。 技术与运营双轮驱动核心银行价值 (1:16) 零售银行的根本职能在于资金托管、财富增值和交易流转。面对全美约 4,500 至 5,000 家金融机构的竞争环境,管理层在评估 AI 投资回报时必须找准发力点。Moukarzel 认为,虽然风险管理和客户体验具备潜力,但财务部门单纯改进电子表格难以形成差异化壁垒,真正的核心增长引擎在于技术与运营的结合:技术团队利用 AI 大幅加速代码编写与重构,运营团队则依靠自动化重塑复杂的后台工作流以释放生产力。 落地三大业务支柱:数据、文档与定制方案 (3:36) KeyBank 将其实施路径划分为三大支柱。第一是数据与商业智能,利用银行独有的海量交易历史加速构建“客户360度视图”(Customer 360),通过实时资金流监测预警客户流失,并开发“下一步最佳行动”(Next Best Action)赋能网点销售,同时以轻量级网页可视化替代配置繁琐的传统 BI 工具。 第二是文档智能与流程检索。针对银行业高度繁复的监管与纸质流程,AI 被用于即时解析竞争对手的商户费率单以辅助定价、快速检索信托资产条款、在保留人工承保核准的前提下加速房屋贷款材料比对,并为网点柜员提供即时的复杂业务操作指引。第三是快速定制方案,涵盖处理中心任务队列自动化与基层自主原型开发;对于客户直接交互的对话式代理,鉴于客户偏好人工沟通及企业对对话风险的把控,部署仍持审慎态度。 三层工具体系与风险校准治理架构 (10:25) 为了让全行约 17,000 名员工享受到生产力红利,KeyBank 建立了三层 AI 赋能框架:第一层是企业级安全的企业通用 AI(如类似 ChatGPT 或微软 Copilot 的工具),按每人每周节省 1 小时计算,全行每周可节约 17,000 工时;第二层是激活既有企业软件(如 Salesforce 或 Tableau Data Stories)的内置 AI 功能;第三层则是由内部专业团队针对业务待办清单中高优先级痛点开发的定制解决方案。 底层的治理机制并非实施一刀切的拦截规则,而是建立差异化的风险与合规审查通道。低风险应用与高风险模型采用不同的治理路径,在确保全面监督与合规风控的前提下,稳步推进业务交付,避免盲目扩张带来的合规隐患。 跨职能协作生态与底层数据脱敏安全 (13:25) 在推动 AI 规模化生产的实践中,Moukarzel 强调单一数据科学团队无法独立完成转型,必须依靠业务端、核心技术、风控与运营负责人的深度协作,并保持与外部供应商生态的交流以获取前沿架构方案。面对内含约 200 个创意的业务储备库,项目常需经历数月市场培育方能获得高管立项,因此设计必须始终逆向锚定一线员工的具体痛点,以此化解抵触情绪并提高采纳率。 在底层数据供应链架构上,根据团队架构师的说明,KeyBank 严禁将客户的社会安全号等原始个人身份标识直接输入模型流水线。核心银行系统数据进入企业数据湖前必须完成令牌化(Tokenization)与混淆脱敏处理,确保开发人员在安全沙盒中进行原型构建和流水线投产时严格遵循隐私保护规范。 KeyBank 的实践表明,AI 在传统银行落地依赖于精准聚焦业务痛点与严密的风险分级体系;然而,面对员工自主开发原型的正式投产合规化,以及直接面向客户的全自主对话代理的风险管理,企业仍需在实践中持续摸索制度与技术的平衡点。

Detailed notes — zh

## Background 本视频由 Ai4 于 2026 年 8 月 19 日发布在 YouTube 平台上。内容为 KeyBank 零售 AI 与数据负责人 Keenan Moukarzel 的主题演讲,主要探讨银行业在运用 AI 时如何跳出技术空谈,聚焦人员与流程的实际挑战,并在不扰乱既有业务的前提下挖掘可落地的商业价值与快速见效的切入点。 ## TL;DR 演讲围绕零售银行如何利用 AI 创造切实业务价值展开,指出在全美激烈竞争中,技术与运营是拉开差距的关键胜负手。KeyBank 将 AI 战略锚定在三大支柱上:通过 Customer 360 与下一步最佳行动激活数据与商业智能、攻坚高监管下的智能文档管理,以及落地中后台任务自动化与定制化解决方案。同时,银行构建了涵盖全员通用工具、供应商生态与定制开发的三层赋能体系。主讲人强调,AI 落地必须坚持业务痛点驱动与全流程跨部门协同,并依托令牌化等脱敏机制筑牢数据安全底线。 ## Atmosphere & style 整个演讲节奏明快、生动务实且极富现场互动感,主讲人以幽默风趣的自嘲和犀利的提问迅速拉近与观众的距离。叙事摒弃了纯技术的概念空转,直击银行日常运营的真实痛点与管理困境。台下互动与致谢同事实践的穿插,让整场分享既有严谨专业的架构洞察,又洋溢着一线落地实战带来的真诚与烟火气。 ## Key takeaways - [00:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=4s) AI 落地应回归商业本质,将焦点从纯技术探讨转向为银行业务创造清晰、可衡量的实际商业回报。 - [01:02](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=62s) 在激烈的银行业竞争中,技术与中后台运营是 AI 构筑核心竞争优势的两大决胜支柱,蕴藏着巨大的降本增效空间。 - [03:36](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=216s) 零售银行 AI 价值创造主要依托三大支柱:数据与商业智能、文档管理自动化以及快速定制解决方案。 - [04:42](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=282s) AI 极大加速了客户全景画像(Customer 360)的构建,并与“下一步最佳行动(Next Best Action)”深度绑定以赋能一线销售,同时重塑敏捷数据流水线与轻量看板。 - [07:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=436s) 针对强监管环境下的繁重文书流程,AI 在竞品对账单极速报价、信托与房贷审查以及网点操作规程精准检索等场景实现高效赋能。 - [09:02](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=542s) 生成式 AI 激发了业务人员自下而上开发原型工具的热情,但如何将轻量自研应用规范化转化为符合企业级标准的生产系统(Productionize)仍是治理挑战。 - [10:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=625s) 采取开箱即用 AI、供应商内置 AI 及深度定制 AI 的三层赋能策略,配合差异化风险治理框架,最大化放大全员生产力规模效应。 - [13:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=805s) AI 落地需要技术、风控、合规与业务全流程多方协同(It takes a village),必须坚持以业务痛点优先倒推工程,切忌脱离实际过度开发。 - [15:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=948s) 数据流转在源头即完成令牌化(Tokenized)脱敏处理,沙箱原型验证与投产链路全程杜绝直接暴露 PII 敏感信息,确保合规安全。 - [15:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=948s) 克服员工阻力、提高 AI 采纳率的核心在于以一线用户为中心切实解决繁琐痛点,而非采取自上而下的强制摊派。 ## Detailed walkthrough ### [00:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=4s) 开场介绍:跳过纯技术空谈,聚焦银行业务价值 演讲者 Keenan Moukarzel 首先向现场观众致谢并简要介绍了自己的背景。他在 KeyBank 工作了四年,涉足人工智能领域已有大约八年,而在过去的大约十个月里,他主要负责领导 KeyBank 零售银行板块的 AI 战略规划与落地执行。他幽默地调侃道,业内很多人喜欢扎堆办圆桌论坛泛泛而谈,而他今天希望分享一些真正能帮到大家的实在干货;接着他又笑着补了一句活跃气氛:“如果大家想拍照的话,我们可是要收 50 美元的,我会在台上盯着大家的手机看。” Keenan 指出,参会者在过去一两天里肯定已经听到了大量关于技术本身的前沿探讨,那些内容确实发人深省、极具启发性。但他今天的演讲重点将回归到商业本质与业务价值,具体聚焦于如何利用 AI 为银行业、特别是零售银行创造可衡量的商业回报。 --- ### [01:02](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=62s) 银行的核心命题与 AI 业务切入点的抉择 在探讨 AI 如何带来商业价值前,Keenan 带领观众退回原点思考:银行到底做的是什么生意?无论是要追求业务增量还是提升收入,都必须先想明白商业主张。剥离繁复的金融术语后,银行本质上为客户提供三件核心服务: 1. **资金安全保障(Safeguarding Money)**:客户手头有闲置资金,需要一个绝对安全的地方存放; 2. **财富增值(Grow Your Money)**:将资金存入银行后,银行帮助客户获取收益、实现财富增长; 3. **资金流转与交易服务(Transactions / Money Services)**:例如日常支付、给远方的父母转账等资金汇划需求。 为了支撑这三项核心职能,现代银行内部构建了庞大复杂的组织架构:包括一线面对客户的柜员与客户经理、负责贷款流程及中后台运转的运营部门(Operations),以及人力资源(HR)、法务(Legal)、风险合规(Risk)和财务(Finance)等职能部门。Keenan 向全场抛出一个关键问题:全美有约 4,500 到 5,000 家银行,竞争极其惨烈。如果你是银行的首席执行官(CEO),面对 AI 浪潮,你会把有限的资源押注在哪一个部门来构筑核心竞争力? 现场观众纷纷给出了“中后台运营”、“客户体验(CX)”以及“风险管理”等答案。Keenan 逐一点评并排除了财务部门,风趣地反问:“财务能做什么呢?靠 AI 做出更好看、更高级的 Excel 电子表格吗?这能颠覆银行业的竞争格局吗?”他总结道,尽管所有部门都能借助 AI 产生一定价值,但在全美数千家银行的激烈角逐中,真正能成为胜负手、拉开竞争差距的两大支柱正是**技术(Technology)**与**运营(Operations)**。技术能大幅加快代码编写与系统开发,而中后台运营的自动化与智能化改造则蕴藏着巨大的降本增效空间。 --- ### [03:36](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=216s) 零售银行 AI 价值创造的三大核心支柱 聚焦于技术与运营的交汇点,Keenan 梳理出了 KeyBank 认为最具潜力和业务回报的三大核心领域: ```mermaid flowchart TD accTitle: 零售银行 AI 创造价值的三大支柱 subgraph Core["零售银行 AI 核心支柱"] BI["数据与商业智能<br/>(Data & BI)"] DM["文档管理自动化<br/>(Document Management)"] CS["快速定制解决方案<br/>(Fast Custom Solutions)"] end BI --> BI1["Customer 360 & 资金外流预警"] BI --> BI2["下一步最佳行动 (Next Best Action)"] BI --> BI3["自动化数据流水线与轻量看板"] DM --> DM1["竞品对账单分析与极速报价"] DM --> DM2["信托治理文件与房贷审批搜索"] DM --> DM3["网点业务操作规程智能问答"] CS --> CS1["中后台任务队列自动化"] CS --> CS2["行内助手 Copilot 与业务自研 Web 应用"] ``` - **数据与商业智能(Data and Business Intelligence)**:银行掌握着极其详尽的用户个人隐私数据,包括消费流水、交易行为等,数据丰富度远超其他行业,核心在于如何把数据资产转化为商业洞察; - **文档管理(Document Management)**:银行业是全美受监管最严格的行业之一,日常运转依赖大量文档——从各类账单、合规披露文件、内部规章,到市场上竞品的宣传与条款文件; - **快速定制解决方案(Fast Custom Solutions)**:利用现代 AI 技术赋能快速开发,构建轻量、敏捷的工具与应用,点对点解决具体的业务卡点。 --- ### [04:42](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=282s) 支柱一:数据与商业智能(Customer 360、销售赋能与看板革新) 在展开探讨商业智能时,Keenan 首先聚焦于被银行业提及多年却始终难以落地的 **Customer 360(客户 360 度全景画像)**。他向台下提问:“现场有多少人的企业真正建成了成熟的 Customer 360?”令人意外的是,全场仅有三个人举手。Keenan 指出,虽然做好 Customer 360 本质上取决于底层数据质量,并不绝对依赖 AI,但 AI 扮演了极其强大的催化剂角色,能让人以过去数倍的速度构建出完整的数据视图。 KeyBank 正在利用 AI 加速落地这一场景,以极高的效率构建集成交易明细与资金划转行为的数据存储库。系统能够敏锐捕捉客户行为异动,例如快速识别出哪些客户正将大笔资金转出银行,从而及早进行预警与干预。在此基础上,银行将全景画像与销售团队的**下一步最佳行动(Next Best Action)**深度绑定:通过对客户偏好和近期行为的研判,为一线销售人员提供更具针对性的谈资和沟通建议,显著提升客户交谈的质感。Keenan 特别提到,他的主管 Ramesh 当天也坐在台下,而推进这项客户画像与行动建议的工作正是 Ramesh 过去一年多来倾注巨大心血的重点方向。 此外,AI 在数据工程与可视化领域的提质增效同样显著: - **数据工程自动化**:AI 能够辅助工程师快速设计并生成数据流水线(Data Pipelines),以更低的工程成本迅速清洗和交付下游所需的数据格式; - **重塑数据可视化**:现场约有一半观众表示日常使用 Tableau 或 Power BI。Keenan 指出传统商业智能看板往往庞大笨重、维护成本高且调整迟缓;如今借助 AI 辅助编程,团队能够敏捷开发出轻量化、定制化的 Web 数据可视化界面,既节省开发精力,又能精准满足业务一线瞬息万变的数据展示需求。 --- ### [07:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=436s) 支柱二:高度监管环境下的智能文档全生命周期管理 针对高度监管与文书堆积如山的行业痛点,Keenan 介绍了 KeyBank 在文档智能领域的四个典型落地场景: - **竞品分析与极速报价**:在商户服务(Key Merchant Services,KMS)等竞争激烈的领域,银行经常要求客户提供竞品对手的对账单。过去人工比对极其耗时,现在引入 AI 后,系统能瞬时解析竞品对账单中的费率结构,并自动计算生成更具吸引力的自主报价,大幅缩短“从客户洽谈到给出报价(conversation to quote)”的周期,以敏捷性击败对手; - **财富管理信托文档检索(Trust Documents)**:在财富管理业务中,信托文件长达数十甚至上百页,且随着时间推移频繁修订补充。AI 能够梳理文件脉络并建立秩序,秒级检索定位到具有法律约束力的核心治理文件(governing documents),精准提取特定上下文与专业法务措辞; - **住房抵押贷款审查(Home Lending)**:房贷业务流程标准、案卷材料极为庞大,是 AI 极佳的用武场景。AI 负责批量提取申报材料数据、加速交叉审核,同时坚持采用人机协同(Human-in-the-loop)机制,在确保合规风控底线的前提下大幅提速审批决策; - **网点业务操作规程检索(Procedure Search)**:一线柜员或客户经理难免会遇到业务盲区,例如复杂的 ACH 跨行转账操作步骤。以往的关键字搜索往往返回十多页无关结果,员工必须逐页翻找;AI 检索能够直接理解员工的自然语言提问,直接定位并呈现标准化操作步骤,避免客户在柜台前漫长等待。 --- ### [09:02](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=542s) 支柱三:快速定制解决方案、任务队列与 AI 落地边界 在谈到第三大支柱——快速定制解决方案时,Keenan 梳理了技术部门赋能业务运营的几条路径: - **中后台任务队列(Task Queues)自动化**:银行集中运营中心每天都会堆积大量待办任务工单,这一领域虽尚未全面完成改造,但已被确立为极具潜力的降本增效高地; - **对话式 AI(Conversational AI)的审慎探索**:联络中心(Contact Center)在对话式 AI 方面积累了较多实践,但面对外部客户的生成式对话依然处在非常敏感和棘手("a bit hairy")的阶段。当前客户对纯 AI 交互的信任度与接受度仍然有限,在涉及重大金融决策或账户问题时依然强烈倾向于与真人沟通; - **形形色色的专业 Copilot**:面向内部不同条线员工的辅助副驾驶工具正在各处生根发芽。 最后,Keenan 重点提及了由 AI 编码引发的**定制化 Web 应用(Custom Web Applications)热潮与治理挑战**。现在业务团队只要有了痛点,就能利用 AI 快速手搓出一套前端应用来尝试解决。他分享了一个生动的真实案例:财富管理部门的一位全国总监业务热情极高,自己借助 AI 捣鼓出了三到五个原型系统的代码,兴冲冲地找到技术团队问:“你们能不能把这几个工具直接发布到生产环境(prod)上线?” Keenan 笑着评价道:“这确实很棒,但一评估发现,它解决的只是三个人工作中的特定问题。”这个例子充分展现了生成式 AI 赋予业务人员自下而上解决问题的巨大能量,但也抛出了一个全行业共同面临的工程治理难题:企业目前尚未建立起一套标准化的体系,能将这些散落各处的轻量级定制 Web 应用安全、规范、可持续地转化为符合企业级标准的生产级应用(productionize)。尽管如此,这种全员用 AI 敏捷拆解业务难题的风气依然令人振奋。 ### [10:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=625s) 赋能全员:开箱即用 AI、供应商方案与定制化开发 在核心聚焦业务领域之外,如何让整个企业其他部门的员工同样享受到 AI 带来的红利,是规模化应用的关键。为了赋能全员,KeyBank 将工具赋能策略划分为三个层级。首先是“开箱即用 AI”(Readily Available AI),即在受控的企业环境中向所有员工开放通用 AI 工具,类似于企业级 ChatGPT 或 Microsoft Copilot。这种全员普及能迅速放大生产力价值:以 KeyBank 约 17,000 名员工为例,如果每人每周通过 Copilot 节省 1 小时,整个企业每周就能省下 17,000 个工时,按月和按年相乘后将转化为巨大的效率收益。辅以必要的使用培训,企业能以极低摩擦快速获得切实价值。 ```mermaid flowchart TD accTitle: AI 工具分层赋能与治理架构 subgraph S1["1. 全员普及层"] A["开箱即用 AI<br/>(企业版 Copilot / ChatGPT)"] B["全员培训与效率倍增"] end subgraph S2["2. 现成生态层"] C["供应商内置 AI<br/>(Salesforce AI / Tableau Data Stories)"] end subgraph S3["3. 深度定制层"] D["定制化 AI 解决方案<br/>(业务痛点优先级评估)"] end subgraph S4["底层支撑与合规保障"] E["分级 AI 治理框架<br/>(高风险 vs 低风险差异化管控)"] end A --> E C --> E D --> E ``` 第二层是利用现有第三方供应商内置的 AI 能力。许多员工日常已在熟练使用各类专业工具,例如 Salesforce 或 Tableau。通过直接启用供应商推出的 AI 模块(如 Tableau 的 Data Stories),员工无需改变既有工作流就能直接获得智能化赋能。当通用工具和供应商方案均无法满足特定业务痛点时,第三层——定制化 AI(Custom AI)开发团队才会介入。团队会持续维护并动态排期一个需求储备池,与各条业务线深入沟通,筛选出优先级最高的问题进行定制构建。此外,整个赋能体系必须依托于强健的 AI 治理与风险评估框架,区分高风险与低风险 AI 项目,在保障合规与安全的前提下推动业务发展,而非不计代价地盲目扩张。 - **全员效益倍增**:企业内 17,000 名员工若人均每周节省 1 小时,企业级每周累计节省 17,000 小时,规模效应极其显著。 - **现成生态整合**:优先激活既有工作流工具(如 Salesforce AI、Tableau Data Stories)的内置智能,降低学习门槛。 - **差异化风险治理**:建立强健的风控框架,针对高、低风险 AI 实施分级治理,兼顾合规安全与创新效率。 --- ### [13:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=805s) 过去 10 个月的核心经验:多方协同、生态共建与业务导向 在过去 10 个月的 AI 落地实践中,团队总结出了几条至关重要的实战心得。首要法则是“独木不成林,AI 落地需要整个团队的协同”(It takes a village)。单靠一个独立的 AI 团队不可能包揽所有环节,必须与技术团队、风险合规伙伴、运营部门以及业务线领导者通力协作,才能真正将 AI 产品推向生产环境。其次,要积极拥抱外部供应商生态。许多人常将供应商简单归类为“推销人员”而刻意回避,但与优秀的供应商保持良好沟通往往能学到最新的行业架构和创新思路;银行并非在真空中运作,活跃的外部智能生态能为团队带来宝贵视角。 在组织管理与项目推进上,团队上下一致的对齐(Alignment)至关重要,既需要高层管理者的鼎力支持,也离不开基层团队的共鸣与配合。在开发策略上,必须坚持“业务问题优先,倒推技术工程”的原则。正如埃隆·马斯克所言,如果工程化了一个错误的东西,那从一开始就解决错了问题;切忌为了工程而工程。面对庞大的创意储备,需要保持耐心与韧性。团队内部虽然积累了 200 多个点子,但不可能所有项目立刻获批。有时一个方案在当下被否决,但随着市场演进和行业认知的成熟,半年后很可能就会迎来通过的契机。 - **跨职能协作**:打破部门壁垒,推动业务端、技术端、风控合规与一线运营的全流程深度协同。 - **善用外部生态**:将供应商视为行业前沿知识与架构方案的输入源,构建良好的外部合作网络。 - **业务需求倒推工程**:坚守“业务痛点先行”,避免脱离实际价值的过度工程化开发。 - **创意周期管理**:当前被否决(No)的项目不代表终结,部分优质构想需要时间酝酿,待时机成熟后重新推进。 --- ### [15:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=948s) 问答环节:数据隐私保护与业务采纳的实战心得 在演讲尾声的问答环节中,主讲人首先向在场的部门主管 Umesh 致谢,感谢其在过去 10 个月中对 AI 战略落地的大力支持与领导。现场观众就数据安全和业务推广两大核心问题进行了深入提问。 针对 AI 研发中如何处理客户数据隐私的提问,主讲人澄清:AI 流程绝不会直接接触或使用客户的真实个人敏感信息(PII,如社保号)。银行的数据供应链在源头就进行了严格的去标识化与令牌化(Tokenized)处理。数据从数据湖拉取到沙箱(Sandbox)进行原型验证再到最终投产,整个流转过程中的数据本身就已处于令牌化安全状态。现场架构师 Chris 也对这一底层安全架构的设计予以了确认,强调 AI 分析处理与传统数据湖分析一样遵循最高安全标准。 ```mermaid flowchart LR accTitle: 数据隐私与 AI 原型流转链路 A["数据湖<br/>(已完成令牌化/脱敏)"] --> B["隔离开发沙箱<br/>(原型设计与验证)"] B --> C["生产环境投产<br/>(智能分析与文档处理)"] ``` 针对现场关于“如何克服员工对 AI 的恐惧与阻力、提高业务采纳率”的提问,主讲人幽默地引用同事 Carlos 的话,称推广过程充满“汗水与心血”。他随后严肃指出,提升采纳率的核心在于“以用户为中心”,真正站在业务人员的角度去解决让他们头疼的实际痛点。如果只是自上而下强行推行工具("force it down their throats"),业务端没有切身体会到价值,推广必然失败;只有当 AI 工具切实帮员工减轻了负担、带来了业务增益,员工才会主动拥抱变革。 - **数据安全与脱敏**:数据湖中的客户信息全面实行令牌化(Tokenized)存储,沙箱原型验证与生产链路全程杜绝直接暴露 PII 敏感信息。 - **以用户为中心的采纳策略**:拒绝强制摊派工具,通过切实解决业务痛点、创造可量化价值来激发一线的主动使用意愿。 ## Notable quotes > [00:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=4s) 如果大家想拍照的话,我们可是要收 50 美元的,我会在台上盯着大家的手机看。 — Keenan Moukarzel > [01:02](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=62s) 财务能做什么呢?靠 AI 做出更好看、更高级的 Excel 电子表格吗?这能颠覆银行业的竞争格局吗? — Keenan Moukarzel > [09:02](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=542s) 这确实很棒,但一评估发现,它解决的只是三个人工作中的特定问题。 — Keenan Moukarzel > [13:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=805s) 独木不成林,AI 落地需要整个团队的协同(It takes a village)。 — Keenan Moukarzel > [13:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=805s) 如果工程化了一个错误的东西,那从一开始就解决错了问题;切忌为了工程而工程。 — Keenan Moukarzel > [15:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo&t=948s) 如果只是自上而下强行推行工具(force it down their throats),业务端没有切身体会到价值,推广必然失败;只有当 AI 工具切实帮员工减轻了负担、带来了业务增益,员工才会主动拥抱变革。 — Keenan Moukarzel ## Mentioned Keenan Moukarzel, KeyBank, Customer 360, Tableau, Power BI, Key Merchant Services (KMS), ACH, Salesforce, Microsoft Copilot, ChatGPT, Tableau Data Stories, Elon Musk, Ramesh, Umesh, Chris, Carlos ## Video description Keenan Moukarzel - Head of Consumer AI & Data, KeyBank When you think about effective management strategy for operational success, you think of People, Process and Technology. The latter (Technology) is not the problem in generating value in the AI field - it's mostly solved. It's the People and Process part that is challenging in an already existing business. In this talk, we will discuss how to think about generating value for the business in the banking world, how to effectively identify AI opportunities that don't disrupt the business but add value. It's not always the most complex things that can give your business quick wins. [Source](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J00q-G3DFo)

Source quotes

[0:04] Keenan Moukarzel: 如果大家想拍照的话,我们可是要收 50 美元的,我会在台上盯着大家的手机看。 [1:02] Keenan Moukarzel: 财务能做什么呢?靠 AI 做出更好看、更高级的 Excel 电子表格吗?这能颠覆银行业的竞争格局吗? [9:02] Keenan Moukarzel: 这确实很棒,但一评估发现,它解决的只是三个人工作中的特定问题。 [13:25] Keenan Moukarzel: 独木不成林,AI 落地需要整个团队的协同(It takes a village)。 [13:25] Keenan Moukarzel: 如果工程化了一个错误的东西,那从一开始就解决错了问题;切忌为了工程而工程。 [15:48] Keenan Moukarzel: 如果只是自上而下强行推行工具(force it down their throats),业务端没有切身体会到价值,推广必然失败;只有当 AI 工具切实帮员工减轻了负担、带来了业务增益,员工才会主动拥抱变革。

Source quotes

Keenan Moukarzel: When you think about effective management strategy for operational success, you think of People, Process and Technology. The latter (Technology) is not the problem in generating value in the AI field - it's mostly solved. It's the People and Process part that is challenging in an already existing business. Keenan Moukarzel: It's not always the most complex things that can give your business quick wins. [10:25] Keenan Moukarzel: all these eyes and hands on keyboard [13:25] Keenan Moukarzel: takes a village [3:36] Keenan Moukarzel: Customer 360 [10:25] Keenan Moukarzel: readily available AI [15:48] Keenan Moukarzel: sweat and blood [3:36] Keenan Moukarzel: Next Best Action

Original transcript

[0:04] Thanks so much for having me today.  Um just a little bit about myself. [0:08] Um I've been at KeyBank for 4 years, but overall  maybe 8 years in AI. Um and it's been about the [0:14] the last 10 months I spent sort of leading the  consumer bank's AI strategy and execution. Um so, [0:21] you know, a lot of people do panels and stuff  like that. I thought today let's put out some [0:25] content that could maybe help people. If you  do to take a picture, uh we do charge $50, so [0:30] um I'll be monitoring this the the phones. Um but  we'll talk today about more business and business [0:36] value. You've heard a lot of uh tech talk uh today  or yesterday. Uh it's been really enlightening. [0:42] Uh but today we'll talk a little bit about  uh sort of generating business value uh [0:47] for with AI and in particular for uh banking. Uh  and in particular for consumer banking. Um and so [0:56] um I'll ask you guys a question here uh as we  think about business value with AI for a bank. [1:02] Um and I want to start first cuz I don't know if  everybody has a background in banking or not, but [1:06] let's think about first what does a bank really  do, right? Like um if you think about business [1:10] value and growing income or whatever, uh we got to  think about our business proposition first, right? [1:16] And if you think about what a bank is, uh  there's really three things that it does for [1:20] the customers, right? The first thing is I have  some money and I want to put it somewhere safe. [1:25] So, like a safeguarding your money. Uh the second  thing it does is grow your money maybe. So, [1:30] if you put money somewhere in the bank, uh maybe  it can help you grow the money a little bit, [1:34] right? Um and then the third thing is uh uh  transactions, like money services, like hey, I [1:39] want to transfer money to my parents or something  like that. Um and ideally the bank can help you [1:45] provide you those three things, right? And in  order for a bank to do these three core things, [1:50] um right? There's multiple divisions within a bank  uh that you generally have and not every bank is [1:56] structured that way, so I try to keep it general.  Uh but uh you have the customer-facing bankers, [2:02] um you have operations, overall just you know, uh  loan operations, getting the bank to do what it's [2:07] supposed to do. You've got um HR, you've got  legal, you've got risk, you've got finance. Um [2:13] whoops, that was a bit loud. Um you've  got all these different departments, [2:16] right? So, if you're CEO of the bank and  you're like, "Hey, AI is big, AI is real, [2:21] um how do I generate value? How do I compete with  the 4,500 other banks that are in the country? [2:27] Um how do I do this, right? So, which area of  these areas would you guys pick to say, "Hey, [2:34] I think this area has the most uh value uh for  the bank?" Um anybody want anybody want to take [2:40] a guess? And there's no wrong answers. There's  value everywhere, but if you have to pick one, um [2:47] operations. Yep. Customer experience, okay. [2:52] Risk management is big, that's fair. So, yeah. So,  all those areas have um quite a lot of value. Um [2:59] but if you think Yeah, so I guess we can eliminate  finance, right? Like, what is it going to do, [3:04] you know, do better spreadsheets maybe with AI?  Is that going to change the game? Is that going [3:08] to help you compete? Um so, obviously, uh one  big area is technology, right? Um technology, [3:15] write coding, AI can help you do a lot of that  stuff fairly quickly, much better, much faster. [3:20] Um and then operations. I think I heard a few  people say operations. Um I think that's a good um [3:25] idea, for sure. Um and again, the other areas can  definitely bring value. I think those two together [3:31] definitely uh big areas that can help you compete  with the 5,000 other other banks in the US. [3:36] Um so, let's double-click into that. Um And these  are really within operations and technology the [3:43] areas that we see uh particularly a lot of value  in. So, data and business intelligence. As you [3:48] know, a bank has access to a lot of your personal  information, quite a bit, probably more than any [3:54] other company you've ever interacted with, right?  So, we have access to a lot of your private data, [3:58] your transaction, what you purchase, things  like that. Uh so, one area is leveraging that [4:03] information uh to do specific things. Um the  second thing is document management and um [4:10] as a regulated company, we're one of the most  regulated entities in the US, right? Banking. [4:15] Um so, we deal a lot with documents. Uh  think about all your bank statements, your um [4:20] uh disclosures and even the competitors, right?  Cuz we compete, so competitors have their own [4:26] documents, uh procedures, things like that,  right? So, document management is big for AI. [4:31] Um and the third one is fast custom solution.  So, this is technology where technology [4:37] comes in and can help you develop custom  solutions to solve your business problems. Um so, [4:42] double-clicking, and again, this is the meat  of things, but customer 360 within business [4:47] intelligence, like I said, we have access to a lot  of information, and customer 360 has been around [4:52] like forever, right? Like everybody wants it,  but I'm curious to know how many of you actually [4:57] have a customer 360 within your company. Um  you can raise your hand if you have that. [5:03] I only see three hands, actually, so surprisingly  low. But, do you need AI to do customer 360? [5:08] Probably not. You need good data, but guess  what? AI actually helps you accelerate and [5:13] get to a customer 360 probably faster than you can  if you did it manually. And that's kind of what [5:19] uh one of the use cases that we're we're working  on, actually. Um and it's surprisingly with AI we [5:24] surprisingly get to there much faster. We're able  to create data stores that have transaction views [5:30] and uh information about transfers and things  like that. We can identify customers who are [5:35] sort of uh transferring a lot of funds out of  the bank um and things like that. But, uh yeah, [5:41] AI definitely big accelerator for customer 360. I  think it's a dream that many people want to have, [5:47] Know your customer. And I think with AI you  can actually do this. Um and the next one with [5:52] uh it's kind of tied to customer 360. If you  know a lot if you know your customer pretty well, [5:56] you can actually design some next best action for  your sales team, right? Uh better conversation, [6:01] better quality conversation can be won. Inquiring  about certain behaviors our customers are doing, [6:06] that's another one. But those two are kind of  tied together and those are really high value [6:10] use cases for sure, right? Um that are tied to  customers and that's something we're working on [6:14] and we're pretty passionate about. My boss is in  the audience here. He's been pretty passionate [6:18] about this for over a year here. So Ramesh. Uh  um The third thing, data engineering in general, [6:24] um you know, AI can help you design pipelines for  whatever you're trying to do. Uh data engineering [6:28] brings a lot of value cuz it accelerates whatever  data you need to get and and give you the output [6:34] that you need. And the third thing is uh data  visualization. Um how many of you guys use Tableau [6:41] for data visualization? Just curious. Okay, about  half the audience or some sort of Power BI. Um [6:48] do you guys feel like sometimes Tableau  is slow or is not really malleable or [6:53] uh can be hard sometimes to uh it takes time  sometimes to create a dashboard and maintain [6:57] it. But with AI obviously you can create web-based  visualization much faster, much leaner, much more [7:04] uh targeted towards what you need and uh takes  less effort. So um definitely nice area to uh [7:10] to explore and invest in with AI. Um that's a  bit on the um data and business intelligence. [7:16] Um let's talk about document management a little  bit. So as I said, we're highly regulated entity [7:21] and we also competing with others. So in our  KMS and our key metrics services for example, [7:27] we're trying to compete with competitors. And  so what we do is we say, "Hey, give me your [7:31] competitor statement. We'll analyze it and give  you better pricing." So um that's one area that [7:36] AI can help you sort of compete in is taking  competitor documents, analyze, and give a better [7:41] quote faster. Beat the competition that way. So,  AI can help you go to from conversation to quote [7:47] faster. Um another one is document search.  Um so, for example, we have a lot of trust [7:52] documents in our wealth management space. Um  the ability to find the right trust documents. [7:57] Trust documents can change over time. So, AI can  put some order in there and try to organize it [8:01] all for you and helps you find the right trust  document, the governing the governing document [8:07] get there faster, give you the right context,  the right language um that you're looking for. Um [8:13] Another big use case is home lending. Uh  home lending is an easy one cuz the process [8:18] is very standard and there's a lot of documents  there, right? So, you're able to extract data, [8:23] uh analyze it faster, make better quality  decisions, keep a human in the loop, of course. [8:28] Uh but that's a big area of focus for us from  a document perspective. And procedure search. [8:33] Um if you go to a banker, you have questions  on how to do something, your bankers may not [8:37] know how to do things. Um the documents or  the procedure search can help them find the [8:42] right procedure to do something faster. So, ACH  transfer, I don't know how to do ACH transfer. [8:48] You look up the procedures and, you know, it  gives you with AI you can get there faster. [8:53] Uh what we had before was keyword search and  what's annoying it gives you 10 different pages, [8:56] you have to scroll through it, but AI can help  you get there faster. Um So, that's a bit on [9:02] documents. Um fast custom solutions. So, again,  this one we have a lot of task queues, people, [9:08] you know, we have an operation center, they get  all uh you know, things that they need to do. [9:13] Uh that's one not one area we've tackled  yet, but it's been identified as well. [9:17] But um automating a lot of task queues just  uh get business done faster in general. [9:22] Um conversational conversational AI that is big.  Um and uh we're still thinking where where's the [9:29] best area to put it in. Contact center has  done a lot of stuff with conversational AI, [9:33] um I believe, but uh there still may be other  spots we can put it in. Uh but customer-facing AI [9:38] conversational is a bit hairy right now. There's  not enough, you know, knowledge or comfort yet [9:44] with the customers. People still like to talk to  people. Uh so, there's an area of exploration. [9:50] Um various co-pilots and finally um custom web  applications. That's again, you have a problem [9:55] in front of you uh with AI you can quickly solve  it, create an application that can do something. [10:00] Um a lot of people in the wealth management  team come up with ideas every day. Uh there's [10:04] a guy who's national director of something and he  came up with three five-coded ideas. He's like, [10:09] "Can you put these in prod?" Um it's like,  "Great. It's solving a problem for three people." [10:13] Uh but we haven't figured it out yet a way to  fully productionize custom web apps, but a lot of [10:18] people see problems and they just use AI to solve  for them and that's pretty awesome um overall. So. [10:25] So, that was the meat of things.  Um and then let's talk about um [10:29] what about the others, right? So, if you're not  in one of the areas, right? What do you do? Um [10:35] So, that's one of the things also we're thinking  about is how do we empower people with AI and give [10:40] them AI tools that can help them solve problems um  without necessarily being an area of focus where [10:46] you have all these eyes and and hands on keyboard  working on it. Um and so, one of them is readily [10:52] available AI is what we call that. It's basically  AI everybody has access to, kind of like ChatGPT [10:57] in your private life, but obviously in a corporate  environment where you have your own version of it. [11:01] Um think about co-pilot, right? Giving everybody  access to co-pilot can can actually uh quickly [11:08] grow as far as value and productivity, right? So,  KeyBank, let's say, has 17,000 employees, right? [11:14] If um every employee can save 1 hour per week  using co-pilot, uh you're saving 17,000 hours [11:22] per week per, right? At at the enterprise level.  And that you multiply that by 12, by four, [11:28] and you quickly get big numbers. So, um empowering  your employees, giving them some AI tools, [11:33] and helping them do stuff, that's that brings a  lot of value to the to the company fairly quickly. [11:38] Um, so readily available AI, making it  accessible, giving them some training. Um, [11:43] the other thing is vendors will come up  with their own AI solutions like Salesforce, [11:47] etc. So, making some of them, you know, available  might help. If someone's already used to Tableau, [11:53] for example, like some of you guys, um, having  using Tableau data, the the um, what is it? Data [11:58] stories, I think, is the AI thing for Tableau.  So, using that might be uh, interesting, right? [12:04] Uh, bring some value. So, if someone's already  familiar with the tool, the vendor usually will [12:08] have its own AI as part of it. So, hey, that's  one way to give AI for more people, right? [12:14] Um, and then if readily available AI or the  vendor solution is not able to solve the problem, [12:20] this is where, um, obviously custom AI comes into  play. And so, we have a team that actually works [12:26] with the different lines of business and figures  out uh, solutions for their uh, business problems. [12:32] Um, of course, they're prioritized. We  have a backlog of ideas right now. And uh, [12:36] yeah, so we look at we keep it, we maintain it. We  we uh, we talk to people consistently. And then we [12:42] like, let's say three. And out of the three,  we we do custom AI for that as well. So, um, [12:48] the last part part is governance.  So, obviously, want to um, [12:52] mention that, um, that we do have  governance. Governance is important. Um, [12:56] we cannot underlie the or understate the  importance of a strong risk framework. Um, [13:03] some AI are risky, some AI are not risky. And  so, understanding, hey, if it's a low-risk AI, [13:08] maybe it needs different type of governance.  But, making sure you follow through with those, [13:12] right? It's not all about growing the business  at any expense. You still got to be careful with [13:17] the risk, um, of your AI the of the AI that you  develop. Um, so that's it on tools enablement. [13:25] And these are just uh, sort of last words of of  things that we've learned over the past 10 months, [13:30] right? Just if you do AI in your company, like  hey, these are small things that we learn. [13:36] But the first one is it takes a village.  Um obviously, there's the idea that hey, [13:40] one AI team will do it all. Doesn't really exist.  You got to work with the different or parts of [13:45] the organization to really make AI effective.  So, working with the tech uh team, we're in the [13:50] business, but working with the tech team is  big, working with the risk partners is big, [13:54] working with operations, the business leaders. All  this stuff is important. It takes a village really [13:59] to put AI products into production. Um the other  one is surrounding yourself with great vendors, [14:05] and I may regret saying that because a lot of  vendors will come talk to us after, but um I do [14:11] learn quite a bit from vendors. Uh so, I do enjoy  keeping good relationship with our vendors cuz [14:15] you never know, you learn something new. Uh  people shy away from talking to be Oh, this [14:19] these guys are the sales people. I wouldn't  take it necessarily that way. Take it like, hey, [14:23] I may learn something from these guys, right? I  may I may learn about a new framework or something [14:27] they're doing that could help me in our in our  job, right? So, there's a greater ecosystem. [14:31] Obviously, the bank doesn't operate in a vacuum,  and having a good network of smart vendors around [14:37] you is always good. Um and then align with top  executives. Alignment is huge. Again, some people [14:43] just say, "Hey, I want to do this thing." and not  sort of socialize it, but getting executive um [14:49] support is huge, and also support from  the team itself, right? So, don't forget [14:53] the top and the bottom uh together. Um and then  work with the business first, solve the problem, [14:58] and then reverse engineer it. A lot of people love  engineering for the sake of engineering, and um [15:03] you know, we love engineering, but obviously, as  Elon Musk said, if you engineer the wrong thing, [15:08] you're working on the wrong problem, right?  So, uh thinking about business problem first, [15:12] working with the business always important.  And the last thing is uh you know, [15:17] we have a a backlog of 200 ideas. If If got a  yes on everything, um we wouldn't we would be [15:23] we wouldn't even be here cuz we'd be too  busy working, but um, a lot of times you [15:26] might have an idea, you might get a no. Um, but  then 6 months later you might get a yes because [15:31] see they heard about something on LinkedIn or  something and started making sense. So, taking a [15:36] note sometimes is okay. Just some some ideas take  time to really simmer and really come to life. So, [15:42] um, that's all I have today. Um, I don't know  how I'm doing on time, but um, I'll take uh, [15:48] 4 minutes left. Um, I'll take any questions from  the audience or Umesh if you want to say a word, [15:54] not to put you on the spot here, but uh, yeah, it  might see he's my boss. So, he's been he's been [15:59] uh, sort of leading this and a lot of other things  as well. So, uh, appreciate the opportunity for [16:03] working on this in the past 10 months, but uh,  any questions from anybody? Yes. Question is is [16:08] she she's asking if when we do AI, do we um, do it  directly on customer data or do we do on metadata? [16:14] So, data about the customers. Um, so our data is  is safely stored. Um, no personal information is [16:21] in our data supply chain. It's all tokenized. So,  we use the tokenized uh, names and information [16:26] about the customer. We don't use directly like any  social or anything like that. So, so definitely [16:31] Correct. So, we we do we pull from a data lake.  You get into a sandbox. You do the prototype [16:36] and then you productionalize it. So, when you pull  it to the sandbox, are you already off skating and [16:44] de-tokenizing? Yeah, the the data lake itself  is already tokenized. Uh, and Chris can correct [16:49] me if I'm wrong. Um, okay. [laughter] He's our  architect. Um, but yeah, I think the data lake [16:55] usually it's safe to pull data from cuz that's how  we do analytics, too, from the data lake, right? [16:58] So, analytics AI is just a faster way to do, you  know, intelligence and document processing. So. [17:04] What strategies have you guys implemented to gain  adoption of AI? Given the fear that's out there, [17:11] given the resistance, what what what it what's  worked for you? Um, to gain adoption, um, I think [17:20] what I would say is So, exactly through  sweat and blood, uh, Carlos would say. [17:25] But, no, I think I think that point, the last one  before last, is really working with the business, [17:29] getting them excited, and actually solving a  problem that brings value. Uh, I would say. Um, [17:34] so, if people are not excited about it,  you're trying to force it down their throats, [17:38] it's not really going to work out. So,  working from a user-centric perspective, [17:42] making sure you're solving a real problem that's  going to make a difference for people, um, is is [17:47] one way to increase adoption, um, I would say. All  right. Well, if you guys have any more questions, [17:52] feel free to come, or connect on LinkedIn, and  happy to talk some more. Thank you for having me.