TVA Browns Ferry Details Inherent Physics That Force Reactor Shutdown

SmarterEveryDay

Commercial boiling water reactors maintain passive safety because rising coolant temperatures generate steam voids that reduce neutron moderation and automatically suppress nuclear fission.

AI-assisted summary of INSIDE a Nuclear Reactor Core - Smarter Every Day 317 — original source. Check the original for full context.

Source published: 2026-09-26

Key ideas

Destin tours the Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant training models to examine the mechanical internals of a Boiling Water Reactor (BWR), which circulates coolant that boils directly within the reactor pressure vessel to drive turbines. (3:08)
The reactor core relies on an inherent negative void and temperature coefficient of reactivity: as coolant heats up and forms steam voids, reduced neutron moderation naturally drives down fission power. (20:24)
Defense-in-depth safety is maintained through five nested physical containment barriers, spanning from the ceramic uranium oxide fuel pellet itself out to the secondary containment building. (35:01)
A single enriched uranium oxide fuel pellet holds the energy equivalent of approximately one ton of coal, allowing the plant to operate continuously for roughly two years between refueling outages. (25:07)

Detailed notes

## Background Published on YouTube by the channel SmarterEveryDay (hosted by Destin) on September 26, 2026, this 43-minute video is an installment of the "50x50: Science Across America" national series uncovering exceptional science across all 50 states. The show notes highlight resources on the Tennessee Valley Authority's Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant, an article detailing Destin's visit to the facility, and a sponsorship from AnyDesk remote desktop software.

## TL;DR Representing Alabama for the 50x50 Science initiative, Destin visits the Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant training center to examine the inner mechanical workings of a commercial Boiling Water Reactor (BWR) alongside instrumentation and systems specialist Bill Ball. Using detailed vintage physical scale models, the two disassemble the reactor pressure vessel from the top down—exploring the containment drywell and torus, jet pumps, cyclone moisture separators, chevron steam dryers, and the core grid of 764 uranium oxide fuel bundles paired with cruciform boron control rods. They unpack the core physics of neutron thermalization and the negative temperature and void coefficients of reactivity, which naturally dampen the nuclear chain reaction as coolant water heats up and boils into steam. Finally, they trace the plant's fail-safe "Mother, May I?" SCRAM mechanisms, the five concentric physical barriers of containment, and how maintaining a coolable core geometry prevents severe accidents.

## Atmosphere & style Watching the episode feels like tagging along on an intimate, unscripted engineering field trip where complex nuclear physics are demystified in real time through tactile models and genuine curiosity. Destin's infectious enthusiasm and relatable mechanical analogies—such as comparing centrifugal moisture separation to slinging a heavy kid off a spinning merry-go-round—pair seamlessly with Bill Ball's calm, seasoned authority and dry industry precision. The mood progresses from wide-eyed appreciation for heavy industrial hardware to a deeply reassuring respect for the passive physics and multi-layered safety philosophies that keep a nuclear reactor under control.

## Bulletin - [03:08](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=188s) Destin tours the Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant training models to examine the mechanical internals of a Boiling Water Reactor (BWR), which circulates coolant that boils directly within the reactor pressure vessel to drive turbines. - [20:24](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1224s) The reactor core relies on an inherent negative void and temperature coefficient of reactivity: as coolant heats up and forms steam voids, reduced neutron moderation naturally drives down fission power. - [35:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=2101s) Defense-in-depth safety is maintained through five nested physical containment barriers, spanning from the ceramic uranium oxide fuel pellet itself out to the secondary containment building. - [25:07](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1507s) A single enriched uranium oxide fuel pellet holds the energy equivalent of approximately one ton of coal, allowing the plant to operate continuously for roughly two years between refueling outages.

## Key takeaways - [03:08](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=188s) Boiling Water Reactors (BWRs) operate on a direct cycle where coolant boils inside the reactor pressure vessel, contrasting with Pressurized Water Reactors (PWRs) that use a pressurized primary loop and steam generators. - [04:37](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=277s) Primary containment consists of a pear-shaped drywell and a lower torus (wetwell) suppression pool, which condenses steam during pipe ruptures and stores emergency core coolant. - [10:51](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=651s) Steam drying utilizes two-stage mechanical extraction—centrifugal cyclone separators followed by chevron vane dryers—to strip moisture and prevent liquid droplets from eroding turbine blades. - [16:24](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=984s) The reactor core contains 764 fuel bundles, grouped into assemblies of four that share a fuel support casting around a central bottom-inserted cruciform control rod. - [18:08](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1088s) Cruciform control rod blades are packed with neutron-absorbing boron and slide between fuel bundles to terminate fission branches by capturing thermalized neutrons. - [22:02](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1322s) Water serves as both a coolant and a neutron moderator; fast neutrons released from fission must collide with hydrogen nuclei to slow down into thermal neutrons capable of splitting Uranium-235. - [20:24](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1224s) Negative void and temperature coefficients ensure that rising coolant temperatures and steam bubble formation inherently suppress reactivity, causing the reactor to naturally bias toward shutting down. - [25:07](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1507s) Operators regulate reactor power and the axial boiling boundary using a combination of bottom-inserted control rods and variable recirculation flow driven by jet pumps. - [27:32](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1652s) Commercial nuclear power isolates all high-level waste on-site in monitored solid containers and dry storage casks, generating zero operating carbon emissions compared to open biosphere fossil fuel releases. - [32:36](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1956s) Nuclear criticality denotes a steady-state condition where exactly one neutron triggers a subsequent fission per generation (k-effective = 1.0), rather than an emergency state. - [33:39](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=2019s) SCRAM systems operate on a fail-safe 'Mother, May I?' philosophy: control rods are held out of the core by pressurized air, automatically inserting under spring and hydraulic force if power or air pressure drops. - [35:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=2101s) Five concentric containment barriers prevent radiological release: ceramic fuel pellets, Zircaloy cladding, the reactor pressure vessel, the nitrogen-inerted primary containment, and the secondary reactor building. - [37:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=2236s) The drywell atmosphere is inerted with pure nitrogen under slight positive pressure to prevent potential hydrogen explosions and ensure net positive suction head for emergency core cooling pumps. - [38:50](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=2330s) Primary containment penetrations feature diverse inboard and outboard isolation valves powered separately by AC motors and DC battery banks to avoid single-point electrical failures. - [40:55](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=2455s) Preserving coolable core geometry prevents molten corium formation; Western light water designs inherently self-regulate via negative reactivity feedback, unlike the Soviet RBMK graphite-moderated configuration.

## Detailed walkthrough ### [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=0s) Alabama, 50x50 Science, and the Mechanics of Nuclear Power

Destin introduces the video as part of the "50x50 Science Across America" initiative, a nationwide celebration of the country's upcoming 250th anniversary where 50 creators highlight exceptional science happening across each state. Proud to represent Alabama and the American South, he sets up under a pecan tree to outline the mission: diving deep into the inner mechanical workings of a nuclear power plant. Rather than sticking purely to theory, this episode aims to demystify what an actual commercial reactor core looks like on the inside.

```mermaid flowchart TD accTitle: Nuclear Power Series Progression accDescr: Progression from basic physics concepts to the core hardware walkthrough. A["Atomic Basics: Uranium, fast neutrons & fission"] --> B["Historical Precedent: EBR-I & nuclear safety culture"] B --> C["Plant Scale: Browns Ferry initial walkthrough"] C --> D["Deep Dive: Reactor core, fuel assemblies & internals"] ```

Reflecting on past videos in his nuclear power series, Destin pulls out props he keeps in boxes around his house—such as wooden models representing uranium and fast neutrons, which behave conceptually like spring-loaded mousetraps when triggered. While previous videos covered the fundamentals of fission, the historic EBR-I (Experimental Breeder Reactor I) in Idaho, and broader radiation safety protocols, Destin wants to get past the high-level summary of "hot rocks make steam, which spins a turbine." A viewer named Alex sent him a vintage book written by Alex's grandfather containing authentic architectural cutaways of the Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant. That diagram sets the stage for a granular inspection of the reactor pressure vessel and fuel assemblies.

[03:08](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=188s) Boiling Water Reactors vs. Pressurized Water Reactors

Destin illustrates the fundamental engineering divergence between the two primary commercial nuclear reactor designs utilized across the United States: the Boiling Water Reactor (BWR) and the Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR). Both designs ultimately serve the same goal—generating high-pressure steam to spin a turbine and generate electricity—but handle coolant phase change in contrasting ways.

```mermaid flowchart LR accTitle: BWR vs PWR Architecture accDescr: Comparison of coolant loops between Boiling Water Reactors and Pressurized Water Reactors. subgraph BWR["Boiling Water Reactor (Direct Cycle)"] direction LR B_Core["Core (Water Boils)"] -->|"Steam"| B_Turb["Turbine"] B_Turb --> B_Cond["Condenser"] B_Cond -->|"Feedwater"| B_Core end subgraph PWR["Pressurized Water Reactor (Dual Cycle)"] direction LR P_Core["Core (High Pressure Water)"] -->|"Hot Water (No Boiling)"| P_SG["Steam Generator / Heat Exchanger"] P_SG -->|"Primary Return"| P_Core P_SG -->|"Secondary Steam"| P_Turb["Secondary Turbine"] P_Turb --> P_Cond["Condenser"] P_Cond -->|"Secondary Water"| P_SG end ```

In a Boiling Water Reactor, water circulates through the core and boils directly inside the reactor pressure vessel. The resulting steam routes straight out of the vessel to drive the electrical turbine before passing through a condenser and cycling back into the reactor. In contrast, a Pressurized Water Reactor maintains the primary cooling loop under extreme pressure so the water never boils inside the core. Instead, this superheated primary water routes to a separate heat exchanger (steam generator), transferring thermal energy into an isolated secondary loop to produce steam for the turbine. Browns Ferry operates as a Boiling Water Reactor.

- **Boiling Water Reactor (BWR):** Single-loop, direct-boiling cycle where coolant boils inside the pressure vessel itself. - **Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR):** Dual-loop system where high pressure prevents core boiling, relying on secondary heat exchangers. - **Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant:** Operates three large commercial BWR units side by side.

[04:37](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=277s) Training Center Models: Primary Containment, Drywell, and Torus

Destin travels to the Browns Ferry training center to meet Bill Ball, an instrumentation and plant systems specialist. Instead of walking through the radioactive operational areas, the training facility houses three detailed, historic physical models originally built in the 1970s and 1980s before the era of 3D printing. The first and largest model illustrates the complete primary containment system housing the nuclear unit.

Bill shows Destin that the containment system consists of two major structural zones: the upper pear-shaped "drywell," which encloses the steel reactor pressure vessel, and the lower "torus" (or "wetwell"), a giant doughnut-shaped suppression pool circling beneath. Destin marvels at the massive physical scale depicted in archival 1970s construction photographs. Bill points out a miniature catwalk under the torus to illustrate the real-world scale and outlines the dual safety roles of the torus pool:

1. **Pressure Suppression:** If a high-energy pipe break or vessel breach occurs, expanding steam vents into the water-filled torus to immediately condense, preventing catastrophic overpressurization of the containment structure. 2. **Emergency Water Reservoir:** It provides a vast reserve volume of coolant that emergency core cooling pumps can draw from to re-inject water directly into the reactor vessel during an emergency.

[07:18](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=438s) Disassembling the Reactor Vessel: Head, Steam Dryers, and Core Guide

Moving to the second mock-up, Bill and Destin examine a disassembled scale model of the reactor pressure vessel itself—a component that spans tens of feet across in real life. Bill lifts off the reactor vessel head, prompting Destin, an aerospace mechanical engineer by training, to pause and admire the heavy threaded fasteners securing the joint. Destin explains that threaded studs and nuts, which hold immense tension under extreme internal pressure, represent some of the most impressive feats of mechanical design. Close-up footage from their previous plant outage tour reveals the ring of massive studs anchored around the vessel flange.

As Bill takes the model apart from the top down, the internal moisture extraction components come into view:

```mermaid flowchart TD accTitle: Upper Reactor Vessel Components accDescr: Internal hardware stack removed during plant refueling outages. RPV_Head["Reactor Pressure Vessel Head & Bolted Stud Flange"] Dryer["Steam Dryer"] Separator["Moisture Separator"] TopGuide["Top Guide (Square grid openings)"] CorePlate["Core Plate"] Fuel["Fuel Bundles / Assemblies"]

RPV_Head --- Dryer Dryer --- Separator Separator --- TopGuide TopGuide --- Fuel Fuel --- CorePlate ```

First comes the **steam dryer**, sitting directly beneath the vessel head, followed by the **moisture separator**. Destin contrasts the miniature models with B-roll footage showing the gargantuan full-scale dryers sitting submerged in the plant's spent fuel pool, where they are parked during refueling outages. Beneath the separators lies the reactor core, framed between the lower **core plate** and the upper **top guide**. When Destin remarks that the square openings in the top guide are where operators "drop the fuel bundles down into," Bill gently corrects him with industry precision: "We prefer to *insert* them instead of drop them." Destin notes archival video of a refueling crane manipulating a fuel bundle down through the top guide before Bill shifts attention to the annular space along the outer perimeter known as the "downcomer."

[09:55](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=595s) Jet Pumps, Recirculation, and Two-Phase Flow

Examining the cutaway model of the boiling water reactor (BWR), Bill explains the mechanics of moving coolant through the reactor core using jet pumps. These white components function essentially as massive venturis. Feedwater enters through nozzles into the downcomer annulus along the outer perimeter of the vessel. From there, external recirculation pumps—powered by the large variable frequency drives Destin toured earlier—draw water out of the downcomer and force driving flow into the jet pumps. The jet pumps entrain additional water and pump it downward into the lower plenum (the under-annulus region) beneath the reactor core.

Because the support structures are perforated, this fluid communicates directly into the bottom of the fuel core. The water is forced vertically upward through the fuel assemblies. As it passes through the intensely radioactive fuel matrix, the water absorbs heat and begins to boil vigorously, transforming into a high-energy two-phase mixture of liquid water and steam.

```mermaid flowchart TD accTitle: Boiling Water Reactor Internal Circulation Path accDescr: Diagram tracing the flow of water and steam through the reactor pressure vessel components. subgraph DowncomerRegion["Downcomer & Recirculation"] FW["Feedwater Injection"] --> DC["Downcomer Annulus"] RP["Recirculation Pumps"] --> JP["Jet Pumps (Venturis)"] DC --> JP end

subgraph CoreRegion["Core & Steam Generation"] JP --> LP["Lower Plenum / Under-Annulus"] LP --> Core["Fuel Bundles (Boiling)"] Core --> CS["Cyclone Moisture Separators"] end

subgraph SteamDrying["Drying & Output"] CS --> CD["Chevron Steam Dryers"] CD --> SL["Main Steam Lines (to Turbine)"] CS -.->|"Separated Liquid Drains"| DC CD -.->|"Drained Water"| DC end ```

[10:51](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=651s) Cyclone Separators, Chevron Dryers, and Enthalpy

Directly above the reactor core sits a dense cluster of cyclone moisture separators. Bill explains that these separators create a deliberate "tortuous path" designed to minimize the moisture content of the rising steam. When Destin expresses confusion at the phrase "minimize the moisture of steam," Bill clarifies the critical operational difference between wet steam and dry steam. In an industrial power cycle, plant operators strictly demand dry steam. If entrained liquid water droplets escape the reactor pressure vessel and travel down the steam lines, those high-velocity droplets can act like sandblasting beads or bullets, severely pitting and destroying the delicate blades of downstream turbines.

To prevent this, the steam passes through cyclone separators that spin the mixture, condensing lower-enthalpy steam and knocking out the dense liquid droplets. Only high-quality, high-enthalpy steam continues upward into the next stage: the chevron dryers. These chevron-patterned vanes force the vapor through another maze of sharp zigzags to strip away any lingering mist. Once purified and dried, the steam exits through the heavy steam lines at the very top of the vessel, routed directly to spin the turbine generator.

- **Wet Steam vs. Dry Steam Risk:** Water droplets carried by wet steam can cause severe mechanical erosion and impact damage to steam turbine blades. - **Two-Stage Mechanical Separation:** Centrifugal cyclone separators knock out the bulk water, followed by chevron vane dryers that capture residual moisture droplets. - **Recycled Coolant:** Water extracted by the separators and dryers simply falls back down into the downcomer annulus to rejoin the recirculation loop.

[12:12](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=732s) Destin's Breakdown: Enthalpy and the "Fat Kid on a Merry-Go-Round"

Destin pauses the conversation to unpack two core mechanical engineering concepts raised by Bill: enthalpy and two-phase separation. Bill's casual reference to "enthalpy" immediately signals to Destin that he is speaking with a consummate engineer. Destin defines enthalpy as the total internal energy contained within a fluid or gas at any point, dictated by its temperature, pressure, and ability to perform thermodynamic work. Steam at identical pressure but lower temperature has less enthalpy; likewise, dropping pressure at constant temperature reduces the energy available to do work on a turbine.

Destin then illustrates two-phase flow and centrifugal moisture extraction with a pair of visceral analogies. Normal breath whistling represents a pure single-phase gas, while whistling with spittle flying out represents a messy two-phase mixture of gas and liquid. To explain how cyclone separators strip that liquid out, Destin offers a playground image:

> "Imagine you're on a merry-go-round and you got a bunch of people on the merry-go-round, and then you got this big kid on the merry-go-round. He's a fat kid, I'll just say it. He's a fat kid. And you're just going to spin the merry-go-round really, really fast, and you sling that fat kid off the merry-go-round. That's what they're doing. They're using the momentum properties of fluids, and the fact that liquid is more dense than gas to make it so that that liquid gets slung off, and it hits the sidewall of the pipe, and it drips back down into the core, which I think is fascinating!"

By exploiting the greater density and inertia of the liquid water, the cyclone forces droplets to impact the outer walls and trickle back down into the reactor vessel, allowing only dry steam vapor to rise.

[14:42](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=882s) The Reactor Pressure Vessel as an Industrial Pressure Cooker

Reviewing the physical stack-up on the model, Destin summarizes the core engineering of the vessel. The outer envelope functions like a massive pressure pipe designed to pump coolant strictly from the bottom up. Inside, fuel bundles are seated within a support grid. Because the interior operates under immense hydraulic pressure, the water does not boil at normal atmospheric temperatures like 212°F (100°C); instead, it reaches boiling temperatures well in excess of 500°F.

Above the core, the steam zigzags through separators and chevron dryers under this identical operating pressure. The whole system is capped by a massive dome known as the reactor vessel head. The head is held down by an array of heavy-duty closure studs and bolts designed to withstand the tremendous internal pressures of what Bill and Destin characterize as essentially a giant, ultra-rugged kitchen pressure cooker. All three operating boiling water reactor units at TVA's Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant share this exact standardized architecture.

- **Operating Regimes:** Coolant boils at temperatures exceeding 500°F due to intense vessel operating pressure. - **Pressure Retention:** The reactor vessel head and massive fastening studs contain the high-pressure steam and water inventory. - **Plant Standardization:** Units 1, 2, and 3 at Browns Ferry operate on this identical boiling water reactor blueprint.

[16:24](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=984s) Anatomy of Fuel: Pellets, Rods, Bundles, and Assemblies

Moving from the vessel shell to the fuel itself, Bill walks Destin through the fuel assembly architecture using a physical training bundle. Inside the Browns Ferry reactor core, there are exactly 764 fuel bundles standing vertically in the core grid. Destin clarifies the nested terminology of the nuclear fuel structure to ensure every tier is distinct:

1. **Fuel Pellets:** Dense cylindrical pellets of enriched uranium oxide ($\text{UO}_2$). 2. **Fuel Rods:** Long metal tubes fabricated from Zircaloy cladding that encase stacks of uranium oxide pellets. 3. **Fuel Bundle:** A square grid matrix containing dozens of individual Zircaloy fuel rods. 4. **Fuel Assembly / Module:** A grouping of four individual fuel bundles that sit down into a single, shared fuel support casting.

The bottom nosepiece of each fuel bundle indexes directly into one of the four quadrants of the fuel support casting at the bottom of the reactor core. This rigid casting keeps the fuel aligned and channels the upward-rushing coolant through the bundle channels.

[18:08](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1088s) Cruciform Control Rods and Thermalizing Neutrons

Destin spots a narrow gap intersecting the fuel clusters and steps up onto the platform to peer straight down into the mock assembly. Instead of the round, cylindrical rod he originally expected, the control rod is a distinctive cruciform blade—a four-bladed cross. This cruciform blade inserts from the bottom and slides directly into the center intersection between four fuel bundles. Bill points out that this cross shape maximizes the physical absorption surface area relative to the surrounding fuel. The blades are packed with boron, an element with an enormous nuclear cross-section for absorbing free neutrons.

Bill then breaks down the physics of a light water reactor. When a uranium atom fissions, it releases a fast neutron traveling at extremely high kinetic energy. To sustain an efficient nuclear chain reaction, those fast neutrons must collide with the surrounding light water coolant. The hydrogen and oxygen atoms in the water bounce against the neutrons, slowing them down without capturing them—a process nuclear engineers call "thermalizing" the neutrons. Once thermalized, these slow neutrons have a far higher probability of interacting:

- **Option A (Fission):** The thermalized neutron strikes a uranium-235 nucleus in an adjacent uranium oxide pellet, splitting the atom, releasing fission energy to heat the water into steam, and emitting new fast neutrons. - **Option B (Control):** The thermalized neutron strikes the boron within a control rod blade, where it is absorbed entirely, rendering it completely inert and terminating that branch of the chain reaction.

Looking down from the top of the core, the entire reactor matrix resolves into this repeating geometric pattern: groups of four fuel bundles surrounding a central cruciform control rod, with high-pressure coolant driven upward through the support casting to sweep past the fuel rods.

[20:24](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1224s) Water Recirculation and Inherent Core Physics

Bill traces the fluid flow through the boiling water reactor (BWR) vessel model. Water is pulled by external recirculation pumps out of the downcomer annular region and driven into the internal jet pumps. Passing through a venturi nozzle, the flow enters the bottom head of the reactor vessel, where turbulent hydraulic force drives it upward through the core assembly.

```mermaid flowchart TD accTitle: Boiling Water Reactor Recirculation Flow accDescr: Diagram illustrating the flow of water through the downcomer, jet pumps, and core, and the negative void reactivity feedback.

subgraph Circulation ["Hydraulic Circulation Loop"] DC["Downcomer Annulus"] --> JP["Jet Pumps & Venturis"] JP --> LowerPlenum["Lower Plenum (Bottom of Core)"] LowerPlenum --> Core["Fuel Assemblies / Core"] end

Bill points out a fundamental design and physics reality of this reactor: "this reactor is always trying to shut itself down." Destin is surprised and asks what he means. Bill explains that the hotter the water gets, the less reactive the core becomes. Because nuclear fission in low-enriched uranium relies on thermalizing (slowing down) neutrons using water molecules, the physical density of the water determines the reaction rate. As water heats up, it expands, spreading its molecules farther apart. With fewer hydrogen nuclei in the direct path of fast neutrons, fewer neutrons collide and thermalize, causing the fission rate and overall power to decrease naturally.

- Water drawn from downcomer annulus and forced through jet pump venturis. - Hydraulic turbulence pushes coolant upward through fuel channels. - Higher coolant temperature directly reduces neutron thermalization efficiency. - Decreased thermalization inherently dampens fission chain reactions.

[22:02](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1322s) Thermalization, Void Coefficient, and Inherent Safety

Destin steps back to work through the nuclear physics step by step. Inside the fuel rods, Uranium-235 is far more likely to capture a slow, thermalized neutron than a high-energy fast neutron produced directly by fission. Water acts as a moderator because fast neutrons collide with the hydrogen atoms in water molecules, losing kinetic energy through elastic scattering until they reach thermal equilibrium. When the water gets hot and expands, its physical density drops, effectively lowering its macroscopic cross section and reducing the likelihood of collisions.

Destin highlights a diagram from an engineering manual illustrating the boiling column along the height of the fuel assemblies. At the bottom, subcooled liquid water provides strong moderation, thermalizing neutrons and sustaining high reaction rates. As coolant moves up the bundle, bubbles nucleate into two-phase flow, and near the top, steam dominates the channel. Because steam has vastly lower molecular density than liquid water, fast neutrons traversing steam voids rarely slow down, preventing runaway fission. This design characteristic, known as the negative void coefficient of reactivity (and negative temperature coefficient of reactivity), means that boiling water creates a self-regulating negative feedback loop: more heat produces more steam voids, which in turn cuts reactor power.

- Fuel relies on Uranium-235 fission triggered predominantly by thermal neutrons. - Water moderates neutrons via repeated collisions with hydrogen nuclei. - Steam voids drastically reduce moderation efficiency compared to liquid water. - Negative temperature and void coefficients provide intrinsic passive shutdown physics.

[25:07](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1507s) Controlling the Boiling Boundary and Fuel Energy Density

Bill confirms that the phenomenon is called the "negative temperature coefficient of reactivity." Operators balance core behavior by combining two primary controls: control rods and recirculation coolant flow. Control rods, inserted from the bottom of the vessel, dictate how much fuel length is exposed to neutron flux. Meanwhile, adjusting recirculation pump flow shifts the "boiling boundary"—the axial height inside the core where latent heat of vaporization triggers boiling. Higher flow suppresses steam void formation lower in the bundle, raising reactivity, while lower flow allows steam bubbles to form sooner, dropping power. Bill clarifies that the fuel rods are never exposed to open air during operation; they are continuously submerged under liquid coolant and two-phase boiling mixtures beneath the steam dryers.

Bill displays an inert fuel mockup provided by the Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI), which helps interpret Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) guidelines. Inside the fuel cladding tubes sit small ceramic uranium oxide pellets. Bill points out that a single pellet holds the energy equivalent of approximately one ton of coal. Destin observes that despite high initial capital and fuel-manufacturing costs, the immense energy density allows the plant to run continuously for roughly two years between refueling outages without continuous fuel deliveries.

- Control rods adjust physical fuel exposure to thermal neutron flux. - Recirculation pump speed raises or lowers the axial boiling boundary. - Reactor core remains permanently submerged under water and boiling steam mixtures. - A single uranium oxide pellet matches the energy content of one ton of coal. - Refueling cycles run on an approximate two-year cadence.

[27:32](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1652s) Nuclear Waste Containment vs. Fossil Fuels

Addressing public debates on nuclear power as green energy, Destin asks Bill how he weighs the environmental footprint, including the energy-intensive front-end fuel manufacturing and the back-end waste problem. Bill expresses strong support for nuclear energy, noting that operations generate zero carbon emissions. Addressing nuclear waste, Bill makes a distinction: unlike fossil-fuel plants that emit combustion byproducts directly into the open atmosphere or watershed, every gram of nuclear byproduct is completely accounted for, contained, and monitored on-site.

Bill states: "I can point to it and say, it's right over there, and we know exactly how much it is, where it is, and how we're tracking it." Destin finds this perspective compelling, observing that most power generation disperses harmful waste invisibly into the air, whereas nuclear plants store solid spent fuel locally in dedicated dry storage casks. Destin previews an upcoming segment where he will visit the facility's spent fuel cask loading operations.

- Nuclear generation produces no carbon monoxide or carbon dioxide during operation. - 100% of high-level spent fuel is tracked, solid, and held in localized containment casks. - Fossil fuel generation dispenses vast volumes of airborne waste directly into the biosphere. - Upcoming video segments explore the physical preparation and loading of fuel storage casks.

[28:54](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1734s) Engineering Simulations and AnyDesk Sponsor Segment

Destin shifts to a workflow demonstration, showcasing heavy engineering finite element analysis running on his workstation using ANSYS LS-DYNA. He displays a high-speed ballistics simulation depicting a bullet colliding head-on with another bullet, explaining that these complex models require days of compute time and multiple dedicated hard drives.

To monitor and adjust his simulations without being tied to his desk, Destin uses AnyDesk remote desktop software. He demonstrates accessing his home workstation from various remote locations, including aboard a passenger train in England, inside the New York Public Library, from his smartphone, and over in-flight Wi-Fi during commercial flights. Destin notes that AnyDesk offers a free tier for personal use alongside commercial licenses, and mentions that this workflow supported his recently published research paper in *Royal Society Open Science*.

- Heavy structural impact models rendered via ANSYS LS-DYNA simulation software. - Destin monitors long-duration physics calculations remotely using AnyDesk. - Access demonstrated across cellular, mobile, public library, and in-flight Wi-Fi networks. - Research simulations contributed to a published paper in *Royal Society Open Science*.

[30:57](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1857s) Fail-Safe Reactor Geometry and Criticality

After wrapping up a sponsor mention for AnyDesk—noting that it was a game-changer used to remotely conduct research for his scientific paper—Destin returns to discussing the physics and fail-safe design characteristics of the nuclear reactor core with TVA nuclear professional Bill. Destin asks whether it is the geometric arrangement of multiple fuel assemblies submerged together in water that allows the reactor to go critical. Bill confirms that this is true: no single fuel assembly can achieve criticality on its own.

```mermaid flowchart TD accTitle: Reactor Geometric and Safety Margins accDescr: Diagram illustrating how subcritical fuel assemblies achieve criticality only in aggregate, protected by control rods and permissive interlocks.

subgraph AssemblyGeometry["Core Geometry"] A["Single Fuel Assembly (Subcritical on its own)"] --> B["Aggregated Core Grid (Critical only when fully arranged in water)"] end

subgraph ControlSystem["Control Rod Safety Margin"] B --> C{"Individual Control Rods"} C -->|"Shutdown Margin Calculation"| D["Single Rod Ejection / Stuck Rod (Core remains fully subcritical)"] end

subgraph OperationalPermissive["Fail-Safe Philosophy"] E["Air-pressurized SCRAM pilot valves"] -->|"Loss of air or instrument trip"| F["Instant spring/hydraulic rod insertion"] F --> G["'Mother, May I?' Operation: Privilege to run, defaults to shut down"] end ```

Bill explains that plant designers perform rigorous shutdown margin calculations ensuring that even if an entire control rod were completely removed or stuck out of the aggregate core, the reactor would still remain fully shut down. Unlike systems bound to a single unified plate, the control rods are driven independently. Destin wonders if a dropped or withdrawn rod might spike local reactivity, and Bill explains that while localized reactivity does increase, the core as a whole will not latch into an uncontrolled reaction; there simply is not enough aggregate reactivity in that isolated section to trigger an uncontrolled chain reaction. Achieving a steady state requires an intricate balance of differential equations, geometry, statistics, and probability.

- No individual fuel assembly has sufficient fissile geometry to go critical on its own. - Control rods operate independently rather than off a single gang plate. - The core design guarantees subcriticality even under a "stuck rod" or deleted control rod scenario.

---

[32:36](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1956s) Demystifying "Critical": Subcritical, Critical, and Supercritical

Destin breaks down why the term "critical"—often interpreted by the general public as an emergency—is actually the desired operating state. Plotting neutron count over time on a graph, he illustrates how a nuclear chain reaction behaves depending on its neutron multiplication factor:

* **Subcritical:** For every neutron introduced into the system, less than one neutron is produced in the next generation. Over time, the reaction dissipates, decays, and eventually stops. * **Critical:** For every one neutron entering the reaction, exactly one neutron is produced ($k_{\text{eff}} = 1.0$). This represents a stable, controlled steady-state condition where the plant can generate commercial power indefinitely. * **Supercritical:** More than one neutron is produced for every neutron absorbed. While required in small, carefully managed amounts to ramp power up during startup, an uncontrolled supercritical state can quickly exceed safe limits.

Bill agrees, pointing out that "critical is a good thing." The reactor's fundamental design is inherently self-limiting; as the coolant water heats up, its density decreases, moderating fewer neutrons and naturally working to shut the reaction down.

---

[33:39](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=2019s) SCRAM Mechanisms and the "Mother, May I?" Principle

Bringing a reactor up to critical is the most delicate phase of operation, largely because the physical plant is biased toward shutting itself down. The control rods are held out of the core against strong insertion mechanisms by energized scram solenoid pilot valves that maintain air pressure. If electrical power is lost, or if pneumatic air pressure drops, the pilot valves de-energize and vent, automatically porting off the air and driving the control rods rapidly into the core under spring and hydraulic pressure.

```mermaid flowchart LR accTitle: Containment and SCRAM Interlock Flow accDescr: Flowchart showing how nuclear monitoring systems trigger scram valves to fail-safe into shutdown.

subgraph MonitoringSensors["Core Monitoring Instrumentation"] M1["SRMs (Source Range)"] M2["IRMs (Intermediate Range)"] M3["APRMs (Average Power Range)"] end

subgraph LogicTrip["Safety Logic Trip"] M1 & M2 & M3 -->|"Non-conservative signal"| T["Trip Circuit Opens"] end

subgraph Actuation["Fail-Safe Insertion"] T -->|"De-energize"| V["Scram Solenoid Pilot Valves"] V -->|"Vent air pressure"| R["Rods Automatically Insert (SCRAM)"] end ```

The reactor is monitored across all power regimes by overlapping instrumentation suites: Source Range Monitors (SRMs), Intermediate Range Monitors (IRMs), and Average Power Range Monitors (APRMs). If any of these instruments detect a non-conservative parameter, the safety logic trips automatically, venting the pilot air and scramming the reactor. Destin summarizes this control philosophy as a strict "Mother, may I?" system: running is a privilege granted only while all parameters say "Yes, you may." The moment any condition becomes abnormal, permission is revoked and the reactor shuts down.

---

[35:01](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=2101s) The Five Barriers of Nuclear Containment

Bill walks Destin through the multiple concentric physical boundaries engineered to isolate radioactive fission products from the outside environment:

```mermaid flowchart TD accTitle: The Five Barriers of Nuclear Containment accDescr: Five physical nested levels of containment protecting against radiological release.

B1["Barrier 1: Uranium Oxide Fuel Pellet Traps raw fission products within the ceramic matrix"] B2["Barrier 2: Zircaloy Cladding Tube Seals the pellets; low neutron absorption; monitored for swelling"] B3["Barrier 3: Reactor Pressure Vessel (RPV) Heavy-walled steel vessel rated to ~1,250 psi operating limit"] B4["Barrier 4: Primary Containment (Drywell & Torus) Nitrogen-inerted steel/concrete structure rated to ~56 psi"] B5["Barrier 5: Secondary Containment Building Reinforced outer structure with dedicated filtered ventilation"]

B1 --> B2 --> B3 --> B4 --> B5 ```

1. **The Fuel Pellet:** The dense ceramic uranium dioxide fuel pellet itself acts as the first barrier, holding the vast majority of raw fission products trapped inside its internal crystal matrix. 2. **The Cladding:** The fuel pellets are sealed inside metal cladding tubes made of a zirconium alloy (zircaloy). This material is virtually transparent to neutrons and highly resistant to corrosion. Because the fuel pellet expands and swells during irradiation, operators carefully control the power ramp rate to minimize pellet-cladding interaction (PCI). Keeping the core submerged and cool in water is the primary method of preventing the cladding from degrading. 3. **The Reactor Pressure Vessel (RPV):** A massive steel vessel secured by heavy bolted flanges. It is designed to handle pressures up to approximately 1,250 psi (operating typically around 1,000 psi, which decays quickly following a shutdown). 4. **Primary Containment (Drywell and Torus/Suppression Pool):** A combination of heavy steel and thick reinforced concrete. If the RPV were compromised, steam and water discharge into the drywell and down into the water-filled torus beneath it, forming a closed loop that provides suction for emergency core cooling pumps to recycle water back into the vessel. 5. **Secondary Containment:** The surrounding plant structure that acts as a final outer envelope before the general environment.

---

[37:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=2236s) Shielding, Tenth-Value Thickness, and Drywell Inerting

Destin notes the exterior of the containment structure uses layers of steel and thick concrete. Bill introduces the concept of "tenth thickness" (tenth-value layer), which is the thickness of a given material required to attenuate the surrounding radiation field to one-tenth (10%) of its original intensity. By combining dense steel with mass concrete, the plant efficiently stops different types of radiation.

The drywell operates under distinct environmental controls: - **Design Pressure:** Because the primary containment encompasses a significantly larger volume than the pressure vessel, it is rated for lower pressures, with an operational limit of approximately 56 psi. - **Nitrogen Inerting:** During normal operation, the atmosphere inside the drywell is purged of oxygen and filled with pure nitrogen under a slight positive pressure (about one pound per square inch gauge). - **Explosion Prevention:** Inerting prevents combustion in the event of an accident; if zirconium-water reactions or radiolytic decomposition produce hydrogen gas, the lack of oxygen prevents any potential hydrogen explosion. - **Net Positive Suction Head (NPSH):** The slight positive nitrogen pressure exerts a downward boundary force on the suppression pool water in the torus, ensuring the emergency core cooling pumps maintain sufficient NPSH to operate without cavitating.

---

[38:50](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=2330s) Primary Containment Isolation Valves and Meltdown Hazards

Destin asks what prevents radioactive coolant—what he colloquially terms "dirty water"—from escaping through the numerous operational pipes penetrating the containment boundaries. Bill explains that every containment penetration is equipped with redundant Primary Containment Isolation Valves (PCIVs) arranged in series: an inboard valve inside containment and an outboard valve on the outside.

To prevent a common-mode electrical failure from disabling both valves, they rely on diverse power supplies: - The inboard valve is driven by an **AC motor**, which produces no commutator sparks inside the inert containment. - The outboard valve is powered by a **DC motor** driven by plant battery banks, which rely on carbon brushes and commutators that do spark, but reside safely in the external atmosphere.

If isolation signals trip, both valves close, trapping all water and steam within the drywell and torus. When Destin brings up what the public fears most during a severe accident—a core meltdown—Bill explains that the primary hazard is the creation of **corium**. If cooling is lost, the fuel pellets, zircaloy cladding, and internal structural metals melt together into a superheated, highly radioactive molten mass capable of slumping to the bottom of the reactor pressure vessel and challenging the physical boundaries if it cannot be cooled.

[40:55](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=2455s) Coolable Core Geometry and RBMK vs. Light Water Safety

Looking back across the fuel bundle arrangement, Bill Ball and Destin examine how water circulates between the fuel rods. Under normal operating conditions, liquid coolant flows freely across the outer surface of every fuel rod cladding tube, removing thermal energy via natural and forced convection. Bill explains that if an unmitigated overheating event were to occur and fuel components began to melt and fuse together, the reactor would lose its "coolable core geometry." Without that open channel spacing, coolant can no longer reach the fuel surfaces, precipitating severe core damage akin to historical nuclear catastrophes.

```mermaid flowchart TD accTitle: Coolable Core Geometry versus Core Degradation accDescr: Flowchart contrasting intact fuel geometry allowing convection cooling with melted degraded geometry that blocks coolant flow.

subgraph Intact["Intact Coolable Core Geometry"] A["Uniform Rod Spacing"] --> B["Unrestricted Coolant Flow"] B --> C["Continuous Convective Heat Removal"] C --> D["Stable Cladding Temperature"] end

subgraph Degraded["Loss of Geometry (Severe Accident)"] E["Fuel Overheating & Clad Melting"] --> F["Fuel Relocation & Flow Channel Blockage"] F --> G["Loss of Coolable Surface Area"] G --> H["Thermal Runaway / Core Damage"] end ```

Destin immediately brings up Chernobyl, prompting a comparison between the Tennessee Valley Authority's commercial boiling water design and the Soviet RBMK architecture. Bill points out that Chernobyl was not a light water reactor in the traditional Western sense; it was a graphite-moderated, water-cooled RBMK reactor that lacked the strongly negative temperature and void coefficients of reactivity inherent to Western commercial light water designs. While the RBMK configuration was prioritized to produce power rapidly on a massive scale, Western commercial boiling water reactors are engineered with inherent physical feedback mechanisms designed to automatically reduce reactor power as temperatures rise and steam voids form. When Destin wonders whether Browns Ferry incorporated lessons learned from the 1986 disaster, Bill clarifies the chronology: Browns Ferry was designed and constructed well before Chernobyl ever happened.

- **Coolable Core Geometry:** The physical arrangement of fuel rods and channel spacing that guarantees coolant can circulate freely around the cladding to extract heat through convection. - **Inherent Safety Dynamics:** Light water reactors rely on a negative temperature coefficient of reactivity, where increasing temperature dampens the fission chain reaction rather than accelerating it. - **Design Timeline:** Browns Ferry’s units were engineered and built in the late 1960s and 1970s, predating the April 1986 Chernobyl disaster.

---

[41:55](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=2515s) The "Asker of All Questions" and What Lies Ahead

Reflecting on the tour from inside the plant, Destin shares his broader philosophy behind the *Nuclear Power Deep Dive* series. For years, he had wanted to devour every textbook and technical manual he could find on commercial nuclear power. However, he deliberately held back from studying everything in advance so that he could experience the discovery authentically alongside his viewers. Stepping onto the refueling floor and peering into the reactor vessel allowed him to ask raw, unscripted technical questions in real time: "I am not the knower of all things. I am the asker of all questions, and I hope you enjoy being right there with me, having a blast."

Destin expresses deep gratitude to Bill Ball and the team at the Tennessee Valley Authority for opening their doors and patiently explaining the plant's intricate engineering. He also thanks his Patreon community, noting that their direct financial backing is what grants him the creative freedom to travel on location and explore complex engineering systems in depth. Looking ahead, Destin previews the next installments of the series, teasing a deep dive into nuclear cross sections with an expert named Bill Williamson, as well as upcoming footage recorded on location at Idaho National Laboratory (INL). He wraps up with his signature sign-off: "I'm Destin. You're getting Smarter Every Day, have a good one. Bye."

## Notable quotes > [00:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=0s) hot rocks make steam, which spins a turbine. — Destin

> [07:18](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=438s) We prefer to insert them instead of drop them. — Bill Ball

> [12:12](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=732s) Imagine you're on a merry-go-round and you got a bunch of people on the merry-go-round, and then you got this big kid on the merry-go-round. He's a fat kid, I'll just say it. He's a fat kid. And you're just going to spin the merry-go-round really, really fast, and you sling that fat kid off the merry-go-round. That's what they're doing. They're using the momentum properties of fluids, and the fact that liquid is more dense than gas to make it so that that liquid gets slung off, and it hits the sidewall of the pipe, and it drips back down into the core, which I think is fascinating! — Destin

> [20:24](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1224s) this reactor is always trying to shut itself down. — Bill Ball

> [27:32](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1652s) I can point to it and say, it's right over there, and we know exactly how much it is, where it is, and how we're tracking it. — Bill Ball

> [32:36](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=1956s) critical is a good thing. — Bill Ball

> [33:39](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=2019s) Mother, may I? — Destin

> [41:55](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=2515s) I am not the knower of all things. I am the asker of all questions, and I hope you enjoy being right there with me, having a blast. — Destin

> [41:55](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg&t=2515s) I'm Destin. You're getting Smarter Every Day, have a good one. Bye. — Destin

## Mentioned 50x50 Science Across America, Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, ANSYS LS-DYNA, AnyDesk, Bill Ball, Bill Williamson, Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant, Destin Sandlin, EBR-I (Experimental Breeder Reactor I), Gordon McGladdery, HHMI Tangled Bank Studios, Idaho National Laboratory (INL), Independent Media Initiative, Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI), Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), Patreon, Royal Society Open Science, Smarter Every Day, Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA), Winn Family Foundation

## Video description You can try AnyDesk for free. It's good. https://anydesk.com/smarter http://www.patreon.com/smartereveryday Get Email Updates: https://www.smartereveryday.com/email

Check out the 50x50 Science Across America! https://5050science.com/

50x50: Science Across America is a national series uncovering exceptional science in all 50 states. It is a production of the Independent Media Initiative in collaboration with HHMI Tangled Bank Studios, Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, and the Winn Family Foundation. See all the states at https://5050science.com/

Sticker Team!: http://www.patreon.com/smartereveryday

Click here if you're interested in subscribing: http://bit.ly/Subscribe2SED ⇊ Click below for more links! ⇊ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ GET SMARTER SECTION

Learn more about the the Browns Ferry Plant at the Tennessee Valley Authority: https://www.tva.com/energy/our-power-system/nuclear/browns-ferry-nuclear-plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tennessee_Valley_Authority

Here's a link to an article about my visit: https://www.tva.com/the-powerhouse/stories/inside-browns-ferry

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Tweet Ideas to me at: http://twitter.com/smartereveryday

Smarter Every Day on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/SmarterEveryDay

Smarter Every Day on Patreon http://www.patreon.com/smartereveryday

Smarter Every Day On Instagram http://www.instagram.com/smartereveryday

Smarter Every Day SubReddit http://www.reddit.com/r/smartereveryday

Ambiance, audio and musicy things by: Gordon McGladdery https://www.ashellinthepit.com/ http://ashellinthepit.bandcamp.com/

If you feel like this video was worth your time and added value to your life, please SHARE THE VIDEO!

If you REALLY liked it, feel free to pitch a few dollars Smarter Every Day by becoming a Patron. http://www.patreon.com/smartereveryday

Warm Regards,

Destin

[Source](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXypQ6d_iDg)

中文简报

TVA布朗斯费里核电站详解促使反应堆停堆的固有物理机制商用沸水堆具备被动安全性，因为冷却剂温度升高会产生蒸汽空泡，从而降低中子慢化能力并自动抑制核裂变。作为“50x50 Science”倡议阿拉巴马州的代表，Destin与仪表与系统专家Bill Ball一同参观了布朗斯费里核电站（Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant）培训中心，深入探究商用沸水堆（BWR）的内部机械结构。利用精密的复古实体比例模型，两人自上而下拆解了反应堆压力容器——考察了安全壳干井与环状抑制池、喷射泵、旋风式汽水分离器、人字形蒸汽干燥器，以及由764个二氧化铀燃料组件与十字形硼控制棒配对组成的堆芯栅格。他们解析了中子热化以及负反应性温度和空泡系数等核心物理原理，这些物理机制在冷却水升温并沸腾为蒸汽时会自然抑制核链式反应。最后，他们梳理了该电站故障安全型的“Mother, May I?”紧急停堆（SCRAM）机制、五道同心物理安全壳屏障，以及保持可冷却堆芯几何构型如何防止发生严重事故。 Destin参观了布朗斯费里核电站的培训模型，细致考察了沸水堆（BWR）的内部机械结构；该反应堆通过循环冷却剂使其直接在反应堆压力容器内沸腾，从而驱动汽轮机运转。 (3:08) 反应堆堆芯依靠固有的负反应性空泡和温度系数运行：随着冷却剂升温并形成蒸汽空泡，中子慢化效果减弱，从而自然抑制裂变功率。 (20:24) 纵深防御安全体系由五道嵌套的实体安全壳屏障维持，范围涵盖从陶瓷二氧化铀燃料芯块本身一直到二次安全壳厂房。 (35:01) 单个浓缩二氧化铀燃料芯块所蕴含的能量大约相当于一吨煤，这使得电站在两次换料大修之间能够连续运行约两年时间。 (25:07)

Reading summary

Drawing on physical scale models at the Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant, host Destin Sandlin and systems specialist Bill Ball explain how commercial Boiling Water Reactors rely on direct-cycle thermodynamics, inherent passive physics, and redundant containment barriers to control nuclear fission. Direct-Cycle Mechanics and Steam Purification (3:08) Unlike Pressurized Water Reactors that isolate coolant in a closed primary loop and use separate steam generators, a Boiling Water Reactor boils coolant directly inside the reactor pressure vessel at temperatures exceeding 500°F under high operating pressure. External recirculation pumps draw water from the outer downcomer annulus and inject driving flow through internal jet pump venturis, forcing coolant upward through the bottom of the fuel core where it turns into a high-energy, two-phase mixture of water and steam. Because entrained liquid droplets act like high-speed projectiles that can severely erode turbine blades, the rising mixture must be dried before exiting the vessel. Cyclone separators spin the rising fluid, using inertial density differences to sling heavy liquid outward against the walls to drain back into the downcomer. The vapor then passes through zigzag chevron dryers to strip residual mist, delivering dry steam directly to the turbine generator lines. Self-Regulating Physics and Void Reactivity Feedback (20:24) Commercial light water reactors rely on liquid water to moderate, or thermalize, fast neutrons emitted by splitting uranium atoms. Because Uranium-235 fissions primarily when struck by slower, thermalized neutrons, elastic scattering against hydrogen nuclei in the water is essential to sustain the nuclear chain reaction. When coolant temperature increases and water expands, its reduced density presents fewer hydrogen atoms to slow down escaping neutrons. This dynamic creates an intrinsic negative temperature and void coefficient of reactivity. As boiling creates steam voids along the fuel bundle column, moderation efficiency plummets, naturally driving down core power without operator intervention. Plant operators balance reactivity by adjusting the insertion depth of control rods from beneath the vessel and regulating recirculation flow rates, which shifts the axial boiling boundary where water transitions into steam voids. Core Geometry and Fail-Safe Scram Interlocks (30:57) A commercial reactor core cannot go critical from an isolated fuel bundle; criticality requires the aggregate geometric arrangement of hundreds of bundles submerged in water. Inside Browns Ferry, 764 fuel bundles are grouped into four-bundle modules around central cruciform control rods containing neutron-absorbing boron. These blades insert upward from the bottom, and plant shutdown margins guarantee that the reactor remains subcritical even if an entire rod is completely withdrawn or jammed. Reactor operation functions under what Sandlin characterizes as a "Mother, may I?" permission philosophy. Control rods are held out of the core by air pressure regulated through energized scram solenoid pilot valves. If monitoring suites—such as source, intermediate, or average power range monitors—detect abnormal, non-conservative parameters, or if electrical power or air pressure fails, the pilot valves immediately de-energize and vent. This loss of pressure automatically drives the rods into the core via spring and hydraulic force to terminate the chain reaction. Five Concentric Containment Barriers (35:01) Radioactive fission products are sealed behind five concentric physical boundaries: ceramic uranium oxide pellets, corrosion-resistant Zircaloy fuel cladding, the steel reactor pressure vessel rated to approximately 1,250 psi, primary containment consisting of a steel-and-concrete drywell and torus suppression pool rated to roughly 56 psi, and the outer secondary containment building. Redundant Primary Containment Isolation Valves secure pipe penetrations in series using diverse power supplies, pairing sparkless AC motors inside containment with battery-backed DC motors outside to prevent common-mode electrical failures. The primary containment atmosphere is purged of oxygen and filled with slightly pressurized nitrogen, preventing potential hydrogen gas combustions. If cooling is lost, expanding steam vents into the water-filled torus pool to condense pressure spikes. This pool also supplies continuous suction for emergency core cooling pumps, circulating water to maintain an open, coolable core geometry and preventing the fuel and cladding from melting into a dense, uncoolable mass of corium. Ball notes that Western commercial boiling water reactors like Browns Ferry were designed well before the 1986 Chernobyl disaster and operate with intrinsic negative reactivity feedback, unlike graphite-moderated RBMK reactors. Later installments in the series plan to examine dry storage cask loading procedures and nuclear cross sections.

Source quotes

[0:00] Destin: hot rocks make steam, which spins a turbine. [7:18] Bill Ball: We prefer to insert them instead of drop them. [12:12] Destin: Imagine you're on a merry-go-round and you got a bunch of people on the merry-go-round, and then you got this big kid on the merry-go-round. He's a fat kid, I'll just say it. He's a fat kid. And you're just going to spin the merry-go-round really, really fast, and you sling that fat kid off the merry-go-round. That's what they're doing. They're using the momentum properties of fluids, and the fact that liquid is more dense than gas to make it so that that liquid gets slung off, and it hits the sidewall of the pipe, and it drips back down into the core, which I think is fascinating! [20:24] Bill Ball: this reactor is always trying to shut itself down. [27:32] Bill Ball: I can point to it and say, it's right over there, and we know exactly how much it is, where it is, and how we're tracking it. [32:36] Bill Ball: critical is a good thing. [33:39] Destin: Mother, may I? [41:55] Destin: I am not the knower of all things. I am the asker of all questions, and I hope you enjoy being right there with me, having a blast. [41:55] Destin: I'm Destin. You're getting Smarter Every Day, have a good one. Bye.

Original transcript

[0:00] I was asked if I wanted to represent Alabama in a really cool thing called [0:04] 50 x 50 Science Across America. Basically, there's 50 videos being made, one from [0:10] every state, about a really cool scientist doing really cool science in that [0:14] location. I think it's awesome. So, being from Alabama, we have the nuclear plant [0:19] nearby, so this video is about how a nuclear reactor works, and we're going to [0:23] get to interview a really cool guy named Bill, it's awesome. So, if you want to see [0:27] some of the other cool stuff that's happening all across America, to celebrate [0:30] 250 years of America, you can do that by going to the link down in the video [0:34] description after this video, and go check out some of the other states and some of [0:38] the cool stuff that's happening. I'm proud to represent the South, this is a pecan [0:42] tree, which is why I set my camera up here, and, I'm excited about the stuff [0:46] that's happening here in Alabama, and I'm excited to learn more about the stuff [0:49] that's happening in other states. Let's go learn about a nuclear reactor. [0:53] Hey, it's me, Destin, welcome back to Smarter Every Day. I've got all these [0:56] boxes here at the house of all the different things that I've made videos of, [1:02] this one, you might remember, this is Uranium, and, you might remember this guy, [1:08] a fast neutron, these are little tools that we use to understand the concepts [1:14] of nuclear power. So basically, we- we hit this thing, and we talked about how like- [1:19] Uranium was kind of like a mousetrap and it would like throw off another fast [1:23] neutron. We kind of understand, if you've looked at previous videos, how nuclear [1:27] power works just from an atomic level. [1:30] Then we took a tour of Brown's Ferry Nuclear Power Plant we got to see the [1:34] hardware. Today's video is very special. We're going going to actually [1:39] understand the hardware; the core, specifically. [1:43] So when I started this Nuclear Power deep dive series, a guy sent me this- this book [1:48] right here. a guy named Alex, and he said, "hey, my granddad wrote this book," and I [1:51] opened it up and to my surprise, on this page right here, that is the actual [1:57] core of the Browns Ferry Nuclear Power Plant. It's called a Boiling Water [2:01] Reactor, and today we're going to learn all about how that works, and we're also [2:06] going to learn about these fuel assemblies over here. here. We're get to like- deep [2:09] dive into the physical components and understand how that works. [2:14] Because we know we've got hot rocks, and we know we've got steam, and that makes [2:18] electricity, but I want to understand exactly how the mechanics of the nuclear [2:24] reactor core work, and that's and that's what we're gonna do today, and it's gonna [2:27] be rad. Alright, that's it. Let's go- jump back into our Nuclear Power Deep Dive [2:32] Series here on Smarter Every Day. We've done all kinds of things already. [2:35] We checked out EBR-I, Experimental Breeder Reactor One out out in Idaho, we learned [2:39] about the world's first nuclear power to come online. We learned about nuclear [2:43] safety, and how people that work in the nuclear industry actually approach being [2:46] around nuclear energy. We've taken the tour, we've learned a ton in this series, [2:51] and it's been fantastic. let's go learn about the inner workings of a Boiling [2:56] Water Reactor, a nuclear reactor core, and continue our series on nuclear power. [3:01] Let's go get Smarter Every Day. [3:08] There are two main types of reactors in the U.S., the first is what's called a [3:12] Boiling Water Reactor, and the second is called a Pressurized Water Reactor. [3:17] They're pretty similar, but they're fundamentally different. So let's say this [3:21] is the reactor core of each, and this is the turbine of each. [3:25] So basically, what we wanna do is we wanna get steam to the turbine on each of 'em, [3:29] right? Well, the way a Boiling Water Reactor works is we have water in the [3:34] reactor there, and it actually starts to boil inside the reactor! [3:39] So, you get steam that goes directly to that turbine, and then it condenses back [3:45] and I didn't draw it well, but it turns back into water after it goes through [3:48] condenser. You get the idea. But long story short, it boils in the reactor, and [3:52] that goes directly to the turbine. In a Pressurized water reactor Water Reactor, [3:56] you have water inside the reactor, but the whole loop stays under pressure. [4:02] So, you end up having nothing but water in the reactor loop. [4:07] now, you end up having another heat exchanger that turns that hot water into [4:11] steam, and that's what goes over to the turbine, and then that goes back through a [4:17] condenser, and then you put that water back into that heat exchanger. [4:20] So basically, our Boiling Water Reactor, you're boiling water inside the reactor [4:25] itself, for a Pressurized Water Reactor, because you're maintaining such high [4:29] pressure, you keep it below the boiling point in the reactor, and you use a [4:33] secondary heat exchanger process to get steam to the turbine. [4:37] Brown's Ferry is a Boiling Water Reactor. Okay, we're we are here at Brown's Ferry [4:42] Nuclear Power Plant. We're not at the plant, though, are we, Bill? [4:45] No, we're in the training center right now. We're in the training center. [4:47] Okay this is Bill Ball. Bill does instrumentation, you know how the nuclear [4:51] plant works, all that kind of stuff, right? [4:52] For the most part, Yeah. Okay, so we're in a little interesting [4:56] room here in the training center, there's three models that we're look at. [4:59] One [4:59] The first model is a big overall model of how the whole thing works. [5:05] We'll look at that here in a second, and then- what do you have over here? [5:08] So over here is just a mock-up of what the actual reactor vessel internals look like, [5:12] right? So this is the, what we call the reactor pressure vessel. [5:15] Okay, so that- that, that's inside that one. [5:17] Correct. Okay, and then we have these over here, [5:20] these are models of the actual fuel rods. That's correct. These are the fuel [5:24] bundles. And so these are inside that- [5:28] Yep. and those are inside that. [5:33] Is that how this works? Yeah, you got it, that big, [5:35] gray cylinder in there is actually that mock-up right there for the reactor [5:38] vessel. in the gray cylinder. Okay, so I think let's [5:40] start with the overall context: so this is the nuclear reactor unit here at [5:46] Brown's Ferry Nuclear Power Plant, right? Yeah, This is actually a model of our [5:49] primary containment. The- what the reactor pressure, vessel is this gray portion [5:54] right here, as we said, was mimicked over there. And then, the reactor itself is the [5:59] fuel, which is inside the pressure vessel- Inside that. [6:02] Correct, which you'll see when we disassemble that 3D [6:05] So this is a beautiful model. Is this- this is old, right? [6:07] this is very old, been here since before I've been here. I came here in like 2009. [6:11] I think this is like 1970s, 1980s. Really? So this is before 3D printers. [6:15] This thing is awesome. But let's look at some pictures of the construction of [6:18] Brown's Ferry back in the 70s so you get a sense of the scale. This thing is huge. [6:23] And keep in mind, they have three of these reactors side by side within this plant. [6:27] This is the reactor as you said, Mhm. [6:29] and you have a sphere under that- Correct. [6:31] And then a outside that. what are what are the different sections of the unit? [6:36] Yeah, so this is what we would call the dry well, this outer portion, and the [6:39] bottom portion here is what we would call the torus and/or the wet well. [6:42] So you'll see a little catwalk where people can walk under here, [6:45] under- under the torus. The whole purpose of the torus, it [6:48] serves two primary functions. One, in the event there was some accident where this [6:52] vessel pressure boundary leaked and it put a bunch of steam in there, like suddenly, [6:56] it would suppress, all that steam would come down into here and suppress all that [7:01] steam and condense it under water, right? And it also serves as a surge volume for [7:05] all of our emergency systems, if we had to use them to pull the water and inject it [7:10] back into the vessel. So there are pipes, like, there are water [7:12] [pipes] going up into this- I guess, I guess we need to understand the reactor [7:17] better, don't I think so. [7:18] Okay, so- you want to go look at the reactor? So we're, we're doing this a [7:21] little weird. We're gonna start, give you context, and then drill down, and then [7:25] maybe when we go back, we'll understand how, how it all works. So this is the [7:28] reactor? Yep. [7:30] And, the real thing would be like tens of feet in diameter. It's really big. [7:34] So this is a 3D model of it? Alright, go for [7:37] It comes in two pieces. You've got the actual reactor, pressure vessel here, and [7:41] then the head, which should come off right here. [7:43] and these are all the bolts. Those would be bolts, right? [7:45] that's right, that's right. these these are the bolts that ring on top of it, or [7:49] the nuts that ring on top of it with the bolts- [7:50] Out of all the things in mechanical engineering, that I studied, one of the [7:53] things that I respect the most is the simple threaded bolt. [7:58] I mean, it's a fascinating thing. It's ultimately about tension in the joint, and [8:03] I could go on a huge, just spill about this ('cause I love threaded fasteners,) [8:08] but when we were on the tour, we got a closer look at these. This is the lid over [8:13] to the side, and when you look close you can see on the side- I'm thinking these [8:17] are the nuts. This is the part that screws down onto the bolts, or the studs, and we [8:21] saw those studs when we looked into the reactor, you could see that these studs [8:25] are sticking around the outside… I think that's how that works. [8:29] can sort of see inside here about what the vessel looks like. So we like to talk [8:33] about the vessel in two sections, there's actually a downcomer area, [8:37] what? A downcomer downcomer area, or an annulus [8:39] area? Comer area? [8:40] Downcomer. Wha- C-O-M-B-E-R? [8:44] C-O-M-E-R. C-O-M-E-R. Okay? [8:46] So I'll explain it here in a little bit bit more detail, but if we start [8:50] disassembling this thing... Oh, wow... [8:54] What you'll see is a steam dryer here- Oh, wow. [8:59] This is your moisture separator, kay? Again, let's check out this B-roll for [9:03] scale here: This is the steam dryer, and this is the moisture separator in the [9:08] spent fuel pool. This is when they took it off the top of reactor so they could [9:11] refuel the reactor during their outage, ...and Then this is where the actual fuel [9:15] sits on the inside here. [9:20] those are the fuel rods. So this would be- these would be the fuel [9:22] bundles like we see over here. This would be your, core plate down here, and this [9:27] would be the top guide. [9:30] Okay, and that's where the square holes, that's where you drop the fuel bundles [9:34] down into. we prefer to insert them instead of them. [9:37] Okay, yeah, that makes sense. Okay. Now, this is looking down into the reactor, [9:41] where you can see that top guide that Bill was talking about, and here you can see [9:45] the fuel bundle at the end the end of a big arm being inserted, (not dropped, as [9:49] Bill pointed out,) down into the reactor core. Yeah. [9:52] so, when I talk about the downcomer, you'll see on the side here, these things [9:55] called jet pumps, right? The white things? [9:58] Yep, these are jet pumps. And all these are just like big venturis, right? [10:01] Okay. So [cough] what we- what we're doing here [10:04] is we're injecting water from our feed water system see if I can halfway put this [10:09] together) into our nozzles here in the downcomer area, right? [10:15] And then we have some recirc pumps, which we looked at some variable frequency [10:19] drives, earlier, that pull water out of area, push them into the jet pumps, [10:25] the jet pumps push them under here, right? To where the fuel is. [10:29] So there’s- there's holes in that so it can communicate with the fuel section. [10:34] Yes, i- in the under-annulus area. Okay. [10:37] So- so, the water goes up under the core, Uh-huh. [10:41] And it's pushed under there, and then, and then the water boils, right? [10:48] Make some steam, A- and what- what are these top things? [10:51] These are moisture separators, cyclone moisture separators. So what they do is [10:54] make like a torturous path for the steam to come through, so we- we minimize the [10:59] moisture content of the steam, that's being coming out of the, of the, [11:04] I don't even understand what you just said. You said- I got the torturous path, [11:08] that's turbulent flow- you're slowing it down to cool it, but you said: oh- [11:13] "minimize the moisture of steam." I don't even- [11:15] Moisture content, right? So steam's, you can have wet steam or dry steam, right? [11:19] Okay. We prefer to have a dry steam going to our [11:22] turbine, right? the more water that's entrained in the steam, the more potential [11:25] we have to damage downstream products like our turbine, right? [11:28] Okay. So we want dry steam coming out of the [11:30] vessel. I've never even thought of every time I've thought of [steam] I think of a [11:34] sauna in Finland? Yeah. Yeah. You know, like the wet, moist heat, but a [11:39] dry steam is what you want. Correct. [11:41] Okay, so this has the torturous path, and what [11:44] it does is sort of condenses the, so it's like pipes. [11:49] Yeah, it condenses the steam with the lower enthalpy, right? [11:52] Okay. Only the high quality steam's gonna come [11:54] out, and then it goes through some dryers, which is really just, again, some more [11:57] torturous paths, some chevron dryers. And then, if we put it back in here again, [12:03] it'll come out the top here through our steam lines, [12:06] Oh. Right which we'll send off to, go to the [12:09] turbine to spin the turbine. Okay, Bill just said two things that were [12:12] fascinating. The first thing is he used this big word called enthalpy. [12:17] Enthalpy is like the internal energy in a fluid or a gas at any time, okay? [12:22] That involves the temperature and the pressure, and what work that fluid can do. [12:27] So if you have a steam that is really hot at a certain pressure, and then it cools [12:32] down cools down, but it's at that same pressure, it's gonna have less enthalpy. [12:36] Conversely, if it- if it's at a temperature and it goes to a lower [12:40] pressure, and it stays at the same temperature, you know, lower pressure, [12:45] that is a gas with less enthalpy. So like a thing that people throw [12:50] around to say: "this is how much energy this fluid has." The fact that Bill is [12:55] talking in terms of enthalpy tells me, a mechanical engineer, dude knows what he's [12:59] talking about. That's just kind of like a signal. Okay? Another thing: this concept [13:04] of wet steam versus dry steam. I find this to be fascinating. So, I've never really [13:09] thought about that, but if you were to whistle- [whistles] okay, you have just [13:15] gas coming out of your mouth, right? But, if you were to whistle and you've got, [13:19] like, a lot of spittle and stuff, like- like- you know, spits coming out of your [13:24] mouth, that is wet steam. so you have what's called two-phase flow, you have [13:29] gas, and liquid, together. So the way I think about it is, [13:35] this steam dryer separator thing that Bill's telling us about, he says: [13:39] “chevrons”. I think of like something going one direction and it has to turn [13:42] around and then keep going- I think of it as trying to get all- this is bad, but I'm [13:47] just going to say it: Imagine you're on a merry-go-round, go round and you got a [13:51] bunch of people on the merry-go-round, and then you got this big kid on the [13:54] merry-go-round. He's a fat kid, I'll just say it. He's a fat kid. And you're just [13:57] going to spin the merry-go-round really, really really fast, and you sling that fat [14:01] kid off the merry-go-round. That's what they're doing. They're using the momentum [14:06] properties of fluids, and the fact that liquid is more dense than gas to [14:12] make it so that that liquid gets slung off, and it hits the sidewall of the pipe, [14:16] and it drips back down into the core, which I think is fascinating! [14:20] Using a momentum property of a two-phase fluid in order to separate the liquid from [14:26] the gas, that's genius! I don't know that I ever would have thought about that, and [14:31] it's a fascinating approach. So the two concepts there are enthalpy, and the fact [14:35] that we're using this momentum nature of a two-phase fluid [14:39] to separate the liquid from the gas. Awesome! [14:42] So let me- let me- let me try- let me try to understand this. [14:46] So I'm going to to take this apart here… So this is like a big pipe. [14:52] Everything on the outside of it is designed for pumping water into it, so it [14:56] goes from the bottom up. Is that correct? Correct. [14:59] Okay. so the water's going in from the bottom up. I've [15:02] got this grid that I can, slowly and gently insert fuel- [15:07] [laughs] fuel bundles into, and so so depending on [15:11] the configuration of those fuel bundles, which we'll learn more about that later, [15:15] right? We're just going to assume that some magic happens at the reactor to make [15:18] heat. And then w- when that heat gets, it boils the water, and [15:24] it doesn't boil at like 212 Fahrenheit or 100 Celsius. It boils at a much higher [15:29] temperature: like 500 something? Yes, that's correct. [15:31] Okay. That's correct. [15:32] And it's because it's under pressure. That's right. [15:34] It's a big pressure cooker. That's the [15:36] best way to think of it. Okay. All right. So then we have this [15:39] right here And this is a bunch of pipes that make the, the steam zigzag on the way [15:44] up. So that only the good steam comes out. And then on top of that, once the [15:47] good steam comes out, you, you dry it even more. Is that the correct term? [15:51] That's correct. [15:53] You dry it even more, and, all that is under pressure. [15:58] And, so what's, what's the top here? So- so, this is the- the [16:03] bulkhead- is this called the bulkhead? It's a- we call it the, reactor vessel [16:07] head. The reactor vessel head. So that's the [16:09] thing that contains the pressure, and that's why all these bolts are so [16:13] important. That's correct. This is- I mean, if you [16:15] just think like in kitchen, this is one big pressure cooker. That's what we're [16:18] making. right? Okay. Got it. Okay. So cool! and then [16:20] all three reactors here at Browns Ferry Fair Ferry are designed the same. [16:24] Correct. Now that we understand the reactor itself, what I want to do is, is I [16:28] want to understand the fuel rods that are in there. [16:33] And that’s- that's where they go. The fuel bundles? Right? [16:37] and that's what we have over here. Yep! Can you, You [16:38] can you explain that to us a little bit? Absolutely. So… [16:41] [Clears throat] Here's a fuel bundle, right? [16:46] And you can see sort of what you're looking at are these pieces right here in [16:49] our 3D model. These vertical pieces, here? Okay. [16:52] There's 764 of these inside the core. That's a lot. [16:55] There is a lot. Now, when you say 760, are you are you [16:58] looking at these little rods, are you looking at these- this the square [17:00] piece [is the assembly, 764 bundles in the vessel. [17:03] Okay. That's a lot. Yeah. So, the way they're assembled is [17:07] you've essentially got four bundles per fuel assembly, okay? So, they all sit down [17:12] here- So is this a bundle? [17:14] This is a bundle- I'm looking at a bundle? [17:17] This is a bundle. Okay. [17:19] This whole thing is an assembly. Okay. Got it. So there's four bundles in an [17:24] assembly- and how many- what do you call the little rods of fuel? [17:27] Yeah, these are fuel rods made and we call this the cladding on the outside. [17:31] Is there pellets inside that? There are, these are uranium oxide [17:34] pellets, [17:35] and then these are zircaloy [17:37] cladding around it. So we have pellets, in rods, in what'd you [17:42] call. that? Inside a fuel, bundle. [17:45] And a bundle goes into an assembly. That's correct. [17:49] Okay. got it. All right. So, how does this work? work? [17:53] So, you've got four bundles that sit down in a fuel support casting. [17:57] You can sort of see where the- where they sort of connect down there on the bottom? [18:01] You see this little piece down here, [18:03] sort of just sits inside that fuel support casting. [18:06] Okay? It indexes in there. And then, In between it, what you have, is [18:11] a control rod blade. This thing right here. [18:14] That's right. This is a- control- it looks like a cross [18:16] from the top? That’s correct. [18:18] Okay- can I- can I stand on this? Okay, so I'm going to look straight down... [18:23] Oh, yeah, so there's the cross down there. [18:27] and- that's the, that's the control I always thought the control rod would be a [18:30] cylinder, but it's actually a cross. Yeah, [18:32] it's [18:32] so it's all about the cross section of absorption, right? So what we want to do [18:37] is we're we're, with these control rods is these control rods like neutrons, right? [18:42] and the whole fission process is about controlling how neutrons interact with [18:46] fuel or the material around them, right? Okay. [18:49] So- The control rods like neutrons? [18:52] Oh yeah, big time. So these are made of boron mostly, right? And boron is a [18:56] gigantic, a gigantic neutron absorber, right? [18:58] Okay. So- [cough] so the way the fission process [19:02] ultimately works, is you have a neutron that comes out, right? And in a light [19:06] water reactor, all this fuel- Now, that neutron that comes out, is it a [19:09] fast neutron? Like the other video? Yep! [19:12] Okay, It is is a fast neutron. And the- these these fuel bundles are [19:16] always covered with water constantly, right? So what we're doin' is in order [19:22] for a light water reactor to work, is the fuel or the neutron will get slowed down [19:27] by the water. Okay. [19:28] So the neutron interacts with the water molecules, right? Slows it down to what we [19:32] call thermalizing, and then it can interact with a multitude of different [19:36] things, right? either, but, for the most part, it either interacts with the fuel, [19:40] the fuel pellet that's in here, Okay. [19:42] Right? cause a fission, which would release energy, to- and that energy that's [19:46] heated when the- or the energy released when the when the fission occurs, heats up [19:50] the water, which we use to boil, Okay, [19:52] and make the steam, yeah- [19:53] or it can be absorbed in the control rods, where it's completely inert, right? [19:57] So when I look top down on the core, I'm seeing every four [20:03] slots right there that goes into an assembly. Correct. [20:07] Okay. Now, I do notice that- there’s- there's a hole right here, and [20:13] this looks very pipe-like. Are you- are you pumping water vertically through that? [20:18] So- so like we talked about earlier over here, [clears throat] the water is [20:24] technically flowing through here, so what happens is the water gets sucked from our [20:29] pumps out of the downcomer here, gets put in to the jet pumps here, where it goes [20:34] through this venturi, goes to the bottom of the core, and then there's enough [20:38] turbulent force with that that pump to push water [20:44] and flow up through the- up through the- the core this way. [20:47] Real big thing about this, [20:49] that I think's important to know: is this reactor is always trying to shut [20:52] itself down. What do you mean? [20:54] The hotter the water gets, the less reactive the reactor is. So think about [20:57] it: we talked about the only way we can interact with the fuel with these neutrons [21:01] is to thermalize them. slow them down with water. [21:04] Correct. So the the water is, how close are the molecules together? [21:08] The hotter the water is, it expands. Water expands when it up. [21:13] So if you have- if you have less molecules close to each other, right, in the water, [21:18] would your thermalization of thermalization neutrons go up or down? [21:21] You'd have less reactions, right? I'm assuming. I don't know this to be [21:24] true, but this- this is something you understand like, natively, I don't. [21:28] Right. So you're saying the hotter the water, the [21:30] more it takes energy away from the neutrons? [21:33] The hotter the water, the less likely a neutron is to collide with water [21:37] molecules, therefore the less likely it is to thermalize. [21:40] Oh, I see. Therefore, therefore the less neutrons [21:43] thermalize, thermalize, therefore less neutrons interact with the core, therefore [21:48] power goes down. Got it. It has to do with- there's a term: [21:54] it's the cross section. It has to do- like, as neutrons are flying out, the [21:58] cross-section of the water changes, is what it sounds like you're saying. [22:02] I love how Bill just understands all this stuff intuitively. I have to slow down and [22:06] think about it, and if you'll permit me, I'm going to do that real quick. [22:09] So the fuel inside the the reactor is Uranium-235 right? [22:15] In a previous video, we talked about this concept of the fast neutron. [22:20] The fast neutron zipping around, right? Well, the fast neutron is less likely [22:26] to interact with Uranium 235 than a slow neutron. [22:30] And so the slow neutron is what Bill is referring to as a thermalized neutron. [22:35] It's going slow. The way you thermalize a neutron is by a moderator. [22:40] Now, water is a moderator for neutrons, and so if you have a fast neutron: wee, [22:46] when it hits water, it has to bang around on all those hydrogen bonds, and it slows [22:52] down, and it becomes thermalized. So what Bill's saying is fascinating. [22:56] He Says: if you have water that's hot, the density of the water, [23:02] gets lower. It starts to expand, and so as it's on one straight path, it's going to [23:07] hit less water molecules. So the heat of the water actually affects how much the [23:12] neutron is thermalized. And when you moderate the fast neutrons less, they [23:17] remain fast and they are less likely to interact with the Uranium. [23:23] So what this means for us, is a really big deal. In the book it has this graphic, [23:27] which is amazing. It is the boiling in the water column in the reactor itself. [23:34] You'll notice that down here at the bottom, that's where the the gas starts to [23:37] nucleate, the bubbly flow, and as it starts to become more gaseous, you can see [23:43] up to the top there's nothing but gas! But down here in the middle, you've got like [23:47] this mix, this halfway between gas, halfway between liquid. [23:51] And so what that means, and I think this is amazing: this means that down in the [23:56] bottom of the column, you have water, and so those neutrons are thermalizing. [24:00] They're slowing down. it slows down and it reacts with the Uranium. [24:05] Up kind of midway, you're like, thermalizing some of 'em, not thermalizing [24:09] ising thermalizing other ones, but up at the top of the reactor they're just [24:13] zipping around, (if there's a-, if there's a neutron up there,) it's-, it remains [24:17] fast, and I'm talking about through the fuel rod, right? [24:22] So what this means is if you have a runaway, and you boil all the water, all [24:27] of your neutrons are going to be fast, and the reactivity of the whole dang thing is [24:33] going to go down. So the fact that you are turning all your water into steam, [24:39] you think that would be catastrophic, but actually, that has a self- correcting [24:44] factor to the reaction itself, which I did not KNOW. [24:49] AND when I understood this, I started to realize: oh, the engineers that made this [24:54] are smart. They made it, this BWR, they made it such that as the steam starts to [25:00] happen, you you no longer have as much reactivity. [25:05] and I thought that was really cool. We call it the negative temperature [25:07] coefficient of reactivity. Okay. [25:11] and- all- all it's really saying is: if the water if there's less water, or [25:15] water molecules are further apart, less neutrons thermalize, thermalize, [25:18] therefore less reactions occur in the core, therefore power drops. So the hotter [25:22] the water is, power wants to go down. [25:26] Interesting. That's interesting. [25:28] So, d- does it- is the reactor designed so ramps up to a certain place and it kind of [25:32] rides there? For the most part, we'll set it somewhere. [25:34] So we'll set a place with these control rods, i.e. how much fuel do we want to [25:38] expose? Uh-huh. Right. [25:40] To be able be able to have interactions with neutrons, right? [25:44] And then, we'll use the [25:46] research pumps to put flow up here to move what we call boiling boundary, right? [25:51] So h- where's the water? Where- where's the latent heat vaporization really [25:54] going to occur on these rods, Right? In the vertical dimension. [25:58] Correct. So is there a part of the- is there a part [26:02] of the- the fuel rods or the assemblies that it's ever exposed to air? [26:06] So no, these- these- these- these rods are always covered, (however, comma,) [26:12] these are- is where the boiling point is for the steam to come off and go up to, [26:17] to the steam dryer. and let the steam- so it's boiling and going up. [26:20] So you got bubbles like you see in a tea kettle [26:22] Correct. Correct. But the core is always, always covered. [26:26] So these little things inside here, those are- that's the actual fuel, right? [26:30] This is just like a tube. These are uranium oxide pellets, here. [26:33] Okay. And you have one of those out over here, [26:36] Yeah, we do. Well, so- it's not a real one. It's a mock-up. We wouldn't let it [26:39] that easily out here. but this is something that the NEI uses. [26:43] What is the They're- [26:46] Nuclear Energy Institute. Okay. [26:48] Ah- but what they do is they help interpret some NRC guidelines, and etc. [26:53] but the [26:53] NEI created sort of a mock-up and it's sort of in the back here you'll like- what [26:57] it's equivalent to. you should be able to see like how many tons of coal, [27:02] it's equivalent to, one ton of coal. So this little pellet has the same energy [27:06] in it as one ton of coal. Correct. [27:08] Wow. okay, so the energy density of nuclear is just off the charts. [27:13] That's right. And that's why we like it- it's expensive up front, right? [27:16] it costs a lot of money to get all the fuel in one location and all that other [27:20] type of stuff. But once we have it, we're stored, we're good for- we refuel, we're [27:24] good for two years. We don't have to continue to, you know, coal or buy or [27:29] anything like that. It's all sitting right there, so it's a reliable source of [27:32] energy. So if you think about a lot of people talk [27:34] about nuclear being a green energy, there's obviously waste associated [27:39] with this that we'll talk about in another video, I'm sure. But there's a lot of [27:43] energy that went into making the fuel as well. So like if you think about the whole [27:46] balance equation, you have to consider making this, you have to [27:49] consider all the stuff. W- are you at on nuclear in terms of do you think [27:55] it's a green energy or what's your... Yeah, well, obviously I'm a big fan of it, [27:59] right? It's very green. There's no carbon monoxide released with it. [28:02] Any- any waste that we produce, right, we know exactly where it is. [28:07] It didn't go somewhere and then we're trying we're trying to figure out, you [28:09] know, years later where in the air it is or how it affected the public. [28:13] I can point to it and say, it's right over there, and we know exactly- how much it [28:17] is, where it is, and how we're tracking it. [28:19] Interesting. So you're saying, yes, there is waste, which is one of the big [28:24] criticisms of nuclear is like, look, there's the waste. But your point is, you [28:28] know where it's at. It's not in the air That's right. [28:30] right Or in the water. That's right. [28:31] I've never heard that point made. That's pretty- that's pretty interesting. [28:34] There's a lot of stuff that just goes away from most power plants into the [28:39] atmosphere. but with a nuclear plant, it's right there. That's fascinating. [28:43] They have a storage area there. So, in a future episode, we're actually going to [28:46] look at this. We're going to meet some people that are preparing these nuclear [28:50] fuel rod casks, it's really fascinating, and I look forward to sharing that with [28:54] you. So I have been working on my school stuff for quite a long time and this [29:00] computer right here is very important to me, because I have some very [29:05] complicated simulations simulations in a program called ANSYS LS-DYNA. [29:10] So this is one of the, this is one of the simulations. This is a bullet hitting [29:14] a bullet. It's really cool. So the way this works is I have to run these [29:19] simulations and I've got all these hard drives hooked up to this computer and it [29:24] takes a long time to run these things. Well, I need to check on those simulations [29:29] when I'm not at home and sometimes I need to tweak some stuff. And so I've actually [29:33] been doing that for a long time with the sponsor of today's video, which is [29:38] AnyDesk. So any desk is like remote desktop software that you can use from [29:43] anywhere and all you do is you pull up any desk on your computer, and you [29:49] host it here and then you can use a password to get into your computer from [29:53] somewhere else. So, for example, this is some footage of me in a train in [29:59] England checking on simulations. Also, here's me at the New York Public Library. [30:04] I really like to work there. I've been doing stuff there. You can also use your [30:08] phone to log into the computer. Here's some footage of me doing that and checking [30:12] on the simulation. This one blew my mind. Now that they have [30:15] Wi-Fi in airplanes, I've been doing work on [30:18] these simulations in airplanes. Apparently, we live in the future now. [30:23] So if you have a need to let somebody access your computer or you [30:28] want to access your own computer remotely password, protect it and all that [30:32] stuff, you can do that by going to anydesk.com slash And the way it works is [30:37] there's a freeware version and they're banking on you liking this software so [30:41] much that you're going to get a corporate version at wherever you work and that's [30:44] how they're going to make their money. So it's a really good tool. [30:47] It's helped me a lot. Actually, I've recently got this paper published, which [30:52] is fantastic. So if you want to see this paper, you can go to Royal Society Open [30:57] Science and, you can check out the paper and a lot of the work done on this [31:03] paper was done via AnyDesk. So it's been a really big deal for me. [31:07] It's been a game changer and it's helped me a lot and, it's helping me with my [31:12] research. So if you want to check that out, supporting the sponsor, support [31:15] smarter every day, and I'm grateful [31:17] If you have a need for this in your life, this is a really good tool. [31:23] I use it all the time. That's it. anydesk.com smarter. Try it if you [31:26] need it, if you don't, whatever. Okay, let's go back and talk to Bill about the [31:30] fail-safe design characteristics of the nuclear reactor itself. [31:34] So, it's the configuration of multiple bundles in the water that allows you to go [31:39] critical. Correct. [31:40] Okay. Correct. No one- no one assembly will go [31:44] critical on itself. In fact, we have a calculation we make, the way these things [31:47] are designed that you could delete a control rod. [31:51] A control rod. aggregately in the big core, right? And [31:54] the core will still remain shut down at all times. So if something happens- so [31:57] are- are the control rods controlled independently are they all together on one [32:00] plate? Independently. Independently. [32:03] Correct. Really? And so if one of 'em were to drop, [32:06] I would assume that would make the [32:07] reactivity in this part of the reactor go up. [32:10] But, yeah, yes it would. But the way- the overall- [32:13] the overall core, nothing would "latch". There's not enough reactivity in this area [32:20] to cause a critical reaction in the core. Wow. So there's a lot of probability and [32:24] statistics and geometry, frankly, that goes into all this. Correct. A lot of [32:28] differential equations. Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely. Everything's balanced. [32:32] Yep. Yeah, so steady state is your- your friend [32:34] in a nuclear reactor. Absolutely. [32:36] Okay. When you hear a nuclear engineer say the word "critical" it sounds like a scary [32:42] thing, but it's actually not. Let's graph a nuclear reaction, and let's see what [32:47] this is all about. If If we have number of neutrons on the y axis here, and we have [32:52] time on the x axis- let's say we have zero right there, we have one neutron here, we [32:57] have two neutrons there. If I put in one neutron and I get less than one neutron [33:02] out, even if it's Over time, my nuclear [33:07] reaction is going to go down. It's going to dissipate, and stop reacting at some [33:12] point. If, however, for every one neutron I put in, I get one neutron out, then that [33:18] is said to be critical. I am in a steady state situation, and that's good! [33:22] I can generate power indefinitely like this. However, if I get more than one [33:27] neutron out for every neutron I put in, that's called supercritical, and that can [33:31] get out of control. We do not want that. What we want is a critical reactor. [33:37] The word "critical" is a good thing. [33:39] So when you're bringing a reactor up, is that the most critical time, pun intended, [33:44] to- to watch everything? Well, it is, really, 'cause because I told [33:47] you- I told you before that the reactor is always trying to shut itself down. [33:51] Not just with the temperature of the water, trying to- you know, cause less [33:55] reactions as it heats up. So these rods, actually, what's holding these rods back [34:00] from inserting into the core is what we call scram solenoid pilot valves. [34:04] So these are- these are- energized, right, to hold air, [34:10] hold air on the control rod to withdraw it. So if at any point in time, we lose [34:15] air, or the scram pilot valves You automatically insert? [34:19] It automatically inserts. right? So then all of our instrumentations that monitor [34:24] reactor power, [34:25] like our SRMs, IRMs, APRMs, if at [34:28] any point in time it sees a value that is non-conservative, it automatically trips [34:33] them and causes- it causes the air to port off and insert the control rods. [34:37] So the way the control theory works, or, I- uh, the theory of operation of a [34:42] reactor, it's a privilege from the reactor standpoint, for it to run. [34:47] Correct. It has to say: “Mother may I, Mother may [34:50] I? Mother, may I?" "Yes, you may." and then it can run, if at any point in time [34:54] anything goes weird, it is, not given the permission to run. [34:58] Correct. Okay. Tell me about these levels of [35:01] containment you were telling me about? Yeah, so got five basic levels of [35:04] containment, right? So the first one is our fuel pellet itself, right? [35:08] All the fission products we really want to contain in the fission itself, or the [35:12] pellet itself, right? Okay? [35:14] So then, our second barrier is actually this clad. Now, as this pellet reacts, [35:19] Right? And more- it's going to swell a little bit, right? So you'll actually see: [35:23] I don't know if you can [35:23] tell, there's actually it'll, it'll grow. [35:26] Right. And we call- we call the spacing between the pellet and the clad, the [35:31] interaction process, right? So we actually highly monitor it, and that's why we come [35:34] up in [35:34] power [35:35] real nice and easy, because this clad is really the primary thing we want to [35:40] contain everything in: inside the cladding of these fuel pellets. [35:42] What's this made out of? Is That's correct. So that's really [35:46] anti-rust, all that other type of stuff. Very very, material. [35:51] Is it invisible to neutrons? For the most part, yes. [35:54] Okay. so this is our second boundary. And in [35:56] fact, when we go through our emergency procedures later in the simulator, you'll [35:58] see that the, cladding, that's what they're always trying to protect. [36:03] and the way we protect most of the cladding is by keeping the core covered [36:06] with water, keeping it nice and cool. Okay. [36:08] In order to minimize the amount of pellet [36:10] to clad interaction that could potentially occur. [36:12] Okay, so first level of containment is the tube. [36:15] First level of containment is the pellet. [36:17] dep The pellet itself. [36:18] That's correct. Okay. [36:19] Then it's the tube. Okay. [36:21] Okay, then if all that else fails, we contain [36:26] here, inside the vessel. All this- we can shut everything off and isolate and [36:30] contain everything inside the vessel itself. [36:32] So this is a mechanical pressure vessel that's designed to withstand a certain [36:37] pressure, and that's a lot of bolts for a pressure vessel. So it can handle crazy [36:43] pressures. Well, it [36:43] handles up to about 1,250 pounds. [36:45] Okay. So normally, when we shut down, we operate [36:48] somewhere around a thousand pounds. Pounds. Normally, when we shut down, the [36:52] pressure will decay off pretty quickly. Okay. And then if that fails, that that's [36:57] where we come into where our primary containment is. [37:00] Okay. So for some reason, the vessel becomes [37:03] compromised, we can contain everything in here. So all everything in here can be [37:08] shut off and it's actually self-sufficient. We talked about the [37:10] emergency cooling pumps? Actually taking suctions from down here? It's just one big [37:14] loop that feeds back into itself constantly. [37:16] I asked Bill, what this part of the reactor is made of. and if you go back to [37:20] those original photos where they were creating the plant, you can see it's a [37:24] combination of steel, and it has concrete on the outside of that. Bill said there's [37:28] a specific reason they do this. The reason we choose different, types of [37:32] material, we can call, what I'll call a tenth thickness, right? [37:36] has a lot to do with radiation. We can explore that a little bit later, [37:39] but effectively: it's how much thickness of a material you'll need to need to [37:43] reduce the radiation in an- in an area by- down to a tenth of what it was. [37:47] Okay, so you got steel, and then steel, and then concrete. And all this stuff down [37:52] here is steel as well? Correct. [37:54] Okay, got it. And so you can contain pressure on this one. Does this have any [37:58] kind of, pressure Capability? It's a larger volume, right? so lower [38:02] pressure, but we- this can maintain up to, approximately pounds. [38:06] [per square inch] We'd We normally try not to limit past fifty-six 56 pounds. [38:10] Normal operation, we intentionally inert this dry well, right? [38:14] we don't want any explosive gases or anything in there. so it's filled with [38:17] nitrogen, and we keep about a pound of pressure in here. [38:20] Positive pressure. Positive pressure, correct. Okay. and you [38:22] do that so that- well why do you do that? Well, for multiple reasons. [38:26] One: it puts a pressure boundary on the water down here in the torus, right? [38:30] So it provides net positive suction head [38:32] for our pumps and emergency pumps if it's needed, [38:34] Okay? And then, two: it ensures that we have an [38:37] inert gas inside the so that in [38:40] event something did leak by, you know there's potential for hydrogen or [38:43] something like that- it doesn't- there's no potential for explosion inside there. [38:48] Got it. Everything's inert. That's correct. [38:50] Got it! So this is the ultimate- but you've got pipes and stuff going to this? [38:55] And got water coming out of this? So how do you contain that? Like, let's say [38:59] something like- I- I'm going to use the word dirty water comes out? or Like, [39:03] what, what's the correct? Correct way to say that? has radiological contaminants. [39:08] Sure. Where does that go? So are you asking like in the event of an accident, [39:13] or are you asking? So, normally we'd want to contain contained all right within [39:17] here, so it would probably come out the vessel, fall onto the bottom of the [39:21] dry well down there, and then fill up and eventually make its way down to the torus, [39:25] where we just circulate that water back into the reactor. Now, you're right, there [39:29] are pipes that come in here. We have to be able to add water sometimes or add [39:33] nitrogen like we talked about, but we have what we call primary containment isolation [39:37] valves. Everything is double-valved. Okay. [39:40] So we have an inboard valve and valve, and both of them will close on the event that [39:44] we get a signal- just like we talked about with the, with the permissives for running [39:49] the reactor and running the core, how it's has to be "safe to operate”? [39:52] "Mother may I?" Yeah. That's wha- the same thing with the [39:54] containment. In fact, we have a, AC valve inside the right? [39:59] No sparks, DC valve on the outside. so multiple power sources. So one of them [40:03] fails, the other is to to come back behind it and close. [40:06] I didn't know that. Does Does an AC an AC valve has no sparks? [40:10] Yeah, as far as I'm aware, yeah. That's why the DC valve actually runs on- DC [40:14] motor will run on brushes, right? Yeah, that's right. So your carbon brush to the [40:18] commutator will cause, a spark, Yeah. You have [40:22] to think about all that. Yeah. Interesting. What are people most [40:25] concerned about with a meltdown? Well, I think it's the corium that's generated, [40:29] right? So what that, what that is, is, is in the event something were to happen with [40:33] meltdown, right? The, the clad and the fuel and the reactor vessel, it would have [40:38] to melt through the reactor vessel. All that stuff combines into one thing. [40:41] one thing and then it's just this highly, highly contaminated potential [40:46] piece of metal, right, that is really hot, that is unable to cool. [40:51] One of the things that's really important for our fuel bundles is what we call core [40:55] geometry. If you go back over here and look at ‘em, water easily flows [41:02] to cool off this cladding everywhere, right through all- [41:05] convection. That's right. So if for some reason, you, [41:09] know, the core operated and all that stuff started melting together, that [41:12] coolable core coolable core [41:13] geometry wouldn't be there for us. And that would be- that's some of the [41:16] catastrophic stuff that you saw, like at Chernobyl. But Chernobyl and everything, [41:20] they're not light water reactors, right? So the- Chernobyl didn't have [41:26] what we call the negative temperature coefficient of reactivity, right? [41:28] They weren't self- they weren't Like we were. They were all about making [41:33] power as quick as possible with those [41:35] RMBK, reactors. [41:37] So it's a completely different core design [41:38] than what we have here. This one's designed more for safety? [41:41] Yes, I think so, Yes. Did we incorporate the lessons learned [41:45] from Chernobyl into this, or was this- Well, this was designed well before [41:48] Chernobyl. Oh, really? [41:49] [inaudible] Well, I don't know when was designed, but happened 1986, I think. [41:55] Got it. The thing I love about this Nuclear Power Deep Dive series is I wanted [41:59] to learn about nuclear power for years. I wanted to get every resource I could get [42:03] my hands on and just dig into it, but I didn't do that because I wanted to [42:09] authentically learn this with you on camera, and that's what we're doing, and [42:13] it's awesome. Like, I'm asking questions I don't know the answer to while in a [42:18] nuclear plant. Talking to people. It's awesome. I hope you are really enjoying [42:23] this, like I am. I am not the knower of all things. I am the asker of all [42:28] questions, and I hope you enjoy being right there with me, having a blast. [42:33] Bill Ball, however, does know a ton about this nuclear plant and he's sharing that [42:37] knowledge with us. So huge thank you to Bill Ball TVA for taking the time to teach [42:42] us all this awesome stuff. We're grateful. So yeah, a big thanks to everybody that [42:47] supports Smarter Every Day at Your support is [42:52] allowing me to do the things I want. Like, I want to ask these really interesting [42:56] questions these really interesting ways, you're helping me do that! [42:59] So, thank you so much, patrons. I am grateful. More videos, More videos to come [43:03] in the Nuclear Power Deep Dive series, we're gonna talk to a guy named Bill [43:06] Williamson. We're gonna talk about nuclear cross section section. I'm excited to- to [43:10] learn that with you, and there's so much more. We went back out to Idaho National [43:14] Labs. There's a ton here. So, big thanks to you for being here here, please [43:18] consider subscribing to Smarter Every Day. If not, no big deal. I'm Destin. [43:22] You're getting Smarter Every Day, have a [43:24] good one. Bye.