Sapolsky Casts Major Depression as Biological Disease Akin to Diabetes
Stanford
Major depression is an organic biochemical pathology driven by stress-hormone dysregulation and gene-environment interactions, rendering demands for emotional willpower as medically baseless as expecting a diabetic to produce insulin on command.
Major depression affects roughly 15% of the population over their lifetimes and is projected by the World Health Organization to become the second leading cause of global disability by 2025. (0:08)
Depression is an organic biological disorder as real as juvenile diabetes, marked by disrupted sleep architecture, elevated resting metabolism, and persistent 24/7 sympathetic stress arousal. (9:17)
Roughly 20% of major depressive presentations represent undiagnosed hypothyroid syndromes such as Hashimoto's disease, which resolve once circulating thyroid hormone is supplemented. (31:08)
Genetic susceptibility to depression acts via gene-environment interactions: the vulnerable variant of the serotonin transporter gene multiplies depression risk up to thirtyfold only when paired with severe developmental stress. (45:45)
Detailed notes
## Background
Published by Stanford on YouTube on November 10, 2009, this full-length lecture features Stanford Professor Robert Sapolsky discussing the pervasive impact of depression in the United States. According to the page description, Sapolsky posits that depression is the most damaging disease an individual can experience, ranking as the fourth leading cause of disability in the U.S., and emphasizes that it is as real of a biological disease as diabetes.
## TL;DR
In this comprehensive lecture, Robert Sapolsky dismantles the divide between biology and psychology to explain why major clinical depression is one of the most crippling diseases on Earth. He details its cardinal symptoms—including anhedonia, psychomotor retardation, delusional guilt, and disrupted sleep architecture—contrasting them with ordinary sadness or reactive grief. Sapolsky walks through the underlying neurochemistry involving norepinephrine, serotonin, and dopamine, alongside the impacts of thyroid disorders and elevated glucocorticoids from chronic stress. Finally, he weaves in psychological models like learned helplessness and gene-environment interactions, arguing that psychiatric illness carries genetic vulnerabilities activated by trauma and must be destigmatized as an organic biological illness on par with diabetes.
## Atmosphere & style
The lecture combines the intellectual rigor of a masterclass in neurobiology with an empathetic, candid delivery that treats severe mental illness with profound seriousness. Sapolsky speaks in an engaging, self-deprecating, and approachable style, cutting through academic formality with dark humor, vivid metaphors, and sharp clinical anecdotes. The emotional arc transitions from scientific analysis of synapses and hormones to a passionate, moral plea directed at high-achieving university students, urging them to shed the shame and silence surrounding depression and recognize it as an undeniably real physical disease.
## Bulletin
- [00:08](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=8s) Major depression affects roughly 15% of the population over their lifetimes and is projected by the World Health Organization to become the second leading cause of global disability by 2025.
- [09:17](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=557s) Depression is an organic biological disorder as real as juvenile diabetes, marked by disrupted sleep architecture, elevated resting metabolism, and persistent 24/7 sympathetic stress arousal.
- [31:08](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=1868s) Roughly 20% of major depressive presentations represent undiagnosed hypothyroid syndromes such as Hashimoto's disease, which resolve once circulating thyroid hormone is supplemented.
- [45:45](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=2745s) Genetic susceptibility to depression acts via gene-environment interactions: the vulnerable variant of the serotonin transporter gene multiplies depression risk up to thirtyfold only when paired with severe developmental stress.
## Key takeaways
- [02:29](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=149s) Everyday sadness and reactive grief differ fundamentally from major depression, which eventually becomes endogenous, chronic, and decoupled from external triggers.
- [04:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=256s) The pathognomonic symptom of major depression is anhedonia—the complete incapacity to feel pleasure—which dismantles the adaptive psychological coping mechanisms that sustain patients through other severe physical illnesses.
- [05:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=325s) Depressive guilt reaches delusional severity, fundamentally warping objective logic to reinforce the conviction that reality is hopeless and deteriorating.
- [07:39](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=459s) The highest risk window for suicide paradoxically emerges as psychomotor retardation begins to lift, restoring physical agency before psychological despair resolves.
- [10:52](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=652s) Vegetative symptoms such as early morning awakening, fragmented 90-minute sleep cycles, and loss of appetite demonstrate that depression is fundamentally grounded in biology rather than character flaws.
- [13:42](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=822s) Seasonal Affective Disorder and strictly cyclical depressive episodes illustrate how bodily biological clocks can dictate psychiatric relapse independently of external events.
- [14:49](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=889s) Early pharmacological insights connected norepinephrine signaling to reward pathways, though the time-course paradox and SSRIs shifted the field toward a multi-neurotransmitter framework.
- [22:57](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=1377s) A working tri-neurotransmitter consensus maps dopamine deficiency to anhedonia, norepinephrine deficiency to psychomotor retardation, and serotonin deficiency to obsessive psychic grief.
- [24:05](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=1445s) Substance P, the chemical messenger responsible for physical pain, is also implicated in depression, demonstrating that psychological and physical pain rely on shared neurochemistry.
- [25:15](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=1515s) Through the triune brain architecture, the expanded human cortex can trigger severe, full-body stress responses solely through abstract thought and rumination.
- [29:09](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=1749s) Anterior cingulotomy offers relief in treatment-resistant cases by surgically severing the anterior cingulate pathway connecting abstract cortical rumination to emotional centers.
- [32:42](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=1962s) Significant sex differences in depressive prevalence correspond to hormonal shifts during postpartum, premenstrual, and menopausal periods that modulate neurotransmitter receptor densities.
- [35:37](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=2137s) Elevated glucocorticoids persistently stress the system, and repeated stress-triggered depressive episodes eventually shift the neurobiology into autonomous, spontaneous cycling.
- [38:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=2294s) Freud's concept of melancholia captures the inward-directed aggression arising from ambivalence toward lost figures, but it cannot be directly integrated into experimental neurochemistry.
- [41:23](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=2483s) Psychological stress stems from a lack of control, predictability, outlets, and social support, driving the cognitive distortion of learned helplessness.
- [42:59](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=2579s) Losing a parent to death before age ten permanently predisposes an individual to learned helplessness and elevates major depression risk across a lifetime.
- [45:45](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=2745s) Genetic predisposition does not dictate fate; rather, variants like the serotonin transporter gene determine an organism's resilience or vulnerability to external childhood stressors.
- [50:07](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=3007s) Stigma surrounding psychiatric illness remains disproportionately severe in high-achieving environments, despite depression being as objective an organic malfunction as pancreatic insulin failure.
## Detailed walkthrough
### [00:08](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=8s) Exotic Diseases vs. the Reality of Human Medical Misery
Professor Robert Sapolsky opens the lecture by observing the strange fascination people have with exotic medical oddities. Medicine is full of dramatic conditions that capture public curiosity—Elephant Man syndrome (Proteus syndrome), progeria (where children tragically age and die of senescence by roughly ten years old), or cannibals contracting prion diseases from consuming human brains. These illnesses make for exciting junior high school biology reports or sensational made-for-television movies. Pausing briefly to invite students lingering in the back of the lecture hall to come down and take the empty front-row seats, Sapolsky shifts from these medical curiosities to the primary subject of the lecture: the true “meat and potatoes of human medical misery.”
When measured by pervasive human suffering, nothing compares to depression. Sapolsky asserts that major depression is thoroughly crippling, wildly pervasive, and arguably the single worst disease an individual can experience. Its scale is staggering: current epidemiological estimates indicate that 15% of the general population will endure a major depressive episode at some point during their lifetime. According to the World Health Organization, depression is already the number four cause of disability on the planet, and by 2025 it is projected to rise to number two, trailing only obesity- and diabetes-related disorders. To understand why this disorder is so uniquely catastrophic, Sapolsky explains that one must dismantle the false divide between biology and psychology; anyone who restricts their understanding to only one of those perspectives will fundamentally fail to comprehend the illness.
“I'll make the argument here today, a number of things, but one critical thing being that basically depression is like the worst disease you can get.” — Robert Sapolsky
[02:29](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=149s) The Semantic Problem: Everyday Blues, Reactive Depression, and Major Depression
A major obstacle to understanding depression is everyday semantics. In casual speech, people routinely use the word "depressed" to describe routine emotional dips: receiving bad news, having to replace a car transmission, or feeling disappointed by an acquaintance. In those instances, someone might feel bummed or down for a few days, but that transient emotional state bears no resemblance to the clinical disorder under discussion.
```mermaid
flowchart TD
accTitle: Spectrum of Depressive States
accDescr: Diagram illustrating the three levels of depression described by Sapolsky: everyday blues, reactive depression, and major depression.
subgraph S1["Transient Moods"]
A["Everyday 'Depression'<br/>Minor setbacks, bad news<br/>Duration: A few days"]
end
subgraph S2["Grief Responses"]
B["Reactive Depression<br/>Major loss: bereavement, job loss<br/>Duration: Weeks of malaise, then recovers"]
end
subgraph S3["Clinical Pathology"]
C["Major Depression<br/>Severe, prolonged flattening<br/>Duration: Months/years; persists without external triggers"]
end
A -.->|escalation of severity| B
B -.->|pathological chronicity| C
```
Sapolsky distinguishes between three distinct categories of depressive experiences:
- **Everyday depression:** The normal, fleeting sadness or frustration everyone encounters after minor setbacks.
- **Reactive depression:** A profound, prolonged period of malaise triggered by a major, legitimate life crisis—such as the loss of a job, extended unemployment, or the death of a loved one—where a person is severely impaired for weeks before eventually recovering and emerging on the other side.
- **Major depression:** A state in which an individual is flattened by despair for weeks and months on end without recovering. Over time, patients with major depression no longer require an external catastrophic event to trigger a relapse; the condition becomes self-sustaining and endogenous.
“If I had to define major depression in one sentence, I would say, it's a biochemical disorder with a genetic component, and early experience influences, where somebody can't appreciate sunsets.” — Robert Sapolsky
[04:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=256s) Anhedonia: The Incapacity for Pleasure
Sapolsky argues that what makes major depression uniquely horrifying compared to severe physical diseases is its destruction of human coping mechanisms. When observing patients suffering from terminal cancer or crippling cardiovascular disease, one frequently witnesses an astonishing human resilience. Patients facing death will often reflect on their circumstances and say that while they would never wish for cancer, the illness forced them to discover the true value of their friendships, reconcile broken relationships with family members, or find spiritual faith. Humans possess a remarkable capacity to extract joy and meaning from the most adverse circumstances.
Major depression, however, attacks that very capacity. Its primary, pathognomonic symptom is anhedonia—the polar opposite of hedonism, defined as the complete inability to feel pleasure. When an individual trapped in a major depression experiences an objective stroke of fortune, such as the achievement of a long-sought goal or the successful beginning of a romance, they feel completely hollow.
“What could possibly be worse than a disease whose defining symptom is the inability to feel pleasure?” — Robert Sapolsky
[05:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=325s) Delusional Guilt and the Structural Engineer
Alongside anhedonia, major depression is characterized by crushing grief and guilt. While everyday sadness causes people to obsess over minor past regrets—such as dwelling on an unkind thing done to someone twelve years prior—the guilt in major depression is so overwhelming that it crosses into genuine delusion. Sapolsky clarifies that this is not the thought disorder or auditory hallucination seen in schizophrenia, but rather a profound, distorted conviction that the universe is irredeemably broken.
To illustrate this depressive delusion, Sapolsky shares the case of a structural engineer, the father of an acquaintance. The man was in late middle age and had always been healthy until he suddenly suffered a major heart attack. Clinically, his prognosis was good; he required lifestyle adjustments, but his medical team expected a full recovery. Instead, the psychological blow shattered his identity. He viewed himself overnight as a frail, ruined old man and plunged into a deep clinical depression.
The hospital where he was recovering had a circular floor plan with a continuous hallway. One afternoon, his family attempted to encourage him, noting that the nursing staff reported he had walked two full laps around the hospital that day, compared to just one lap the day before. The engineer vehemently rejected their encouragement, insisting that the hospital staff had performed construction during the night, closed the outer perimeter, and opened a smaller inner loop—meaning his two laps were actually shorter than the previous single lap, proving that he was deteriorating toward death. For a trained structural engineer to believe that crews had reorganized the interior architecture overnight exemplifies how depressive cognition warps objective reality to confirm total hopelessness.
“This is what a structural engineer looks like when they're delusional to the point of saying that this is a world in which everything is inevitably getting worse, depression built around that.” — Robert Sapolsky
[07:39](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=459s) Psychomotor Retardation and the Paradox of Suicide Risk
The physical toll of depression often manifests in self-injury and suicide. Alongside accidental injuries, suicide ranks as the leading cause of death among teenagers and young adults. Another cardinal symptom is psychomotor retardation, where every physical movement and mental operation requires immense, exhausting effort. Simple, mundane domestic chores become insurmountable obstacles: doing a load of laundry becomes impossible because locating the laundry hamper, finding coins for the machine, and fetching the detergent demands an impossible amount of cognitive and physical energy. The individual becomes completely paralyzed by fatigue.
```mermaid
flowchart LR
accTitle: The Clinical Paradox of Psychomotor Retardation and Suicide
accDescr: Flowchart showing how extreme psychomotor retardation prevents suicide, whereas partial recovery creates energy for self-harm.
subgraph LowRisk["Deep Depressive Paralysis"]
A["Severe Psychomotor Retardation"] --> B["Inability to leave bed or plan"]
B --> C["Suppressed Suicide Execution"]
end
subgraph HighRisk["Early Treatment / Remission"]
D["Psychomotor Retardation Lifts"] --> E["Despair Remains Intact"]
E --> F["Surge in Physical Energy"]
F --> G["Catastrophic Suicide Risk"]
end
This severe psychomotor retardation produces a well-known clinical paradox regarding suicide risk. When a hospitalized patient is so deeply depressed that they cannot muster the energy to get out of bed or get dressed, they generally lack the executive capacity and physical drive to attempt suicide—they are incapable of fashioning a noose from mattress fibers. The most perilous window occurs when the patient begins to respond to treatment or starts emerging from the depression. As the psychomotor retardation begins to lift, the patient regains physical energy and motivation before their psychological despair and nihilism have resolved. This sudden return of physical agency combined with enduring emotional agony creates the catastrophic window where clinicians must enforce strict suicide watches.
“When they're starting to come out, that's where the psychomotor retardation relieves enough that suddenly they've got the energy to do something catastrophic.” — Robert Sapolsky
[09:17](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=557s) Biological Reality: Beyond the Myth of "Pulling Yourself Together"
Sapolsky emphasizes the single most critical misconception that depressed patients must battle: the social stigma of being told to simply snap out of it. Because almost every human being experiences periods of feeling down, withdrawing, grieving, and eventually coping and recovering, society tends to view patients with major depression through a moralizing lens. There is an insidious undercurrent of judgment implying that chronic depression represents personal weakness or a lack of character: "Come on, pull yourself together; we all deal with this."
Sapolsky rejects this view entirely, arguing that major depression is an organic biological illness. Telling a clinically depressed patient to shake off their despair is as medically nonsensical as telling a juvenile diabetic to stop babying themselves and produce insulin through sheer willpower. Depression is a physical disease characterized by distinct vegetative symptoms—objective alterations in how the body functions, starting with drastic disruptions in basic physiological cycles like sleep architecture.
“I will make the argument throughout here that depression is as real of a biological disorder as is juvenile diabetes.” — Robert Sapolsky
[10:52](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=652s) Biological Hallmarks: Disrupted Sleep, Appetite, and Stress Physiology
When an everyday person feels stressed or unhappy, they often lie awake tossing and turning, unable to fall asleep. Robert Sapolsky points out that major depression presents a completely different clinical picture: early morning awakening. A patient with major depression will wake up at four or five in the morning, utterly exhausted, yet completely unable to get back to sleep. This symptom is so indicative of the illness that any emergency room clinician assessing a severely depressed patient ought to immediately inquire about their sleep patterns. Furthermore, sleep is not a monolithic state; it possesses a complex internal architecture of roughly 90-minute cycles moving through slow-wave sleep, deep sleep, and REM sleep. Brain scans of depressed individuals reveal that this structure completely falls apart: “Look at somebody when they're sound asleep, and their brain sleeps differently.” This internal disorganization cannot be dismissed as a character flaw; as Sapolsky emphasizes, “This screams biology.”
Appetite and stress physiology reveal similarly profound biological disruptions. While everyday sadness often drives people to overeat comfort food—a response rooted in the neurochemistry of carbohydrates decreasing stress hormone release—clinical depression typically manifests as a severe loss of appetite. At the same time, the body’s physiological stress apparatus goes into overdrive. A depressed patient exhibits highly elevated levels of stress hormones alongside massive over-activation of the sympathetic nervous system and adrenaline release. While psychomotor retardation might make a patient look like an inert “sea sponge” who cannot summon the energy to get out of bed, their physiology tells an opposite story. “This is someone whose body is having a massive stress response 24/7,” Sapolsky explains, driven by an intense internal battle marked by increased metabolic rate and elevated muscle tone.
- **Early morning awakening**: Waking up at 4:00 or 5:00 AM exhausted and unable to return to sleep is a diagnostic hallmark of major clinical depression.
- **Disrupted sleep architecture**: The normal cyclical 90-minute progression across sleep stages (including slow-wave, deep sleep, and REM) breaks down entirely in the depressed brain.
- **Carbohydrates and stress**: Eating carbohydrates physiologically reduces stress hormone release, explaining why everyday sadness triggers comfort eating, whereas major clinical depression suppresses appetite.
- **Internal hyperarousal**: Despite an outward appearance of profound lethargy and motor slowing, patients experience elevated resting metabolism, increased muscle tone, and relentless sympathetic nervous system activation.
---
[13:42](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=822s) Biological Clocks and Rhythmic Depressions
Major depression frequently exhibits distinct rhythmic and cyclical patterns, demonstrating that the disorder is deeply anchored in bodily rhythms and internal clocks rather than mere reactions to adverse events. Clinicians regularly encounter patients whose depressive episodes follow precise temporal cycles: an individual might endure two months of debilitating, severe symptoms, recover completely, and then, exactly a year and a half later, descend into the identical depressive pattern on schedule.
A prominent example of this temporal patterning is Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD), where depressive episodes occur exclusively during specific seasons—typically winter. Sapolsky illustrates this contrast with a striking scenario: a person with SAD might experience a devastating personal event in June, feel appropriately sad for a few weeks, and bounce back; yet, in January, with no external trigger whatsoever, they fall into a profound depression that leaves them hospitalized for six weeks, repeating a cycle that has recurred every winter for a decade. “And that is all about biological clocks that are out of whack there,” Sapolsky underscores, showing that such patterns cannot be cured by telling someone to simply pull themselves together.
---
[14:49](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=889s) Synaptic Transmission and the Norepinephrine Hypothesis
To explain what goes wrong chemically in the depressed brain, Sapolsky outlines the mechanics of synaptic transmission between two neurons. Brain cells do not physically touch; when an electrical impulse travels down a neuron, it triggers the release of chemical messengers—neurotransmitters—stored in tiny packets resembling "little water balloons." These chemicals are discharged across the synapse, binding to receptor proteins on the receiving neuron to relay the message. Once the signal is transmitted, the synapse must be cleared. The presynaptic cell can either take a "green," recycling route by pumping the neurotransmitter back inside for reuse (reuptake), or take an enzymatic degradation route, where enzymes break the chemical down to be flushed out through the cerebrospinal fluid, bloodstream, and urine.
```mermaid
flowchart TD
accTitle: Synaptic Transmission and Antidepressant Targets
accDescr: Diagram illustrating presynaptic neurotransmitter release, breakdown by MAO, reuptake pumps, and where antidepressants intervene.
subgraph Presynaptic ["Presynaptic Neuron"]
V["Vesicles ('Water balloons')"] -->|"Release into synapse"| NT["Norepinephrine (NE)"]
Pump["Reuptake Pump"] -.->|"Recycles NE"| V
end
subgraph Synapse ["Synaptic Cleft"]
NT -->|"Binds to"| Rec["Postsynaptic Receptors"]
NT -->|"Degraded by"| MAO["MAO Enzyme"]
end
subgraph Interventions ["Pharmacological Mechanisms"]
MAOI["MAO Inhibitors"] -->|"Inhibit enzyme"| MAO
TCAs["Tricyclic Antidepressants"] -->|"Block pump"| Pump
Reserpine["Reserpine (Blood Pressure Drug)"] -->|"Destroys vesicles"| V
end
```
The earliest neurochemical theory of depression emerged in the 1960s around the neurotransmitter norepinephrine. The first generation of antidepressants, monoamine oxidase (MAO) inhibitors, worked by inhibiting the enzyme that degrades norepinephrine, leaving the neurotransmitter in the synapse longer to hit receptors repeatedly and alleviate depressive symptoms. Shortly thereafter, tricyclic antidepressants achieved the same therapeutic outcome through a different mechanism: blocking the reuptake pump. Further evidence came from the antihypertensive medication reserpine, which depleted norepinephrine by breaking down storage vesicles; patients taking reserpine frequently fell into deep clinical depressions as a side effect. Sapolsky summarizes the logical conclusion drawn by researchers: “You take a depressed person. You find a way of boosting up there norepinephrine signaling. They feel better. You take a normal person. You drive down their norepinephrine signaling. They get depressed.”
- **Neurotransmitter cleanup mechanisms**: Neurotransmitters in the synapse are either actively pumped back into the presynaptic neuron for recycling or enzymatically degraded and expelled through bodily fluids.
- **MAO inhibitors**: Inhibit the monoamine oxidase enzyme, preventing norepinephrine degradation and allowing it to repeatedly activate postsynaptic receptors.
- **Tricyclic antidepressants**: Gum up the presynaptic reuptake transporter pump, preventing norepinephrine re-absorption and prolonging synaptic signaling.
- **Reserpine**: A blood pressure medication that destroys vesicular storage; depleting norepinephrine in non-depressed individuals triggered depression, reinforcing the norepinephrine hypothesis.
---
[19:09](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=1149s) The Pleasure Pathway in Animals and Humans
The strong pharmacological link between norepinephrine and mood forced researchers to consider what norepinephrine pathways actually do in the healthy brain. Pioneering animal research from the 1950s revealed that stimulating specific tracts with implanted electrodes could induce intense positive affect. In classic self-stimulation experiments, rats equipped with an intracranial electrode were trained to press a lever to receive a brief burst of electrical stimulation in this circuit. The rats found the stimulation overwhelmingly rewarding.
As Sapolsky details, rats given access to this lever would hit it 25 times in succession to receive a pulse, repeating the behavior compulsively: “Rats will work themselves to death to get stimulated in this area.” The sensation proved more desirable than food, sex, or even drugs of abuse during active withdrawal. Dubbed the "pleasure pathway," this circuit was subsequently identified in humans during neurosurgery. Because brain tissue lacks pain receptors, neurosurgeons routinely operate on patients who are conscious under local anesthesia to map functionality—observing whether a test stimulation makes the patient move an arm or recite the Pledge of Allegiance. These surgical mappings confirmed that humans possess the identical neural reward circuitry that drives pure pleasure.
[20:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=1248s) The Pleasure Pathway, Norepinephrine, and the Flaws in the Initial Hypothesis
By the early 1960s, researchers had mapped the brain's reward circuitry well enough to stimulate the exact same pleasure pathway in humans that had previously been studied in rats. The transcripts from these early deep-brain stimulation experiments revealed striking reactions. Patients described sensations of intense, cozy gratification: comparing the feeling to sex, to finally getting to scratch an unbearable itch, or to getting back into a warm bed after playing outside in the autumn leaves until called in for fresh cookies and footie pajamas. Researchers discovered that this pathway relies heavily on the neurotransmitter norepinephrine. The logical deduction at the time was clear: a shortage of norepinephrine in that circuit explains anhedonia, the classic loss of pleasure seen in depression.
```mermaid
flowchart LR
accTitle: The Tri-Neurotransmitter Model of Depression
accDescr: Diagram linking dopamine, norepinephrine, and serotonin to their respective depressive symptoms.
subgraph NT["Neurotransmitter Deficits"]
DA["Dopamine Shortage"]
NE["Norepinephrine Shortage"]
5HT["Serotonin Shortage"]
end
subgraph Symptoms["Clinical Manifestations"]
ANH["Anhedonia<br/>(Inability to feel pleasure)"]
PMR["Psychomotor Retardation<br/>(Slowed movement & fatigue)"]
GRIEF["Obsessive Grief<br/>& Perseveration"]
end
DA --> ANH
NE --> PMR
5HT --> GRIEF
```
Despite initial confidence, serious cracks quickly appeared in the norepinephrine-only hypothesis:
- **The Time-Course Paradox**: Drugs targeting norepinephrine alter synaptic signaling within about an hour, yet depressed patients typically do not experience clinical improvement for several weeks.
- **The Discovery of Dopamine**: It soon became evident that dopamine plays an even more foundational role in the pleasure pathway than norepinephrine, as demonstrated by drugs of abuse like cocaine that act directly on dopamine systems.
- **The Rise of SSRIs**: In the late 1980s, the introduction of Prozac—a Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitor (SSRI)—shifted the scientific landscape entirely by demonstrating that boosting an entirely different chemical, serotonin, successfully alleviates depression.
[22:57](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=1377s) Neurochemical Synthesis and the Role of Substance P
The clash between proponents of norepinephrine and serotonin led to an era of fierce academic debate, which Robert Sapolsky jokingly characterizes: “So it was during this period where there was just endless tragic drive-by shootings of norepinephrine people by the serotonin crowd, or the other way around-- huge, huge controversy.” Ultimately, the field adopted a more integrated model. While acknowledging that any clean division is “insanely simplistic,” Sapolsky outlines the best working consensus for the roles of these three primary neurotransmitters in major depressive disorder:
- **Dopamine deficiency** corresponds to **anhedonia**, the inability to experience pleasure.
- **Norepinephrine deficiency** drives **psychomotor retardation**, the physical and mental sluggishness where even mundane tasks feel exhausting.
- **Serotonin deficiency** accounts for the relentless, **obsessive sense of grief** and psychic pain.
This model is reinforced by the clinical utility of SSRIs in treating Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD), where patients perseverate uncontrollably on rituals such as washing their hands for eight hours a day or aligning utensils symmetrically. Whatever the intrusive perseveration is, augmenting serotonin signaling helps quiet it.
Beyond these three systems, other neurochemical leads have emerged, most notably **substance P**. Long established as the spinal neurotransmitter responsible for relaying physical pain—from stubbing a toe to the agonizing sensations of whole-body burn injuries—substance P was unexpectedly found to alleviate depressive symptoms when blocked with antagonists. Sapolsky points out that this connection shows depression is far more than a poetic metaphor for suffering: “Your body is using the same brain chemistry to feel this psychic pain of depression as just telling you, oh, I just stubbed my toe-- interesting similarities there.”
[25:15](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=1515s) Neuroanatomy: The Triune Brain and Emotional Signaling
Turning to brain structure, Sapolsky introduces the "triune brain" framework, developed in the 1940s, to explain how different evolutionary layers of the brain interact:
| Brain Layer | Evolutionary Origin | Primary Functions | Role in Stress & Depression |
|:--- |:--- |:--- |:--- |
| **Reptilian Brain** (Brainstem & base) | Ancient vertebrates (lizards) | Autonomic regulation: blood glucose, blood pressure, vessel tone | Executes the physical stress response (plumbing/regulatory commands) |
| **Limbic System** | Mammalian evolution | Mediates core emotions: fear, lust, rage, anger, poignance | Interprets social and environmental threats, signaling downward to activate stress hormones |
| **Cortex** | Vastly expanded in primates / humans | Abstract reasoning, sensory processing, taxes, art, language | Generates abstract, existential, or sorrowful thoughts that trick lower centers into full stress mobilization |
```mermaid
flowchart TD
accTitle: Cortical Cascades in Major Depression
accDescr: Flowchart showing how abstract cortical thoughts trigger lower-brain stress responses.
subgraph CX["Cortex (Abstract Thought)"]
Thought["Contemplating mortality, refugee camps, or despair"]
end
subgraph LB["Limbic System (Emotional Center)"]
Emotion["Senses danger, sorrow, and intense grief"]
end
subgraph RP["Reptilian Brain (Autonomic / Physiological Core)"]
Stress["Massive Stress Cascade:<br/>Appetite suppression, loss of libido,<br/>psychomotor collapse, elevated hormones"]
end
Thought -->|"whispers to"| LB
LB -->|"mobilizes"| RP
```
In animals, the limbic system communicates down into the reptilian core during acute physical crises—for instance, when an elk smells a threatening rival and begins pumping out stress hormones. Humans have this same system, but with an enormously expanded cortex that handles abstract associative tasks. When a human experiences physical trauma—such as unexpectedly walking out of a lecture and being gored by an elephant—the body mobilizes a massive stress response, causing appetite to vanish, libido to shut down, and a sense of shock and psychomotor retreat to take over.
Sapolsky emphasizes that in major depression, this identical physiological cascade is launched not by an external beast, but by abstract thoughts alone. When an individual ruminates on loved ones' mortality or the plight of refugees, the cortex activates the rest of the brain identically: “On a certain, totally simplistic level what depression is about is the cortex whispering in the ear of the rest of the brain, saying, this is as real as you were just physically assaulted by some sort of predator, whatever.”
[29:09](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=1749s) Neurosurgical Disconnection: The Cingulotomy
If the fundamental architecture of depression involves the cortex inundating the lower brain with abstract sorrow, an extreme theoretical intervention would be simply severing that neural bridge. In modern neurosurgery, this exact concept is realized through an **anterior cingulotomy** (or cingulum bundle cut). Sapolsky distinguishes this targeted microsurgical procedure from crude historical frontal lobotomies: instead of creating diffuse damage, the neurosurgeon precisely cuts the cingulum bundle, disconnecting the anterior cingulate cortex from emotional and autonomic structures below.
- **Candidate criteria**: This intervention is reserved strictly as a desperate, last-resort measure for intractable, treatment-resistant patients who have failed every permutation of medication, psychotherapy, and electroconvulsive shock therapy (ECT), and who remain confined to state hospital wards chronically attempting suicide.
- **Clinical outcome**: Surprisingly, following this disconnection, patients often display significant relief from their profound, intractable depression.
- **Cognitive side effects and philosophical counterarguments**: Severing this pathway also dampens the capacity for abstract pleasure, prompting the philosophical objection that stripping away an individual's psychic pain also robs them of their capacity to experience higher-level joy. Sapolsky dismisses this critique as detached intellectual nonsense for this population: “You get someone who is a candidate for this procedure back in the state hospital there with their wrists scarred over. And this is not somebody feeling a whole lot of abstract pleasure anyway.”
[31:08](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=1868s) The Endocrine Connection: Thyroid Hormones and Depression
Moving from brain anatomy to the endocrine system, Robert Sapolsky examines how peripheral biology directly shapes affective states. A prime example is the thyroid system. Thyroid hormones regulate basal metabolism, thermoregulation, and overall cellular energy expenditure. When thyroid hormone levels crater into severe hypothyroidism, patients routinely plummet into major depressive episodes. A classic manifestation is Hashimoto’s disease, an autoimmune condition in which the thyroid gland is attacked, impairing hormone synthesis and secretion. Once clinical thyroid hormone supplementation restores normal circulating levels, the depressive symptoms vanish.
Sapolsky emphasizes that this is far from a rare medical curiosity. Epidemiological data suggest that roughly one-fifth of major depressive cases are actually misdiagnosed hypothyroid conditions. This reality carries a crucial diagnostic lesson: psychiatric health cannot be treated in isolation from whole-body physiology, nutrition, and systemic endocrinology. As Sapolsky asserts, “First one is best estimates are about 20% of major depressions are undiagnosed hypothyroid syndromes instead.”
- Thyroid hormones sustain systemic metabolism and body temperature; their deficiency induces secondary major depression.
- Hashimoto’s disease serves as a clear model: replacing the missing thyroid hormone reverses the affective disturbance.
- Comprehensive psychiatric assessments must routinely screen endocrine profiles, because systemic bodily states dictate brain function.
---
[32:42](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=1962s) Gender Disparities, Rumination, and Reproductive Hormones
The second endocrine dimension concerns the stark sex differences in depressive illness. Women experience major depression at approximately twice the rate of men, with vulnerability peaking during key reproductive inflection points: post-parturition (postpartum), the premenstrual phase, and perimenopause or menopause. These distinct clinical windows point toward an undeniable biological driver, even as sociological and psychological frameworks attempt to explain the disparity. Sociological explanations propose that institutional lack of control across cultures drives higher rates of female helplessness and depression. Another school of thought points to gendered differences in emotional coping mechanisms, noting that women, on average, ruminate more intensely on upsetting emotional events.
To illustrate rumination, Sapolsky describes behavioral studies where subjects choose activities after experiencing a conflict with a close friend. Women predominantly select questionnaires analyzing the relationship—how they met, the health of the friend’s marriage, and emotional interpersonal dynamics. Men, by contrast, frequently opt for unrelated distraction, such as trivia quizzes about the American Civil War. Sapolsky humorously observes the common reaction to this gap: “They can't express their emotions. Oh my God, no wonder they're impossible.” Yet while the sex difference in rumination is established empirical science, the leap claiming rumination directly causes clinical depression remains speculative.
The most robust explanation traces back to endocrine flux. During childbirth, menses, and menopause, circulating concentrations of estrogen and progesterone undergo dramatic swings. These changing ratios directly reshape the brain's baseline neurochemistry by modifying neurotransmitter receptor densities and modulating monoamine reuptake transporters. As Sapolsky summarizes, “Whatever depression is going to turn out to be on this nuts and bolts level, estrogen and progesterone can do something to it.”
---
[35:37](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=2137s) Stress Hormones: Glucocorticoids and the Progression to Autonomy
Turning to stress endocrinology, Sapolsky bypasses adrenaline—which he playfully calls a “vastly overrated hormone that I despise”—to focus on the glucocorticoids, the steroid hormones of the adrenal cortex to which he has dedicated three decades of research. In humans, the primary glucocorticoid is cortisol (hydrocortisone). In roughly half of all individuals diagnosed with major depression, baseline glucocorticoid levels are persistently sky-high. This hormonal surge confirms that a depressed person is not passive or inert, but rather enduring an agonizing, unrelenting physical stress emergency entirely within their own mind.
Elevated glucocorticoid exposure directly sensitizes an individual to depressive illness. Epidemiologically, an initial episode of depression is almost invariably preceded by a catastrophic external life stressor. If a patient recovers, their baseline vulnerability returns to that of the general population. A second severe stressor can precipitate a second episode, again followed by an apparent reset. However, repeated stress-induced episodes eventually cross a critical threshold. Around the fourth or fifth episode, the underlying neurobiology shifts, decoupling the illness from external events. At this stage, the depressive cycle becomes autonomous and self-sustaining, recurring spontaneously without any precipitating trauma. Clinical conditions like Cushing's disease, where the body oversecretes glucocorticoids, or high-dose synthetic corticosteroid therapies, consistently produce depression via glucocorticoid-mediated dopamine depletion.
```mermaid
flowchart TD
accTitle: Progression of Stress-Induced Depression
accDescr: Flowchart showing how repeated severe stressors transition from external triggers to autonomous cycling.
subgraph ReactivePhase ["Reactive Episodes"]
A["Severe External Life Stressor"] --> B["First Depressive Episode"]
B --> C["Full Recovery & Return to Baseline Risk"]
C --> D["Second Severe Stressor & Episode"]
end
subgraph AutonomousPhase ["Autonomous Cycling"]
D --> E["Repeated Episodes (Episodes 4-5)"]
E --> F["Autonomous Neurobiological Shift"]
F --> G["Spontaneous Depressive Cycling Without Stressors"]
end
```
- Glucocorticoids (cortisol in humans) are elevated to extreme levels in approximately 50% of major depressives.
- Cushing’s disease and high-dose exogenous steroid therapies directly trigger depressive episodes.
- Prolonged, massive glucocorticoid exposure depletes central dopamine reserves, blunting hedonic processing.
- Sapolsky summarizes the shift into independent cycling: “Somewhere around the fourth or fifth stress-induced depression, something happens. And things start cycling on their own there.”
---
[38:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=2294s) The Limits of Biological Psychiatry and Freud’s "Mourning and Melancholia"
Despite immense progress in mapping neurotransmitters, brain structures, and endocrine loops, Sapolsky cautions against a reductionist biological view. A clinician who relies exclusively on biology will be fundamentally ineffective, because pharmacotherapies succeed in only about 30% to 40% of major depressive cases. To understand the condition fully, one must integrate cognitive and psychological principles.
To bridge this gap, Sapolsky invokes Sigmund Freud's landmark 1917 essay, *Mourning and Melancholia*. Freud contrasted ordinary mourning—the painful but adaptive process of grieving a loss and eventually recovering—with melancholia, the turn-of-the-century Viennese term for intractable major depression. Freud posited that human relationships are inherently fraught with ambivalence, housing combinations of deep love, resentment, envy, and hostility. In standard mourning, a bereaved person successfully isolates the affection, grieves the lost loved one, and gradually emerges whole. In melancholia, the individual cannot compartmentalize their negative feelings; they drown in an agonizing morass of affection, anger, and unresolved resentment.
This Freudian model cleanly accounts for the devastating guilt and cognitive despair typical of the disorder. When a loved one dies, an ordinary mourner grieves a single loss. A melancholic mourner suffers a double trauma: they lose the person, and they permanently lose any opportunity to resolve their internal conflict and make amends. Secret feelings of relief or bitterness immediately morph into crushing self-condemnation. Out of this dynamic emerged one of psychoanalysis's most enduring insights: “Depression is aggression turned inward, because you've got nobody else out there to have these arguments with.”
- Solely biological approaches leave roughly 60% to 70% of depressed patients without adequate relief.
- Mourning represents adaptive grief over a lost person, concept, or goal, concluding in emotional resolution.
- Melancholia involves an inability to separate love from resentment, trapping the individual in unresolved ambivalence and self-punishing guilt.
[41:23](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=2483s) Freudian Ambivalence vs. Experimental Stress Psychology
Reflecting on the psychological definition of depression, Sapolsky explores the psychoanalytic idea of grief gone wrong: losing someone who was simultaneously loved and hated, without ever getting the chance to say what needed to be said. When that opportunity is lost forever, the unresolved hostility turns inwards. While this formulation of "aggression turned inward" intuitively accounts for why someone cannot feel pleasure, secretes stress hormones, or struggles to get out of bed due to psychomotor retardation, it suffers from a fundamental scientific limitation. As Sapolsky puts it: “What isn't great is how in the hell do you turn Freudian ambivalent feelings into something about neurochemistry?” It is virtually impossible to run modern biological experiments mapping estrogen-to-progesterone ratios onto love-to-hate ratios, highlighting the core flaw found even in the best parts of Sigmund Freud's theories.
```mermaid
flowchart TD
accTitle: Stress to Learned Helplessness Flow
accDescr: Flowchart showing how psychological stressors and the lack of coping mechanisms lead to cognitive distortion and learned helplessness.
subgraph Stressors["Psychological Stress Triggers"]
A["External Misery / Stressor"]
B["No Outlets for Frustration"]
C["Lack of Predictability"]
D["Lack of Control"]
E["No Social Support / Shoulder to Cry On"]
end
subgraph PsychologicalOutcome["Cognitive Distortion"]
F["Learned Helplessness"]
G["'I am always helpless, always hopeless'"]
end
A --> B & C & D & E
B & C & D & E --> F
F --> G
```
Because psychoanalysis cannot interface with neurobiology, one must look instead to experimental psychology and the specific factors that make psychological stressors damaging. A vast body of literature demonstrates that given the exact same amount of external misery, an organism experiences far more stress, mounts a larger stress response, and faces a much higher risk of stress-related disease if it lacks coping mechanisms:
- Having no outlets for frustration.
- Feeling a total lack of control over the event.
- Having no predictability regarding when the stressor will occur.
- Having no social support or shoulder to cry on.
[42:59](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=2579s) Learned Helplessness and Childhood Loss
When these psychological stressors reach pathological extremes, depression manifests in the cognitive psychology framework as "learned helplessness." In classical animal experiments, a rat subjected to unpredictable, uncontrollable shocks eventually stops trying to escape; even when moved to a new environment where pressing a lever a couple of times easily terminates the shocks, the animal simply sits there and endures them because it has learned that actions do not matter. In human depression, an individual experiences a painful loss or setback and engages in a profound cognitive distortion: instead of realizing that an awful situation is circumscribed, they decide it represents the entire world. Sapolsky summarizes this mental trap: “And do this cognitive distortion, and decide, this is, indeed, the entire world. And I have no control. I am always helpless. I am always hopeless.”
This cognitive vulnerability is strongly rooted in developmental history. One of the most reliable and replicated findings in psychiatric epidemiology is that losing a parent to death before the age of 10 significantly elevates the risk of major depression for the rest of an individual's life. During the first decade of life, a child learns basic lessons about cause and effect, personal agency, and whether they can exert any efficacy over their surroundings. Experiencing the catastrophic loss of a parent teaches a child in the starkest way possible that terrible things happen outside of their control, leaving them permanently positioned on the precipice of learned helplessness.
[45:45](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=2745s) The Genetics of Vulnerability and Gene-Environment Interaction
To bridge psychological helplessness and neurochemistry, the critical intersection is stress. Depression is partially heritable and clusters within families, but genetic relatedness does not dictate an inevitable fate:
- An identical twin of a depressed individual has roughly a 50% concordance rate.
- Full siblings have about a 25% risk.
- Half-siblings have about an 8% risk.
- An unrelated person selected randomly off the street has approximately a 2% baseline risk.
Because identical twins share 100% of their genes yet have a 50% chance of *not* developing depression, genes confer vulnerability rather than inevitability. Several years prior, researchers identified a key gene related to depression risk—specifically a gene governing the serotonin transporter involved in the reuptake pump mechanism. The gene exists in two primary variants or "flavors," with one theoretically conferring higher vulnerability.
The breakthrough understanding of this gene came from a landmark longitudinal study following 1,000 children (the Dunedin Multidisciplinary Health and Development Study cohort, misstated in lecture as 17,000) growing up in New Zealand into their twenties. Researchers found that having the "bad" version of the gene alone did not elevate depression risk under normal conditions. However, when combined with a childhood history of severe stressors—such as parental divorce, physical abuse, or family bereavement—the gene's impact diverged dramatically:
| Gene Variant | Low Stress History | High Stress History |
|:--- |:--- |:--- |
| **"Good" (Protective) Variant** | Baseline risk | Modest, gradual increase in depression risk |
| **"Bad" (Vulnerable) Variant** | Baseline risk (identical to good variant) | Sharp escalation; up to a **30-fold increase** in depression risk |
As Sapolsky highlights, “This is not about genes control our brains. And genes control our behavior. This is a gene that's relevant to how readily we pick ourselves up after life has dumped us on our rear ends, how readily we recover from stressors.” Furthermore, the final biological link is that glucocorticoids (stress hormones) directly regulate the transcription and function of this serotonin transporter gene, neatly uniting psychological stress, endocrine signaling, and neurochemistry.
[50:07](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=3007s) Biological Reality and the Stigma in High-Achieving Communities
Drawing the lecture together, Sapolsky reiterates that childhood trauma and stress fundamentally imprint biological vulnerability for life, but the foremost takeaway is the tangible reality of the disease. In his central appeal to the students, Sapolsky stresses: “This is as real of a biological disorder as is diabetes. And that's the thing I most want you guys to take off from here.”
Despite the overwhelming neurobiological evidence, psychiatric illness remains shrouded in embarrassment, shame, and silence. Unlike medical conditions where a afflicted family member of a powerful politician leads to congressional hearings, foundations, and generous funding, psychiatric disorders are kept quiet. Sapolsky warns that this corrosive stigma is especially intense in an elite university environment populated by high-achieving, Type A individuals where everyone feels immense pressure to appear flawless, perfectly functional, and smoothly gliding through life. Major depression is ubiquitous within such communities, yet the prevailing culture makes it one of the most painful and difficult conditions to openly acknowledge.
[51:49](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=3109s) Depression as Biological Disease and Concluding Remarks
Robert Sapolsky brings his lecture to a close by reinforcing the core takeaway regarding the nature of major depression: it is fundamentally grounded in biology. Addressing the persistent societal stigma and hesitation surrounding mental illness, he explains that struggling with a genetic vulnerability or neurochemical imbalance is no different from any physical medical malfunction. Sapolsky emphasizes this parity directly: “And you should be no more inhibited about admitting that you've got something going on that's funny with this type of gene than you would be to admit that your pancreas isn't secreting insulin.”
Concluding the session, Sapolsky expresses regret that a tight schedule prevents him from opening the floor to an audience discussion. He notes that he unfortunately has to sprint out the door rather than stay to take questions, thanking the audience as the lecture wraps up to enthusiastic applause.
## Notable quotes
> [02:29](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=149s) If I had to define major depression in one sentence, I would say, it's a biochemical disorder with a genetic component, and early experience influences, where somebody can't appreciate sunsets. — Robert Sapolsky
> [09:17](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=557s) I will make the argument throughout here that depression is as real of a biological disorder as is juvenile diabetes. — Robert Sapolsky
> [04:16](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc&t=256s) What could possibly be worse than a disease whose defining symptom is the inability to feel pleasure? — Robert Sapolsky
## Mentioned
Robert Sapolsky, World Health Organization, Sigmund Freud, Mourning and Melancholia, Dunedin Multidisciplinary Health and Development Study, Prozac, Hashimoto's disease, Cushing's disease
## Video description
This lecture has been updated:
https://youtu.be/fzUXcBTQXKM
Stanford Professor Robert Sapolsky, posits that depression is the most damaging disease that you can experience. Right now it is the number four cause of disability in the US and it is becoming more common. Sapolsky states that depression is as real of a biological disease as is diabetes.
Stanford University:
http://www.stanford.edu/
Stanford University Channel on YouTube:
http://www.youtube.com/stanford
Stanford professor Robert Sapolsky argues that major depression is a severe, organic biological illness driven by disruptions in neurochemistry, neuroanatomy, and endocrinology that interact directly with psychological stress and genetic vulnerability.
Clinical Phenomenology and Pathognomonic Hallmarks (4:16)
Sapolsky distinguishes major depression from everyday sadness and temporary reactive grief, noting that the clinical disorder is characterized by anhedonia—the complete inability to experience pleasure—and delusional guilt that distorts objective reality. Patients often suffer from psychomotor retardation, where basic domestic tasks become exhausting obstacles, as well as disrupted sleep architecture marked by early morning awakening at 4:00 or 5:00 AM, appetite loss, and biological clocks falling out of synchrony.
This physical impairment produces a perilous clinical paradox regarding suicide risk. While individuals immobilized by severe psychomotor retardation typically lack the physical agency and executive function to carry out self-harm, the initial stages of recovery present the highest danger: physical energy returns while underlying psychological despair and nihilism remain unresolved.
Neurochemical Pathways and the Tri-Neurotransmitter Consensus (14:49)
The neurobiology of depression initially focused on norepinephrine following observations that MAO inhibitors and tricyclic antidepressants prolonged synaptic signaling, whereas reserpine depleted norepinephrine vesicles and triggered depression. However, the immediate neurochemical action of these drugs conflicted with the multi-week delay before patients achieved clinical relief, prompting broader inquiry into other monoamines.
Sapolsky outlines a tri-neurotransmitter working model: dopamine deficits drive anhedonia, norepinephrine shortages fuel psychomotor retardation, and serotonin depletion underlies obsessive grief and perseverative psychic pain. Beyond monoamines, elevated substance P—a neurotransmitter responsible for relaying physical pain signals—has also been implicated, indicating that psychological anguish shares physiological pathways with bodily injury.
Neuroanatomy and the Endocrine Stress Axis (25:15)
Within the triune brain framework, human depression represents the expanded cortex ruminating on abstract distress and continuously signaling the limbic and reptilian systems to trigger a full-scale physical emergency response. In treatment-resistant cases where patients exhaust pharmacotherapies and electroconvulsive therapy, neurosurgeons sometimes perform an anterior cingulotomy to sever the cingulum bundle, physically disconnecting cortical despair from downstream emotional centers.
Peripheral endocrine mechanisms heavily influence affective health. Sapolsky notes that roughly 20% of major depressions represent undiagnosed thyroid deficiencies like Hashimoto's disease. Furthermore, dramatic swings in estrogen and progesterone help explain why women experience twice the depressive vulnerability of men during key reproductive inflection points. Persistent elevations in glucocorticoids (cortisol) occur in about 50% of depressed patients, eventually depleting dopamine; after roughly four or five stress-triggered episodes, this stress neurobiology often becomes autonomous, recurring without external precipitants.
Learned Helplessness and Gene-Environment Interaction (42:59)
Because biological treatments alone fail in 60% to 70% of cases, Sapolsky bridges neurobiology with psychology through the concept of learned helplessness, where organisms subjected to uncontrollable, unpredictable misery conclude that personal agency is futile. Developmental factors heavily influence this cognitive vulnerability; losing a parent before age 10 significantly increases lifetime depression risk by teaching a child that catastrophic events occur beyond their control.
This cognitive vulnerability intersects directly with genetics. Concordance rates reach approximately 50% for identical twins, 25% for full siblings, and 2% for unrelated individuals. A prominent longitudinal study following a New Zealand cohort showed that possessing the vulnerable variant of the serotonin transporter gene does not alone elevate depression risk under low-stress conditions. However, when paired with severe childhood stressors, the vulnerable gene variant increases depression risk up to thirtyfold, demonstrating that genes govern stress vulnerability rather than predetermining an inevitable outcome.
Sapolsky concludes that clinical depression should carry no more social stigma than juvenile diabetes, urging high-achieving environments to drop cultural pressures of effortless perfection and recognize depression as an authentic, disabling biological disease.
Source quotes
[2:29] Robert Sapolsky: If I had to define major depression in one sentence, I would say, it's a biochemical disorder with a genetic component, and early experience influences, where somebody can't appreciate sunsets.
[9:17] Robert Sapolsky: I will make the argument throughout here that depression is as real of a biological disorder as is juvenile diabetes.
[4:16] Robert Sapolsky: What could possibly be worse than a disease whose defining symptom is the inability to feel pleasure?
Original transcript
[0:00] [MUSIC PLAYING]
[0:05] Stanford University.
[0:08] OK, there are all sorts of
interesting diseases out there.
[0:12] And lots of them
are quite exotic.
[0:15] You've got elephant
man syndrome.
[0:17] And you've got progeria,
which is the disease where
[0:21] you basically die of old age
when you're about 10 years old.
[0:24] Then you've got cannibals
eating brains and getting
[0:27] prion diseases.
[0:29] And those are very exciting.
[0:30] And they're great, and great
junior high school papers
[0:34] about disease and such.
[0:36] Oh no, come up to the front.
[0:37] There's lots of room up here.
[0:55] I see a couple
more seats up here.
[1:06] So there are all sorts of these
great made for TV movie disease
[1:09] out there.
[1:09] But when you want to come
to basic meat and potatoes
[1:13] of human medical misery,
there is nothing out there
[1:16] like depression.
[1:18] Depression is
absolutely crippling.
[1:20] Depression is incredibly
pervasive, and thus important
[1:23] to talk about.
[1:26] I'll make the argument here
today, a number of things,
[1:28] but one critical thing being
that basically depression
[1:32] is like the worst
disease you can get.
[1:34] And I'll make the argument
for that in a bit.
[1:37] It is devastating.
[1:38] It is wildly common.
[1:39] Current estimate are
15% of us in this room
[1:42] will have a major
depression at some point
[1:44] or other in our lives.
[1:46] So that is not good.
[1:48] What is also clear
is it is worldwide.
[1:51] Currently, World
Health Organization
[1:53] says depression is
the number four cause
[1:55] of disability on this planet.
[1:57] And by the year 2025
it's going to number two,
[2:01] after obesity,
diabetes-related disorders.
[2:04] So it is bad news.
[2:06] And it is becoming more common.
[2:08] OK, so what I'm going to talk
about today are seemingly
[2:11] two very, very different
topics, and tie them
[2:13] together at the end.
[2:14] And what the main is
if you live inside only
[2:18] one of those topics,
you're not going
[2:19] to understand this disease
at all-- first topic being
[2:22] what does biology have
to do with depression?
[2:25] Second topic being, what does
psychology have to do with it?
[2:29] OK, so starting off, first
giving a sense of symptoms.
[2:32] And right off the bat, we've
got a systematic problem,
[2:35] which is we all use
the word depression
[2:37] in an everyday sense.
[2:39] You get some bad
news about something.
[2:43] You have to replace the
transmission in your car.
[2:46] Somebody disappoints
you enormously.
[2:48] And you feel bummed.
[2:49] You feel depressed.
[2:50] You are down for a few days.
[2:52] That's not the
version of depression
[2:53] I'll be talking about.
[2:55] Next version, you do have some
sort of large, legitimate loss,
[3:00] setback, whatever, losing a job,
unemployment, death of a loved
[3:04] one.
[3:05] And you are extremely impaired
by a sense of malaise for weeks
[3:11] afterward.
[3:12] And then you come
out the other end.
[3:14] That's sort of what
I'll be talking about.
[3:16] But even more so
what I'll focus on
[3:18] is the subset of individuals
who, when something like that
[3:21] occurs, falls into
this depressive state.
[3:25] And weeks and months
later, they still
[3:27] have not come out the other end.
[3:28] Terminology-- the
everyday depression
[3:31] that we all have now and
then, that sort of version.
[3:34] The second one,
the something awful
[3:36] happens and you feel
terrible for a while,
[3:39] and then come out the other
end, a reactive depression.
[3:43] The third version, where
you are flattened by it
[3:46] for long periods afterward,
a major depression.
[3:50] And what you also see with
people with major depression
[3:52] after a while is as doesn't
take something awful externally
[3:56] to trigger one of those again.
[3:59] OK, so what are
the symptoms about?
[4:00] If I had to define major
depression in one sentence,
[4:05] I would say, it's a lot
biochemical disorder
[4:06] with a genetic component, and
early experience influences,
[4:10] where somebody can't
appreciate sunsets.
[4:13] And that's what this
disease is about.
[4:16] And when you think about it,
that is a very sad thing.
[4:20] You look at some of our major
diseases, somebody with cancer,
[4:24] somebody crippled
by heart disease,
[4:26] and you see the most
unlikely things out there.
[4:29] You see somebody
saying, well, obviously
[4:31] I'm not glad I'm
dying of cancer.
[4:33] But without this
disease, I never
[4:36] would have realized the
importance of friends.
[4:38] I never would have reconciled
with my family members.
[4:41] I never would have found my God.
[4:43] On a completely weird
level, I'm almost
[4:46] glad this has happened to me.
[4:48] Humans have this
astonishing capacity
[4:51] to derive pleasure out of
the most unlikely domains.
[4:54] What could possibly be worse
than a disease whose defining
[4:58] symptom is the inability
to feel pleasure?
[5:02] Thus, at the top of the
list, anhedonia-- hedonism,
[5:05] the pursuit of pleasure,
anhedonia the inability
[5:07] to feel pleasure.
[5:10] That is what a
depression is about.
[5:12] And you get someone who has just
had some enormous good luck,
[5:15] a long-sought relationship
works out well, whatever.
[5:19] And they feel
nothing, an inability
[5:22] to feel pleasure,
way at the top list.
[5:25] What else?
[5:26] Grief guilt, and
that's where we've
[5:29] got the semantic
problem again, which
[5:31] is the everyday
sort of depression.
[5:33] Something happens, bums us
out, and by definition we
[5:36] are feeling some
version of grief.
[5:39] Often, we started
obsessing at that
[5:41] point over some miserable thing
we did somebody 12 years ago
[5:45] and sort of despair in that.
[5:46] When you're talking
about major depression,
[5:48] the grief and the guilt can
be so severe that it actually
[5:52] takes on a delusional quality.
[5:54] OK, not delusional in the
sense of a schizophrenic
[5:57] with delusions
hearing voices thought
[5:59] disorder, but a certain style
with extreme depression.
[6:02] Let me give you an example.
[6:03] You have late middle aged guy,
perfectly healthy, and suddenly
[6:08] out of nowhere he has
a major heart attack.
[6:11] He's lying there
in the hospital.
[6:13] And the reality is,
he's going to recover.
[6:16] He's going to have to make
some changes in his lifestyle.
[6:18] But he's going to recover.
[6:20] He, instead, falls into
a major depression.
[6:22] This has transformed
his sense of who he is.
[6:25] Suddenly, he's an old man.
[6:27] Suddenly there's all
these things he can't do.
[6:30] He falls into a
major depression.
[6:31] Yet, he's recovering.
[6:33] Every day, his family is
in there, saying, look,
[6:37] you're just depressed.
[6:38] You're getting stronger.
[6:39] The doctors are saying
you're getting stronger.
[6:41] You're just depressed.
[6:42] It happens the
hospital is circular.
[6:45] It has a corridor that
forms a circle in it.
[6:47] And one day, the family
is in there saying,
[6:49] you're getting stronger.
[6:51] Look, the nurses said
yesterday you did one loop
[6:54] around the hospital.
[6:55] And today you did two loops.
[6:56] You're getting better.
[6:57] You're getting stronger.
[6:58] And the person says, no,
no, you don't understand.
[7:03] They're doing some construction.
[7:04] Last night, they closed
down the outer corridor.
[7:07] And they opened up a new little.
[7:09] So the two versions of
this one, two loops there
[7:11] is shorter than the large one.
[7:13] I'm getting weaker.
[7:14] I'm getting weaker.
[7:15] I'm going to die.
[7:16] I'm hopeless.
[7:16] This is like someone
expecting to believe
[7:19] that last night there
were beavers digging
[7:21] through the walls there
making this new-- this
[7:23] was the father of an
acquaintance of mine,
[7:26] a structural engineer.
[7:28] This is what a
structural engineer
[7:29] looks like when they're
delusional to the point
[7:32] of saying that this is a
world in which everything
[7:36] is inevitably getting worse,
depression built around that.
[7:39] Next, of course, one
of the most dramatic
[7:42] and one of the most awful
symptoms of depression-- self
[7:45] injury.
[7:47] Depressives mutilating
themselves at a high rate,
[7:50] and of course most notoriously,
suicide, risks of suicide.
[7:54] And that is absolutely tragic.
[7:56] And teenagers, early adults,
that along with accidents
[8:00] is the leading cause of
death-- major bad news.
[8:04] Another set of symptoms that
wind up being informative,
[8:07] something called psycho
motor retardation.
[8:11] Everything is exhausting.
[8:12] It's exhausting to do stuff.
[8:15] It's exhausting think stuff.
[8:17] You are there.
[8:18] And you can't do the laundry
because, where's the basket?
[8:23] And you gotta find
change for the machine.
[8:25] And you've got to go detergent.
[8:27] And it's too much.
[8:29] Everything is too much.
[8:31] And you fall into
this paralyzed state.
[8:34] Something very
interesting in that
[8:36] regard-- you get
someone who is severely
[8:38] depressed, like to the
point of hospitalization,
[8:41] and when they are
absolutely crippled
[8:43] with psychomotor
retardation, that's not
[8:46] when you worry about suicide.
[8:48] This is someone who's having
enough trouble getting out
[8:50] of bed and getting
dressed each day.
[8:52] They're not going
to figure out how
[8:53] to shred the hospital mattress
and make a noose out of it.
[8:57] Where you've got
your problems is
[8:59] when somebody
begins to get better
[9:01] from a severe depression.
[9:03] When they're
starting to come out,
[9:05] that's where the psychomotor
retardation relieves enough
[9:08] that suddenly they've
got the energy
[9:09] to do something catastrophic.
[9:12] That's when people are
on suicide watches,
[9:14] when you have clinicians
who are oriented well.
[9:17] Next-- something
really interesting,
[9:19] and in lots of ways
the single point I
[9:22] want to hammer in here
over, and over, and over, is
[9:25] something that people
with depression
[9:27] constantly battle with.
[9:28] Back to semantics,
we all get depressed.
[9:31] Bad stuff happens to us.
[9:33] We all get depressed.
[9:34] We feel lousy.
[9:34] We feel withdrawn.
[9:36] We feel a sense of grief.
[9:38] And we're not taking
much pleasure.
[9:40] And we withdraw.
[9:41] And then we get better.
[9:43] We cope.
[9:44] We heal.
[9:45] We deal with things in life.
[9:47] What's the deal with you
that you can't do that?
[9:50] And there's this lurking
sense given that all of us
[9:54] have periods of being depressed
and come out the other end.
[9:57] When you look at people who
instead go down and stay down
[10:00] there to this crippling
extent, there's
[10:02] always this little voice between
the lines there of, come on.
[10:06] Pull yourself together.
[10:08] We all deal with
this sort of thing.
[10:11] I will make the
argument throughout here
[10:13] that depression is as real
of a biological disorder
[10:17] as is juvenile diabetes.
[10:19] And you don't sit down a
diabetic and say, oh, come on,
[10:22] what's with this insulin stuff?
[10:23] Stop babying yourself.
[10:24] Pull it together.
[10:26] You will see this is just as
much a biological disorder.
[10:30] Part of what makes that
clear are a bunch of symptoms
[10:33] called vegetative symptoms.
[10:36] The bodies of major
depressives work differently.
[10:40] First set of symptoms-- no
surprise, lots of people
[10:43] have trouble
sleeping when they're
[10:44] having every day off
the rack depression.
[10:47] There's a certain pattern with
people with major depression.
[10:50] What would you think--
you're depressed,
[10:52] you have trouble falling
asleep, toss and turn.
[10:55] That's not what you see
with a major depressive.
[10:57] Instead, you wake up early.
[11:00] You wake up four in the
morning, five in the morning.
[11:03] You're exhausted.
[11:04] But you're not going to sleep.
[11:06] Early morning wakening-- you
wind up in an emergency room
[11:10] somewhere deeply depressed.
[11:11] And the clinician there
better ask you at some point,
[11:14] how's your sleep been?
[11:15] Do you tend to wake
up early in the day?
[11:18] Early morning
wakening, classic sign.
[11:21] Additional thing,
sleeping-- sleep
[11:25] is not this monolithic process.
[11:26] There's all these
different stages
[11:28] of sleep, slow wave sleep, deep
sleep, REM sleep, all of that.
[11:33] There's a structure, an
architecture, to how we sleep,
[11:36] sort of 90-minute
cycles as you go
[11:38] through the different phases.
[11:39] You look at the brain of
somebody with depression
[11:42] while they're sleeping.
[11:43] And these different phases
are completely disordered.
[11:47] The whole structure of
sleep goes down the tubes.
[11:50] Look at somebody when
they're sound asleep.
[11:52] And their brain
sleeps differently.
[11:54] This is not oh, come on,
stop babying yourself.
[11:57] This screams biology.
[12:00] More versions of
it-- most of us,
[12:02] what we do when we're
feeling kind of down is we
[12:05] eat more out of
this general belief
[12:08] that when you feel
unloved carbohydrates
[12:09] make you feel better.
[12:11] And bizarrely, there's actually
a brain chemistry of it
[12:14] of carbohydrates decrease
stress hormone release.
[12:17] So for most of us,
you're feeling bummed out
[12:19] about things, you eat more.
[12:21] That's not what you see in
major depression-- decreased
[12:24] appetite.
[12:25] Another thing you
see is activation
[12:27] of the stress response.
[12:30] A class of stress hormones
are highly elevated in people
[12:34] with major depression.
[12:35] You also have
over-activation of something
[12:39] that's called the sympathetic
nervous system, adrenaline.
[12:42] Overactivity of these components
of the stress response,
[12:45] and that's really important.
[12:46] Because you look at someone
with a major depression who's
[12:49] just mired in this
psychomotor retardation stuff,
[12:53] and there's this
temptation to start
[12:54] thinking about them as
some sort of sea sponge,
[12:57] some invertebrate thing, where
you're just so wiped out.
[13:00] You can't even get out of bed.
[13:02] It is just debilitating
in that sense.
[13:05] That's not what's going
on during depression.
[13:07] What you have instead
is somebody whose body
[13:10] is blasting through there,
over-activated stress
[13:14] response, this enormous battle,
all of it going on internally.
[13:19] And the fact that you
see changes like these
[13:21] tell you this is not,
oh, just so wiped out
[13:25] you can't even activate.
[13:26] This is someone whose body
is having a massive stress
[13:30] response 24/7.
[13:32] There's a huge battle going on.
[13:34] And it's all internally--
increased metabolic rate,
[13:37] increased muscle tone, all of
this again screaming biology.
[13:42] The final thing that
says tons of biology
[13:45] is lots of people
with major depression
[13:47] have rhythmic patterns
to the depression.
[13:51] You will get somebody where
they will fall into a depression
[13:54] where it will have two months
of extreme severe symptoms,
[13:57] debilitating, come
out the other end.
[13:59] And a year and a half later,
the exact same pattern, a year
[14:03] and a half later,
exact same thing.
[14:05] You have some people who
only get their depressions
[14:07] during the winter, something
known as seasonal affective
[14:11] disorders, SADs.
[14:13] And this is someone where
something horrible happens
[14:15] to them in June.
[14:17] And they feel sort of sad
for a couple of weeks.
[14:19] And they come out the other end.
[14:20] And nothing happens in January.
[14:22] And they fall into a depression.
[14:23] And they're hospitalized
for a month and a half,
[14:25] just like every January
for the last 10 years.
[14:29] And you see that.
[14:30] And that is all about
biological clocks
[14:32] that are out of whack there.
[14:35] It's biology.
[14:36] This is not, oh, come
on, pull it together.
[14:39] OK, so hopefully what
that begins to introduce
[14:42] is the notion amid all
these debilitating symptoms,
[14:45] these are ones that
are about biology.
[14:47] These are bodies
working differently.
[14:49] So starting to focus in
more on the biology of it--
[14:53] what's going on in the
brain in major depression?
[14:56] What I'll start off with
is the chemistry of it.
[14:59] OK, what we've got
here-- do not panic
[15:01] if you are not
familiar with this
[15:03] and have not wanted to think
about science since high school
[15:06] sort of thing.
[15:07] You've got two brain cells.
[15:08] You've got two neurons.
[15:09] The way they talk to each
other, they don't actually
[15:11] touch each other.
[15:12] In order for one neuron to
send a message to another one,
[15:16] it needs to release a chemical
messenger that goes floating
[15:19] over here and does something
or other to this neuron,
[15:23] chemical messenger called
a neurotransmitter.
[15:26] And here we have a case of this.
[15:28] And by law, all neurons
go from left to right.
[15:30] So this is a cell that
continues down this way.
[15:32] It's all excited.
[15:34] It's trying to pass on
some news to this neuron.
[15:38] There's a space in
between called a synapse.
[15:40] And what this one is doing,
because it's all excited,
[15:43] it has these little
water balloons
[15:45] filled with neurotransmitters.
[15:47] Excitation signal comes along,
dumps the neurotransmitters.
[15:51] They go floating across the
synapse, bind to a receptor
[15:54] there.
[15:54] And then, suddenly, something
changes in this neuron.
[15:58] That's how neurons
talk to each other.
[16:00] How many different types of
neurotransmitters there are,
[16:03] probably hundreds.
[16:04] And what will be pertinent
here is in depression,
[16:08] there's just a handful of them
that seem to be implicated.
[16:12] First neurotransmitter--
something
[16:15] called norepinephrine.
[16:17] Norepinephrine first got
implicated in depression
[16:20] in the early '60s.
[16:22] What was the evidence?
[16:24] Around that time,
the first generation
[16:25] of antidepressant drugs
had been developed,
[16:28] something called MAO inhibitors.
[16:31] What do they do?
[16:32] OK, so you got your
neurotransmitters released.
[16:34] This neuron is excited.
[16:35] What do you have to do?
[16:36] It comes out.
[16:37] It does its thing
with the receptors.
[16:39] And then you have to
clean up after yourself.
[16:41] You've dumped all the
stuff in the synapse.
[16:43] What do you do then?
[16:44] You got two options.
[16:45] You can take the
neurotransmitter.
[16:47] And you can be green
in your orientation.
[16:50] You can recycle.
[16:51] You can take it back up
in here and stick it back
[16:54] into one of these.
[16:55] You can do this
recycling business.
[16:57] Or you could be terrible
and carbon footprint.
[16:59] You can throw out
your neurotransmitter.
[17:01] There's enzymes
sitting around here
[17:04] that break it up and
flush it down the toilet.
[17:07] What's the toilet?
[17:08] Out into your
cerebral spinal fluid,
[17:10] your bloodstream,
your urine, whatever.
[17:13] So either recycling
or degrade this stuff.
[17:17] So what do these
MAO inhibitors do?
[17:19] They inhibit the activity
of this enzyme that
[17:23] breaks down norepinephrine.
[17:25] OK, so what's the logic there?
[17:26] So you inhibit the
activity of this enzyme.
[17:30] You don't break
down norepinephrine.
[17:32] So it's just floating
around there.
[17:34] And for lack of
anything else to do,
[17:35] it hits the receptor
a second time,
[17:37] and a third time, and
a gazillionth time.
[17:39] And, suddenly, somebody's
depression goes away.
[17:43] What's your theory have
to be at that point?
[17:46] Oh, I bet there wasn't enough
norepinephrine coming out.
[17:49] You find a means to
increase the signaling.
[17:51] Somebody gets better.
[17:52] And you now hypothesize
there's a problem
[17:55] with too little norepinephrine.
[17:57] By the late '60s another
class of antidepressants
[18:00] came in called tricyclic
antidepressants.
[18:03] What do they do?
[18:04] Essentially the
same exact thing.
[18:06] What they do is they gum up this
pump that recycles the stuff.
[18:11] Norepinephrine doesn't get
removed from the synapse,
[18:14] has nothing else to
do, hits the receptor
[18:16] a second, third, tenth time.
[18:17] Person feels better, oh, I
think the problem in my theory
[18:21] is too little norepinephrine
coming out-- thus,
[18:24] the norepinephrine hypothesis.
[18:26] More evidence for
it-- there are classes
[18:28] of drugs that will decrease
your norepinephrine release.
[18:32] Why would you want to do that?
[18:34] In some parts of the body,
an excess of norepinephrine
[18:36] has something to do with
high blood pressure.
[18:38] So you take a class of drugs,
something called reserpine.
[18:41] And what it does is it
disintegrates these things.
[18:43] And, thus, you don't dump
as much norepinephrine.
[18:47] Major side effect in lowering
somebody's blood pressure
[18:50] that way is they fall
into a depression.
[18:53] So you take a depressed person.
[18:54] You find a way of boosting up
there norepinephrine signaling.
[18:58] They feel better.
[18:58] You take a normal person.
[19:00] You drive down their
norepinephrine signaling.
[19:02] They get depressed.
[19:03] There's gotta be a problem here
of too little norepinephrine.
[19:06] So that's incredibly convincing.
[19:09] So at this point, what you've
got to say is, OK, great.
[19:11] That's convincing.
[19:12] That's irrefutable.
[19:13] What does norepinephrine do?
[19:16] And people figured
it out in the '50s.
[19:18] And it's got something
to do with this.
[19:21] Take a rat.
[19:23] And take a certain
part of the brain.
[19:24] You put an electrode
down in there
[19:26] where you can
stimulate the neurons.
[19:28] You can force them
to talk to each other
[19:29] when otherwise they
have nothing to say.
[19:32] Stimulate this pathway,
and what you do
[19:34] is you make a rat
unbelievably happy.
[19:37] So, of course, the
question is, how do you
[19:40] tell when a rat is
unbelievably happy?
[19:42] And what you do is you
make it work in order
[19:46] to get stimulated there.
[19:47] It presses a lever.
[19:48] And it presses a lever 25 times.
[19:50] And it gets a little buzz there.
[19:51] And it does another.
[19:53] And rats will work
themselves to death
[19:56] to get stimulated in this area.
[19:58] It is better than food.
[19:59] It is better than sex.
[20:01] If they're addicted to a drug
and going through withdrawal,
[20:04] it is better than the drug.
[20:06] And what you see is these
mediates pure pleasure.
[20:09] And this was called the
pleasure pathway in the 1950s.
[20:13] So, of course, you look at it.
[20:14] And then what you have
to then say is, oh,
[20:16] do we have the same pathway?
[20:18] Can I get a new one?
[20:19] Can I get a second one?
[20:20] Shortly after that,
people went looking,
[20:22] and saw the exact
same thing in humans.
[20:25] And this would be during
neurosurgery-- classical
[20:28] neurosurgical techniques.
[20:29] You don't anesthetize
the person.
[20:31] The brain doesn't feel pain.
[20:33] Once you've witnessed
the skin and the skull,
[20:35] you get through there.
[20:36] And you can actually keep
somebody awake during surgery.
[20:39] And they used to
need to need to do
[20:40] that, because you put
your little needle down
[20:43] in one part of the brain. d
the person flaps their arm.
[20:45] And another part and
they say the Pledge
[20:47] of Allegiance or whatever.
[20:48] And then you look at
your little roadmap.
[20:50] And it says, OK, go three
neurons and make a left.
[20:53] People had to do that.
[20:54] So it was around the
early '60s that people
[20:57] started stimulating the same
area in the human brain.
[21:00] And it is unbelievable
what you got.
[21:03] There were transcripts
of some of these.
[21:05] And you read it.
[21:06] And the person is going on.
[21:07] And they're saying stuff
like, oh that's great.
[21:10] That's great.
[21:11] That's kind of like sex.
[21:12] But you know when
you have this itch
[21:14] and finally you
get to scratch it?
[21:16] And, oh, it's like
getting back into bed.
[21:19] And remember how
in the fall you'd
[21:21] go out and play in the leaves,
and mom would call you in,
[21:23] and she made
cookies, and then you
[21:25] get into your jammies
with the feet on?
[21:27] They just go on like this.
[21:29] It's like, where can you
sign up and have this happen?
[21:32] The same exact sort
of these as in a rat.
[21:34] And it was around
that time that people
[21:37] discovered that in this
pathway it uses norepinephrine.
[21:42] So if you've got a
shortage of norepinephrine
[21:45] in that part of the brain,
what have you just explained?
[21:48] That's the loss of pleasure.
[21:50] Great, utterly
convincing-- here's
[21:52] all the reasons why you
shouldn't be convinced.
[21:54] Problems began to emerge.
[21:56] First problem was
there's something
[21:58] weird with the time course.
[21:59] You throw in any of the
drugs I just talked about
[22:02] and norepinephrine signaling is
changing within like an hour.
[22:06] You put a depressed
person on those drugs
[22:08] and they don't get better
for a couple of weeks.
[22:11] Something isn't working there.
[22:13] So that was mysterious.
[22:15] Next problem was it
turned out norepinephrine
[22:17] is useful in this pathway.
[22:19] Another neurotransmitter turned
out to be even more important,
[22:22] a neurotransmitter
called dopamine.
[22:24] Dopamine-- cocaine works
on dopamine systems.
[22:28] So, suddenly, norepinephrine
is just a minor player
[22:31] in this pleasure pathway stuff.
[22:33] But the biggest problem
came in the late '80s
[22:36] with the introduction of Prozac.
[22:39] Prozac, which is an SSRI, a
Selective Serotonin Re-uptake
[22:44] Inhibitor-- what that does is
work on a completely different
[22:47] neurotransmitter system,
this neurotransmitter
[22:49] called serotonin.
[22:51] What that drug does is
it does the same deal.
[22:54] It stops the Re-uptake
Increased Serotonin Signaling.
[22:57] And then what's your hypothesis?
[22:59] You give somebody a Prozac SSRI.
[23:02] They feel better.
[23:03] I bet you there was
too little serotonin.
[23:05] So it was during
this period where
[23:07] there was just endless
tragic drive-by shootings
[23:10] of norepinephrine people
by the serotonin crowd,
[23:13] or the other way around--
huge, huge controversy.
[23:16] And, of course, the middle
of the road liberals are
[23:19] like, why can't
we all get along?
[23:21] Which starts suggesting that
maybe it's got something
[23:24] to do with norepinephrine,
and serotonin, and dopamine,
[23:27] and everybody hold hands.
[23:31] And that's absolutely
what's going on.
[23:34] The best evidence at this point,
to be insanely simplistic,
[23:37] is that dopamine has something
to do with the anhedonia,
[23:42] an absence of dopamine.
[23:44] The absence of
norepinephrine has
[23:46] something to do with the
psychomotor retardation.
[23:49] The absence of serotonin is
this obsessive sense of grief.
[23:54] And, interestingly,
supporting that notion is you
[23:57] can have an obsessive
sense of something else.
[24:00] You could have an obsessive need
to keep your utensils perfectly
[24:03] symmetrical and obsessively wash
your hands eight hours a day.
[24:07] Obsessive compulsive
disorder, that's
[24:10] helped by SSRIs
like Prozac as well.
[24:13] Whatever it is you are just
perseverating over like mad,
[24:17] increasing serotonin
signaling can help.
[24:20] So you've got at least three
different neurotransmitters
[24:22] relevant to the pleasure, the
psychomotor retardation, all
[24:25] of this, all sorts
of other leads
[24:27] floating around in the field.
[24:29] There's a neurotransmitter
called substance P.
[24:33] And what substance
P is about is pain.
[24:37] Like, poke your finger
and your spinal cord,
[24:39] there's neurons there
are releasing substance,
[24:42] talking to each other.
[24:43] It's about pain.
[24:44] It's about chronic
pain syndrome, which
[24:46] is about whole body burns.
[24:47] Everybody knew this.
[24:48] And then it was
discovered that if you
[24:50] get a drug that decreases
substance P signaling,
[24:56] sometimes depressives
get better.
[24:57] What does that suggest?
[24:59] It is not just a metaphor of
depression as psychic pain.
[25:03] Your body is using the
same brain chemistry
[25:07] to feel this psychic
pain of depression
[25:10] as just telling you,
oh, I just stubbed
[25:12] my toe-- interesting
similarities there.
[25:15] OK, so we've got something
about the neurochemistry.
[25:17] How about the neuroanatomy,
the structure in the brain?
[25:20] And what you've got here
is this is the human brain.
[25:23] This is exactly
what it looks like.
[25:25] It comes in three colors.
[25:26] And this was this
formulation that
[25:28] came out during the '40s called
the triune brain concept, which
[25:32] winds up being really,
really explanatory.
[25:35] Down here at the bottom, you've
got the really boring nuts
[25:38] and bolts part of the brain.
[25:40] And as it was termed,
this is the reptilian part
[25:42] of the brain.
[25:43] Take a lizard, and its'
basically the exact same stuff
[25:47] down there.
[25:47] What does this part
of the brain do,
[25:49] like regulatory boring things?
[25:53] It measures your
blood glucose levels.
[25:55] Or if your blood
pressure has dropped,
[25:56] it sends out a signal to
tighten up your blood vessels--
[26:00] just hope total boring
plumbing-type issues.
[26:03] Sitting on top of it is a much
more interesting brain region
[26:08] called the limbic system.
[26:10] Limbic system is about emotion.
[26:12] You don't see a
big limbic system
[26:14] until you get to mammals.
[26:16] Lizards are not famous
for their emotional lives.
[26:18] Limbic system is much more about
emotive stuff-- fear, and lust,
[26:23] and anger, and rage, and
poignance, and God knows what.
[26:27] What you've got
there are all sorts
[26:28] of ways where the
limbic system talks
[26:32] to this part of the brain.
[26:34] And what it does
is rather than you
[26:36] being hemmoraged--
oh, [INAUDIBLE],
[26:38] your body getting cold,
whatever, you're some elk.
[26:43] And there's some scary other elk
there that's got you all upset.
[26:47] And you start secreting
stress hormones.
[26:49] That's your limbic
system saying,
[26:51] oh, I don't like the smell of
that guy talking down there--
[26:54] all sorts of means by which
your emotional part of the brain
[26:56] can talk to stuff down here.
[27:00] Then you've got the
really interesting area
[27:03] up on top-- the cortex.
[27:06] Cortex, all sorts of creatures
out there have cortexes.
[27:08] We got more than anybody.
[27:10] It is this hugely
expanded area in primates.
[27:15] We proportionally have
the biggest one out there.
[27:17] What does cortex do?
[27:18] It makes you do your taxes.
[27:21] And it does processing
visual information,
[27:24] and tells you, that's punk rock.
[27:28] And that's not Beethoven, and
all sorts of sensory stuff,
[27:32] associative cortex things.
[27:34] But then there's
an interesting part
[27:37] of the cortex that's very
relevant to all of this.
[27:41] Suppose you finish the lecture.
[27:43] You go outside.
[27:44] Unexpectedly, you are
gored by an elephant.
[27:46] What are you going to do?
[27:48] You are going to activate
your stress response.
[27:51] You may feel a sense
of grief at that point.
[27:55] You may kind of hunker
down at that point,
[27:56] a little psychomotor
retardation.
[27:59] Appetite, there goes
the dinner arrangements.
[28:02] Sex may not be the
most appealing thing
[28:04] under that context.
[28:06] You are having a stress
response in response
[28:08] to the sort of insult that
this part of the brain
[28:11] is thinking about.
[28:13] So what's a depression?
[28:14] You sit there.
[28:15] And you think about
kids in refugee camps.
[28:18] You think about the inevitable
mortality of your loved ones.
[28:21] You think about whatever.
[28:23] And, suddenly, your body
does the exact same thing
[28:27] as if you were gored
by an elephant.
[28:29] And what's going on there
is you get the feelings,
[28:33] the abstract sort of
depressive stuff there.
[28:37] And this part of the
brain is able to make
[28:40] the rest of the brain
go along with it,
[28:42] as if this was an
elephant goring you.
[28:44] On a certain, totally
simplistic level
[28:47] what depression is about
is the cortex whispering
[28:50] in the ear of the rest
of the brain, saying,
[28:52] this is as real as you
were just physically
[28:55] assaulted by some sort
of predator, whatever.
[28:58] And you turn on the
exact same thing.
[29:00] On a very simplistic level,
what a depression is,
[29:04] is the cortex having
too many sad thoughts
[29:07] and getting the rest of the
brain to go along with it.
[29:09] OK, so if that's how you
think about depression, which
[29:12] is insanely simplistic,
you could come up
[29:14] with an insanely simplistic
treatment for depression,
[29:16] which is get yourself a pair of
scissors and just kind of cut
[29:20] through there.
[29:21] And separate that part of the
brain from the rest of it.
[29:24] And you're home free.
[29:25] Oh, yeah, right,
well, that's certainly
[29:28] an advance in medicine.
[29:29] That is a medical procedure.
[29:32] It is called a cingulotomy,
the part of the cortex
[29:35] is called the
anterior cingulate.
[29:37] A cingulotomy, or a
cingulome bundle cut.
[29:39] And what you do is you
sever this pathway.
[29:42] And people get less
depressed at that point.
[29:45] OK, when does this happen?
[29:48] This is someone where
every type of medication,
[29:51] and every type of therapy, and
electroshock interventions,
[29:54] and all of that has been
tried in every combination.
[29:57] Are they're still in the back
ward of the state hospital
[29:59] slashing their wrists
every three months.
[30:01] That's when people try this.
[30:02] And the amazing thing with
this desperate measure
[30:05] is people get less
depressed at this point.
[30:09] OK, so at that point, you
may want to look at that
[30:11] and say, well, anything
else about these people
[30:13] when you've gone through
there and just snipped away?
[30:16] Mind you, this not
a frontal lobotomy.
[30:18] Frontal lobotomy is doing
something very undefined
[30:20] up there.
[30:21] But instead, you're
disconnecting here.
[30:23] What else is up with
somebody when you've just
[30:25] disconnected part
of their cortex
[30:27] from the rest of the brain?
[30:29] Insofar as the cortex can come
up with abstractly sad thoughts
[30:33] and get the rest of the
brain to go along with it,
[30:35] maybe the cortex also comes
up with abstractly pleasurable
[30:37] thoughts and gets the
rest of the brain--
[30:40] have you just wiped
out somebody's ability
[30:42] to have abstract pleasure?
[30:44] Absolutely.
[30:45] So, suddenly, you are off and
running with a great philosophy
[30:48] term paper.
[30:49] It's important that we have
pain in order to have pleasure.
[30:52] This is nonsense.
[30:54] You get someone who is a
candidate for this procedure
[30:56] back in the state hospital there
with their wrists scarred over.
[31:00] And this is not somebody
feeling a whole lot
[31:02] of abstract pleasure anyway.
[31:04] So what does this tell us?
[31:06] You come up with some
ridiculously simplistic
[31:08] explanation, that you make it
impossible for this sad part
[31:11] of the brain to whisper
sad thoughts to the rest
[31:13] of the brain, the best people
in the field thinking about this
[31:16] can't come up with
anything a lot more
[31:17] sophisticated than that.
[31:19] So that tells you something
about the brain structure
[31:23] with depression.
[31:24] Final bit of biology
here-- hormones,
[31:27] what do hormones
have to do with it?
[31:29] One very important domain of
hormones-- you take somebody.
[31:33] And they're having
problems with a class
[31:35] of hormones, thyroid hormones.
[31:37] What thyroid hormones are about
is maintaining your metabolism,
[31:42] keeping your body warm enough,
all that sort of stuff.
[31:45] If you have a severe shortage of
thyroid hormone, lots of things
[31:50] happen, including you fall
into a major depression.
[31:53] Hypothyroidism is associated
with major depression.
[31:57] There's an autoimmune disease
called Hashimoto's Disease,
[32:01] which involves problems with
secreting thyroid hormone.
[32:03] And that's a basic
feature of it.
[32:05] And somebody comes in.
[32:06] And you diagnose it.
[32:07] And you give them normal
levels of thyroid hormone.
[32:10] And away goes their depression.
[32:12] Lots of lessons with that.
[32:14] First one is best estimates are
about 20% of major depressions
[32:19] are undiagnosed hypothyroid
syndromes instead.
[32:23] The next one that
demonstrates is you better,
[32:25] when somebody is thinking
about your psychiatric state,
[32:28] you better have
somebody there who's
[32:30] thinking about your nutrition,
your hormone levels,
[32:34] your-- nothing about
what's going on here
[32:35] is independent of
the rest of the body.
[32:39] So a big role for
thyroid hormones.
[32:42] Next domain of hormones being
relevant-- you take women.
[32:47] And they have a higher
incidence of major depression
[32:50] than men do-- approximately
twice the rate.
[32:53] In addition, women have
their highest vulnerability
[32:56] to depression at certain points
in their reproductive life
[32:59] histories.
[33:00] After you've given birth, a
post-parturition depression.
[33:04] Around the time of your
period, around the time
[33:06] of your menopause, all
of these scream biology.
[33:11] So you look at why women have
elevated rates of Depression.
[33:14] And there's biology.
[33:15] There's all sorts of
other schools of thought
[33:18] that have gone into it.
[33:19] There are ones having more
sociological framework.
[33:23] Lack of control can
cause depression.
[33:25] In society after society,
women traditionally
[33:28] have less control.
[33:29] No wonder they fall
into more depression.
[33:31] There's another
school that focuses
[33:33] on a certain style of
emotional differences
[33:35] you see between the genders.
[33:37] On the average, women
tend to ruminate more
[33:41] on emotionally upsetting
things to focus in on more.
[33:44] And this sounds
totally stereotypical.
[33:46] And when you do the
studies, there's
[33:48] overlaps between individuals.
[33:50] But nonetheless, on the
average, what you see
[33:52] is these sorts of studies
where you get someone
[33:55] after they've just had a
fight with a close friend.
[33:58] And what do women do
when they give a choice
[34:00] of a whole bunch of activities?
[34:01] They choose to fill
out questionnaires
[34:03] about how they met
their friend, and what
[34:05] the nature of the
relationship is,
[34:06] and does the friend
have a good marriage?
[34:08] And all of that.
[34:09] You do it to guys.
[34:10] And they fill out questionnaires
about trivia questions
[34:12] about the Civil War.
[34:13] Oh my God.
[34:14] They can't express
their emotions.
[34:16] No wonder they're impossible.
[34:17] And, of course, again,
individual variation, this
[34:21] is highly stereotyping.
[34:22] On the average, though,
women ruminate more
[34:26] on upsetting
emotions than men do.
[34:28] So that is solid science.
[34:30] What is completely
unsolid science
[34:32] is the speculation at
that point that if you
[34:35] ruminate on bad feelings, you're
more prone to a depression.
[34:39] So that's a whole emotional
regulation argument.
[34:43] But you come back
to that business
[34:44] of, women are most at risk for
a depression in the two weeks
[34:48] after giving birth, around
the period of their periods,
[34:51] menopause.
[34:52] And that's all about hormones.
[34:54] And by now, there's
a huge literature
[34:56] having to do with the effects
on all of that stuff over there
[35:00] of estrogen, and
progesterone, and probably
[35:04] most importantly the ratio
of estrogen progesterone.
[35:07] And what's going on around
giving birth, period?
[35:11] Levels of this stuff is
just shooting around all
[35:14] over the place.
[35:15] And the sense is something goes
out of whack with the ratios
[35:18] there.
[35:19] And everything about estrogen,
progesterone, and the ratio
[35:22] can change the
number of receptors
[35:24] for these neurotransmitters,
the extent to which you
[35:27] do this re-uptake pump.
[35:28] Whatever depression
is going to turn out
[35:31] to be on this nuts
and bolts level,
[35:33] estrogen and progesterone
can do something to it.
[35:37] Final class of hormones that are
relevant-- a class of hormones
[35:40] released during stress.
[35:42] OK, what's the most famous
stress hormone on Earth?
[35:45] Adrenaline is this
vastly overrated hormone
[35:48] that I despise because there's
a much more important stress
[35:51] hormone out there to which
I've devoted the last 30
[35:54] years of my life, class
of stress hormones
[35:56] called glucocorticoids.
[35:56] They come out of your
adrenal gland during stress.
[36:00] The human version is
hydrocortisone, also
[36:02] known as cortisol.
[36:04] All sorts of other
species out there,
[36:05] you secrete these
glucocorticoids
[36:08] when you are stressed.
[36:10] You look at people
with major depression.
[36:12] And about half of them
have elevated levels
[36:15] of glucocorticoids
through the roof.
[36:18] There's something out of
whack with the regulation
[36:20] of this stress hormone
during depression.
[36:23] What's that about?
[36:24] That's back to people
with depression are not
[36:27] invertebrates sitting
on their beds.
[36:29] These are bodies undergoing
massive stress responses.
[36:32] There's a huge emotional
battle going on,
[36:35] all of it inside their heads.
[36:38] So elevated stress hormone
levels-- what's very clear
[36:41] is you get exposed to a
lot of glucocorticoids,
[36:45] and you're more at risk
now for depression.
[36:47] You can see this
epidemiologically.
[36:49] You get people,
and statistically
[36:52] before their first major
depressive episode,
[36:54] something awful
stressful occurs.
[36:57] And that's where this happens.
[36:59] And this is the subset of people
who stay down there far longer.
[37:03] Have one of those first
depressive episodes
[37:05] due to some stressful event,
you come out the other side
[37:08] eventually.
[37:09] You are no more at risk for
depression than anybody else.
[37:13] Along comes a second
major stressor.
[37:15] And you fall into a depression.
[37:17] Come out the other end, no
more at risk than anyone else
[37:21] for depression.
[37:22] Somewhere around
the fourth or fifth
[37:25] stress-induced depression,
something happens.
[37:29] And things start cycling
on their own there.
[37:32] And you no longer
need a major stressor
[37:34] to cause you to get
depressed like that.
[37:37] That's when the clocks
are often running.
[37:39] That's the transition.
[37:41] OK, so major stress
can predispose you
[37:43] towards depression.
[37:45] More evidence--
there's a disease
[37:47] called Cushing's disease,
where people secrete boatload
[37:50] of this glucocorticoid stuff.
[37:52] People with Cushing's
fall into depressions.
[37:55] There's a whole
bunch of diseases
[37:57] where people have to be treated
with lots of glucocorticoids.
[38:00] They fall into depression.
[38:01] What are glucocorticoids doing?
[38:04] A whole lot of
them, and your brain
[38:06] gets depleted of dopamine.
[38:09] And you're right
back in this domain.
[38:10] That's probably
the neurochemistry
[38:12] of how you get there.
[38:14] OK, so what do we
get at this point?
[38:16] We've got something about
brain chemistry and depression.
[38:18] We've got something about
the structure of the brain.
[38:20] We've got something
about hormones.
[38:22] You are a card-carrying
biological psychiatrist.
[38:25] And that's all you need
to know about the subject.
[38:27] And if that's all you
know about the subject,
[38:29] you are going to be pitifully
bad in making anybody
[38:31] get better, because all
of this knowledge winds
[38:36] up being effective for treating
maybe 30%, 40% of depressives.
[38:39] Vast majority of people,
the antidepressant drugs
[38:42] don't do a whole lot there.
[38:44] All you've got there is modern,
cutting edge biology stuff.
[38:49] And that's not enough.
[38:51] So what I'll transition
to here is now
[38:53] talking about the
psychology of depression,
[38:55] because you better have
that piece in the story.
[38:57] Or else you're
absolutely useless.
[39:00] Starting off with, I
make apologies here.
[39:03] But I actually have to say
the name of Sigmund Freud
[39:06] here, because he winds up being
very relevant to depression.
[39:09] Freud back when dealt with
this puzzle of the difference
[39:13] between we all get depressed
and come out the other end,
[39:16] and the subset of
people who crash.
[39:19] The turn of the
century Viennese term
[39:21] for people who come out
the other side, mourning.
[39:25] You mourn something
and you recover.
[39:27] Term of the century
Viennese term
[39:28] for major depression,
melancholia.
[39:31] And Freud and this
famous essay said,
[39:33] why is it that a subset
of us fall into it?
[39:36] What's the difference between
mourning and melancholia?
[39:40] And he came up with a
really interesting model.
[39:43] OK, according to Freud,
you have mixed feelings,
[39:47] ambivalencies about
everybody you love out there.
[39:50] You love them.
[39:50] And you hate them.
[39:51] And you resent them.
[39:52] And you reject them, and
all that Freudian stuff.
[39:55] So in this Freudian view,
you have lost a loved one.
[39:59] That can also be a loved
concept, a loved goal.
[40:02] You have lost a loved one.
[40:05] What happens then
is, in most people,
[40:08] you are able to focus on the
love and the sense of loss.
[40:12] You mourn.
[40:14] And you come out the other end.
[40:15] In Freud's view,
what melancholia
[40:17] is about is the
subset of people who
[40:20] can't put the negative
feelings in the background.
[40:23] And instead, you are awash
in the love, and the hate,
[40:27] and the regret, and the
pain, and the delight,
[40:30] and all of that.
[40:31] And what a depression
is, is this wallowing,
[40:34] this melancholic loss,
and the ambivalencies
[40:36] you have about the
lost loved one.
[40:39] It explains tons.
[40:41] No wonder you have the grief.
[40:43] Lose somebody and go through
the mourning business.
[40:46] And only one thing is wrong.
[40:48] You've lost this loved one.
[40:49] Lose somebody with melancholia,
and two things have happened.
[40:53] You've lost the loved one.
[40:54] And you have now lost
the opportunity to ever
[40:57] make things better with them.
[40:59] No wonder you have the guilt.
You're sitting there saying,
[41:02] thank God, I'm finally
done with this person.
[41:04] They are never
gonna control my--
[41:06] how can I think such
a thing like that?
[41:09] Sudden, crippling guilt,
all sorts of other symptoms.
[41:12] And out of this came this
wonderful soundbite--
[41:15] depression is aggression
turned inward, because you've
[41:20] got nobody else out there to
have these arguments with.
[41:23] This is the person who you have
most loved, but most hated.
[41:27] And you've never said the
things you needed to hear,
[41:29] and pounding at the door
to get them to finally
[41:31] to e able to tell them.
[41:33] And now you have lost
that opportunity forever.
[41:36] And all you can
do is internalize
[41:38] all of that-- aggression
turned inward.
[41:41] No wonder you're not feeling
a whole lot of pleasure.
[41:44] No wonder you're
secreting stress hormones.
[41:46] No wonder you're not
getting out of bed
[41:48] all that readily with the
psychomotor retardation
[41:50] stuff-- this really powerful
soundbite of aggression
[41:54] turned inward.
[41:56] That's great.
[41:57] What isn't great
is how in the hell
[41:59] do you turn Freudian ambivalent
feelings into something
[42:03] about neurochemistry?
[42:04] Or what do estrogen
progesterone ratios have
[42:08] to do with love hate ratios?
[42:09] It's great.
[42:10] It feels very intuitive.
[42:12] You can't do modern
science on it,
[42:14] which is the problem with
the best parts of Freud.
[42:17] So instead, you
need to shift over
[42:19] to looking at experimental
psychology, and understanding
[42:23] what is the
psychology of stress?
[42:25] What is it that makes
psychological stressors
[42:27] stressful?
[42:28] And an enormous
literature now shows
[42:31] that for the same external
misery, you feel more stressed,
[42:36] you turn on a
stress response, you
[42:37] are more at risk for a
stress-related disease
[42:40] if you don't have outlets
for the frustration caused
[42:43] by the stressor, if
you feel like you
[42:44] have no control over
what's happening,
[42:46] you have no predictability
as to when it's occurring,
[42:49] and you don't have anybody's
shoulder to cry on.
[42:52] This is what psychological
stress is about.
[42:54] And what a depression is, is
pathological extremes of this.
[42:59] You fall into the
cognitive psychology
[43:02] soundbite of what a depression
is, it's learned helplessness.
[43:07] It is learning to be helpless.
[43:09] Something bad happens to you.
[43:11] You a rat, getting some
shocks now and then,
[43:14] you a human
experience some loss,
[43:16] and the logical thing you should
do is learn, this is awful.
[43:20] When I'm in this
situation, there's not
[43:22] a damn thing I can do about it.
[43:24] It's awful.
[43:25] I feel terrible.
[43:26] But this is not the whole world.
[43:28] And what a major depression
is about is you sit there.
[43:31] And you're that rat.
[43:33] And in this setting, you
get uncontrollable shocks.
[43:36] But put you in another
setting and just
[43:37] by hitting the lever a couple
of times you avoid the shocks.
[43:40] You don't bother doing
it because you've
[43:42] learned to be helpless, just
like a human depression.
[43:45] What depression, what
learned helplessness is,
[43:48] is taking a circumstance
where by any logic, again,
[43:51] you should be saying,
this is awful.
[43:53] But it is not the whole world.
[43:55] And do this
cognitive distortion.
[43:56] And decide, this is,
indeed, the entire world.
[44:00] And I have no control.
[44:02] I am always helpless.
[44:03] I am always hopeless.
[44:05] This is the psychology of
what a depression is about.
[44:09] At that point, you don't
have a whole lot of trouble
[44:12] seeing how you wind up in here.
[44:14] Stress affects on some dopamine,
all that sort of stuff.
[44:17] So we've got two extremely
different viewpoints here
[44:20] as to what depression is about--
modern, biological stuff,
[44:24] and this totally different
world of psychology, loss, lack
[44:29] of control.
[44:30] One version of it, one of
the most reliable findings
[44:34] in the whole epidemiology
of depression
[44:36] is lose a parent to death when
you are under 10 years of age,
[44:41] and for the rest of you
life you are more at
[44:43] risk for a major depression.
[44:45] This makes perfect sense.
[44:47] What is a lot of what's
going on during your first 10
[44:50] years of life?
[44:51] You are learning about
cause and effect.
[44:55] You're learning, is
this a world out there
[44:57] where I have any
sort of efficacy,
[44:58] where I have any
sort of control?
[45:00] And you have just learned in
the most big time, awful way,
[45:05] there are things
you can't control.
[45:06] And sometimes they are awful.
[45:08] And what have you just learned?
[45:10] There's all sorts of reasons
where one can be helpless.
[45:13] And you're that much
closer to the edge
[45:15] of this learned
helplessness cliff
[45:17] for the rest of your life--
extremely powerful model
[45:20] here of that.
[45:22] So you got all
the biology stuff.
[45:24] You've got this weird Freudian
aggression turned inwards,
[45:26] which just feels right.
[45:29] But you can't do
modern science on it.
[45:30] You've got this whole world.
[45:32] How do you begin to put this
world and that world together?
[45:36] And the critical link
turns out to be stress.
[45:40] Stress is the
intersection of the two
[45:43] in a very interesting domain.
[45:45] OK, depression is
a genetic disorder.
[45:49] What do I mean by that?
[45:51] Depression has some
degree of heritability.
[45:56] Depression tends
to run in families.
[45:58] Depression runs more
reliably as you look
[46:01] at closer and closer relatives.
[46:02] And you eventually look
at identical twins.
[46:04] And if one of them
has depression,
[46:06] the other has a 50% chance.
[46:09] Full siblings who
are not identical
[46:11] twins, 25% chance,
half sibling about 8%,
[46:15] person off the
street, about a 2%.
[46:17] 50% chance when they
share the identical genes.
[46:21] What does that do?
[46:22] That tells you this
is a disorder that
[46:23] has a genetic component.
[46:26] What does that also tell you?
[46:28] If you've got 50%
likelihood-- if you've
[46:31] got all the genes in
common, and you've
[46:33] got a 50% chance of not getting
the depression-- it tells you
[46:36] genes are important.
[46:37] But they're not more important
than any other component.
[46:40] So genes and depression are
not about inevitability.
[46:44] They're about vulnerabilities.
[46:46] So what is the
vulnerability about?
[46:48] A few years ago, people
discovered a particular gene
[46:52] that's really relevant
to whether or not
[46:55] you get depression.
[46:56] What was exciting about that?
[46:58] It was a very clear finding.
[47:00] It has since been replicated.
[47:02] What else was exciting about it?
[47:04] It made sense.
[47:05] This was not some weirdo
gene having something
[47:07] to do with how your
big toe functions.
[47:09] This was a gene having
something to do with serotonin.
[47:13] And this was a gene relative
to this whole re-uptake pumping
[47:17] business, all of that.
[47:19] The main point of
it is this gene
[47:20] comes in two different flavors.
[47:23] Each one of us has one
of the two versions.
[47:26] And you immediately get
this prediction, one
[47:28] of the versions by
all logic should
[47:31] be predisposing to depression.
[47:33] One of them is the one that
should get you in more trouble
[47:35] here.
[47:36] So what does it look like
when you go and study it?
[47:40] First paper that reported
this a few years ago--
[47:43] and this, I suspect,
is going to wind up
[47:45] being viewed as the
most important paper
[47:47] in biological psychiatry
for a quarter century.
[47:50] This was this massive study
where a bunch of researchers
[47:54] looked at 17,000 kids
growing up in New Zealand,
[47:58] following them year
after year, and looking
[48:01] at the genetic makeup
of these individuals.
[48:04] And then asking in their
early '20s, who's got problems
[48:07] with major depression?
[48:08] And then asking this
critical question,
[48:10] what does it have to
do with this gene?
[48:13] Does the version of that gene
that gets you into trouble,
[48:17] by all logic, is that
going to set you up
[48:20] for more of a depression?
[48:21] Are you more at risk
for a depression
[48:23] if you've got the bad
version of the gene.
[48:26] And back comes the finding
which is no, no, it
[48:29] doesn't increase your risk.
[48:31] You look here.
[48:32] And what's your
likelihood of depression?
[48:34] And you've got the good version.
[48:36] And it's this likely.
[48:37] And you've got the bad version.
[48:39] And it's this likely.
[48:40] It doesn't make a difference,
unless something else is
[48:44] going on, unless you have
a history of exposure
[48:49] to major stressors.
[48:50] And what you are able
to do is quantify
[48:52] how many major
stressors somebody
[48:55] has had during their
childhood, their development.
[48:58] And that involves parental
divorce, and physical abuse,
[49:01] and death of family member,
all that sort of thing.
[49:04] And what you see
is in the folks who
[49:06] have the good
version of the gene,
[49:07] as you have more and more of
a history of major stressors,
[49:11] our risk of depression
goes up, absolutely.
[49:13] Now you look at the people with
the bad version of the gene.
[49:17] And as you have more and
more of history of stress,
[49:21] your risk of
depression does this.
[49:23] And when you look at the
major history of stressors,
[49:27] a thirty fold difference
in the likelihood.
[49:30] This is not about genes
control our brains.
[49:33] And genes control our behavior.
[49:35] This is a gene that's relevant
to how readily we pick
[49:39] ourselves up after life has
dumped us on our rear ends,
[49:42] how readily we recover
from stressors.
[49:46] What's the final
piece of that story?
[49:48] Glucocorticoids regulate
the function of this gene.
[49:52] All the pieces fall into place
there-- wonderfully logical.
[49:56] And, suddenly, you
have a way of taking
[49:58] this whole world of
psychological components
[50:01] of stress, and tying it into all
that biochemistry-- wonderfully
[50:05] integrated model.
[50:07] OK, so in lots of
ways, this is where
[50:09] the field is at this point.
[50:11] And what should mostly
have come through here
[50:13] amid all this minutia, and
factoids, and all of that,
[50:16] is the role of stress, and the
intersection of the biology,
[50:19] and the psychological stuff, and
childhood as a very important
[50:23] time to imprint how vulnerable
you are to depression
[50:26] for the rest of your life.
[50:27] But, again, the
single thing I want
[50:29] to emphasize over and over
implicit on everything
[50:32] on that left side of the board
there, which is this is not,
[50:35] oh, pull yourself together.
[50:37] We all get depressed.
[50:39] This is as real of a biological
disorder as is diabetes.
[50:43] And that's the thing I most want
you guys to take off from here.
[50:47] And in the context
of a university
[50:50] setting is rife with
major depression.
[50:53] A community of high
achieving, type A individuals
[50:55] is rife with major depression.
[50:57] It is all around us.
[50:59] And amid it being
all around us, there
[51:01] is this weird, corrosive
inhibition, embarrassment,
[51:06] discomfort we have with the
world of psychiatric diseases.
[51:09] One of the greatest
things-- if you're
[51:12] a researcher with a disease,
one of the things you pray
[51:14] for is to for some
powerful Senator
[51:16] have their loved one come
down with your disease
[51:19] because they're going
to setup a foundation,
[51:20] and get special funding.
[51:21] And there's advocacy
groups and all of that.
[51:24] Not for a psychiatric
disorder, that's
[51:26] the one where people
don't talk about it.
[51:30] And amid this screaming
biology, and this
[51:32] is a devastating disease, and
all of that, in any place,
[51:36] and especially in a
community like this
[51:38] where everyone is
supposed to be golden,
[51:40] and functioning, and flawless,
and just gliding through life,
[51:44] this is one of the
hardest diseases
[51:45] for people to admit to.
[51:47] So it is there.
[51:48] It's all over the place.
[51:49] And it's biology.
[51:51] And you should be no more
inhibited about admitting
[51:53] that you've got
something going on that's
[51:56] funny with this type
of gene than you
[51:58] would be to admit that your
pancreas isn't secreting
[52:00] insulin.
[52:02] So let me stop at this point.
[52:03] And, again, unfortunately, I
got to spring out the door.
[52:05] Otherwise, I would take
questions, but thanks.
[52:10] [APPLAUSE]
[52:24] For more, please visit
us at stanford.edu.